Google Must Sell Chrome Browser, DOJ Says

Summary

WSJ What’s News: Detailed Summary of "Google Must Sell Chrome Browser, DOJ Says" – November 21, 2024

Hosted by The Wall Street Journal

---

1. Department of Justice Targets Google in Antitrust Case

Overview: The episode opens with a significant update on the U.S. Department of Justice's (DOJ) antitrust case against Google. The DOJ has escalated its efforts to curb Google's dominance in the online search market by demanding structural and behavioral remedies.

Key Points:

• DOJ’s Demands: The DOJ has requested that Google divest its Chrome web browser, a move aimed at dismantling what it perceives as monopolistic control over the online search landscape. Additionally, the DOJ seeks to prevent Google from granting preferential access to its search engine on devices running its Android operating system. Should Google violate this rule, the DOJ proposes that the company should also be compelled to sell Android.

• Google’s Response: A Google executive criticized the DOJ's proposed remedies as "wildly overbroad," indicating the company's intention to present its own remedy plan in the upcoming month (02:37).

• Legal Proceedings: The antitrust trial is set to commence in April, with the presiding judge aiming to deliver a final decision by late 2024 or early 2025.

Notable Quote: Miles Krupa, Journal reporter in San Francisco, elaborates on the DOJ's strategy:

“The Department of Justice has been clear that it's seeking all possibilities here, structural remedies such as divestitures and more behavioral remedies... this is going to be a real test of how far antitrust laws can go in limiting the conduct of a large company like Google” (01:56).

Implications: This case is poised to set a precedent for antitrust enforcement in the tech industry, particularly concerning major platforms that dominate multiple facets of the digital ecosystem.

---

2. Adani Group Faces Bribery Allegations

Overview: The DOJ has also charged Gautam Adani, the billionaire founder of one of India's largest conglomerates, with orchestrating a $250 million bribery scheme aimed at securing advantageous solar energy contracts.

Key Points:

• Charges: Adani is accused of personally engaging with Indian officials to facilitate illicit deals, benefiting his companies with contracts worth billions. In total, eight executives have been charged.

• Company’s Stance: The Adani Group has vehemently denied the allegations, labeling them as baseless.

• Market Reaction: Following the announcement, shares of Adani Group companies experienced a sharp decline.

---

3. Russia’s Alleged Use of an Intercontinental Ballistic Missile in Ukraine

Overview: Ukraine has reported that Russia has launched an intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) targeting the city of Dnipro, marking a potential escalation in the ongoing conflict.

Key Points:

• Details of the Attack: According to Ukraine’s air force, the ICBM was part of a larger assault involving eight missiles, resulting in two casualties.

• Significance: ICBMs are typically equipped with nuclear warheads, and their use signals a significant intensification of Russia’s military tactics. This act serves as a stark reminder of Russia's nuclear capabilities, especially in the context of recent Ukrainian advancements using Western-supplied missiles against Russian targets.

---

4. Senate Rejects Bernie Sanders' Measures to Halt Arms Sales to Israel

Overview: On Capitol Hill, the Senate dismissed multiple proposals spearheaded by Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders aimed at restricting the sale of offensive weaponry to Israel.

Key Points:

• Legislative Outcome: The measures, which sought to block transfers of specific tanks, mortar rounds, and guidance kits for bombs, failed to secure sufficient support, passing with only 17 to 19 senators in favor.

• Senator Sanders' Commentary: Sanders emphasized the vote's broader implications for U.S. credibility, stating:

“How do you critique Iran for their terrible human rights record? How do you critique China or Russia for their terrible human rights records? ... people around the world will laugh at you” (04:44).

• Context: This political maneuver comes amidst the Biden administration's 30-day ultimatum for Israel to address humanitarian concerns in Gaza, which Israel has yet to fully meet.

---

5. Nvidia’s Financial Performance and Future Projections

Overview: Nvidia’s latest quarterly results revealed a slowdown in meeting investor expectations despite continuing robust sales and profits, leading to a slip in share prices during after-hours trading.

Key Points:

• Current Quarter Performance: While Nvidia reported another quarter of strong sales, the results fell short of investor projections, causing a decline in stock value.

