The Art of the Peace Deal

Summary

---

WSJ What’s News: “The Art of the Peace Deal”

Date: October 10, 2025
Host: Kate Bullivant (The Wall Street Journal)

---

Main Theme

This episode dives into President Trump's surprising diplomatic breakthrough in brokering a peace deal between Israel and Hamas, which marked a major shift in Middle East politics. Additional segments cover domestic legal battles over National Guard deployment, early signs of economic distress among American car owners, internal Republican tensions over renewable energy in Iowa, and the announcement of the Nobel Peace Prize. The tone is brisk, informative, and tightly focused on breaking developments.

---

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Trump’s Middle East Diplomatic Breakthrough

[00:17 – 06:16]

• Major development: Israel has approved a US-brokered agreement with Hamas, paving the way to free hostages and establish a ceasefire in Gaza.
• Netanyahu’s Statement: Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu publicly credited Trump, Steve Witkoff, and Jared Kushner for making the deal possible.
  • Quote: "We couldn't have achieved it without the extraordinary help of President Trump and his team, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner." (Goldman Sachs Markets Podcast Host, 01:37)
• Deal’s Immediate Steps:
  • Israeli forces are set to withdraw from parts of Gaza, with a ceasefire to follow almost immediately.
  • Early next week: prisoner and hostage exchange, including 20 living Israeli hostages and some bodies of deceased (total of 48, but not all due to Hamas' uncertainties about locations).
  • The deal was rushed; many contentious issues, like Gaza’s future governance and demilitarization, remain unresolved.
• Unique Approach:
  • Trump’s diplomatic style involved “declaring victory” before many details were finalized, creating public and political pressure for parties to follow his lead.
  • Quote: "He really turned kind of classic diplomacy on its head... He basically declared victory first... daring, like, say no to me after he had announced it." (Anat Peled, 04:14-04:41)
  • Trump pressured both Netanyahu and Hamas (the latter via regional Arab and Muslim states: Qatar, Egypt, Turkey), forcing momentum even if details were lacking.
• Next Challenges:
  • Stage two (demilitarization, international governance) is unresolved. Notably, a "board of peace" possibly chaired by Tony Blair is proposed.
  • Ongoing risk: whether Trump will sustain engagement to push through the hardest parts.

Notable Quote:

• “A lot of the more tricky issues were not even touched... the demilitarization of Gaza and international governance of Gaza, so that, all of those things are kind of explosive issues.” (Anat Peled, 02:57)

2. US Forces' Role in Israel and Gaza Ceasefire

[03:25 – 03:58]

• US Central Command is leading an international stabilization force, setting up a civil-military coordination center in Israel.
• Main goals: monitor the ceasefire, manage transition to civilian rule in Gaza, and facilitate humanitarian aid.

---

3. National Guard Deployment Blocked in Chicago

[06:16 – 07:30]

• Federal judge blocked President Trump’s National Guard deployment to Illinois for at least two weeks, citing potential civil unrest.
• Over 500 troops had already been sent; Illinois governor welcomed the ruling while the White House remained silent.
• Context: Part of a broader pattern of federal and state-level conflict over emergency powers.

---

4. Government Shutdown and Health Care Funding

[07:30 – 08:30]

• Ongoing government shutdown has both parties debating how to extend ACA (Obamacare) subsidies with new income caps.
• Debate centers on whether to limit aid to families earning $200,000 or less, rather than having an uncapped benefit.
• The Senate is adjourned until Tuesday; the shutdown is likely to continue, delaying essential reporting (e.g., September’s Consumer Price Index).

---

5. Justice Department Indicts New York Attorney General

[08:30 – 09:01]

• Letitia James, NY Attorney General, indicted for bank fraud and false statements—a notable reflection of the Trump administration’s efforts to retaliate against officials from Trump’s earlier terms.
• The charges are linked to mortgage fraud allegations, with James denying wrongdoing and set for court on October 24.

