
Loading summary
Al Murray
Thank you for listening to we have ways of making you talk. Sign up to our Patreon to receive bonus content, live streams and our weekly newsletter with money off books and museum visits as well. Plus early access to all live show tickets. That's patreon.com we haveways.
Hershey's Ad Voice
One sweet, melty bite of a Hershey's bar and suddenly I'm right back, sitting on the front porch with my grandmother on a slow summer afternoon. She doesn't say much, just breaks the bar in half and hands me a piece. I open my mouth to say whatever a 9 year old wants to say and she replies with a low
Al Murray
listen.
Hershey's Ad Voice
So we sat there listening. That was the first time I learned that quiet can feel full. Hershey's it's your happy place.
Al Murray
Rated T for teen.
CM Punk
Hey everyone, it's the best in the world. CM Punk back to shake up WWE 2K26 this year, the show never stops. You're running the greatest spectacle on earth with the biggest roster we've ever had. Over 400 superstars and legends from every era. Stack the tables, break the rules, burn it all down. And yeah, my very own showcase. Telling my story the way it should have been told. Because when the show never stops, anything is possible. Available March 13th pre order now.
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
Ugh.
Depop Ad Voice
You said you were over him, but his hoodie is still in your rotation. It's time. Grab your phone, snap a few pics and sell it on Depop. Listed in minutes with no selling fees. And just like that, a guy 500 miles away just paid full price for your closure. And right on cue.
James Holland
Hey, still got my hoodie?
Depop Ad Voice
Nope. But I've got tonight's dinner paid for Start selling on Depop where taste recognizes taste list. Now with no selling fees, payment processing fees and boosting fees still apply. See website for details.
Al Murray
Actor act soon. Welcome to we have Ways of Making Talk with Me, Al Murray and James Holland, the Second World War podcast of choice for those people with taste and sophistication and an interest in the greatest story ever told. That's basically the way to tee the show up, isn't it, Jim?
James Holland
Yeah. You don't need to say anything else.
Al Murray
Exactly.
James Holland
That is the perfect intro. I have nothing to add. We cover everything. We even cover naval matters these days.
Al Murray
I know, I know. We've gone Navy crazy and today we're having a basically a war waffle chat. A kind of a catch up talking about some things that have grabbed our attention. What we're up to. We've got a timeline for February, February 24th across the war. You've now embarked. Let's start there. You've just embarked, Jim, haven't you, on your next round of research, as you're preparing to write about the first stage of the Atlantic War? Is that right? Or the second stage? Just the first, yeah.
James Holland
Basically all the stuff we've just covered in the podcast from September 1939 on the Atlantic War series, then the eight episodes we've done on the Hood and the Bismarck collectively, that's what I'm covering. The only bit we haven't covered, and maybe we should do a two part special is the capture of U110 or U110 because, you know, I don't think we can have enough Navy. And U1110, of course, is Ulyss Lemp, who sank the Athena on day one in U30. But he's been promoted and he's got a bigger. He's got a bigger U boat by this point, and that's the one with the Enigma machine captured. And it's quite the epic story, I can tell you.
Al Murray
Well, I was going to ask actually tangentially to that, you know, naval. Naval intelligence is one of the main players. It's Bletchley's most important client for a long stretch of the war, isn't it?
James Holland
Well, there you go. This is the game changer, really. And the other thing is one of. One of the destroyers involved in that action was commanded by a chap called Captain Funj. Smith.
Al Murray
Come off here.
James Holland
It's really funny. What's really funny? I've got his account of the capture of U110 and in all his signatures it's just Captain Smith. F U N G E Funge. Fung.
Al Murray
Fungi, fungi, fungi. Imagine the ribbing, the ribbing he received at Dartmouth. God blimey.
James Holland
He decided to just go for plain old Smith.
Al Murray
Old Smith, rather.
James Holland
For the rest of his life.
Al Murray
That must be. But that must be some previous relative thinking, well, I'm not called Smith.
James Holland
We're.
Al Murray
We're better than just plain Smiths. We're fun.
James Holland
We're Sponge Smith. Chalky Fun Smith.
Al Murray
So, I mean, question to ask, where are you going for this research then? So you're going to Greenwich or are you going to Portsmouth to the Historical branch? You're going to scap a flow.
James Holland
Oh, boy. I'm going all over. I'm going all over.
Al Murray
So where is it all?
James Holland
Kew Imperial War Museum? Yeah, Greenwich. Haven't been to Chatham yet, but probably will. Steve Prince and I were talking about going to Halifax. Big Museums there. And although the Canadians weren't really kind of hundred percent in here at this point, you know, it was quite a, you know, it's still a major, major port. One thing I noticed yesterday, this is absolutely amazing, there isn't a single HX convoy, which is one coming from Halifax to Britain between June 1941 to September 1942. Not a single ship is sunk in convoy. Wow.
LifeLock Ad Voice
Wow.
James Holland
I kid you not.
Al Murray
That's quite something, isn't it?
James Holland
Not one. So, you know, this whole thing about kind of, you know, over 80% of convoys came through unscathed. They fricking did.
Al Murray
Yeah.
James Holland
There's the proof. It just underlines, doesn't it, that in the narrative all we do is focus on the terrible ones, you know, the ones that are kind of, you know, three day battles in which sort of 14 go to the bottom and all the rest of it. But that's not normal.
Al Murray
Did you read that piece by John Buckley about air power in the Atlantic War?
James Holland
No, I haven't yet, but I really want to.
