Windows Weekly 966: "You Can't Spell Gmail Without AI" – Is Microsoft's AI Strategy Doomed to Burst?

Date: January 14, 2026
Hosts: Leo Laporte, Paul Thurrott, Richard Campbell
Setting: From Acapulco, Mexico (with tequila on the horizon)

Episode Theme & Purpose

This lively episode dives deep into Microsoft’s evolving AI strategy, the truth behind AI PCs, and where the tech giant is headed as sustainability, regulation, and intensifying competition shake up the industry. Paul, Richard, and Leo debate whether Microsoft’s AI push is a healthy revolution or a classic tech bubble about to burst, juxtaposing it with Apple and Google’s strategic moves and larger shifts across the PC and AI landscape. Sprinkled throughout are hands-on insights, skeptical hot takes, and even a crash course on tequila authenticity.

Major Discussion Points & Insights

AI Failures and Skepticism

• AI Hallucination by Microsoft Copilot: The UK police used Microsoft Copilot at a soccer game, resulting in a hallucinated recommendation to ban soccer fans—a decision later admitted as a pure AI error.
  • “Have you been asking a non-deterministic programming model for facts? Well, error was your first mistake.” — Paul Thurrott (03:45)
  • Highlights the inherent unreliability and risk of using generative AI in serious settings.

AI PCs: Real Revolution or Hype Cycle?

Dell’s Anti-AI Marketing & the Truth of the Market

• Dell executive claimed "consumers are not buying PCs because of AI," which hosts dissect and debunk:
  • Dell’s consumer PC sales have plummeted and are dwarfed by Lenovo, HP, and Apple.
  • Lenovo and HP’s data show robust consumer adoption and aggressive AI PC marketing.
  • Insight: AI is fast becoming an expected baseline capability, not necessarily a selling point, but also not deterring buyers.
  • “That’s like saying, I’m not buying a car because it has power windows or wiper blades or four tires.” — Paul Thurrott (09:05)

PC Market Breakdown

• Stats (06:38–09:59):
  • Lenovo: 33% of sales are AI PCs, $15B in quarterly sales, market leader.
  • HP: 30% of sales are AI PCs, $11B revenue.
  • Dell: Only $1.9B in consumer PCs, declining.
  • Apple: Pushing “Apple Intelligence”; Mac sales up 13%.
• “When they [consumers] do buy a PC, they’re going to get a lot of AI capability. They may not understand that, but they’re getting real advantages.” — Paul Thurrott (09:01)

The Future of "AI PCs"

• AI is becoming commoditized; soon every PC will be an "AI PC".
• “Maybe the mistake is they made it [Copilot] a paid SKU. If they just said, ‘Hey, Copilot’s included,’ they would look like heroes—and have a wider market!” — Paul Thurrott (26:18)

Microsoft's AI Strategy – Bubble or Boom?

AI Sustainability & Messaging

• Microsoft’s new pledge: make AI infrastructure “sustainable,” not raise local power prices, replenish water, avoid seeking tax breaks, and boost local jobs.
• "It's the same message they were saying about data centers years ago… just swapped 'data center' for 'AI.'" — Paul Thurrott (13:16)
• Hosts remain skeptical—see it as PR more than reality.

Satya Nadella's Leadership & Who Runs Microsoft Now?

• Nadella has delegated much of his CEO role; hosts debate if Amy Hood (CFO) or Brad Smith are the true power brokers now.
• “Microsoft is transitioning to… less a technology company and more a business management and regulatory navigation company.” — Richard Campbell (20:23)
• Parallels drawn to McDonald’s shift from food to real estate: Microsoft’s future may be about managing infrastructure, not software innovation.
• “They're enthusiastic about making money… I don't even understand how we got here.” — Paul Thurrott (21:45)
• Discussion of whether Nadella is stepping back to avoid being the “fall guy” if the AI bubble pops. (23:07–23:18)

The AI Bubble Comparison

• AI is following the classic tech hype/bubble pattern, with unsustainable growth promises made to investors and real product confusion among users.
• “We need a better term than ‘bubble’… it's like when Alderaan exploded in Star Wars!” — Richard Campbell (28:54)
• They predict the top 5 tech companies will remain, only more entrenched.

AI Market Dynamics

• Microsoft, Google, and Amazon sprinting to maximize data center buildout and market “AI” as a growth vector.
• “When the dust settles, the top five companies in the world will still be the same.” — Richard Campbell (33:30)

The Real-World Value and Risks of AI

Host Positions on Real Value

• Leo: “I’m betting on the success of AI… the overall value creation will be dramatic.”
• Richard: “AI is real… we’ll look back and wonder how we ever lived without it.”

Risks & Skepticism

• AI-driven layoffs are mostly an excuse for bad management, not actual automation (86:17).
• AI insidification—good products getting worse through money-chasing, not innovation.

AI Industry Horse Race & Apple-Google Deal

• Apple Chooses Gemini (Google) for Siri: Apple will use Google’s Gemini model for core AI and Siri integration.
  • “This is the real fallout of Gemini 3—not ChatGPT, not Anthropic.” — Paul Thurrott (72:34)
• Hosts see the "top three" (OpenAI, Google, Anthropic) as neck-and-neck, with industry switching speeds high and models rapidly fungible (76:22–77:15).

