Atlantic War: The Loss Of Three Aces (Part 6)

Episode Overview

Podcast: WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk
Episode: Atlantic War: The Loss Of Three Aces (Part 6)
Date: December 4, 2025
Hosts: Al Murray and James Holland

This episode dives deep into a pivotal phase of the Battle of the Atlantic in early 1941, spotlighting the British response to the U-boat threat and the shattering loss of three legendary German U-boat commanders ("aces"). Murray and Holland blend expert analysis and humor as they detail evolving convoy tactics, Allied technological breakthroughs, and the immense impact of losing key figures in the U-boat arm.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Commander Donald McIntyre & the Royal Navy Escort Groups

The episode opens with a first-person account (read by the hosts) from Commander Donald McIntyre, vividly recounting a U-boat hunt with HMS Walker ([02:26]-[03:17]).
McIntyre is introduced as a key figure, a seasoned career naval officer who transferred from the modern HMS Hesperus to the older HMS Walker to lead the 5th Escort Group ([03:24]-[05:06]).
The RN command hierarchy and the significance of senior officer escort (SOE) roles are explained:
- RN (Royal Navy) = regulars
- RNR (Royal Naval Reserve) = mariners from the merchant navy
- RNVR (Royal Navy Volunteer Reserve) = "the Wavy Navy" ([05:06]-[05:58])
- Uniform distinctions and promotion limits for each group; balance between nurturing career naval officers and supplementing with reservists.

Quote [04:42, Holland]: "McIntyre's one of those... career naval officer type backbone of the wartime Navy, 35 in March 1941, former Fleet Air Arm pilot... got sea in his blood."

2. Convoy Organization & Escort Tactics

Detailed breakdown of convoy assembly, code names (HX = Halifax, SC = Sydney Cove, ON/ONS = Outbound North), and the gathering/rendezvous process ([05:58]-[08:31]).
Explanation of the command relationship between the Commodore (who commands the merchant ships) and the SOE (who trumps the Commodore at sea due to military realities) ([08:31]-[09:13]).
Escort group composition: mix of destroyers and smaller corvettes, with varying capabilities and levels of maneuverability, underscoring the challenges of cohesive defense ([09:41]-[10:52]).
Great difficulty in operations: poor weather, limited radar, unreliable communications, need for constant vigilance ("sheepdogs beetling around the convoy" - [09:41]-[09:44]).

Quote [10:52, Holland]: "As we discussed... at night there's no radar for escort groups in the early stages... so a lot of navigation is by compass and human eye... communications at sea is clearly an area that needs urgent improvement and it's on its way."

3. The Atlantic “Pocket Battleship” & Cruiser Threat

Lighthearted riff on what qualifies as a “pocket battleship” (recurring joke), with the hosts reflecting on the public and military anxiety over these German surface raiders ([12:05]-[15:00]).
Admiral Hipper’s raid: sinks 7 of 19 ships in a convoy, but hosts question how emblematic or devastating these attacks really were in light of the effort involved ([13:20]-[13:42]).
Psychological and strategic significance: British concern that a breakout by battleships or battlecruisers would be catastrophic ([15:00]-[16:00]).

Quote [12:32, Murray]: "It's the foundation. If you don't get this right, all your fighter sweeps and your strategic bombing campaigns can all go whistle."

4. Churchill's Battle of the Atlantic Committee & Reforms

Churchill personally chairs the new committee addressing convoy and port issues, and issues a memorable 13-point memo ([16:00]-[17:20]).
- Anti-aircraft defenses in ports, merchant ships armed, idle shipping to be put in service.
- Churchill’s controversial push for “fast independents,” i.e., fast merchantmen to sail unescorted ([17:38]-[18:04]).
Discussion of port efficiency bottlenecks and efforts to improve convoy system effectiveness; inherent inefficiencies of convoys and the need to get armor and materiel to the front ([18:23]-[18:47]).
Pressure to hunt and destroy more U-boats ("Churchill wants U-boats offed" - [18:47]-[18:57]), investment in detection/weapon R&D.

Quote [19:22, Murray]: "He says the U-boat at sea must be hunted. The U-boat in the building, yard or dock must be bombed. The Fokker Wulf must be attacked in the air and in their nests."