• Future Outlook: Positive news emerged regarding the demand for Nvidia's next-generation AI chips, Blackwell. Customers including Microsoft, Google, Meta, and Xai have shown heightened interest, with projections indicating even higher revenue than previously anticipated (05:55).

Expert Insight: ASA Fitch from the Journal highlights:

“Blackwell... are set to do very well. They said they were expecting even better revenue from those chips than they had previously discussed” (05:55).

---

6. Elon Musk’s AI Startup Xai Secures $5 Billion in Funding

Overview: Elon Musk's artificial intelligence venture, Xai, has successfully raised $5 billion in its latest funding round, significantly increasing its valuation to approximately $50 billion.

Key Points:

• Investors Involved: Qatar's sovereign wealth fund, Valor Equity Partners, Sequoia Capital, and Andreessen Horowitz are among the notable participants.

• Utilization of Funds: Xai intends to allocate part of the capital to acquire an additional 100,000 Nvidia chips, essential for training advanced AI models.

---

7. Donald Trump’s Education Department Plans and Nomination of Linda McMahon

Overview: The episode delves into former President Donald Trump's proposals to overhaul the U.S. Education Department, coupled with his nomination of Linda McMahon as the new Education Secretary.

Key Points:

• Nomination Details: Trump announced Linda McMahon, co-founder of WWE, as his pick for Education Secretary. McMahon is a staunch Trump supporter, having served on his transition team and played a significant role in fundraising efforts.

• McMahon’s Educational Stance: She advocates for school choice, supporting alternatives to traditional public schooling such as charter schools, homeschooling, and private institutions. Additionally, she emphasizes tougher accountability and enhanced local oversight in education (08:20).

• Future of the Education Department: Trump has repeatedly stated his intention to dismantle the Education Department. Sarah Randazzo discusses the ambiguity surrounding whether this means merely restructuring or significantly reducing federal support to schools (09:07).

Notable Quote: Sarah Randazzo explains the potential impact of eliminating federal support:

“On average makes up about 10% budgets for K to 12 school districts... if you got rid of 10% of funding, school districts would have to scramble to find ways to meet those needs” (09:01).

Challenges:

• Congressional Support: Drastic changes to the Education Department would require substantial backing from Congress, making the complete dismantling of the department a complex and uncertain prospect (10:24).

• Curriculum Control: Trump's promise to combat the "WOKE curriculum" conflicts with federal limitations, as the government cannot directly dictate classroom content. This presents a significant challenge in implementing his educational agenda (10:55).

Conclusion: While Trump and McMahon may initiate discussions and start making incremental changes within the Education Department, a full-scale dissolution remains uncertain and contingent on legislative support.

---

Production Credits

The episode was produced by Kate Bullivant and Daniel Bach, with supervising producer Christina Rocca. Special thanks to Sarah Randazzo for her insights on educational policy.

---

For comprehensive coverage of daily business and political developments, tune into WSJ What’s News twice daily on weekdays, with extended analyses on Saturdays and Sundays.

Transcript

[Merrill]

This episode is brought to you by Merrill. Join one of the most iconic names in wealth management, Merrill. You'll be part of a dynamic team of advisors and specialists working hard every day to grow their clients wealth. And with the support of best in class research, advanced digital tools and the resources of a global institution, it's truly an opportunity you can be bullish about. Learn more@careers bankofamerica.com Copyright 2024 bank of America Corporation.

[Luke Vargas]

The DOJ says that Google should be forced to sell its Chrome web browser plus Nvidia's sales soar. But topping investor expectations for the company is becoming increasingly difficult and will go inside Donald Trump's push to eliminate the Education Department.

[Sarah Randazzo]

The question is, is he just going to eliminate a bureaucracy and send these functions to other agencies, or is he actually going to reduce federal support in a substantial way to schools?

