Send us a text

A single gunshot in the darkness of a Dodge City night forever altered the course of Western history, claiming the life of beloved performer Dora Hand in a case of tragic mistaken identity. When James "Spike" Kenedy fired into Mayor James Kelly's home on October 4, 1878, he had no idea his vengeful bullets would strike the talented singer sleeping in the mayor's bed while he was away on business.

What followed was one of the most remarkable manhunts of the Old West. An all-star posse of legendary lawmen—including Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, and Charles Bassett—pursued Kenedy across rugged terrain and swollen rivers. Their dramatic confrontation and Kenedy's subsequent capture might have been the stuff of dime novels, but what happened next reveals the complex reality of frontier justice.

Despite Kenedy's apparent admission and the overwhelming circumstantial evidence, this son of a wealthy cattle baron walked free when his father arrived in town with a satchel full of money. Dora Hand's funeral drew the entire town in mourning, yet justice remained elusive. Through firsthand accounts, newspaper reports, and historical records, we piece together this forgotten tragedy that embodied both the best and worst of the American frontier—where a woman known for her generosity and beautiful voice could be gunned down in her sleep, and where even the combined efforts of the West's most famous lawmen couldn't secure justice against the power of wealth and influence.

Listen now to discover this captivating story that brings together celebrity, violence, pursuit, and the fascinating contradictions of Western justice. If you enjoy tales where history's footnotes reveal profound truths about the American experience, subscribe to our podcast and leave a review to help others find these forgotten stories of the Wild West.

Don't miss out on the excitement—tune in and explore the stories of "This Week in the West" by clicking on the link "This Week in the West."

If you want to own one or more of the beautifully illustrated dime novel publications, click Order Now.

She Leads with CARE
She Leads with CARE is a limited podcast series hosted by actor and producer Bellamy...

Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Support the show

Deadly Moonlight: The Tragic Tale of Dora Hand

Powered by Wave AI