Loading summary
Transcript39 lines
- [00:00]
Oracle Representative
AI requires a lot of compute power and the cost for your AI workloads can spiral. That is, unless you're running on oci Oracle Cloud Infrastructure this was the cloud built for AI, a blazing, fast, enterprise grade platform for your infrastructure, database, apps and all of your AI workloads.
- [00:16]
Oracle Advertiser
Right now, Oracle can cut your current cloud bill in half if you move to OCI. Minimum financial commitment and other terms apply. Offer ends March 31. See if you qualify@oracle.com Wall Street Oracle.com.
- [00:29]
Journalist
Wallstreet if you were sitting in Beijing right now and you were looking at a global dashboard of China's overseas infrastructure project portfolio, you would see a lot of flashing red lights.
- [00:44]
Bradley Parks
That is Bradley Parks, the executive director of AidData, the development research lab at William and Mary's Global Research Institute that tracks how much China spends on its Belt and Road infrastructure program. In the early years of Belt and Road, China went on a spending spree in pursuit of its economic and strategic goals, financing bold engineering projects from mines and highways to ports and pipelines, in addition to growing its influence around the globe. But as the Journal's chief China correspondent Ling Lingwei pointed out at the end of the first episode in this special what's News Sunday series, those loans that China handed out to developing countries around the world weren't free money. Eventually, the debt would have to be repaid, and when it started coming due, signs of strain began to show. I'm Luke Vargas for the Wall Street Journal, and in today's episode, my colleague Kate Bullivant will be taking a look at how Beijing is trying to dig itself out from the financial hole it created in the Belt and Road's early years and shield itself from risks going forward, all while keeping the wheels turning on its goal of building up its influence around the globe.
- [01:55]
Kate Bullivant
Here's Kate When China started Belt and road back in 2013, its economy was growing fast, expanding by nearly 8% that year. That made it easy for Beijing to lavish investments on a wide range of large infrastructure projects. Since then, China's faced a lot of challenges the COVID 19 pandemic, the meltdown of its property sector, mounting local government debt, even public frustration about Beijing's decision to channel investments abroad when there were still needs at home. As we heard last week, China's Belt and Road investments started to drop off in 2018, and even today, its overseas lending remains a lot lower than its peak, though it is still around $80 billion a year. Brad Parks from Aidata says China is still nursing a hangover from the excesses of the program's first years, Beijing went.
- [02:53]
Journalist
On a lending spree and now its borrowers are having difficulty repaying their debts. So 80% of China's overseas lending portfolio is currently supporting countries in financial distress. And with the grace periods on many Chinese loans expiring, Beijing now finds itself in an uncomfortable position as the developing world's largest official debt collector. So I mean, here's the thing. Beijing is not going to stand by and watch its flagship global infrastructure initiative create crash and burn. The Chinese authorities have already launched a far reaching effort to de risk bell and road and they call it BRI 2.0. Beijing is scanning its global portfolio and firefighting in response to crises. So it's refocusing its time and its money on distressed borrowers, on troubled projects and on sources of public backlash. But at the same time, it's playing the long game. It's putting in place new safeguards to future proof the bri and it's making course corrections that address three different types of risk in its portfolio. Repayment risk, project performance risk, and then finally reputational risk.
- [04:13]
Kate Bullivant
So what's China doing to cut down on risk? For starters, let's look at who's doing the lending. Remember how we said in episode one that in the early years of the program, Chinese development banks were spraying money across the world to open new markets? Well, state backed commercial banks are doing a lot more of the financing these days and they're spreading the risk around by teaming up with other lenders to underwrite loans, a practice called syndicated lending.
- [04:43]
Journalist
We're increasingly seeing Western commercial banks, Deutsche Bank, ING Bank, HSBC participating in these larger loan syndicates with Chinese banks, as well as multilateral institutions like European bank for Reconstruction and Development in London. So yes, syndicated lending is becoming a feature rather than a bug. In Beldham Road 2.0, about 50% of the project loan portfolio is now occurring through syndicates.
- [05:15]
Kate Bullivant
Beyond the partners involved, the terms of the loans themselves have changed. Beijing's been lending on commercial terms from the start, but now the interest rates of those loans are getting higher. They average 4.2% according to aid data, which is significantly higher than competitors. Meanwhile, the repayment periods are getting shorter and China's putting extra safeguards in place to make sure it won't be stuck with unsustainable debt, effectively passing on more of the risk to poor countries.