[Luke Vargas]

It's Thursday, November 21st. I'm Luke Vargas for the Wall Street Journal, and here is the AM edition of what's the top headlines and business stories moving your world today. We begin with an update on the US Government's successful antitrust case against Google. The Department of Justice says Google should be forced to sell off its popular Chrome web browser as part of a suite of requested remedies that a told a judge are needed to fix the monopolization of the online search market. The DOJ also requested Google be prevented from giving preferential access to its search engine on the billions of devices that use its Android mobile operating system, and that if it was found to violate that rule, it should also be forced to sell Android. Journal reporter Miles Krupa in San Francisco reacted to the DOJ's requested remedies.

[Miles Krupa]

The Department of Justice has been clear that it's seeking all possibilities here, structural remedies such as divestitures and more behavioral remedies. And so in some ways it's not totally unexpected that they would ask for a divestiture of Chrome. But it's somewhat surprising in that the case really centered on Google's contracts with third parties, not its own self preferencing on the Chrome browser. So this is going to be a real test of how far antitrust laws can go in limiting the conduct of a large company like Google in the year 2024, or as it may be, 2025.

[Luke Vargas]

A Google executive described the DOJ's suggested remedy as wildly overbroad and said the company would file its own proposed remedy next month. A trial to decide how to address Google's antitrust violations is scheduled to begin in April, with the judge in the case saying he plans to finalize his decision by well Also in the DOJ's crosshairs is Gautam Adani, the billionaire founder of one of India's biggest conglomerates who was charged yesterday with orchestrating a $250 million bribery scheme to secure lucrative solar energy supply contracts. Prosecutors allege the executive personally met with Indian officials to advance the illicit deal and secure contracts worth billions of dollars for one of his companies, and that he and others misrepresented the company's anti bribery and corruption pract US Investors and financial institutions. Eight executives have been charged in total. In a statement, the Adani Group denied the allegations, calling them baseless. Shares in Adani Group companies fell sharply on the news today. Ukraine says Russia has fired an intercontinental ballistic missile targeting the city of Dnipro, which if confirmed, would be the first time Moscow has used an ICBM in the war. According to Ukraine's air force, the ICBM was fired along with eight other missiles in an attack that local authorities say wounded two people. ICBMs are designed to carry nuclear warheads and their use would mark a sharp escalation in the war as well as a reminder of Russia's nuclear capability just days after Ukrainian forces began using newly authorized Western missiles to hit targets inside Russia. On Capitol Hill, the Senate has rejected multiple efforts by Vermont's Bernie Sanders to stop the sale of offensive weapons to Israel, with only 17 to 19 senators backing measures that would have prevented the transfer of certain tank and mortar rounds and guidance kits attached to bombs. Speaking before the votes, Sanders described them as a test of America's credibility on the world stage.

[Bernie Sanders]

How do you critique Iran for their terrible human rights record? How do you critique China or Russia for their terrible human rights records? Because if you get here on the floor of the Senate and you make that critique, people around the world will laugh at you.

[Luke Vargas]

Sanders push comes after the Biden administration led a 30 day deadline for Israel to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza come and go. The administration previously warned Israel it risked a cut to arms sales if it failed to reverse what it called the downward humanitarian trajectory in the territory. Nvidia's shares are slipping in off hours trading after its results. Another quarter of surging sales and profits failed to meet the lofty expectations of investors who've been piling into the stock. However, Nvidia's revenue projections for the current quarter suggest that its next generation AI chips known as Blackwell, are in high demand from customers like Microsoft, Google, Meta and Xai. ASA Fitch covers Nvidia for the Journal.

[ASA Fitch]

Nvidia had had some issues manufacturing those chips in its previous quarter, and it took a significant amount of charges, in fact, more than $900 million of charges in this last quarter because of that. But this time around, if anything, the company projected that Blackwell, its next generation chips, were set to do very well. They said they were expecting even better revenue from those chips than they had previously discussed. They previously talked about several billion dollars of revenue in the current quarter. That's going to end in January here. So now they're saying that things are looking even better than they thought before.

[Luke Vargas]

And in other Markets, News Elon Musk's artificial intelligence startup Xai has told investors that it raised $5 billion in its latest funding round, valuing the company at about $50 billion, more than twice what it was valued at several months ago. According to our reporting, Qatar's sovereign wealth fund and investment firm's Valor Equity partners, Sequoia Capital and Andreessen Horowitz are expected to take part. XAI plans to use the new cash in part to finance the purchase of 100,000 additional Nvidia chips for training AI models. Coming up, Journal education reporter Sarah Randazzo joins us to explain what Donald Trump's selection of Linda McMahon tells us about his plans for the Education Department. That's after the break.