---

6. Subprime Auto Loan Delinquencies on the Rise

[09:30 – 10:55]

• Subprime auto loan delinquencies hit record highs; 1.73 million vehicles repossessed last year (most since 2009).
• Economists see this as a clear sign of growing economic stress among lower-income Americans, with inflation and unemployment worsening.
• Quote: "Economists and analysts generally consider auto loans to be among the last things to falter among borrowers... You'll continue to pay your car loan because you need your car. So it is a specific sign of distress that we're seeing higher delinquencies." (Ben Glickman, 10:15-10:47)

---

7. Trump and Republican Tensions over Renewable Energy

[10:55 – 12:01]

• Trump administration’s hostility toward wind power is creating pushback in Iowa, where wind is a huge employer and keeps power prices low (59% of state’s electricity in 2023).
• Offshore wind projects have been stalled; the administration threatens to make federal permitting more difficult, risking investment and jobs.
• While Trump supports Iowa’s biofuels, he remains adamantly anti-wind.
  • Quote: “Any time you see a windmill, you’ll say they have bad energy costs.” (Trump, cited by Kate Bullivant, 12:01)

---

8. Nobel Peace Prize Awarded to Venezuelan Opposition Leader

[12:01 – 12:31]

• Maria Corinna Machado recognized for her ongoing fight for democracy in Venezuela, praised as a "brave and committed champion of peace."

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Trump’s diplomatic style:
  • “He basically declared victory first. He announced the deal first...daring, like, say no to me after he had announced it.” (Anat Peled, 04:14-04:41)
• On economic stress and auto loans:
  • “People might not pay back, you know, a loan on like a TV that you bought...but you’ll continue to pay your car loan because you need your car.” (Ben Glickman, 10:25)
• On Iowa’s wind power politics:
  • “Any time you see a windmill, you’ll say they have bad energy costs.” (Donald Trump, cited at 12:01)
• On unfinished parts of the peace plan:
  • “A lot of the more tricky issues were not even touched.” (Anat Peled, 02:57)

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [00:17] – Main headline: Peace deal brokered by Trump
• [02:09] – Ceasefire process and phases of the peace plan
• [03:25] – US troop deployment and role in Israel
• [04:14] – Trump’s negotiating tactics and challenges ahead
• [06:16] – National Guard deployment blocked in Illinois
• [07:30] – Government shutdown and ACA subsidy debate
• [08:30] – NY Attorney General Letitia James indicted
• [09:30] – Record subprime auto loan delinquencies and economic outlook
• [10:55] – Wind energy controversy in Iowa; Trump’s stance on renewables
• [12:01] – Nobel Peace Prize awarded to Maria Corinna Machado

---

Tone and Style

The episode is facts-first, with brisk back-and-forth commentary. Language is accessible but firmly anchored in Wall Street Journal’s even-handed, analytic tone, with journalistic neutrality and clarity.

---

Conclusion

This episode captures a dramatic shift in Middle Eastern diplomacy engineered by President Trump, highlighting the blend of brash tactics and unfinished business that characterize his foreign policy. Domestic segments underscore continued legal, economic, and energy sector tensions in the US—underscoring the complex, interlinked crises facing American and global audiences.

Transcript

[Viking Cruise Announcer]

Viking committed to exploring the world in comfort. Journey through the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship with thoughtful service, cultural enrichment and all inclusive fares. Discover [e-mail].

[Kate Bullivant]

President Trump's unorthodox diplomatic style helps broker a foreign policy victory between Israel and Hamas.

[Anat Peled]

So both sides were under immense pressure to get this done despite deep disagreements. And so what ended up happening is that as they were kind of trying to work this out, Trump declares victory.

[Kate Bullivant]

Plus, a federal judge blocks the deployment of the National Guard in Chicago. And Americans defaulting on car loans signals economic stress for lower income families. It's Friday, October 10th. I'm Kate Bullivant for the Wall Street Journal and here is the AM Edition of what's news, the top headlines and business stories moving your world today. We start in the Middle east where Israel has approved an agreement brokered by President Trump which puts the wheels in motion to free the remaining hostages held by Hamas and establish a ceasefire in Gaza. In a brief statement, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed the approval of the deal while thanking the president.

[Goldman Sachs Markets Podcast Host]

We fought during these two years to achieve our war aims. The central one of these war aims is to return the hostages, all of the hostages, the living and the dead. And we're about to achieve that goal. We couldn't have achieved it without the extraordinary help of President Trump and his team, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner.

[Kate Bullivant]

The hostage deal, which Trump announced earlier this week, seals a diplomatic breakthrough after months of failed talks and brings the first significant pause in fighting since March. Joining us now with the latest is Journal reporter Anat Peled, who's in Tel Aviv. Anat, this is just one stage of many when looking at President Trump's 20 step peace plan. So can you tell us what happens now?

