You Made It Weird with Pete Holmes – Morgan Jay (March 5, 2025)
Episode Overview
In this spirited and genuinely funny episode, Pete Holmes sits down with musical comedian and entertainer Morgan Jay—with frequent cameo-style interjections from Kumail Nanjiani—for an openhearted, hilarious, and at times poignant discussion on the evolution of comedy, crowd work, artistic insecurity, the pressures and joys of going viral, and the surprising realities behind Morgan’s unique show style. As always, Pete peels back the layers of the performer, exploring secret weirdness and what drives comedians to create.
Main Themes
-
Comedy’s Evolution & Experiential Shows: Morgan Jay describes his shift from classic stand-up to a hybrid, music-driven, interactive show, tailored to a younger, attention-fractured audience raised on social media and crowd work clips.
-
Going Viral & The Internet’s Impact: The conversation delves into the viral moment that changed Morgan’s career and the new landscape wherein internet clips can matter more than TV credits.
-
Audience Connection, Pressure & Boundaries: Morgan and Pete discuss the rewards and emotional challenges of crafting “experiences” for fans—especially in the TikTok era—while grappling with the flip side: internet haters, audience entitlement, and artistic pigeonholing.
-
Personal Backstory & Family: Morgan shares stories about his multicultural background, the impact of his father's death, and how his upbringing shapes both his comedic voice and life choices (including childfree living and getting a vasectomy).
Detailed Breakdown & Key Insights
1. Opening Vibes & Early Comedy Days
- The episode begins with quick banter about nervousness before the recording, which segues into Morgan reflecting on his roots performing stand-up in NYC (03:00).
- “I don’t really consider what I do stand up anymore...I’m in the entertainment business now. I’m an entertainer.” — Morgan Jay (03:54)
- Nostalgic tales of NY alt-comedy venues (Housing Works, Knitting Factory) and bombed sets illustrate the long, winding road of comics "coming up" (04:04–10:30).
2. The Social Side of Comedy & Crowd Dynamics
- Morgan and Pete reminisce on the balance between socializing vs. performing as a comic, with Kumail stating: “I like to hang before the show. Get there early. Like you did. See, I’m like you...” (10:42)
- Morgan recounts his time as a NY bike tour guide—an early template for connecting with strangers, improvising, and managing group energy, which now feeds into his stage shows (21:00–21:16).
3. Experiential Comedy, TikTok & The “Second Screen” Audience
- A recurring core topic is how today’s audiences, especially under 25, require more than “just stand-up”—they crave participatory, dynamic experiences to keep them engaged.
- “They really need a show that’s experiential. That’s kind of what my show is...I run into the crowd, I get people to sing, I bring people on stage. It's not just stand-up.” — Morgan Jay (25:38)
- Pete recounts how managers now ask if show pitches pass a “second screen test”: “Like, can someone watch this while they scroll on their phone?” (27:41)
- The three discuss the anxiety and required adaptation behind breaking an hour-long special into TikTok-able segments and the existential weirdness of curating art for an algorithm (26:51–27:19).
4. Viral Moments & Artistic Pigeonholing
-
Morgan opens up about the viral “Ethan” clip that catapulted his show (“...it’s not even a good clip. I tell no punchlines. It’s just a vibe.” — 56:51)
- He underscores how essence and energy, rather than tightly written jokes, can now be a comic’s most powerful tool for audience growth.
- “Your essence comes through... like a whiff of your comedic pheromones.” — Pete Holmes (57:19)
-
On the flip side, “franchised” acts: Morgan describes how his auto-tune crowd work has already been imitated abroad, and how he balances pride, frustration, and acceptance about losing that control (61:20).
- “There’s people doing auto-tune crowd work in Chile, Portugal, Germany...I guess I’m flattered. What am I gonna do, invent Auto-Tune?” — Morgan Jay (61:36)
5. Preparation, Wellness, and the Grind of Touring
- Detailed look at how Morgan preps for high-wire, crowd-driven shows: yoga, vocal exercises, meditation, nebulizer sessions for the voice, staying hydrated, eating light, and learning to manage GERD (gastric issues) and the stress of perpetual travel (50:55–54:56).
Notable Quotes:
- “My audience is so much younger now...they have this brain rot, they can’t lock in.” — Morgan Jay (25:20)
- “There’s like a pressure to make sure the show delivers more than a 60-second clip—how do you turn those 3 minutes into a whole hour?” — Morgan Jay (60:38)
6. Childfree Life, Vasectomies & Social Judgment
- In a frank, funny segment, Morgan and Kumail swap stories about getting vasectomies, including awkward doctor visits and post-procedure sample collection:
- “I want to go to a doctor and have them put me in a room. That’s not a jerk off room. It’s just an examination room. It's the least erotic environment.” — Morgan Jay (46:41)
- The discussion turns personal—Morgan and his partner have chosen to remain childfree, triggering both support and musings on societal expectations.
- “We just want to really raise two beautiful bank accounts and use that money to...send the bank to college.” — Morgan Jay (48:05)
- Pete and Kumail express support: “Having kids is not for everybody...it’s so ingrained in our culture, the Game of Life...but you don’t have to do anything you don’t want to do.” — Kumail Nanjiani (48:27)
7. Audience Participation: Joy, Entitlement & The ‘Dance Trap’
- Morgan describes both the magic and stress of interactive shows in big venues—audience members get upset if their section wasn’t picked to sing, or if they don’t get a joke or DM read.