[Walmart]

Want to shop Walmart Black Friday deals first? Walmart plus members get early access to our hottest deals. Join now and get 50% off a one year annual membership. Shop Black Friday deals first with Walmart + see [e-mail].

[Luke Vargas]

Donald Trump said this week that, quote, we will send education back to the states and Linda will spearhead that effort. The Linda Trump is referring to is Linda McMahon, whom he's nominating for education secretary, overseeing a department that the president elect has vowed to dismantle. And to find out more about those plans, our Kate Bullivant spoke to Journal education reporter Sara Randazzo.

[Kate Bullivant]

So, Sarah, let's start with Trump's pick for education secretary. Linda McMahon is probably most well known for being the co founder of WWE World Wrestling Entertainment. But could you tell us a little bit more about her and her views on education?

[Sarah Randazzo]

So she was definitely a surprise pick in education circles. But what Linda McMahon is is a real Trump loyalist. She's served on the transition team. She's helped raise tons of money for him and fundraise. And so she's someone who's close to the president and had been widely seen as the leading contender for the commerce secretary job. So when that position went elsewhere. Some are seeing this as a bit of a consolation prize, I suppose. But she does have a little bit of education we could find in her background. She supports school choice, which is a bit of a euphemism for supporting options away from the traditional public schools, such as going to charter school or maybe homeschooling or private school or options like that. And also she supports tougher accountability and local oversight in education.

[Kate Bullivant]

So what does Trump's pick for Education secretary tell us about his plans for the department?

[Sarah Randazzo]

Yeah, it's hard to tell how Linda McMahon's choice in particular impacts this, but on the campaign trail, Trump repeatedly said he would get rid of the Education Department. And there's been a lot of speculation on what that would mean and how he would do it. The big question is whether by dismantling the department, he would act, actually shut down the programs and supports that it provides for schools. Some of the big ones are money that the Education Department helps oversee, that it sends to schools with low income students and students with disabilities. And so the question is, is he just going to eliminate a bureaucracy and send these functions to other agencies, or is he actually going to reduce federal support in a substantial way to schools? Really, the majority of education is run locally through local and state dollars. A lot of it is tax dollars and other money. The federal money, on an average makes up about 10% budgets for K to 12 school districts. It varies by state. Interestingly, we did the math in the 14 states who get the largest proportion of their education budget from the federal government, all voted for Trump this term. And so it's not the majority of a budget, but if you got rid of 10% of funding, school districts would have to scramble to find ways to meet those needs.

[Kate Bullivant]

So with that in mind, are Trump and McMahon likely to actually shut down the Education Department?

[Sarah Randazzo]

You know, I'm not in the prediction business, so I don't want to say, but there will definitely be discussions about it. There's probably steps they could take immediately on their own. I don't know if that would be a reduction in workforce, something like that, but to actually fundamentally change the department and get rid of it would take quite a bit of support from Congress. So it remains to be seen whether that can be achieved.

[Kate Bullivant]

Another thing Trump has promised to do is to fight the so called WOKE curriculum, meaning left wing ideology in schools and universities. How would he go about doing this?

[Sarah Randazzo]

Yeah, this is one of the contradictions in what the President elect has said about the Education Department, because the federal government really can't by law, they really cannot dictate what shows up in individual classrooms across the country. And so at the same time that he says he wants to get rid of what curriculum that isn't really a function that the federal government could do, at least under our current system.

[Kate Bullivant]

That was Journal education reporter Sarah Randazzo. Sarah, thanks so much for your time.

[Sarah Randazzo]

Sure thing. Thanks.

[Luke Vargas]

And that's it for what's news for Thursday morning. Today's show was produced by Kate Bullivant and Daniel Bach, with supervising producer Christina Rocca. And I'm Luke Vargas for the Wall Street Journal. We will be back tonight with a new show. Until then, thanks for listening.