Al Murray
It's so interesting. He looks at the operational research, right, because they get like across the board in the British services. They get the operational research, gets going after a couple of years where they start looking actually, you know, they set up an operational research unit, they start looking actually how they're doing stuff and trying to sort of crunch the numbers. And there's the whole thing about the, you know, the Bay of Biscay air patrols that the British run to suppress the U boats. And they're doing this before they've got the cavity magnetron, before they're able to strike at those U boats. But what it actually does is forces the U boats under. So by the time the U boats get further out to sea, they haven't got as long legs, they aren't able to engage as easily. And he points out that simply aeroplanes in the sky is enough to put the willies up the U boat captains. And so they have to resort to countermeasures that are costly to them. The point John makes is how are you going to weigh this? A sunk U boat is obviously top of the shop, that's what you want. But a U boat that's hindered, that's restricted, that's held up, that can't do what it's supposed to achieve. That's great, you know, that's pretty good. And he talks about the air contribution is much more successful earlier than is generally like perceived because, because, because of this patrolling the Bear Biscay and there's you know, there's some criticism that says, well, why are they only pat? But that's all they can do with the aircraft. They've got the range to go anywhere else. So they're making the best use of the equipment they've got at the time. They've got the equipment and it is making life much more difficult for the U boat crews, which is leading to them having, you know, the tap turned off, or at least they're being throttled back by aggressive air action. All it takes is for them to see a plane, for them to dive, and then that basically ruins their morning.
James Holland
Well, yes, because of course, they're just going so much slower when they're under the water. I mean, they're going, you know, third quarter of a speed and too slow to catch convoy.
Al Murray
And burning more fuel. And burning more fuel and not charging the batteries.
James Holland
They're burning their batteries, aren't they? That's the point.
Al Murray
Well, so they then need recharging, which is going to cost them more fuel. And he makes this really interesting point. He says sometimes the sort of technical breakthroughs get lent into too much in the story. But actually, when you look at what Coastal Command are achieving with what they've got, because they haven't been prioritized either. It's really, really interesting because in the First World War, Ayre had been instructive in dealing with the U boat threat. They'd actually been able to use it effectively. And that kind of get. That fell out of people's perception the start of the war. The Navy thinks they could do it without. Without that. It's just so interesting. And again, you've got to look at where are the gains? It's not just sunk U boats. Where are the gains? So, for instance, we've just done some family stories, just recordings of family stories, and one of them was about, from a lister called meredith was about u358. If you look u358 up on the U boat.
James Holland
U boat.
Al Murray
U boat net, whatever it's called. How many tons of shipping did you. 358 sink across the war, Jim?
James Holland
Don't know. I mean, if 358, that means it's later one. So it's only going to be coming in in 1942, 43.
Al Murray
Well, it's 19,000, 20,000 tons of ships shipping.
James Holland
Okay, that's not very much.
Al Murray
There's peanuts. That's nothing like enough, is it? No.
James Holland
When you're thinking sort of Schepka and Kretschmer and Preen and company. They're all, you know, they're 170,000, 200,000, that kind of stuff.
Al Murray
And her top ace captain is Otto schuhardt, who commanded U8, U25, U29.
James Holland
Okay, so he's an old boy.
Al Murray
So he's an old boy. He's responsible for sinking something like 90,000 tons of shipping. Nothing like enough. 12 ships, one warship. Nothing like enough. That's because they're being, they're being throttled, they're being held back, they're being held up. And if you go to, you know, as you say, this Halifax, this period, I mean, there's a happy time in reverse, isn't there? That's a convoy happy time.
James Holland
Yes. Well, it's interesting yesterday because I was at the Naval Historical Branch, which is where I saw Steve Prince, great friend of the show. Of course, the Naval Historical Branch is brilliant because they've got, you know, they've got Aidan Butler, who spoke at the. We have Wastefest in the past and I think he's coming back again this year. Oh, yes, yes. He is doing sea over sand. He's doing swordfish operations over the desert.
Al Murray
Oh, come on.
James Holland
Thought you'd be happy about that.
Al Murray
Charles Vlam writes a lot about that.
James Holland
Yeah, he did. I might have to also include albacores. And I said, that's fine. As long as the swordfish, I'll be happy.
Al Murray
I mean, fairy aircraft in General Fulmar's albacores, swordfish, we're good with it.
James Holland
Okay, you're fine with all of that?
Al Murray
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
James Holland
Okay, so that's good. So I thought that'd be okay. Anyway, so I reassured him on that front. Then also Kate Brett, who is a kind of German speaking Yubo expert, she wants to talk about coastal, German coastal defenses. Bring it on.
Al Murray
Why not?
James Holland
Anyway, so I was there yesterday and they've, they've got some amazing stuff. So they've got, they, they after, if they ever capture any U boat crew, they interrogated them and they then do these reports. So you don't get verbatim interrogations. But what you do get is precis and a whole loads of technical information on the, on, on the various U boats and also details about morale and what they're up to and what they were doing in the mission while they're doing previous raids, all that kind of stuff. It's all fascinating right down to the kind of what type of cigarette they're smoking. And as you can imagine, it's all pretty juicy stuff. And then you get to, you know, Interrogation of prisoners from the sinking of the Bismarck. And you think, wow. And guess what else they've got. Yeah, really, really good. I'm just absolutely amazing. But guess what else they've got. They've got the war diary of the bdu. They've got donuts. War diary.
Al Murray
Really?
James Holland
Yes.
Al Murray
So absolutely every day.
James Holland
Every day.
Al Murray
Goodness me.
James Holland
And they've also got after action reports of people who have claimed to have hit U boats. And then there's the sort of western approaches and intelligence sections kind of deciding whether it did get sunk or not. You know, it's really funny. It's like, nah, this one got away. It's really obvious, really. That's amazing. But regardless of that, that you've got quite detailed accounts of the attacks and how they go about doing the attacks and all the rest of it. So it's really, really, really incredibly interesting. And then Steve gave us all a tour of the Royal Navy's trophy cabinet, which is a sort of storeroom in the historic dog cars. And you've never, I mean you've never seen more silver in your life. And there on a shelf is a letter from, from Nelson, signed also by Lady Hamilton for example, going please make sure you give her £100 every month from now on. It's just, it's just absolutely incredible. And they had, they had the relics of, of. Of. I think is it is S111, something like that or 311, I can't remember which. Which S boot it was. They had the guys Zeiss binoculars which were absolutely butchered with shrapnel marks.
Al Murray
Wow.
James Holland
You know, they killed 11 of the crew in the attack. Still had its ensign and all this kind of stuff. Steve's thinking about doing a second World War Royal Navy trophy store roadshow which he's going to bring to. We have Wastefest 6.
Al Murray
Oh wow.
James Holland
That would be cool, wouldn't it?
Al Murray
That'd be super cool.
