Boycott Over Diversity Dents Target’s Sales

Summary

WSJ What’s News Podcast Summary Episode: Boycott Over Diversity Dents Target’s Sales
Release Date: May 21, 2025
Host: Alex Osola

---

1. Target’s First Quarter Slump Amid Diversity Policy Backlash

Overview:
Target Inc. reported underwhelming first-quarter results, marking a significant 3.8% decline in comparable sales for the three months ended May 3. This downturn surpassed analysts' expectations and prompted the company to revise its fiscal year forecast downward.

Key Factors Affecting Sales:

• Macroeconomic Environment: Weak consumer confidence and reduced spending on discretionary items.
• Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Policy Changes: Implemented earlier in the year, these changes sparked nationwide boycotts, contributing to decreased store traffic and sales.

Notable Insights: Sarah Nassauer, a Wall Street Journal reporter covering large retailers, explained, “Target is sort of being hit by a multitude of things... as well as negative reaction to some of their DEI changes from earlier this year” [01:26].

Target’s Response: Target CEO Brian Cornell emphasized the company's commitment to DEI, stating, “Every day in everything we do, we will continue to be anchored in the belief that creating an environment where people feel included, supported and respected makes us a stronger company” [01:52].

Impact of DEI-Driven Boycotts: During the earnings call, Target acknowledged the boycotts as a factor dampening sales but refrained from quantifying their exact impact. Nassauer noted, “They talked about it as one of several factors that dampened sales and traffic to their stores... couldn’t really quantify how much the boycott versus other factors negatively impacted sales” [02:22].

Comparison with Other Retailers: While similar macroeconomic challenges faced companies like Home Depot and Walmart, Target's DEI-related issues appear more pronounced. Nassauer highlighted that Walmart benefited from its strong grocery segment and low-price strategy, which helped offset cautious consumer spending [02:55].

Future Outlook for Target: Target plans to reinforce its market position by focusing on trendy, affordable products and maintaining low prices despite the tariff environment. Nassauer shared, “Their approach is do more of what they have been doing, which is leaning into this idea of interesting new things and lowering prices” [03:43].

2. Boston Fed Economists Highlight Risks in Private Credit Growth

Overview:
Economists from the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston issued a cautionary report on the rapid expansion of the private credit sector, underscoring potential systemic risks associated with lending to increasingly riskier borrowers.

Interconnectedness of Private Credit Firms and Investment Banks: Isaac Taylor, Platform Editor at WSJ, detailed the symbiotic relationship: “banks lend money to those non-bank lenders... which in turn make loans to businesses... banks are indirectly funding the private credit industry's lending activities” [08:43].

Risks Identified:

• Increased Systemic Risk: As private credit firms extend loans to riskier borrowers, the financial system may accumulate vulnerabilities.
• Leverage and Borrower Resilience: Higher leverage in private lending could weaken borrowers' resilience, leading to market instability.

Boston Fed’s Concerns: Taylor explained, “if private credit lending is growing because these loans are being made to riskier borrowers, then it could lead to an accumulation of greater systemic risk and weaken the financial system” [09:37].

Mitigation Measures: The report does not prescribe specific solutions but emphasizes the need for market participants—banks and private credit firms—to develop strategies to address these vulnerabilities. Taylor noted, “the whole point of the report is really examining and highlighting the potential risk or vulnerabilities... leave it up to the market participants themselves to come up with solutions” [10:15].

3. Geopolitical Tensions: U.S. and South Africa Clash Over Genocide Claims

Overview:
A high-stakes meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump and South African President Cyril Ramaphosa in the Oval Office escalated tensions over Trump’s unsubstantiated claims of genocide targeting white South African farmers.

Key Developments:

• Trump’s Allegations: President Trump asserted that white South Africans are victims of genocide and accused the South African government of failing to protect them [05:47].
• Ramaphosa’s Counterpoints: President Ramaphosa refuted these claims, clarifying that criminal activities affecting farmers are not racially motivated. He stated, “People who do get killed, unfortunately, through criminal activity are not only white people. Majority of them are black people” [06:15].
• Public Rebuttals: An unnamed commentator highlighted the racial dynamics, stating, “The farmers are not black. I don't say that's good or bad, but the farmers are not black” [06:31].

U.S. Policy Shifts: Since taking office, Trump has implemented measures affecting South Africa, including:

• Cutting Foreign Aid: Suspension of aid to South Africa.
• Afrikaner Immigration: Invitation for Afrikaners, descendants of Dutch, German, and other settlers who speak Afrikaans, to immigrate to the U.S. as refugees with a fast-track path to citizenship. The first group arrived this month [06:38].