5. Intelligence Breakthrough: Bletchley Park & Enigma

In March 1941, Bletchley Park achieves a step-change: the hand cipher "VAFT" is broken, allowing British intelligence to begin intercepting and (albeit with delay) decrypting large quantities of naval Enigma traffic ([19:36]-[20:55]).
The importance is not tactical re-routing, but building a much more complete operational/intelligence picture, giving the Allies a strategic edge.

6. The Wolf Pack and Critical Losses: The “Three Aces”

Central narrative focus: the German U-boat arm’s over-reliance on "aces" (Prien, Kretschmer, Schepke, and to a lesser degree, Lemp), and how this dominance masks underlying vulnerabilities ([22:32]-[23:14]).
By early March 1941, only 8 U-boats patrol the North Atlantic; effectiveness highly centralized in just a few men.

Quote [23:14, Holland]: "It's an absolutely critical, crucial part of the entire story... the aces are starting to give a massively disproportionate sense of the strength of the BDU, the U-boat arm. And I think this is the fatal flaw."

Key Incidents

Eric Topp rescuing the morale of his navigator by turning back for a lost lucky charm ([24:33]-[25:18]).
- Quote [24:55, Holland]: “The personal feelings of my men, faith, superstition, play a vital role in exercising command successfully.”
U-boats attacking convoy OB293. The failure of Dönitz's wolfpack tactics as only 5 boats remain in action and communication errors abound ([28:13]-[28:49]).
Detailed play-by-play of several convoy battles, capture and destruction of U-boats:
- U70 rammed and sunk, its new commander making "schoolboy errors" ([30:14]-[30:58]).
- U47 (Prien) disappears—relentlessly depth-charged, never heard from again ([32:25]-[32:27]).
- Convoy HX112: Walker’s group comes under severe attack; hosts vividly describe the hunt for U-boats in the aftermath ([32:27]-[34:08]).

7. Technological Turning Points

First significant use of shipborne radar (Type 286M) gives British escorts a crucial edge ([37:56]-[38:30]).
Star shells, improved ASDIC (sonar), and better depth charge tactics mark an evolution in anti-submarine warfare.

8. The Downfall of the Aces (Dramatic Climax)

Within days, three of Germany’s greatest U-boat commanders are lost:
- Preen (U47): lost after last signal, cause debated but never resurfaced ([32:25]-[32:27]).
- Schepke (U100): rammed and killed by HMS Vanoc after being forced to the surface by depth charges ([37:56]-[38:46]).
- Kretschmer (U99): forced to surface after being fatally depth-charged, captured along with his crew ([38:53]-[40:45]).
  - Memorable exchange over ship emblems and the fate of Kretschmer’s Zeiss binoculars ([41:26]-[41:32]).

Quote [39:40, Holland]: "They’re picked up by Vannack again, which signals to Walker and McIntyre, then hits the U99 with both Searchlight and its 4 inch guns... U99 soon signals: 'we are sunking' in Morse. I think it’s absolutely brilliant."

Vivid descriptions of the recovery of survivors (and hostilities between them!) aboard HMS Walker ([41:39]-[42:12]).
Reflections on the irreplaceable impact: the U-boat arm relied on "just 3,000 men in 1939," and these pre-war experts can't be replaced fast enough ([42:12]-[43:50]).

9. Aftermath, Reflections & Anecdotes

Postwar: Kretschmer rises to admiral in the Bundesmarine and is reunited with McIntyre, who returns his binoculars ([44:09]-[44:30]).
Hosts emphasize the psychological/complacency pitfalls on the German side, with a notable underestimation of Allied technological progress ([44:30]-[44:58]).

Quote [41:32, McIntyre via Murray]: “In our belief, a horseshoe that way up allows the luck to run out.”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

[04:42, Holland]: “McIntyre's one of those... career naval officer type backbone of the wartime Navy... got sea in his blood.”
[10:52, Holland]: “Communications at sea is clearly an area that needs urgent improvement and it's on its way.”
[12:32, Murray]: "It's the foundation. If you don't get this right, all your fighter sweeps and your strategic bombing campaigns can all go whistle."
[19:22, Murray]: "He says the U-boat at sea must be hunted. The U-boat in the building, yard or dock must be bombed. The Fokker Wulf must be attacked in the air and in their nests."
[24:55, Holland quoting Topp]: “The personal feelings of my men, faith, superstition, play a vital role in exercising command successfully.”
[23:14, Holland]: "The aces are starting to give a massively disproportionate sense of the strength of the BDU, the U-boat arm. And I think this is the fatal flaw."
[39:40, Holland]: "U99 soon signals: 'we are sunking' in Morse. I think it’s absolutely brilliant."
[41:32, Murray via McIntyre]: "In our belief, a horseshoe that way up allows the luck to run out."
[44:09, Holland]: "[Kretschmer] ends up being an admiral and in 1955 he's reunited with Donald McIntyre and you know what Donald McIntyre does? Gives him back his binoculars."