Usability, Small Models, and the User Experience

• Everyday users benefit from “invisible” AI (autocorrect, night mode, etc.), even as they claim they never use it (74:19).
• Commoditization: Gmail adds AI, others must follow. AI is becoming table stakes, not a premium offering (87:57).
• AI models for specific, local tasks (health data, coding) are the future; user-level "orchestration" of best-model-for-the-moment is coming (91:09).

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On AI Hype & Bubble:
  "We're going to have these stories where this stuff screws up. At least nobody died this time." — Richard Campbell (03:31)
  “We get it, yeah. And I'm just thinking you found a way around HIPAA…” — Paul Thurrott (83:21)
  “You wanted your billion-dollar win. AI is the new bubble.” — Paul Thurrott (29:53)

• On Satya Nadella & the Future:
  “Maybe he’s freeing up time to try and straighten the AI ship, or maybe he’ll leave and let the blame land on Judson when the bubble bursts.” — Paul Thurrott (23:07)
  “It’s a parallel to McDonald’s. Microsoft isn’t software anymore. They’re infrastructure. They own data centers.” — Paul Thurrott (20:56)

• On User Impact & Adoption:
  “It's not why they're buying [PCs]—but it’s just there, an expectation.” — Richard Campbell (09:05)
  “AI is real and it’s going to be a big deal, but like the Internet, it’ll have its bust cycle—if you’re patient, the returns are real.” — Leo Laporte (35:33)

• On Gmail & AI Commodity:
  “You can’t spell Gmail without AI—nailed it.” — Richard Campbell (88:36)

• On Insidification:
  “I’m going to insidify my website, just to see what it’s like. Everyone’s doing it.” — Richard Campbell (92:13)

Important Segment Timestamps

• [02:10] Copilot AI police “hallucination” incident
• [06:03–10:18] Reality check: AI PCs and PC market breakdown
• [12:26] Microsoft’s “sustainable” AI PR and its parallels with previous data center messaging
• [14:32] Satya Nadella’s reduced CEO role and shift in company power structure
• [20:56] Microsoft’s business transformation—a McDonald’s analogy
• [28:34] Feeling the AI bubble—dot-com era comparisons
• [33:53] Top tech companies will only get more entrenched via AI/data center investment
• [40:18] Patch Tuesday: What’s new (and not) for Windows in January 2026
• [45:43] IDC and PC sales volatility heading into 2026
• [57:07–59:54] Intel’s new CPU generations: AI, performance, and battery life
• [70:04] Return to AI talk, Apple & Google AI deal, the reality of on-device AI features
• [74:19] Samsung survey: Most users interact with AI constantly, though they don’t realize it
• [87:52] Gmail launches AI features; AI is table stakes for all productivity platforms
• [94:43] Xbox: Xbox Developer Direct event announced, Avowed coming to PS5
• [102:57] Paul’s Tip: Modern security “start of year” checkup
• [114:50] RunAs Radio segment: Azure’s 2026 direction, with Jeremy Winter
• [117:19–140:52] Tequila deep dive: How not all tequila is created equal, the dangers of “cristalinos,” and the ongoing fight for authenticity

Additional Highlights

Security Focus: New Year, New (Passwordless) You

• Paul recommends a comprehensive password/passkey manager review.
• “The best password is one you don’t even know.” — Paul Thurrott (107:20)

Hardware Insights

• Panther Lake and Lunar Lake CPUs: Great graphics, but confusing variants. Real-life gaming test showed impressive performance and almost silent, cool operation—caveat: only for the highest-end chips! (57:07–59:54)

AI at the Command Line

• Paul experiments with running local models (like Phi, Mistral, DeepSeek) using Microsoft’s Windows Foundry, finding them practical, customizable, and surprisingly snappy for travel planning and “offline AI.”

Tequila’s Adulteration Crisis

• Not all is well in Mexico’s most famous spirit: Large-scale tequila production is rife with additives (glycerin, sweeteners, even grain spirit), regulatory pushback, and legal action against major distillers like Diageo.
• Quick tip: “After tequila dries on your hand, if it’s sticky, it’s been adulterated.” (141:00)

Tone & Takeaways

The tone is witty, lightly irreverent, and often skeptical—especially toward press-release AI optimism and tech company marketing. The hosts' lived expertise provides a real-world grounding for both the bullish and cautious sides of AI’s next wave, making the episode a valuable primer on how to separate genuine tech transformation from bubble economics.

In Summary

• AI is becoming ubiquitous—but not always for the right reasons.
• PC landscape is stabilizing, but “AI PC” is mostly a rebranding, not a revolution.
• Microsoft faces an inflection point as AI hype collides with real investment risk. Its leadership may be quietly shifting to financial and regulatory experts.
• The AI industry’s future is likely to remain in the hands of a concentrated, entrenched group of tech giants—unless the predicted “pop” is more of an Alderaan-level event than a bubble.
• And if you’re drinking tequila in 2026… buyer beware.

(For exclusive notes, back-of-the-book tips, and a complete guide to passkeys and security hygiene, subscribe to Club TWiT or visit twit.tv.)