
In this heartfelt episode, Kimberley Quinlan and relationship therapist Elizabeth Shaw explore how to manage the anxiety, grief, and pressure that often come with dating and the fear of never finding love.
Loading summary
A
Hello, my friends. Welcome back to your anxiety toolkit, the show where we talk about how to build a life you love while managing anxiety, ocd, panic, and all the challenging emotions that come with it. My name is Kimberly Quinlan, and today we're tackling one of the biggest fears so many of us face, which is, what if I never find true love? Whether you're single or feeling hopeless, struggling with dating anxiety, or stuck in a relationship that doesn't feel quite right, relationship fears can feel overwhelming. The fear of being alone, the pressure of timelines, the exhaustion of putting yourself out there, it's a lot. And that's why I'm so thrilled to have Elizabeth Earnshaw with us today. Elizabeth is a renowned relationship therapist and author who has helped countless people navigate love, dating, and partnership with wisdom and self compassion. So no matter where you are in your love journey, this conversation is for you. We're here to bring you some assurance and tools and maybe even change the way you think about love. One that's a little less pressured and a lot more helpful. So thank you, Elizabeth, for being on the show.
B
Thank you for having me.
A
All right, this has been one of the most requested topics, and it's a topic that I did not feel confident tackling on my own. So thank you for being here.
B
Yeah, well, thank you for being here too, because this is a difficult topic, so hopefully we can tackle it together.
A
Yeah, yeah. I mean, I can do all the things anxiety, but this is one where I really genuinely, like, I. I don't know all the answers, and I feel like I'm not as in touch with the solutions here, so I'm so grateful you're here. Let's sort of get to sort of this main core fear that people have, which is that they fear that they won't find love or true love. How can someone manage the anxiety of feeling like true love or finding this, like, idea of the quote, unquote, the one is out of reach?
B
Well, I want to start by saying that I think this is. It's really challenging to navigate the feelings around. You know, what if I never find somebody? What if I'm alone forever? Because, number one, for many people, it feels like it's a core need. So with other anxieties, like, what if I don't get this job? Or what if I don't, you know, whatever it is, you might be able to navigate around it being a core need. Right. You might be able to say, well, what if, you know, like, the worst case scenario is that I never do that? Or the worst case scenario is that my boss yells at me or whatever it is. But the what if here feels very embedded in a core meat for many people. Right. And so it's the what if is, well, if, if I don't meet anybody, then I'll be alone. And like that is truly a big fear for me. It's something that feels like if I'm alone for the rest of my life, is that going to meet these desires that I have for life. So I always like to start when people come into the therapy room by saying it makes complete sense that this is painful for you, it's challenging, it's overwhelming, and that it could cause a lot of distress because it might feel like it's related to a deep core need. With that being said, there are ways that we can figure out how to manage the intensity of the anxiety that's related to, to that fear. So we're not saying you're not going to feel any anxiety about it ever. Right. What we can say is let's figure out how to deal with the intensity. Like your fear that you're never going to meet somebody. What is that like for you? What are some of the intense thoughts and feelings that come up for you physically, mentally? Let's talk about those things first first. And then let's talk about some ways that we can reduce the intensity. Because I'm never going to talk somebody out of being anxious about it if they really want to meet somebody. I'm not going to say you're never going to feel anxious. You're going to be completely Zen. There might be a small population of people that say, I could feel completely Zen about never having that. And what we can say is we can feel anxious about something, sad about something, worried about something, and not have it take over our lives.
A
So how I love that you're talking about the intensity, because I think it is, it's a value based fear, meaning like it's in line with their values to have a partner. It's what they want. How can someone manage that intensity?
B
I think that it also depends on how their anxiety is presenting itself. If we're thinking about with relationships the way that anxiety presents itself, there's usually a few different ways. One is that some people feel completely kind of collapsed and frozen under the anxiety. So you might see somebody who is saying, I really want a partner, but I cannot put myself out there. Like I will not put myself on a dating app. I, I just, I can't even fathom what it would be like to be rejected or to Be seen. That is too scary for me. And so you have somebody that desperately wants this thing, but they feel so overwhelmed by the anxiety of it that they aren't actually doing anything to engage in it. And with this type of person, you want to help empower them. Like, number one, we can soothe some of these responses so that you're not feeling so collapsed anymore, so that you feel like, even if it's a little scary, like, can we. We can't control that somebody is going to fall in love with us or date us, but we can control the odds a little bit. And so if we can get somebody empowered, what are some things that are a little less scary to do? I know it feels really scary to go on the dating app, but would it feel a little less scary to just look at a dating app, like, make a fake profile and scroll through and see who's going there and give these little steps to this person who feels completely overwhelmed and shut down? We also have people who feel very anxious about, am I never going to find somebody? And what happens to them is they're very activated by their anxiety. And so they are always on the dating apps and they are going on all the dates, and somebody treats them like crap, and they date them for a very long time because I'm not going to find anybody. And they kind of can't figure out, like, why am I in all of these horrific relationships? And their fear is like, oh, my God, I might just have a lifetime sentence. These horrible people where I'm dating, and then like, two months in, they ghost me or whatever. But I. I'm so anxious that I still talk to them the next week or whatever it is. And so with them, there's kind of, can we start to think about life in broader terms? Can we think about, where else are you deriving pleasure? Where else are you feeling connected? Because this is a value of connection, right? And are you making any space for that? And so with one type of anxiety, we're. And I would love to hear, like, kind of some of the things that you would tell people to manage the sensation of it. But with one type, we're like, how do we lean in in very small, very safe ways? Where we are, we can safety check. We can say, all right, I'm very afraid of rejection. So what if I just look at first and notice how that feels my body, just to see who's there? I can make a fake account for a little bit, and then maybe the next time I make a real account, but I don't have to engage. I just see what that feels like. But then on the other side, it's, what does it feel like to pull back a little bit? What does it feel like to say, I'm, I'm really afraid that I'm never going to meet anybody? And actually I'm so activated by this, putting so much energy into it. What would it be like if this week I said, I'm only going to get on my dating apps twice a day instead of scrolling on them as if they're Instagram? So that's kind of like a initial answer to this very big question. But there's a lot of different ways that this manifests, and depending on how it manifests is how we want to look at how do we help people.