James Holland
Which is a gun barrel cover which washed up a year later in Norway.
Al Murray
What they call a condom.
LifeLock Ad Voice
Wow.
Al Murray
Amazing.
James Holland
Absolutely amazing. Because the guy said, well this is here we've got frame. We just had it recently framed. This is the ensign from HMS Panel Penelope, better known as. I went pepper pot. And he went yeah, absolutely right. And he said we got loads of stuff here, you know, got relative hood. I said what do you mean you got relic of the hood? I didn't see that. It was amazing. Anyway, so, so yeah, very fruitful day yesterday. But, but we did. Steve and I did think that probably unfortunately we'd have to go to Halifax. But obviously coming up I've got Narvik and, and Scapa Flow. So it's good to hear that there's a museum that we heard from family stories that's worth seeing.
Al Murray
Have you started to cast it yet?
James Holland
Yeah, yeah, just, just, just starting that, just starting that. Don't worry. There's some amazing people probably good of which Peter Gretton, he. Of being thrown overboard and back again will definitely be a star.
Al Murray
That account of George Wally's that you sent me that we quoted in the Bismarck series.
James Holland
Yeah. How good is that?
Al Murray
It's really, really good, isn't it? I, I do. It is interesting because he, he, he says in it, he says, you know, we're not supposed to write about this but every now and again there's an event where it seems silly not to put down how you feel about it because everyone knows about it, it's public knowledge, so you might as well.
James Holland
Yeah, can't argue with that.
Al Murray
And then he goes to write this extraordinary sort of florid, florid, beautifully written account of chasing the Bismarck down and the feeling of the feeling, you know, because he is doing night watches or he's in the WT room and he's. So he lives in the sort of extraordinary twilight world of night and at the signals desk and all that sort of stuff and in absolutely punishing c. It is interesting, isn't it, that the whole action takes place in diabolical weather. You know, we talk about the weather getting a vote in land actions, right, or air actions, but on the sea it's like a, it's of a different order, isn't it? Because you can have a thunderstorm but the earth doesn't move, does it? You might get, you might get flooded on land but you're, you're not thrown about by gigantic rollers and, and having to stay upright in the colossal surf. I mean the idea of all those, you know, he paints a picture of like the physicality of being on a ship. It's incredibly hard work, isn't it?
James Holland
I think so. And I think what I'm doing. I've been thinking about this a lot. You know, when are you doing the book? You really got to get your, your prose hat on and summon all your descriptive juices and really give it two barrels worth for the weather. Because there's a reason why it's referred to as a cruel sea. I mean, I mean it's, it's just brutal. Absolutely brutal. Particularly on a destroyer or even worse, a corvette. I mean, you know, it's a total tint up being tossed about all over the place. Do you remember those. That line from vine where he just goes, you know, several people were washed overboard but we couldn't stop. It's very much sort of. This is part and parcel anyway. So it's all really good and I'm having. I'm having fun thinking about it all and plotting it and just starting to piece it all together. I'm definitely going to do a thing on Mirza Kabir because, you know, Mercel Kabir, you know, had the fleet of French fleet, that would have changed everything for the battle. Well, not change everything. We would have had a big impact on the Battle of the Atlantic, I think. I think the British were absolutely right to shut down the French fleet. I mean, really were.
Al Murray
They had no choice, I think is the truth of it.
James Holland
No, no choice. No choice at all.
Al Murray
Because you can't control, you can't engage in the Mediterranean if the French fleet is, you know, and if you're drawing on your imperial resources, you need to be able to control the Mediterranean. Everything knocks on from everything George Wally says. I mean, stuff he says about the physicality of being at sea is really something, you know, he says, I've lost track of the days, it seems in looking back that were like one long twilight day punctuated by meals that would scarcely stay on the table long enough to be eaten. What it's like being keyed up all that time is extraordinary.
James Holland
And of course, he's serving one of his fellow officers is Ludovic Kennedy.
Al Murray
Yeah, exactly. And it's interesting actually how Kennedy's prose is sort of the next level up in terms of sort of vivid prose style. But Wally's quite capable of batting that kind of average as well.
James Holland
You know, people were taught how to write in those days.
Al Murray
Well, it did. It did make me think of a literate age on the subject of sinking to Bismarck, though. I had to speak to year six at Daisy's primary school yesterday to talk about the Second World War.
James Holland
Fantastic.
Al Murray
So you know, what's the Second World War, everyone? Oh, it's a big war, like a long time ago. Right, okay, great. Any idea when it was from?
James Holland
1930, something black and white?
Al Murray
Well, not quite 1930. Something to 8 May 1945. One of the kids said, oh, that's quite good.
James Holland
Was that Daisy?
Al Murray
No, no, no, no. Year six. She's not year six. It's the older kids. Anyway, I did this last year and so we handed round bits of twisted parts of a hurricane that I've Got. And then my para helmet. And then we watched London Can Take it, which for a thing for kids to watch is like, yes, brilliant. Because, you know, there's enough. There's enough of the city in it that's still the same, you know, St. Paul's and then I thought, but we've got to do something to entertain them. We watched Lego sink the Bismarck.
James Holland
Yeah, brilliant.
Al Murray
Which I'm sure many of our regular listeners will have had a look at. I thoroughly recommend it. If you've not seen Lego sink the Bismarck yet.
James Holland
I haven't, but I want to.
Al Murray
Oh, God, it's so good. It's a condensed, Condensed. It's the Swordfish attack. So kud's attack. So the second one where they. Where they strike the rudder and then it's, you know, lots of Lego men going, bismarck can no longer maneuver. We will fight to the last shell.
James Holland
Fantastic.
Al Murray
Then, you know, kg, kg 5, the Prince of Wales appear on the horizon and sink the Bismarck. And at the end she turns over the. The Bismarck and you've got little Lego men swimming away in the foreground, which is. But we watched that and the kids were completely invested in it. So when the, you know, the first torpedo for the swordfish goes in and it misses, the whole class went, oh, like that. When it went past this guy's bows. Yeah, yeah. Then the second one goes underneath it like that. Right.
James Holland
Oh, brilliant.
Al Murray
And then the third one hits the rudder and the screws and there's this great big cheer from the. Yeah, from the class. Right.
