WSJ What's News – Alternative Indicators: Can Nevada Employment Predict Where the Economy is Headed?
Date: November 10, 2025
Host: Alex Osola
Guest: Andrew Woods, Director of the Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Nevada, Las Vegas
Series: Alternative Economic Indicators (Part 1)
Episode Overview
This episode launches a four-part series investigating alternative indicators of economic health. Host Alex Osola zeroes in on employment data from Nevada, exploring its potential as an early-warning system for national recessions. She teams up with economist Andrew Woods to unpack why Nevada’s job trends might predict U.S. economic turning points—while noting the nuances and caveats behind reading too closely into a single state’s numbers.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Why Use Alternative Indicators?
- Traditional economic indicators are often backward-looking, giving only delayed snapshots of economic reality.
- “Most economic indicators that you get from the government are pretty backward looking. It’s old news already and so it’s hard to find things that really give you an indication of the future.”
— Spencer Jacob, Investing Columnist (01:13)
- Private sector or region-specific data can sometimes offer a faster, more precise view of emerging national trends.
2. Nevada’s Economy: A Mirror of American Consumer Health
- High exposure to discretionary spending:
- “One in five jobs across the entire state are tied to leisure and hospitality...About 54% of the state budget is influenced by consumer spending. A third of [Nevada’s] GDP is tied to leisure and hospitality, travel and tourism.”
— Andrew Woods (02:56)
- Tourism as a bellwether:
Nevada's strong correlation with visitor counts (40–42 million annually) and hospitality jobs means the state often feels downturns earlier—reflected across the 2001 dot-com bubble, 2008 financial crisis, and 2020 pandemic.
3. Recent Data: Flatlining Employment in Nevada
- Current situation (as of August data):
- Nevada employment remained flat year-over-year, with a slight month-on-month decline—usually an early caution sign, especially when national data is missing due to a shutdown.
- Woods describes “a tale of two economies”:
- Growth persists in some Las Vegas and Nevada sectors, but visitor traffic and Strip activity has notably quieted over the last six months. (03:49)
- “We finished pretty strong last year with 41.6 million visitors...But this year it seems like that’s kind of switched a bit...It was pretty quiet if you were walking around on the Strip compared to years past.”
— Andrew Woods (03:49)
4. What Does “Flat” Employment Mean?
- Labor market dynamics:
- Businesses are no longer laying off en masse but are also hesitant to hire, creating a “frozen job market.”
- Post-pandemic hiring rush has slowed, and companies are being far pickier due to uncertainty about consumer strength.
- “I’m not laying off people, but I’m not trying to grow either. Right now I’m trying to build a moat and protect my business and protect my profit margin.”
— Andrew Woods (05:59)
- Comparison with workforce surveys:
- Employees find it tougher to get jobs while businesses report difficulty finding the right skills, likely due to selective hiring amid uncertainty. (04:59–05:59)
5. Interpreting the Signal: Economy in Limbo
- Split consumer base: High-end vs. budget traveler
- Wealthy, “price-insensitive” consumers continue travelling and spending robustly, while budget travelers are pulling back or seeking better value.
“If you look at private jets coming to Vegas, it’s even with last year...but the weekend warrior, that impulsive traveler...they’re not necessarily coming to Vegas.”
— Andrew Woods (06:54)
- “This weird dichotomy in the economy right now. Are we growing or are we slowing? Right. And you can pick your number and it feeds kind of whatever your narrative is.”
— Andrew Woods (07:47)
- Uncertainty and mixed signals dominate:
Both national and Nevada data, consumed selectively, can reinforce either optimism or pessimism.
6. Potential Weaknesses in Using Nevada as a Predictor
- Alternative factors muddying the water:
- Shrinking labor force participation may be linked to migration, demographics, or lingering pandemic shifts.
- Increased automation is changing the employment footprint—from casino gaming to bars; reliance on technology is advancing especially among lower-end establishments.
“You already see [automation] in bars. Nice bars will have really nice bartenders, but if you just want a drink on the floor...it’s made by a machine in the back.”
— Andrew Woods (09:05)
7. Looking Ahead: Stagnation Rather than Recession?
- Woods on recession risk:
- He foresees slow growth and specific sectors facing more shocks, with Nevada itself likely stagnant rather than sharply declining.
“I think we’re going to muddle through this. My thinking is that growth will be slow...Vegas itself will struggle for another year or two to meet what we met last year. That doesn’t mean that we’re decreasing. It just means we’ll be stagnant.”
— Andrew Woods (10:25)
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On backward-looking official data:
“Most economic indicators that you get from the government are pretty backward looking. It’s old news already...”
— Spencer Jacob (01:13)
-
On the unique structure of Nevada’s economy:
“One in five jobs across the entire state are tied to leisure and hospitality. And we entertain between 40 to 42 million visitors a year.”
— Andrew Woods (02:56)
-
On mixed economic signals:
“Weird dichotomy...Are we growing or are we slowing?...We’re getting both numbers and we’re getting both narratives.”
— Andrew Woods (07:47)
-
On keeping existing staff amid uncertainty:
“I’m not laying off people, but I’m not trying to grow either. Right now I’m trying to build a moat and protect my business and protect my profit margin.”
— Andrew Woods (05:59)
-
On automation in Vegas—future of work:
“You already see [automation] in bars...That drink isn’t made by a bartender. Most of the time it’s made by a machine in the back.”
— Andrew Woods (09:05)
-
On the outlook for recession:
“I think we’re going to muddle through this. My thinking is that growth will be slow...Vegas itself will struggle for another year or two...That doesn’t mean that we’re decreasing. It just means we’ll be stagnant.”
— Andrew Woods (10:25)
Timestamps for Key Segments
- 01:13 — Value and risk of alternative indicators (Spencer Jacob)
- 02:56 — Nevada’s economy: consumer spending and jobs breakdown (Andrew Woods)
- 03:49 — Anecdotal evidence: the vibe in Las Vegas and visitor trends
- 04:59 — Synchronization of Nevada and national economies; flat job growth explained
- 05:59 — What “flat” employment means, business behavior during uncertainty
- 06:54 — Divergence between high-end and budget consumers
- 09:05 — Role of immigration and automation in labor force shifts
- 10:25 — Woods’ “Vegas bet” on whether a recession is coming
Conclusion
This episode sets the stage for a nuanced look at alternative economic data, using Nevada’s unique, tourism-driven economy as a possible barometer for national trends. While the state’s employment patterns often foreshadow turning points for the broader economy, experts urge caution and context: shifts in demographics, automation, and consumer segmentation may be starting to cloud the once-clear connection. Woods ultimately forecasts stagnation rather than a sharp recession—echoing the theme of persistent economic uncertainty in 2025.