Military Developments: The Pentagon announced the acceptance of a $400 million luxury airliner from Qatar to serve as the new Air Force One. This decision has sparked security and ethics debates, especially since there are plans for the aircraft to be donated to the Trump Presidential Library post-presidency [07:00].

4. OpenAI’s Strategic Shift with Jony Ive’s Appointment

Overview:
OpenAI is undergoing a significant transformation by bringing on Jony Ive, former Chief Architect of the iPhone and co-founder of his design firm, to spearhead creative and design initiatives. This move signals OpenAI’s ambition to evolve into a more consumer-centric products company.

Role of Jony Ive: Jony Ive’s expertise will influence various aspects of OpenAI’s offerings, including future iterations of ChatGPT, audio features, and other applications. His involvement aims to enhance the user interface and overall product design, moving beyond the traditional screen-based interactions [11:01].

Insights from WSJ’s Tech News Briefing: Keech Hagee, a reporter covering technology, explained, “What you're really seeing is OpenAI is becoming a consumer products company... to really push things forward, it's going to be about the interfaces and that's why they brought on Jony” [11:34].

Implications for OpenAI:

• Product Innovation: Emphasis on creating intuitive and engaging user interfaces.
• Competitive Edge: Differentiating from competitors like Anthropic, Google, and Microsoft by focusing on design excellence.
• Future Developments: Potential introduction of new devices that transcend traditional screens, aligning with Ive’s vision [11:16].

---

Conclusion

This episode of WSJ What’s News delves into Target’s financial struggles amid diversity policy backlash, the Boston Fed’s concerns over the burgeoning private credit market, escalating geopolitical tensions between the U.S. and South Africa, and OpenAI’s strategic evolution with Jony Ive’s leadership. Through expert analysis and direct quotes, the podcast provides a comprehensive overview of these critical issues impacting business, finance, and global politics.

For more in-depth coverage, listeners are encouraged to explore the special two-episode series titled "Boycotting Target."

Produced by Pierre Bienname and supervised by Michael Cosmides.

Transcript

[Amazon Business Representative]

Free your team from time consuming tasks with Amazon Business. Our smart buying tools help leaders streamline purchasing and empower teams to focus on strategy and growth. Discover how to boost efficiency and support your team's future. @amazonbusiness.com.

[Alex Osola]

A boycott over Target's diversity policy dents the retailer's first quarter sales. Plus Boston Fed economists warn that the growth of private credit comes with risks.

[Isaac Taylor]

If private credit lending is growing because these loans are being made to riskier borrowers, then it could lead to an accumulation of greater systemic risk and weaken the financial system.

[Alex Osola]

And tensions flared between President Trump and the South African president over alleged claims of genocide of white South African farmers. It's Wednesday, May 21st. I'm Alex Osola for the Wall Street Journal.

[News Anchor]

This is the PM edition of what's.

[Alex Osola]

News, the top headlines and business stories that move the world today.

[News Anchor]

Target's troubles are mounting. The retail giant reported tepid first quarter results this morning.

[Alex Osola]

In a three months ended May 3, comparable sales fell 3.8%, a steeper drop than analysts expected. The company lowered its forecast for the fiscal year. Sarah Nassauer covers large retailers for the Wall Street Journal. Sarah, what happened here? What is affecting Target sales?

[Sarah Nassauer]

Target is sort of being hit by a multitude of things. They called out the overall macroeconomic environment, the weak consumer confidence, lower spending on discretionary items so like the things you want but might not need, as well as negative reaction to some of their DEI changes from earlier this year.

[Alex Osola]

About those DEI changes, Target CEO Brian.

[News Anchor]

Cornell alluded to them in this morning's earnings call.

[Target CEO Brian Cornell]

Every day in everything we do, we will continue to be anchored in the belief that creating an environment where people feel included, supported and respected makes us a stronger company. It helps us build and support our talented team, serve millions of guests in all 50 states, and be a valued partner in the communities we serve.

[Alex Osola]

So Sarah, some of the negative reaction to the DEI changes included a number of nationwide boycotts. How did the company talk about those during the earnings call?

[Sarah Nassauer]

They talked about it as one of several factors that dampened sales and traffic to their stores in the most recent quarter. They didn't really get into details beyond that, beyond saying that they couldn't really quantify how much the boycott versus other factors negatively impacted sales.

[Alex Osola]

So we've seen earnings come out this season from some other big retailers like Home Depot and Walmart. Are some of the issues that made Target sales fall also affecting these other places or is it really just unique to Target?