James Holland
No, that's amazing.
Al Murray
It was brilliant.
James Holland
Well, it sounds to me like you're doing very valuable and important work here.
Al Murray
This is essential outreach, Jim. Essential outreach.
James Holland
Essential outreach. Getting them. Getting them young. Small seeds.
Al Murray
Yeah, exactly. And then one of the kids, one of the kids goes, oh, I never knew Lego could so be so intense, bruv.
James Holland
In years. Ex. That's just super, like, jackpot. Wow.
Al Murray
I've done it.
James Holland
Yeah, yeah, yeah, well done. That's fantastic. That's really good. I'm proud.
Al Murray
But that's really funny. Really funny. After I said, so, any. Any questions? And I'd said, you know, the Bismarck's the biggest battleship and the. The British have got to sink it. They absolutely have to, to protect their own shipping, you know, like, laid it all out for them. I didn't say, by the way, that Swordfish is not obsolescent in this set of circumstances anyway. But the point, the point is. Any questions? One of the boys puts his hand up like, yes. And he goes, I've done. Age 14. Lego, actually.
James Holland
That was his. All right.
Al Murray
Yeah. That's great. Well done.
James Holland
What did you say to that?
Al Murray
I said, well, that's that. Well done.
James Holland
Can I suggest that you move on to tamiya? And what you'll need is a spray gun. And then one of the kids.
Al Murray
Then one of the kids goes. That kind of shooting with those big guns, that must have been extremely difficult. How did they do that?
James Holland
Tell you what. Never dumbed down to kids. Never dumbed down to school kids. No.
Al Murray
Then you're onto plunging fire. You're onto a sighting.
James Holland
Computer zones of invulnerability.
Al Murray
Yeah. It's absolutely amazing. Wow.
James Holland
God, I'd have died to have known all that stuff when I was that age. Why was I doing Latin when I could have been learning about Bismarck?
Al Murray
Why you were doing Latin or why I was doing Latin was never sufficiently explained to me at the time and has never been sufficiently explained since.
James Holland
Explain since.
Al Murray
There never was a reason, was there?
James Holland
No. Caesar had some jam for tea.
Al Murray
Pompey had a rat. Exactly, yeah. Gerunds and gerundives. No, thanks. Not interested.
James Holland
I don't want to know that. I want to know about Bismarck.
Al Murray
Exactly.
James Holland
Plunging fire.
Al Murray
Plunging fire.
James Holland
My career could have been so different.
Al Murray
Well, you'd have got started a little earlier, basically.
James Holland
That's my point. I'd have had early background knowledge rather than having to start from scratch. Age 30.
Al Murray
You've made up a lost time, Jim. Don't panic.
James Holland
Quite resentful sitting here now.
Al Murray
Should we take a break and then look at what was going on in the Februarys of the second world war? Should we do that? Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
James Holland
Yeah, let's do that.
Al Murray
We'll be back in a second.
Hershey's Ad Voice
When you want your spring break to feel like and your kids pool day typically feel like. And your hotel bed to feel like. Ooh. And room service to feel like. Because at Hilton, hospitality feels like.
Al Murray
Your cabana's ready. Would you like fresh towels?
Hershey's Ad Voice
It matters where you stay. Book now@hilton.com Hilton for this day.
Al Murray
Close your eyes. Exhale. Feel your body relax and let go of whatever you're carrying today.
Hershey's Ad Voice
Well, I'm letting go of the worry
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
that I wouldn't get my new contacts in time for this class. I got them delivered free from 1-800-contacts. Oh, my gosh, they're so fast.
Depop Ad Voice
And breathe.
Hershey's Ad Voice
Oh, sorry. I almost couldn't breathe when I saw the discount they gave me on my first order.
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
Oh, sorry. Namaste.
Hershey's Ad Voice
Visit 1-800-contacts.com today to save on your first order.
Al Murray
1,800contacts.
Dominic Sambrook
Hello, everybody, and welcome to the Book Club, a new podcast from Goal Hanger, hosted by me, Dominic Sambrook, and me, Tabitha Syed.
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
As some of you may know, I have been Dominic's producer on the Rest Is History, and we even did a miniseries last year about all things books.
Dominic Sambrook
And since we enjoyed that so much, we have decided to roll it out as its own show. So it'll be coming out every Tuesday. We'll be doing a different book each time and digging into all the stories behind them.
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
And we are going to be talking about the historical contexts behind some of the greatest and most famous books of all time. We're going to be digging into the remarkable people behind them, the unexpected stories behind the stories, and also unraveling the plot of each book a bit and delving into the depths of the story.
Dominic Sambrook
Now, you don't have to have read the books to listen to the show, but we hope that by the end of each episode you will be able to pretend to people that you've read them. That is the key thing. And either way, whether you read them or not, we hope that you'll learn lots of fascinating, fascinating facts. You'll be lots of great stories and maybe Tabby the odd laugh.
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
We will be looking at thrilling gothic bodice rippers like Wuthering Heights and Frankenstein, as well as iconic stories like the Great Gatsby or Little Women, and then also some more modern stuff. So Game of Thrones, Normal People, the Hunger Games, Hamnet, all manner of exciting stories.
Dominic Sambrook
So please join us on our journey into all things books. Wherever you get your podcasts, just search for the book club every Tuesday and hopefully we will see you there.
Al Murray
Welcome back to we have Ways of aq Talk with Me. I'm Murray and James Holland for a warm waffle episode strewn with regret. That last part that James didn't have someone come into primary school to explain plunging fire to him.
James Holland
I am regretful. Like, where were you when I was in Year six? Well, I suppose that was called the. That was called like the fourth form or something.
Al Murray
When I was at school, I was in the remove. I think when you were in Year six, I was in the. Or the lower six.
James Holland
I'm not sure in the remove. What is the remove?
Al Murray
I never really understood that. Just like the Latin. That was never explained to me sufficiently at the time. It's never been explained since.
James Holland
The other thing is. The other thing is really funny is at our school you could be rusticated, which meant you were sent home, but to be rusticated actually means Going into the country, which I think is really funny. The assumption that anyone who is at a minor public school in the south coast of England wouldn't return to somewhere urban, would return to their country seat. So just before we get on to what happened in February. February during the war. Third week of February in the war. You've been reading some interesting stuff recently, haven't you?