[Anat Peled]

The Israeli government voted on this deal last night, Israel time. It went till quite late into the night. And once they voted, we're starting now the ceasefire process. So we have Israeli forces right now withdrawing from parts of Gaza. They're expected to finish that process tonight, according to an Israeli official. Then we have the ceasefire going into effect. The next stage we have then is going to be either Monday or Tuesday. We're going to see an exchange of Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli prisons for Israeli hostages. So that's going to include 20 hostages who are believed to be alive and also some of the bodies of the deceased hostages. So we have a total of 48. We understand that it's not going to include all of the deceased hostage bodies because Hamas does not know where all of them are. So that may take more time. So that's the immediate step. And then basically what happens with these negotiations is that they were very rushed. And so basically what ended up happening is that a lot of the more tricky issues were not even touched. For example, the second stage of this deal, which is about demilitarization of Gaza and international governance of Gaza, so that all of those things are kind of explosive issues that we're going to have to see how they get resolved moving forward.

[Kate Bullivant]

And in your reporting, you have said that US Forces are already arriving in Israel. What's the kind of reason for that?

[Anat Peled]

U.S. central Command is going to be leading an international stabilization force, and they're going to set up kind of a civil military coordination center. So the troops are going to help monitor the implementation of the ceasefire and also the eventual transition to a civilian government, according to a U.S. official. They're also going to help facilitate the flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza that has been agreed upon in the deal.

[Kate Bullivant]

So this was a deal brokered by President Trump and his team, but he isn't the first president to try and bring peace to the Middle East. Why has Trump been able to get this phase of the deal over the line and make the progress that he has?

[Anat Peled]

So one of the things that Trump did is he really turned kind of classic diplomacy on its head, and he went with this clever approach where he basically declared victory first. He announced the deal first. He announced it in the Oval Office alongside Netanyahu, declaring that that was the deal. And kind of daring, like, say no to me after he had announced it. And then Hamas gave its answer. A lot of people saw that as a yes, but, but, but Trump immediately said it was a yes. Then the two sides went to Egypt to hammer out the details. And so what happened is when they got into the negotiating room, it was not so smooth. There's still a lot of disagreements, but they had this constant pressure from Trump. So he basically pressured Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who had been reluctant, to end the war, according to people who are taking part in the talks, and pushed him to get this done. And on the other hand, he also put pressure on Hamas through Arab and Muslim countries, so that includes Qatar and Egypt and also Turkey. And so they pushed Hamas to get this done. And so what ended up happening is that as they were kind of trying to work this out, Trump declares victory. And they haven't worked out all the details. It's still being worked out right now, but basically nobody can really say no to Trump. And that was the bet And I think that's been very classic of his diplomatic style. It's looking at the big picture business deal and then having, you know, the professionals work out the little nitty gritty. But there's a lot of exploring explosive issues that have been left for, you know, the second stage of the deal that includes the demilitarization of Gaza. So, you know, the deal says that Hamas is going to have to disarm. We're going to see how is this governance going to work. There's an idea that there's going to be some sort of board of peace chaired by former UK Prime Minister Tony Blair. And so there's a lot of elements here that we're going to have to work out. So we need to see if Trump will continue pushing both sides to reach the agreement for the second stage or is it possible that he will lose interest.

[Kate Bullivant]

Journal reporter Anat Peled Anat, thanks so much for bringing us this update.

[Anat Peled]

Thanks for having me.

[Kate Bullivant]

A federal judge has blocked President Trump from deploying National Guard members to Illinois for two weeks, citing the potential for civil unrest. At least 500 troops, including some from Texas and California, have been sent to the Chicago area. The White House didn't respond to an email seeking comment, While Illinois Democratic Governor J.B. pritzker quickly praised the Chicago ruling. National Guard troops were expected to begin patrolling in Memphis today, a move supported by Republican Governor Bill Lee. Back in Washington, Republican and Democratic senators are trading ideas on health care funding in a bid to end the government shutdown. Informal discussions have centred on temporarily extending enhanced Affordable Care act subsidies, but with new guardrails meant to trim aid for higher income families. Democrats have discussed limiting the subsidies to households at or below $200,000 of income, rather than leaving the benefit uncapped. The Senate wrapped up late Thursday and won't return until Tuesday. It isn't clear when the House will come back in session, meaning the shutdown is almost certain to stretch through a second weekend. The Bureau of Labour Statistics says it's bringing back some workers to publish the Consumer Price Index for Sept. An administration official didn't specify how many staff would be recalled, but said the department would promptly resume work on the key economic data point relied on by investors, businesses and policymakers, including the Federal Reserve. The CPI is also crucial for calculating Social Security payments and was originally due to be published next week. It's unclear when the report will be published, and the Justice Department has indicted New York Attorney General Letitia James on charges of bank fraud and making false statements to a financial institution. The felony indictments follow an investigation into mortgage fraud allegations against James and Mark, an escalation in the Trump administration's campaign to bring criminal cases against officials who pursued the president before his return to the White House. The case was presented by the president's former personal lawyer, who last month also secured the indictment of former former FBI Director James Comey. James called the charges against her baseless. Her first court appearance is set for the 24th of October. Coming up, Americans are falling behind on their car payments, signaling economic pain for lower income consumers as unemployment ticks up and wages stagnate. That's after the break.