- “Even when I did Kansas City or St. Louis, they’re like, you didn’t come to our section, you didn’t ask us to sing...there’s 2,000 people here!” — Morgan Jay (72:32)
- Pete draws the parallel to Ellen DeGeneres’ famous “dance trap”—when what starts as a bit becomes an audience mandate (63:09).
8. Roots, Family & Comedy Origin Stories
- Morgan talks movingly about the impact of losing his father at age 6, his multicultural roots (Sicilian/Argentine/Brazilian), his father’s life as a “singing chef,” and finding his way into comedy.
- The joy of being able to now bring his mother on stage at a sold-out NYC show—the full circle of “making it” after years of struggle (111:01–113:10).
- “To her credit, she’s just a happy boy...Now I’m bringing her on stage at a sold-out show.” (98:41, 111:17)
- Humorous anecdote about bombing at Caroline’s, and his mother’s frank feedback: “We didn’t really say anything in the car last night because you were awful.” (114:17)
9. Art vs. Entertainment and Evolving the Act
- Wrestling with impostor syndrome: “I wouldn't say my show is funny, it’s a fun show...We're going to be transitioning even more to a concert type of show.” — Morgan Jay (68:38)
- Morgan describes his philosophy: “I'm a big believer in not trying to be the best, but trying to evolve the most.” (84:11)
- From acoustic sets to roaming cameras and bands, he details the technical and creative leaps required as shows outgrow intimate rooms.
10. Philosophy of Connection, Hosting, and Responsibility to Fans
- Morgan takes pride in “hospitality”—thinking through audience sight-lines, the effort people make to attend a show, and their emotional stakes.
- “You want to make sure they have a good night...You might be the last thing between them and a divorce!” (109:01)
- On responsibility, pleasing the crowd, and the dangers of “people-pleasing” as a performer.
Memorable Moments & Quotes
Crowd Joy vs. Haters
“Does anybody else think this shit isn’t funny? ...The kind of person who doesn’t like what I do is like someone at a wedding who refuses to dance.” — Morgan Jay (05:25, 05:30)
On Going Viral
“It was one clip. The ‘Ethan’ clip. ...It's just like a vibe... The energy of the show comes through.” — Morgan Jay (56:51, 57:00)
On Artistic Copycats
“My act has been franchised. There’s people doing auto-tune crowd work in Chile, Portugal, Germany. ...I'm flattered. I'm not gonna, like, file a suit. What am I gonna do? Invent Auto-Tune?” — Morgan Jay (61:36)
On Prepping for Shows
“We’re gonna do yoga. We're gonna try to meditate. ...Be quiet, hydrate…probably use a nebulizer for my voice.” — Morgan Jay (50:55)
On Family Legacy
“My dad was a pop star in Argentina…when he moved to America, became a chef...In New York at the time, you could go to a restaurant, he'd cook, then come out with a guitar and sing.” — Morgan Jay (96:12–96:54)
On Parenting Choices
“We just want to really raise two beautiful bank accounts and use that money to send the bank to college and watch it grow up.” — Morgan Jay (48:05)
On Hospitality and Show Responsibility
“Be your first fan. Be the first person to buy your own merch... because if you don't, how can you expect other people [to]?” — Morgan Jay (108:06)
“You want to make sure they have a good night. You might be the last thing between them and a divorce.” — Morgan Jay (109:01)
On Joy of Laughter
“Giannis [Pappas] said once, we’re all just trying to be as funny as a fart.” — Morgan Jay (117:36)
“There are good comedians, and there are just funny people who are sometimes good comedians.” — Kumail Nanjiani (116:57)
Timestamps for Important Segments
- Morgan’s Reimagining of Stand-up – 03:43–04:01, 21:41–25:21
- Bombing, Early Gigs, Comedy Roots – 04:13–10:40
- Touring and Virus Impact on Comedy – 25:45–27:41
- Viral Clip & Social Media Impact – 56:43–60:38
- Auto-Tune Crowd Work & Copycats – 61:14–63:07
- Touring Prep, Health & Wellness – 50:55–54:56
- Vasectomy & Childfree Choices – 46:07–50:13
- Hospitality in Performance – 108:06–109:27
- Funniest Moments and Lasting Joy – 115:56–117:36
- Musical Improv & Outro – 118:14–120:57
Episode Highlights & Listener Takeaways
- If You’re an Aspiring Comic: The episode offers both a masterclass and a reality check on the modern career—resilience, adaptability, and genuine connection matter more than ever.
- For Fans of Morgan Jay or Live Comedy: This episode is both an introduction to Morgan’s creative process and an honest, human look at the price and reward of making art that connects in the age of the internet.
- Big Laughs and Soft Heart: Underpinning all the riffing is a friendship and warmth that lets Morgan discuss vulnerability, grief, and artistic insecurity with the same playful energy as his crowd work.
Closing Thought
As Pete says, “You create an environment of joy and silliness and playfulness that is the opposite of atrophy and decay. It’s very alive, what you do.” (04:53)
Whether “funny” or just “fun” or “horny and goofy,” as Morgan puts it, this episode is a celebration of artistic evolution, collective joy, and the weird, unexpected ways real connection happens in the modern age of comedy.
“Keep it crispy!” — Morgan Jay (120:44)