Al Murray
I've been reading all sorts of stuff. I've been. I mean, I've been channel dashing, mainly. That's the thing I've been looking at. And Eugene Esmond and his career. What's quite interesting about that is that one of the RAF's jobs, as well as providing an air force, seems to be to produce a surplus of pilots in order to connect the empire together. You know the way. Now, if you join the Royal Air Force and you fly the Airbus at the end of it, you're kind of almost ready to go as a. As an airline pilot. It feels a bit like that because that's what happens to Esmond. It doesn't get a commission, permanent commission, so ends up, you know, massing. I mean, what is five thousand 550 hours in his logbook before the war starts?
James Holland
Yeah, it's just nuts, isn't it?
Al Murray
It's completely insane. And that's eight or nine years after he leaves the raf, gets a job with Imperial straight away. And there's a great account of a guy who flew with him, who'd come from British Airways, who sort of says that the lads at Imperial, they're all like seat of the pants flyers because they're all so madly experienced. And the first time he flies with Esmond, it basically scares him witness, because Esmond's just like completely confident with the Aircra aircraft, you know, like totally knows every possible permutation of what the plane will do. And there's all sorts of stories about him flying. Flying in disgusting weather off Burma, you know, getting caught in a thermal, having to bring it down, flying at sea level, all this sort of stuff. So flying that's as hardcore and as adventurous as anything you'd ever do in the services, but. But in these float planes and then in all sorts of different aircraft and he's sort of. He's basically a sort of. By the. By the end of his civilian air career, he's basically a float plane expert. It's just a genius, a genius pilot. You see that quite clearly. That's one of the sort of secretions from the Royal Air Force. While it may be taking care of the Sort of people like Barda because, you know, it takes them a while to fire Barda. After all, let Barda go. Or him to let himself go. But basically they're producing pilots as well. And so you, again, come away from just, you know, the defense aspect of what the Air Force is for. Plug it into an imperial quotient. You know, there's a virtuous circle there, isn't there? Of you're producing pilots for the empire because the empire's as important as anything else in British strategic thinking. I was really, really, really struck by that.
James Holland
I've been reading up about Philippines, and I've been reading. I'll tell you what else I've been reading, which is absolutely brilliant. I read it years and years and years ago and haven't looked at it since, is into that Darkness by Gitta Sareni. Oh, God, what a book. Have you ever read it?
Al Murray
No, but I read her Speer book. It's absolutely incredible.
James Holland
Okay, well, the Fran Stangle one, Into that Darkness is really short. It's not a big book at all, and it's just amazing. So he was the guy who ended up as commandant of Sobibor, the death camp.
Al Murray
Yeah.
James Holland
And it's forks in the road. It's forks in the road, Forks in the road. It doesn't start off a bad guy at all, you know, and every time there's just this. Just this comes to this fork in the road, and he takes one decision rather than the other decision, and it sends his life down a completely different, you know, before you know where you are, he's running the T4 euthanasia program, and then he's commandant of Sobibor. It's just amazing. And he wasn't even really a Nazi. I mean, you know, it's sort of. He does this, then this happens, and because of that happens, that makes him then do the next thing, which then makes him.
Al Murray
But.
James Holland
And he's. And he's constantly feeling compromised, and he doesn't know what to do. And he. And he. And he then wrestles and thinks it's okay because such and such is treating it like it's okay. And, you know, I've got to look after my wife and my kids, and I've got to think about my career. And, you know, oh, my God.
Al Murray
It's just.
James Holland
It's just the descent. It's just incredible.
Al Murray
Anyway, one of the things I was looking into was. And I read a very, very funny paper about this, about Hitler, the Hitler's Only Got One Ball song, because, you know, last Year, just before Christmas. There's a thing about where they.
James Holland
Oh, yeah, yeah. They came out, that he might have had only one ball.
Al Murray
Yeah, yeah. And where that song comes from, how it emerged, there's someone who claims his father wrote it, that he was working for the government in propaganda and that he'd written it. Right. But that's probably not true.
James Holland
Might be, might not be, might be, might not be.
Al Murray
Right, but very hard to tell. But what's so interesting is there was an earlier parody. There was an earlier parody from the First World War that goes. That's all the band could play. They played it every day. Tarara, tarara, like that. So it's in the sort of military mind.
James Holland
The tune is there.
Al Murray
The tune is there, right? And then it changes to bollocks. And the same to you. Bollocks. They make a damned good stew. Bollocks mixed up with scallops and a nice tasty asshole or two, right? And sometimes instead of bollocks mixed up with scallops, it's knackers go well with crackers. Right? These are the versions that are bubbling under before the Second World War, right? And then by 1939, Hitler has only got one ball going as two very small. Himmler is rather similar, but poor Goebbels has nobles at all. That's. By the time the war starts, that song has got its boots on. Right, but this paper. So can I read you some of this academics?
James Holland
Yeah, yeah, please do.
Al Murray
A means of ridiculing the Nazis. Hillo's Only Got One Ball became immensely popular among both British and American troops, who, in transmitting this song, were exercising something of a wartime convention by demeaning the sexual faculties of enemy leaders. But the mockery extended further. Since the 1920s, the words balls or ballsy had come to denote notions of courage, nerve and fortitude. In that sense, defective testicles rendered the Nazis defective soldiers. This song's itemized taxonomy of malformed German genitalia, the monorchid, the micro orchid, the anorchid, was particularly forceful and satisfying to Allied soldiers in that it scattered satiric buckshot across the whole Nazi high command. Hitler, Hermann Goering, Commander in Chief of the Luftwaffe, Heinrich Himmler, Reichsphere of the SS Goebbels, Reichs Minister of Propaganda. I mean, imagine sitting down to explain that.
James Holland
Yes, I mean, put that in suede's corner.
Al Murray
There's a play called Dear Dr. Goebbels from 2001, which is a story about. That goes with the song, that supposedly the song tells you what happened then There's, I mean, some really interesting stuff about how, you know, culture studies people have argued about, you know, jokes belong to the black market. Popular humor operates independently of any strategy that the official controllers of wartime propaganda would like to impose on it. I think that's definitely true, but. Did you know. Do you know the other verses?