[Goldman Sachs Markets Podcast Host]

What's driving the markets this week? What's on investors minds as they look ahead? Find out on the Markets podcast from Goldman Sachs. A breakdown of market moves and macro signals in 10 minutes or less. The Markets podcast from Goldman Sachs. Listen now.

[Kate Bullivant]

One of the cylinders in the US Economy is sputtering. Subprime auto loan delinquencies have climbed to record highs as more lower income Americans fall behind on car payments. An estimated 1.73 million vehicles were repossessed last year, the most since 2009, according to Cox Automotive. Economists say it's a clear sign that low income workers are feeling the strain. With unemployment edging higher and and inflation lingering, many borrowers have stretched their budgets to the limit. The Journal's Ben Glickman has been following the story.

[Ben Glickman]

Generally, what we're seeing among people who tend to be lower income borrowers and who have less access to credit, the portion of subprime auto loans that are 60 days or more hit a record high earlier this year. That's according to Fitch Ratings, which is a credit rating agency. So in most of America, you need a car to get to work. It's not a discretionary purchase. You need one for all the basic functions of life. And for that reason, economists and analysts generally consider auto loans to be among the last things to falter among borrowers. So people might not pay back, you know, a loan on like a TV that you bought or something like that, if you bought that on credit. But you'll continue to pay your car loan because you need your car. So it is a specific sign of distress that we're seeing higher delinquencies among those borrowers.

[Kate Bullivant]

Let's go now to Iowa, one of the places where President Trump's disdain for renewables is creating some awkward politics. Together with Texas, Oklahoma and Kansas, it's one of the country's top wind power producers. And though all four states backed Trump in the polls last year, that hasn't kept the president's administration from taking actions that threaten jobs and tens of billions of dollars. New investment. As the Journal's Jennifer Hiller reports, there.

[Jennifer Hiller]

Is a lot of uncertainty across the wind industry right now. There are some offshore projects that are under construction that have been halted by the administration before they were able to restart again. But even on land, the Trump administration has promised to make permitting more difficult for projects that are on federal land. It's just not yet clear the extent to which federal agencies are going to work with them. Politicians in Iowa have tried to persuade President Trump that wind is a good thing for their state's economy, and so far he is with them on biofuels, which is their other local energy resource. But he is not with them on wind.

[Kate Bullivant]

Electricity demand is soaring, thanks partly to the AI frenzy. And wind covers more than 10% of the US's needs in Iowa, though that share is much higher, 59% in 2023, according to state governor Kim Reynolds, a Republican. It has helped keep electric electricity prices low. Trump, meanwhile, said this summer that, quote, any time you see a windmill, you'll say they have bad energy costs, end quote. And finally, this year's Nobel Peace Prize has been awarded to Venezuelan opposition leader Maria Corinna Machado for her work promoting democracy and fighting dictatorship in the country. Announcing the prize, the Nobel committee chairman described Machado as a brave and committed champion of peace who keeps the flame of democracy burning amid a growing dark darkness. And that's it for what's news for this Friday morning. Today's show was produced by Daniel Bark. Our supervising producer was Pierce Lynch. And I'm Kate Bullivant for the Wall Street Journal. We'll be back tonight with a new show. Until then, have a great weekend and thanks for listening.

[Viking Cruise Announcer]

This message comes from Viking committed to exploring the world in comfort. Journey through the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship with thoughtful service, destination focused dining and cultural enrichment on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all inclusive with no children and no casinos. Discover [e-mail].