- [05:47]
Journalist
The so called good borrowers are not governments, you know, because there's so much debt distress in the developing world. So what's happening is big Chinese state owned companies are first, first securing loans from Chinese state owned commercial banks. Then they're saying, I'm going to issue a subsidiary loan to the government of Nicaragua as an example. And so when the company essentially becomes the bank, they want extra protections in place, they're doubling up or tripling up on safeguards. And they're saying, look, cash collateral is not enough. I need that, plus I need you, the borrower, to buy a credit insurance policy. And that additional credit insurance policy might be worth 5 to 7% of the nominal value of the loan. Right. So the price of debt is going up for borrowers in the developing world.
- [06:42]
Kate Bullivant
So China is becoming more careful with its money, but what is it actually investing in now? And have efforts to shield itself from risks linked to the Belt and Road paid off? We'll look into that after the break.
- [07:00]
Oracle Representative
Okay, business leaders, are you here to play or are you playing to win? If you're in it to win, meet your next mvp. Netsuite by Oracle netsuite is your full business management system in one convenient suite. With NetSuite, you're running your accounting, your finance, your HR, your e commerce and more, all from your online dashboard. Upgrade your playbook and make the switch to NetSuite, the number one cloud ERP.
- [07:23]
Oracle Advertiser
Get the CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at netsuite.com Wall street netsuite.com Wall Street.
- [07:36]
Kate Bullivant
As China continues to adapt the Belt and Road, the types of projects it's investing in are changing too. In recent years, Beijing has been keen to highlight a shift away from massive infrastructure projects. All those dams, ports and highways at the center of belt and Road 1.0 and instead is touting what it small and beautiful builds like solar and wind power facilities.
- [07:59]
Oracle Advertiser
Southeast Asia's green revolution has been driven by innovative Chinese technology and projects.
- [08:05]
Kate Bullivant
Construction of another solar plant is also underway, this time with the support from China.
- [08:11]
Oracle Advertiser
Chinese company Haui recently opened an experimentation center in Sao Paulo, an investment of about $6.5 million, to showcase its technology.
- [08:19]
Kate Bullivant
Brad Parks from AidData told me that while Beijing hasn't abandoned traditional larger scale projects, this rebrand is an answ Beijing's evolving needs.
- [08:29]
Journalist
We are seeing a marked shift towards projects that are focused on the extraction and export of a small set of critical minerals that are necessary to fuel the clean energy transition. So we're talking about copper, cobalt, lithium, rare earth minerals and a couple of others. So that is a key feature of belt and Road 2.0. And Chinese companies are also trying to gobble up market share in a variety of renewable energy sectors, whether that's solar, wind, hydro, there's a concerted effort by the banks and the companies to cement the competitiveness of Chinese companies around the globe in these clean energy sectors.
- [09:23]
Kate Bullivant
Those sorts of course corrections help the Belt and Road program invest in the industries and supply chains that Beijing sees as the future. And as we heard before the break, China has changed the way it cuts deals, charging higher rates and asking countries to put up more collateral.
- [09:41]
Journalist
They have also tried to muscle their way to the front of the repayment line by requiring something that their competitors do not require, and that is that governments keep cash collateral in lender controlled escrow accounts that Beijing can unilaterally debit with a keystroke. Right. They could just grab that cash and pay themselves in the event of default.
- [10:07]
Kate Bullivant
But as we talked about last week, China isn't for the most part going around the world grabbing collateral from countries that are struggling to repay their debts. So does this mean that China's portfolio is out of the woods? Could Beijing actually be about to reap a financial windfall as those loans start getting repaid? Here's what Brad had to say.
- [10:27]
Journalist
So on paper, I would say that China appears to be well positioned to reap a big windfall. But I think in practice, the likelihood that it's going to play out the way that they think it's going to play out is not quite that high. When China first got into the emergency rescue lending business, it was operating under the optimistic assumption that some of its biggest borrowers needed short term bridge financing to weather a storm that would soon pass. But I think it's now learning that some of its biggest belt and road borrowers are actually insolvent. I would say that they are still actively firefighting and they're going to be firefighting for many years to come. They're doing serial bailouts year after year. So ultimately, to get out of this, China may have to take financial losses. The big question for China is how quickly it will learn and adapt to what it's seeing in its portfolio.
- [11:32]
Kate Bullivant
We reached out to China's Ministry of Foreign affairs for comment on their debt portfolio. And how many of their borrowers are insolvent. They didn't address this specifically, but they did say they provide developing countries finance financing at preferential interest rates and with longer maturities. Up next, we take a look at how all these changes to Belt and Road set up Beijing to continue gathering global influence. That's after the break.
- [12:07]
Capella University Representative
Imagine what's possible when learning doesn't get in the way of life. At Capella University. Our game changing flexpath learning format lets you set your own deadline so you can learn at a time and pace that works for you. It's an education you can tailor to your schedule. That means you don't have to put your life on hold to pursue your professional goals. Instead, enjoy learning your way and earn your degree without missing a beat. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more at Capella Eduardo the jury.