James Holland
I can't remember.
Al Murray
Rommel has four or five. I guess no one's quite sure about Rudolph Hess. Schmeling is always yelling, but Poirot, Goebbels has no balls at all.
James Holland
Goebbels gets it, doesn't he?
Al Murray
Yeah, Goebbels gets it every time.
James Holland
Is there another verse?
Al Murray
Well, no, there's a longer British version. Hitler has only got one ball. The other is in the Albert Hall. His mother, the dirty bugger, chopped it off when Hitler was small. She threw it into the apple tree. The wind blew it into the deep sea where the fishes got out out their dishes and ate scallops and bollocks for tea. And sometimes instead of Albert hall in Manchester, it's Free Trade Hall, Leeds Town hall in Glasgow. The variant is Kelvin Hall, Northern Ireland, the Ulster Hall. And that this, this guy says, you know, it's the civic participation involved in immortalizing Hitler that. That's what that's telling us, rather than just famous places. People have got that rhyme with ball.
James Holland
That's absolutely amazing. I had no idea, but I remember seeing it a lot when I was kids. It seems to. It seems to have moved away from. From popular common knowledge these days.
Al Murray
Yeah. And there was a Mitchell and Webb sketch about it, I think. Or Armstrong and Miller sketch. I can't remember one of the. One or the other. Armstrong and Miller did a sketch about. They're decoding something and it comes through
James Holland
that, you know, really, really funny.
Al Murray
Yeah, yeah, exactly.
James Holland
Maybe we should do the whole. All verses, all verses that we have Waze Fest with a little bit of a twist.
Al Murray
I think we could. We could, we could add to them.
James Holland
We could do at the end of the show. Can't we bring everyone in for the grand finale?
Al Murray
Grand finale of Hitler's Only Got One Ball. I think there's a lot to be said for that. But I think what's. What is really interesting, though, is that those songs can transmit themselves in an age really pre. You know, you're not. That's not on the telly, it's not on the radio, it's not being put on Tick Tock, it's not on Instagram, it's not how that's transmitting itself across the whole Army. You're pretty certain that everyone in the army would have sung or heard that at some point. And the Air Force and the Navy at some point it would have. The way these things would spread, I think is really, really interesting.
James Holland
Well, I, I' you remember it. I mean, it was, it was 100% a part of the vernacular when I was a nipper.
Al Murray
Yeah, of course it was.
James Holland
Everyone knew that.
Al Murray
It's a little surprising when people don't. Anyway, there's a rabbit hole. Hitler's only got one bull rabbit hole.
James Holland
It's a gray rabbit hole.
Al Murray
It's a tremendous rabbit hole.
James Holland
Yeah, I've enjoyed that.
Al Murray
And of course that they did that test that proved he might have some sort of, some sort of problem, didn't they?
James Holland
Some reduced testicle.
Al Murray
Yeah. From the blood taken from the sofa where he blew his brains out. Thank you very much. I mean, what was quite interesting is when that story came out, it didn't result in a load of pushback from people going, well, he didn't kill himself, but, you know, they used his blood for that test.
James Holland
He went, south America. Maybe everyone's just got bored of that story, the whole South America rubbish.
Al Murray
But when we were talking to Matt Tressida, right, the other day about swimming on the wreck of the Prinz Eugen in the nuclear testing area at Bikini Atoll, this thought crossed my mind, you know, because they build that fleet and it's all U boats. What if. Here's a plot twist for you. What if amongst those U boats was the one with Hitler on that was trying to get to South America, never got there and he got blown up
James Holland
by an atomic test. He got nuked. That's a, that's a great thought, isn't it? After all that.
Al Murray
After all that.
James Holland
And as he was thinking, he just went, oh, scheisse him and Lutchens.
Al Murray
Yeah, he wasn't a Nazi either, Jim. I mean, it is interesting. The German Imperial Navy, the Kriegs before you know that, then, is reborn as a Kriegsmariner. They very much saw themselves as like, like maintaining the imperial tradition. And if the Third Reich is one thing, it's an imperial venture. It's a Reich, it's an empire. Right. So the idea that you could be an old school imperialist, but the new one wasn't quite your taste. That's quite a bendy concept, isn't it?
James Holland
It's a ridiculous way. It's a ridiculous concept. It's so nuts. I mean, the whole thing is so nuts. It's so mad. But then, you know look around the world at the moment. Don't want to get maudlin about it, but you know, cheapers.
Al Murray
Should we look at the Februarys of the war?
James Holland
Well, should we rattle for it? Because we were, we were supposed to do that in the first 10 minutes and here we are 40 minutes in with testicular rabbit holes and we haven't quite got around to it.
Al Murray
Right, okay. So we can include 1939. In 1939. February. So not quite the second world. Well, of course that depends on your point of view. Of course. Because you know, if you are in the Sudetenland, the war has started, right? Because you've been invaded, you've been gobbled up already by Nazi expansionism, by this Reich that isn't like the old Reich. So Hungary joins the anti Comintern pact which is initially signed by Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany back in 1936. Yeah, 36. So Spain and Hungary signed the agreement against the Communist International in 1939. And the puppet government the Japanese got in China signs later in the war. So I mean there's a pretty firm signal of intent for the Hungarians, isn't it that they don't like the Soviets, but also that they are going to align with the Germans.
James Holland
Don't like commies, just don't like commies.
Al Murray
If you're a British Communist, how must the Nazi Soviet Pact, how did you deal with that?
James Holland
Psychologically crushing, absolutely crushing.
Al Murray
The blow that must have constituted. Because, you know, you're paid up, aren't you? You're in as an anti fascist. And lots of people are communist because they're anti fascist, aren't they? Because it's one or the other.