[Sarah Nassauer]

Yeah, some of the issues are definitely affecting other retailers, especially this idea that people continue to need to spend more on needs. Right? Groceries, prices have been elevated compared to pre Covid now for years and the tariff situation looks like it's adding to that to some extent. Walmart, Home Depot both called out the fact that people continue to spend pretty cautiously on discretionary items. However, both Walmart and Home Depot reported a sales lift and in Walmart's case a pretty strong sales lift. That's in part because Walmart sells a lot of groceries and a lot of groceries that are less expensive than other places and they're known for low prices and that's a real draw in this environment. But there's also some things that Target flagged and that analysts and others have flagged that are also self inflicted at Target.

[Alex Osola]

Target did lower its forecast for this fiscal year. What does the future look like for them?

[Sarah Nassauer]

They have talked a lot about leaning further into their Target image, which really is the idea that you can get trendy things that aren't that expensive there and having a lot of new and exciting products thinking about prices. They already talked about the tariff environment and that their goal is to keep prices as low as possible and not raise prices if they can and mitigate it other ways. Their approach is do more of what they have been doing, which is leaning into this idea of interesting new things and lowering prices.

[Alex Osola]

That was WSJ reporter Sarah Nassauer. Thank you, Sarah.

[Sarah Nassauer]

Thank you.

[News Anchor]

And you can hear more about Target's.

[Alex Osola]

Rollback of DEI policies and the impact of consumers boycotts on the company and the black entrepreneurs with on Target's shelves in our special two episode series Boycotting Target.

[News Anchor]

We'll leave a link to the series in the show.

[Alex Osola]

Notes.

[News Anchor]

Stocks finished lower today after a disappointing treasury bond auction accelerated a sell.

[Alex Osola]

Off in the debt market. The Nasdaq dipped about 1.4%, the S&P 500 dropped roughly 1.6% and the Dow.

[News Anchor]

Fell more than 800 points or 1.9%. Top Republicans pushed for a quick vote on President Trump's multi trillion dollar fiscal.

[Alex Osola]

Package today as negotiators raced to find.

[News Anchor]

The right combination of tax breaks and.

[Alex Osola]

Spending cuts to please warring wings of the party.

[News Anchor]

Passage would mean a major win for.

[Alex Osola]

Trump, marking a step towards extending tax.

[News Anchor]

Cuts and cementing other conservative priorities.

[Alex Osola]

But the fate of the measure is.

[News Anchor]

Still still up in the air.

[Alex Osola]

This afternoon, some holdouts warned that the.

[News Anchor]

Legislation was unlikely to cross the finish.

[Alex Osola]

Line by House leaders. Target of later today, as House Speaker Mike Johnson was leaving for an afternoon.

[News Anchor]

Meeting at the White House, he said that the bill was moving along on.

[Alex Osola]

Schedule and that he was optimistic. South African President Cyril Ramaphosa came to.

[News Anchor]

Washington seeking what he called a reset.

[Alex Osola]

In relations with the U.S. but his.

[News Anchor]

Meeting with President Trump in the Oval Office today devolved into a tense exchange.

[Alex Osola]

Over perceived threats to white farmers in South Africa. During a lengthy back and forth in.

[News Anchor]

Front of television cameras, Trump repeatedly made unsubstantiated claims that white South Africans were the victims of genocide, and he alleged.

[Alex Osola]

That the country's government wasn't doing enough to protect them. Rimafosa pushed back against Trump's claims there.

[Cyril Ramaphosa]

Is criminality in our country. People who do get killed, unfortunately, through criminal activity are not only white people. Majority of them are black people and we have now been utilized.

[Unnamed Commentator]

The farmers are not black. I don't say that's good or bad, but the farmers are not black.

[News Anchor]

Since returning to office in January, Trump.

[Alex Osola]

Has cut off foreign aid to South Africa and invited Afrikaners, descendants of Dutch.

[News Anchor]

German and other settlers who speak the.

[Alex Osola]

Afrikaans language, to immigrate to the US as refugees and become fast track citizens. The first group of several dozen Afrikaners arrived for resettlement this month.

[News Anchor]

The Pentagon said today that it had formally accepted a donated $400 million luxury.

[Alex Osola]

Airliner from Qatar that President Trump has.

[News Anchor]

Said will serve as Air Force One. The decision to accept a donated commercial.

[Alex Osola]

Aircraft has raised security and ethics questions.

[News Anchor]

Since Trump disclosed the offer last week to during his trip to the Middle.

[Alex Osola]

East, the administration has said the plane.

[News Anchor]

Would go to the Trump Presidential Library.