Important Segment Timestamps

[02:26]–[03:17] — McIntyre’s vivid personal account of U-boat hunt
[03:24]–[05:06] — Background on McIntyre, naval hierarchy
[05:58]–[09:13] — Convoy procedures, conference, and route codes
[10:52]–[12:05] — Operational difficulties, early radar, and communications
[13:20]–[13:42] — Assessment of Admiral Hipper’s attack and limitations
[16:00]–[17:20] — Churchill’s Atlantic War Committee reforms
[19:36]–[20:55] — Bletchley Park intelligence windfall
[22:32]–[23:14] — Opening of wolfpack/three aces segment
[24:55]–[25:18] — Topp returns for the navigator’s lucky charm
[30:14]–[30:58] — U70 sunk due to inexperienced command
[32:25]–[32:27] — Loss of Prien (U47)
[37:56]–[38:46] — Schepke (U100) rammed and killed
[38:53]–[40:45] — Kretschmer (U99) forced to surrender
[44:09]–[44:30] — McIntyre returns binoculars to Kretschmer postwar

Takeaway

This episode captures a critical inflection point in the Atlantic War, as technological maturation and improved tactics enable the Allies to not only defend convoys more effectively but also eliminate the most feared German U-boat commanders. Murray and Holland emphasize that the real loss was not just the U-boats, but the irreplaceable core of experience within the Kriegsmarine. Their blend of technical detail, historical narrative, and personality-driven anecdotes brings to life the razor-edge tension of this phase of WWII at sea.

Up next: The story continues toward another epic confrontation—the hunt for the Bismarck.

“Where’s the movie, Al?” – James Holland, [40:53]

Episode Overview

Podcast: WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk
Episode: Atlantic War: The Loss Of Three Aces (Part 6)
Date: December 4, 2025
Hosts: Al Murray and James Holland

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Commander Donald McIntyre & the Royal Navy Escort Groups

The episode opens with a first-person account (read by the hosts) from Commander Donald McIntyre, vividly recounting a U-boat hunt with HMS Walker ([02:26]-[03:17]).
McIntyre is introduced as a key figure, a seasoned career naval officer who transferred from the modern HMS Hesperus to the older HMS Walker to lead the 5th Escort Group ([03:24]-[05:06]).
The RN command hierarchy and the significance of senior officer escort (SOE) roles are explained:
- RN (Royal Navy) = regulars
- RNR (Royal Naval Reserve) = mariners from the merchant navy
- RNVR (Royal Navy Volunteer Reserve) = "the Wavy Navy" ([05:06]-[05:58])
- Uniform distinctions and promotion limits for each group; balance between nurturing career naval officers and supplementing with reservists.

Quote [04:42, Holland]: "McIntyre's one of those... career naval officer type backbone of the wartime Navy, 35 in March 1941, former Fleet Air Arm pilot... got sea in his blood."

2. Convoy Organization & Escort Tactics

Detailed breakdown of convoy assembly, code names (HX = Halifax, SC = Sydney Cove, ON/ONS = Outbound North), and the gathering/rendezvous process ([05:58]-[08:31]).
Explanation of the command relationship between the Commodore (who commands the merchant ships) and the SOE (who trumps the Commodore at sea due to military realities) ([08:31]-[09:13]).
Escort group composition: mix of destroyers and smaller corvettes, with varying capabilities and levels of maneuverability, underscoring the challenges of cohesive defense ([09:41]-[10:52]).
Great difficulty in operations: poor weather, limited radar, unreliable communications, need for constant vigilance ("sheepdogs beetling around the convoy" - [09:41]-[09:44]).