James Holland
But you have to, you have, one has to think of all these countries, you know, Hungary and all the rest of it. All these countries that have just been for centuries, they've, they've been ruled by the Habsburgs and Empire and imperialism and militarism. Suddenly in 1919, all that's gone. And now just to make matters worse, everything you thought you knew and everything you thought was solid and secure and kind of, you know, part of the ancien regime is given a further threat by the advent of lots of Bolsheviks, which is, you know, the last thing you want. So I think you can understand, you know, why there is this split and why it feels so shocking to the
Al Murray
traditional ruling class when the Nazis embark on Barbarossa and they frame it as a crusade against Bolshevism and their European allies join in. A lot of them are paid up in that regard.
James Holland
They Believe it.
Al Murray
And the Finns certainly are and have reason to be. That's the thing. So the next February, Hitler celebrates the 20th anniversary of the Nazi Party of Munich with a speech calling, of course, for the inevitable victory of Germany in the Second World War. Although it's quite a different war in February 1940 to the one he ends up getting.
James Holland
Yeah. And also he's not interested in what's going on at sea, is he? He's not interested in that.
Al Murray
No, he's not worked that out. Neville Chamberlain upholds the independence of Poland by doing nothing, of course, and calls upon Nazi Germany to reject might is right.
James Holland
Well, that's going to count for a lot. You can see that Hitler's likely to be swayed by that. 1941. Then suddenly everything is kicking off and it's now the 21st anniversary of the founding of the Nazi Party. And Hitler, now his tension is turned to the U by war and he announces that it's going to intensify against the Allies in the coming months. Well, that says maybe, but not with. Not with 8U boats it isn't. Or however many he's got in February, I think there's only eight in the Atlantic in February 1941.
Al Murray
Is this when he sent a load to the Med as well? So it's not good if you're doing it, is it? Running. Trying to run that thing from a tiny headquarters, you know, with a small staff and all that. It's not being taken seriously at all, is it? It HMS Dainty. Look, you write to your mum and dad, you say, I'm on HMS Dainty and your mum and dad are. Oh, no, you want to be posted to Invincible, not Dainty.
James Holland
What's happened to Ted?
Al Murray
Yeah, exactly. He's on. He's on Dainty.
James Holland
It's not what we. We. We'd hoped for our boy. We'd wanted him on the Ramillies.
Al Murray
She sunk by a ju88. I think it's quite interesting, isn't it? Because one of the things that emerges about air power in, in naval warfare is that it's difficult to hit ships with bombs, isn't it? It's hard, but when you do it, it's really effective, isn't it? It's the thing.
James Holland
It's worth an awful lot of effort, but if you can do it.
Al Murray
Yeah, exactly, Exactly. So in 1942, an order is issued for the internment of Japanese Canadians, which affects about 90% of the Japanese Canadian population. How big that population is, I don't know. And they weren't granted Full freedom of movement again until 1949. Crikey, that's a bit stiff, isn't it?
James Holland
Well, this is a big one and this is a very controversial one with. In America as well.
Al Murray
Yeah, hugely controversial.
James Holland
Yeah, because Roosevelt does the same, but he doesn't do it for Italian Americans and he doesn't do it for German Americans, but he does for Japanese Americans. And it's got the whiff of racism there. It just has the whiff big time. I mean, it's a big black. It's a bit. It's a black mark against Roosevelt, there's no question about it.
Al Murray
But also, if you had to, if you were going to return all German Americans, I mean, how big are you a prison? Have you got to build camp? Have you got to build.
James Holland
Well, quite. But it's unedifying and it's not good, it's rotten.
Al Murray
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And they get an apology in compensation for the Canadian government in 1988 for their treatment.
James Holland
Yeah, just amazing, isn't it?
Al Murray
And in Norway, this is good stuff. Norwegian bishops mass resign in protest rather than swear fealty to the Quisling government. Wonderful stuff. And I mean, of all things, the Soviets are trying to bump off Franz von Papen in Turkey and they fail to do so.
James Holland
Can you believe it?
Al Murray
What's that all about?
James Holland
And then a British submarine in 1943, in February, third week of February, the U class submarine, which the same ones, of course, that Upholder and Urge and all the rest of it, HMS Vandal is lost with all hands just four days after commissioning, which is the shortest career of a submarine in the Royal Navy's history.
Al Murray
That's awful.
James Holland
Meanwhile, U649 sinks during her training after a collision with U232 in the Baltic. And then not long after that, U232 is then sunk in early July 1943 on her third patrol by a Wellington in the Bay of Biscay with no survivors. So again, your point about bombers dropping bombs on vessels are darn effective if you can make it work.
Al Murray
That was the other thing that happened this week is Jamie Heffer, who looks after Norham Burcham. He's found my friend Dominic's dad in all the records and posted photos of him and everything because he got in touch with his brother. It's just absolutely amazing. And the photo he posted, he is his father is the absolute spit of Dom. It's actually a bit like, oh, my God, it's him in the photo, but in an RAF uniform and without a goatee with Like a natty with a natty beard, you know. Quite extraordinary. Quite extraordinary, yeah.
James Holland
That is.
Al Murray
He met his wife on the station, you know, and she was a. She was a Waf. And there's some photos of the Waffs hanging out.
James Holland
Oh, that's brilliant.
Al Murray
Then the next February 1944, U257 is sunk on her six patrols.
James Holland
Sticking with a naval theme in this one, aren't we? In the third week of February and
Al Murray
she's sunk by the river class frigate Canadian river class frigate HMCS Waskissieux. And the Americans and the Australians capture Irawe in New Britain as part of the much larger Operation Cartwheel.
James Holland
God, that's two of the unpronounceables, isn't it?
Al Murray
Yeah, exactly.
James Holland
Yeah.
Al Murray
It's all quite difficult that in 1945, February 1945, HMS Duckworth, which is a Captain class frigate, it sinks its fifth U boat, U1208, with HMS Rowley in the English Channel. Crikey. The Soviets declare victory in the Lower Silesian offensive and start their start line, forming their start line for the Battle of Berlin. That's to come.
James Holland
Yes, of course, in February 1945 is also operation Veritable. Don't leave that out. Still thundering away. Capturing cleave, etc.
Al Murray
Well, cleave's basically completely flattened, isn't it?
James Holland
There's also, of course, the bombing of Dresden and Fort Sime and Varisoft things and Wurzburg. It's all that, that neck of the woods, isn't it? Plenty going on. That's the truth of it.