[Alex Osola]

At the end of his term. Coming up, why economists from the Boston Fed warn that private credit growth comes with risks to the financial system? That's after the break.

[Lowe's Advertiser]

Lowe's knows that no matter your paint or stain project, saving is at the top of your to do list. Save now with Buy one, get one half off select paint stains and primers from top brands like Valspar, hgtv, Home by Sherwin Williams and Cabot via Visa gift card rebate Find more Memorial Day deals now at Lowe's we help you save. Selection varies by location while supplies last discount taken at time of purchase. See Sales Associate for details. Offer valid 515 through 528.

[News Anchor]

As we've.

[Alex Osola]

Talked about before on the show, the private credit industry has expanded quickly. That's in part thanks to investment banks financing the private credit firms, who in.

[News Anchor]

Turn make loans to riskier borrowers.

[Alex Osola]

Now in a new report out today, economists at the Federal Reserve bank of Boston have examined the potential risks of this non bank lending. For more, I'm joined by Platform editor Isaac Taylor. Isaac, break down for me the relationship between private credit firms and investment banks.

[Isaac Taylor]

The relationship between private credit firms and investment banks is characterized by increasing interconnectivity. Specifically, banks lend money to those non bank lenders, including the firms and business development companies themselves, which in turn make loans to businesses. This means banks are indirectly funding the private credit industry's lending activities.

[Alex Osola]

I heard someone characterize this as a symbiotic relationship. Is that right? Like they both kind of lift each other up?

[Isaac Taylor]

It could definitely be characterized in that way. In some instances they do compete against each other for deals, but oftentimes with private funds, they will collect capital from institutional investors like pension funds or endowments. And until that capital actually comes in, sometimes they will borrow from banks to go ahead and get that capital working.

[Alex Osola]

Okay, so what about this is the Boston Fed saying is risky?

[Isaac Taylor]

The Boston Fed economists are saying that this relationship is risky because banks could be indirectly exposed to the higher risk taken on by private credit lenders. These private credit firms will often lend to riskier borrowers that banks just don't have the risk appetite to lend to. And the concern is that if private credit lending is growing because these loans are being made to riskier borrowers, then it could lead to an accumulation of greater systemic risk and weaken the financial system.

[Alex Osola]

So so far that hasn't really happened.

[News Anchor]

But if there's a potential systemic risk.

[Alex Osola]

From those loans, does the report offer.

[News Anchor]

Any solutions to mitigate that?

[Isaac Taylor]

Even in this report from the Boston Fed, they do lay out arguments for it and also against it. They do believe that there are clear vulnerabilities if private credit growth is driven by lending to riskier and riskier borrowers, and if private lenders use more leverage, it could weaken borrower resilience and leads to instability in the markets. The whole point of the report is really examining and highlighting the potential risk or vulnerabilities, as they say, and really leave it up to the market participants themselves, the banks, the private credit firms to really come up with solutions.

[Alex Osola]

That was WSJ platform editor Isaac Taylor. Thank you Isaac.

[Isaac Taylor]

I appreciate it. Thank you.

[News Anchor]

And Jony, I've a chief architect of.

[Alex Osola]

The iPhone and his design firm are.

[News Anchor]

Taking over creative and design control at.

[Alex Osola]

OpenAI according to people familiar with the matter.

[News Anchor]

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman and I've's design.

[Alex Osola]

Firm Love from have been working on.

[News Anchor]

A new device that will move consumers beyond screens.

[Alex Osola]

The people said that the former Apple Employee's work at OpenAI will extend across the company's ventures from future versions of ChatGPT to audio features, its app and other products.

[News Anchor]

Reporter Keech Hagee told our Tech News.

[Alex Osola]

Briefing podcast what this move means for the future of OpenAI.

[Keech Hagee]

What you're really seeing is OpenAI is becoming a consumer products company. Not exclusively, but that's clearly where the energy is right now. They're always going to be working on these LLM that are going to be powering things, but that is becoming increasingly commodified. They have a lot of competitors, anthropic, Google, even Microsoft, their partners, a competitor in some ways. And to really push things forward, it's going to be about the interfaces and that's why they brought on Jony.

[Alex Osola]

I've and you can hear more from Keech on tomorrow's episode of tech news briefing.

[News Anchor]

OpenAI has a content licensing deal with.

[Alex Osola]

The Wall Street Journal's parent company, News Corp. And that's what's news for this Wednesday afternoon. Today's show is produced by Pierre Bienname.

[News Anchor]

With supervising producer Michael Cosmides.

[Alex Osola]

I'm Alex Osulla for the Wall Street Journal. We'll be back with a new show tomorrow morning. Thanks for listening.