3. The Atlantic “Pocket Battleship” & Cruiser Threat

Lighthearted riff on what qualifies as a “pocket battleship” (recurring joke), with the hosts reflecting on the public and military anxiety over these German surface raiders ([12:05]-[15:00]).
Admiral Hipper’s raid: sinks 7 of 19 ships in a convoy, but hosts question how emblematic or devastating these attacks really were in light of the effort involved ([13:20]-[13:42]).
Psychological and strategic significance: British concern that a breakout by battleships or battlecruisers would be catastrophic ([15:00]-[16:00]).

Quote [12:32, Murray]: "It's the foundation. If you don't get this right, all your fighter sweeps and your strategic bombing campaigns can all go whistle."

4. Churchill's Battle of the Atlantic Committee & Reforms

Churchill personally chairs the new committee addressing convoy and port issues, and issues a memorable 13-point memo ([16:00]-[17:20]).
- Anti-aircraft defenses in ports, merchant ships armed, idle shipping to be put in service.
- Churchill’s controversial push for “fast independents,” i.e., fast merchantmen to sail unescorted ([17:38]-[18:04]).
Discussion of port efficiency bottlenecks and efforts to improve convoy system effectiveness; inherent inefficiencies of convoys and the need to get armor and materiel to the front ([18:23]-[18:47]).
Pressure to hunt and destroy more U-boats ("Churchill wants U-boats offed" - [18:47]-[18:57]), investment in detection/weapon R&D.

Quote [19:22, Murray]: "He says the U-boat at sea must be hunted. The U-boat in the building, yard or dock must be bombed. The Fokker Wulf must be attacked in the air and in their nests."

5. Intelligence Breakthrough: Bletchley Park & Enigma

In March 1941, Bletchley Park achieves a step-change: the hand cipher "VAFT" is broken, allowing British intelligence to begin intercepting and (albeit with delay) decrypting large quantities of naval Enigma traffic ([19:36]-[20:55]).
The importance is not tactical re-routing, but building a much more complete operational/intelligence picture, giving the Allies a strategic edge.

6. The Wolf Pack and Critical Losses: The “Three Aces”

Central narrative focus: the German U-boat arm’s over-reliance on "aces" (Prien, Kretschmer, Schepke, and to a lesser degree, Lemp), and how this dominance masks underlying vulnerabilities ([22:32]-[23:14]).
By early March 1941, only 8 U-boats patrol the North Atlantic; effectiveness highly centralized in just a few men.

Key Incidents

Eric Topp rescuing the morale of his navigator by turning back for a lost lucky charm ([24:33]-[25:18]).
- Quote [24:55, Holland]: “The personal feelings of my men, faith, superstition, play a vital role in exercising command successfully.”
U-boats attacking convoy OB293. The failure of Dönitz's wolfpack tactics as only 5 boats remain in action and communication errors abound ([28:13]-[28:49]).
Detailed play-by-play of several convoy battles, capture and destruction of U-boats:
- U70 rammed and sunk, its new commander making "schoolboy errors" ([30:14]-[30:58]).
- U47 (Prien) disappears—relentlessly depth-charged, never heard from again ([32:25]-[32:27]).
- Convoy HX112: Walker’s group comes under severe attack; hosts vividly describe the hunt for U-boats in the aftermath ([32:27]-[34:08]).

7. Technological Turning Points

First significant use of shipborne radar (Type 286M) gives British escorts a crucial edge ([37:56]-[38:30]).
Star shells, improved ASDIC (sonar), and better depth charge tactics mark an evolution in anti-submarine warfare.

8. The Downfall of the Aces (Dramatic Climax)

Within days, three of Germany’s greatest U-boat commanders are lost:
- Preen (U47): lost after last signal, cause debated but never resurfaced ([32:25]-[32:27]).
- Schepke (U100): rammed and killed by HMS Vanoc after being forced to the surface by depth charges ([37:56]-[38:46]).
- Kretschmer (U99): forced to surface after being fatally depth-charged, captured along with his crew ([38:53]-[40:45]).
  - Memorable exchange over ship emblems and the fate of Kretschmer’s Zeiss binoculars ([41:26]-[41:32]).

Vivid descriptions of the recovery of survivors (and hostilities between them!) aboard HMS Walker ([41:39]-[42:12]).
Reflections on the irreplaceable impact: the U-boat arm relied on "just 3,000 men in 1939," and these pre-war experts can't be replaced fast enough ([42:12]-[43:50]).