Al Murray
Plenty going on. Immense sets of meanwhiles, anyway. Well, I think we've. I think we've war waffled to great aplomb here, Jim. I wish Junior luck in coming up with a title for this show.
James Holland
I can see it's official. Hitler's only got one ball.
Al Murray
Surely we've got tons to come. More series. We're going to be looking at Audie Murphy's extraordinary career in the Second World War, Japan's road to war. We're going to be looking at the visionaries, the thinkers and the movers and shakers on the Allied side of the Second World War and how they arrived. The global security apparatus that maybe is unraveling little at the moment. And the Bruneval raid.
James Holland
Yes, can't wait for that unequivocally successful
Al Murray
operation of the Second World War.
James Holland
Meanwhile, the Channel Dash.
Al Murray
Yeah. Oh, God, we'll have had the Channel Dash by now. Thing is, I think you can explain it. It's easy to explain.
Stephen Fry
If you want.
James Holland
We will do Singapore one time.
Al Murray
We will.
James Holland
One day.
Al Murray
One day we'll get around to it.
James Holland
We'll probably record our lowest ever downloads. No one wants to listen to it. It's too depressing, right?
Al Murray
Our last membership live stream was on Monday the 23rd. The next one is scheduled for March 9th. They're fortnightly live streams on a Monday and they're exclusive for our Patreon subscribers. So please do sign up now. If you go on the Patreon you get live stream membership. You get chunks of audiobook and stuff that I've been reading to go with the series that we've been doing. And you've also got ticket offers and stuff for we have ways Fest 6, which is of course that weekend proper of September later in the year. Thanks very much for listening everybody. We hope you've enjoyed this slab of war waffle. The other is in the Albert Hall. We'll see you soon. Cheerio.
James Holland
Cheerio.
Hershey's Ad Voice
This episode is brought to you by Nespresso Introducing Virtuo up, the latest in a long line of innovation from Nespresso. It's innovation you can touch, sense and taste in every single cup. With a three second start, easy open lever and dedicated brew over ice button, it's even easier to enjoy your coffee your way. Sip for yourself. Shop Virtuo up exclusively@nespresso.com it's tax season.
LifeLock Ad Voice
And at LifeLock, we know you're tired of numbers, but here's a big one
Al Murray
you need to hear.
LifeLock Ad Voice
Billions. That's the amount of money and refunds the IRS has flagged for possible identity fraud. Now here's another big number. 100 million. That's how many data points LifeLock monitors every second. If your identity is stolen, we'll fix it. Guaranteed. 101 last big number. Save up to 40% your first year. Visit lifelock.com podcast for the threats you can't control. Terms apply.
Empire Podcast Host
Troy, the Odyssey, the Iliad. All of these great ancient epics depict a monumental collapse that destroyed the interconnected empires of 3,000 years ago. And to understand the Bronze Age apocalypse that homer wrote about 400 years after it happened, subscribe to Empire Where World History A fellow goal hanger podcast where we are deep diving into the biggest imperial collapse in ancient history. To get a flavor of the series, here is a clip from our episode with none other than Stephen Fry.
Stephen Fry
It is one of my favorite subjects. The story of the Greeks and the siege of Troy and Odysseus return home. Of course I say Greeks. Homer called them The Achaeans, the Danaans, the Argives. The word Greeks is a much later one, but it refers really to the Mycenaeans, a warrior aristocracy essentially obsessed with honor and reputation that would give them an eternal glory. A kleos, as they call it. It's the kleos that's in the name of so many Greeks. You know, Cleopatra and all, the Socrates, Heracles, who's Hercules, you know, Hera's glory. He was actually named Heracles because she hated him, because he was a love child of Zeus. And she never liked Zeus's love childs. Her husband, her errant husband. And so, as an attempt to placate her, Teiresias, because he was born in Thebes, suggested that he change his name as a baby. This was, to Heracles, the glory of Hera.
Al Murray
It didn't help much.
Stephen Fry
It didn't help at all. Athena even put her on Hera's breast when Hera was asleep because it would bond them if he suckled her milk. But she. She woke and saw it and tossed him away, and her breast milk spread across the sky to form the Milky Way.
Al Murray
I didn't know that story because Galaxy,
Stephen Fry
of course, is from the Greek for milk, Galactic, as in lactic. So the chocolate makers are right. Anyway, this is completely separate.
Al Murray
Funnily, though, Cleop, keep going. Don't start. Well, we really hope you enjoyed that clip. To hear more on the Bronze Age
1-800-Contacts Ad Voice
apocalypse and how it shaped the ancient Greek epics, just subscribe to Empire wherever
Al Murray
you get your podcasts.
Podcast: WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk
Hosts: Al Murray, James Holland
Episode Date: February 24, 2026
In this "war waffle" episode, Al Murray and historian James Holland catch up on recent WWII research, share naval history anecdotes, discuss WWII songs and cultural memes, and take a lively, humorous sprint through "the Februarys" of the Second World War. This episode blends deep historical insight with the hosts’ trademark camaraderie and irreverence, offering both vivid storytelling and reflections on how WWII stories—both grand and granular—continue to fascinate.
| Timestamp | Segment / Topic | |---------------|-----------------------------------------------------| | 02:03 | Show proper begins, naval focus | | 05:12 | Convoy stats: Halifax–Britain, not a ship sunk | | 06:32 | Air patrols and U-boat countermeasures | | 09:47 | Impact of air and family history contributions | | 11:24 | Naval archive treasures: Bismarck, trophies | | 15:07 | George Wally, Kennedy & life at sea | | 17:50 | Teaching kids with Lego Sink the Bismarck | | 19:12 | Hilarious student reaction | | 27:33 | Recent book readings: Into That Darkness | | 28:45 | Cultural analysis: "Hitler's Only Got One Ball" | | 35:28 | "Februarys" of WWII year-by-year flash review | | 42:16 | Closing thoughts, future episode teasers | | 43:55 | Membership pitch and sign off |
Witty, discursive, and unafraid of tangents, the show remains deeply rooted in rigorous historical inquiry. The interplay between Al’s comedic instincts and James’s historian's precision keeps the episode accessible, informative, and often laugh-out-loud funny, even while handling dark or complex subject matter.