- [12:44]
Kate Bullivant
Is still out on whether China will take an economic hit from the Belt and Road. But how do the changes to its signature lending project that we've been talking about support Beijing's strategic goals, especially when it comes to boosting China's standing on the world stage?
- [13:01]
Steve Tsang
The whole idea of BRI has been changed to serve a very clear, specific purpose, which is to support the three global initiatives Xi Jinping announced back in 2021, 22, 23.
- [13:15]
Kate Bullivant
That's Steve Tsang. He's the director at the SOAS China Institute, a leading research centre based in London. And those three initiatives he just mentioned are the Global Development Initiative, the Global Security Initiative and the Global Civilization Initiative.
- [13:31]
Steve Tsang
And the three global initiatives were introduced to support the even grander idea Xi Jinping had to forge a common destiny for humankind, primarily in the Global south countries.
- [13:45]
Kate Bullivant
In a nutshell, the three initiatives seek to position China as a partner to developing countries, largely in Africa, Asia and Latin America, often referred to as the Global South, a partner that nations wary of US Dominance can do business with and seek national security guarantees or energy, finance and food security.
- [14:09]
Steve Tsang
The BLI provides that additional material advantages to autocrats in the Global south to have the capacity to have some development projects which they cannot get from the imf, World bank or European countries, or for that matter the United States, because for those there are always conditionalities. BLI combined with the three global initiatives may well put China at the center, but still bring a lot of political advantages to the more autocratic leaders of countries in the Global South.
- [14:49]
Kate Bullivant
And Sang says this focus from Beijing on lower income countries is meant to make China nothing less than the world's number one power.
- [14:57]
Steve Tsang
The BLI is primarily intended for China to engage with the Global south and gain support in the Global south for China's wider agenda globally, including at the United Nations. So if China pushes for changes in the way the United nations operates in the name of the Global south, then it is much more difficult for the Inquisition maps elitist small democratic west to try to block it from doing so. The BLI has in fact increased in its geostrategic significance, even though its economic value to China has clearly declined.
- [15:42]
Kate Bullivant
China is spending less on Belt and Road loans today than it was a few years back, almost half what it did at the program's peak. But there's one more change we've seen from Beijing that supports its broader ambitions. It started issuing more debt in its own currency instead of in dollars.
- [16:03]
Steve Tsang
China does want the Chinese yuan to be more accepted as an international currency. There's a limit to what it can do. But reducing the significance of the dollar, increasing the importance of the yuan in global trade is something which is in line with what Xi Jinping or China would like to do in terms of how to enhance China's global standing and reduce Chinese dependence on the United States.
- [16:36]
Kate Bullivant
Since the birth of Belt and road back in 2013, the geopolitical landscape has changed dramatically with both the start of the war in Ukraine and escalating conflict in the Middle East. Journal reporter Chun Han Wong covers Chinese politics and foreign policy. He told me that in this new world, China wants to present itself as an honest broker, a contrast to the US which it criticizes for prolonged and exacerbating conflict. By supplying arms in Ukraine and the.
- [17:06]
Chun Han Wong
Middle East, Xi Jinping is trying to present China as a benign, responsible, positive force in global affairs. The BRI actually supports this in the sense that they are bringing investments, they are bringing economic cooperation, they're bringing trade. They are the ones who help people develop, provide you with the tools, the expertise, the sort of global connections that are necessary for developing, whether it's green technologies or building connections between markets. That's the benign and positive force that China represents.
- [17:40]
Kate Bullivant
China's Foreign Ministry told us that the Belt and Road is an economic cooperation initiative, not a geopolitical tool, and that China provides financing to developing countries without attaching any political conditions. China's National Defense Research Committee and the State Council Information Office didn't respond to our request for comment for this episode. Despite the challenges, Beijing is showing no signs of giving up on Belt and Road. Quite the opposite. China is learning from its experience, and while it's had to rein in its spending, it's lending more cautiously in an effort to ensure that the program will continue to advance Xi Jinping's strategic goals for years to come.
- [18:27]
Bradley Parks
So what does Washington make of this more focused and streamlined version of the Belt and Road and the role it plays in challenging the US Led global order? And is the Trump administration prepared to respond to it? Those questions will be the focus of our next episode, the final one in this special series, but for now, that's it for what's News Sunday. Today's show was hosted and produced by Kate Bullivant. Our sound designers are Jessica Fenton and Michael Lavalle. Michael wrote this series'theme music. Our supervising producer was Christina Rocca. We had editorial support from Chris Sinsley and Falana Patterson. And special thanks to Jonathan Chang and James Arity. We will be back tomorrow with a new show. Until then, thanks for listening.