9. Aftermath, Reflections & Anecdotes

Postwar: Kretschmer rises to admiral in the Bundesmarine and is reunited with McIntyre, who returns his binoculars ([44:09]-[44:30]).
Hosts emphasize the psychological/complacency pitfalls on the German side, with a notable underestimation of Allied technological progress ([44:30]-[44:58]).

Quote [41:32, McIntyre via Murray]: “In our belief, a horseshoe that way up allows the luck to run out.”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

[04:42, Holland]: “McIntyre's one of those... career naval officer type backbone of the wartime Navy... got sea in his blood.”
[10:52, Holland]: “Communications at sea is clearly an area that needs urgent improvement and it's on its way.”
[12:32, Murray]: "It's the foundation. If you don't get this right, all your fighter sweeps and your strategic bombing campaigns can all go whistle."
[19:22, Murray]: "He says the U-boat at sea must be hunted. The U-boat in the building, yard or dock must be bombed. The Fokker Wulf must be attacked in the air and in their nests."
[24:55, Holland quoting Topp]: “The personal feelings of my men, faith, superstition, play a vital role in exercising command successfully.”
[23:14, Holland]: "The aces are starting to give a massively disproportionate sense of the strength of the BDU, the U-boat arm. And I think this is the fatal flaw."
[39:40, Holland]: "U99 soon signals: 'we are sunking' in Morse. I think it’s absolutely brilliant."
[41:32, Murray via McIntyre]: "In our belief, a horseshoe that way up allows the luck to run out."
[44:09, Holland]: "[Kretschmer] ends up being an admiral and in 1955 he's reunited with Donald McIntyre and you know what Donald McIntyre does? Gives him back his binoculars."

Important Segment Timestamps

[02:26]–[03:17] — McIntyre’s vivid personal account of U-boat hunt
[03:24]–[05:06] — Background on McIntyre, naval hierarchy
[05:58]–[09:13] — Convoy procedures, conference, and route codes
[10:52]–[12:05] — Operational difficulties, early radar, and communications
[13:20]–[13:42] — Assessment of Admiral Hipper’s attack and limitations
[16:00]–[17:20] — Churchill’s Atlantic War Committee reforms
[19:36]–[20:55] — Bletchley Park intelligence windfall
[22:32]–[23:14] — Opening of wolfpack/three aces segment
[24:55]–[25:18] — Topp returns for the navigator’s lucky charm
[30:14]–[30:58] — U70 sunk due to inexperienced command
[32:25]–[32:27] — Loss of Prien (U47)
[37:56]–[38:46] — Schepke (U100) rammed and killed
[38:53]–[40:45] — Kretschmer (U99) forced to surrender
[44:09]–[44:30] — McIntyre returns binoculars to Kretschmer postwar

Takeaway

Up next: The story continues toward another epic confrontation—the hunt for the Bismarck.

“Where’s the movie, Al?” – James Holland, [40:53]

wavePod

Powered by Wave AI

Summary

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Commander Donald McIntyre & the Royal Navy Escort Groups

2. Convoy Organization & Escort Tactics

3. The Atlantic “Pocket Battleship” & Cruiser Threat

4. Churchill's Battle of the Atlantic Committee & Reforms

5. Intelligence Breakthrough: Bletchley Park & Enigma

6. The Wolf Pack and Critical Losses: The “Three Aces”

Key Incidents

7. Technological Turning Points

8. The Downfall of the Aces (Dramatic Climax)

9. Aftermath, Reflections & Anecdotes

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

Important Segment Timestamps

Takeaway

Summary

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Commander Donald McIntyre & the Royal Navy Escort Groups

2. Convoy Organization & Escort Tactics

3. The Atlantic “Pocket Battleship” & Cruiser Threat

4. Churchill's Battle of the Atlantic Committee & Reforms

5. Intelligence Breakthrough: Bletchley Park & Enigma

6. The Wolf Pack and Critical Losses: The “Three Aces”

Key Incidents

7. Technological Turning Points

8. The Downfall of the Aces (Dramatic Climax)

9. Aftermath, Reflections & Anecdotes

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

Important Segment Timestamps

Takeaway