A
Yes. And so I think I'm in the head of. I know a lot of my clients and my listeners, and I think the question they immediately have to this is this sort of urgency of, like, but is there the one?
B
Like, is that a thing?
A
Is it that there is one person and we have to find them? Sort of like the needle in the haystack kind of thing? Or is it because that idea creates a lot of anxiety, even for me, thinking about, like, if I had to date and find the one, Yikes. Like, how would I trust myself to know who that person would be? Especially some of the people ask, like, they've been hurt in the past or they've, you know, so is there. I know it's a personal decision, an idea, but is there the one? What are your thoughts on that?
B
Yeah, I think it's a great question. And I think when people are suffering under this pressure of I need to find somebody, that idea is usually very prevalent. So there's kind of this, like, layer of perfectionism in there, which we know goes hand in hand with anxiety. Right. So there's this idea of if I do this the right way, I present myself the right way, or I read the red flags the right way or whatever it is, I'm going to find the one. So now I have this meta level of pressure on top of me, and I've added a new layer of anxiety. So not only am I afraid I'm going to be alone forever, but I'm also afraid I'm going to pick the wrong person. And so you kind of get pummeled under the weight of that. I've worked with hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of couples, so I've seen people once, and I've worked with individuals who are in the place where the listeners are right Now I'm never going to meet anybody. And then I've also worked with them once they meet somebody and they marry them and they're with them. And what I can say is there is not the one. There are a lot of different people in the world that could work as your partner. And that takes some of the romance out of it. Right. And in those early days, we need that romance because it like, motivates us and it builds these good feelings that are like, yes, I want to be with you forever because you're the only one I could ever love. And that's not a bad thing to feel that when it's happening necessarily. However, if the idea is giving you anxiety, I think it's really important to recognize that what the One is, ideally, when you're thinking, when I'm looking at couples who come to couples therapy, is a person who's going to be a good partner to you. And there are so many people out in the world who can be a good partner to you specifically. And there are many people who will not be a good partner to you specifically and will be a good partner to somebody else. But instead of us hyper focusing on like these feelings that we're going to have, like excitement and love and da da da da, which I, I hope for everybody to have, it's feels good. What you really want to think about is the vast number of people out there who would be a good partner, who would be somebody who want to work, wants to work with you on life, life goals. How does life feel day to day? Somebody who wants to accept your love, somebody who wants you to make their life feel better as well. Somebody who has some of the same values and goals as you. And so there's not the One. And I've met with many couples who, they've met the One. And this might add more anxiety. They've met the One and then six years later, that person is not the one anymore. Yeah, and there's many people who meet the One and six years later that person is the One. And the more that people hyperfocus on am I getting it perfect? You know, am I having the exact feelings that TV tells me I should have? Or did I read enough into their dating profile or did you know, are they giving me red flags or whatever it is. The more that you do that and you don't allow yourself to get to know people and connect with people over like, would you be a good partner in a human way? Not in a supernatural way, in a human way, the more you hyper focus on it. The less options you're going to have.
A
I'm so relieved that you say this. I was actually worried that you were going to say, like, yes, there is the one. Keep going. But, you know, I'm pretty open on the podcast. Like, I've been married for 22 years. I love my partner, but we choose to be married every day. That's why we've stayed married. Not because it was easy. We just keep choosing to stay married. And for me, that I know, I love the idea of the romance and the fantasy and all of that, but the real safety, I think, is being with someone where you're willing to be growing together and be curious. And I think for me is when I take the pressure off them being perfect and just focus more on how can I show up in a way that's value based and that is authentic to me. I get less perfectionistic, I get less nitpicky and anxious. And because I'm like, no, I can. I've got to control my side of this Lane. And I have seen so many clients where as they're dating, they. They're either so zoomed in on the person they're dating on checklists.
B
Yes.
A
Or so zoomed in on themselves on am I being perfect, Acting perfect, not being awkward and so forth. And they're missing the actual connection.
B
Yes. I love that you just brought that up, because I think that what gets missed is what is real life actually going to be like? Like when you're dating somebody and you're zooming in on these checklists, like, do I look perfect? Am I funny enough? Do I ask the right questions? I read a blog that said I shouldn't have asked this on a first date. Oh, my God, what's wrong with me or this person? They said something weird in the first text. And, like, I read something and it says, they shouldn't do that. Should I never see them again, even though I'm interested? Like, that's not real life. You know, you've been married a long time. I've been married a long time. Like, in real life, we're dealing with life day to day. And I am. I do not have the time anymore to be like, am I pretty enough today? Did I ask the question in the perfect way when I was running out the door that I had to ask the afternoon, or did my partner do that? And I think that in some ways, our anxiety and this need to find a perfect partner, which I think is also very much fueled by our information age of like, yes. Oh, gosh. There's so much out here that's saying if I don't do it right, I'm going to end up miserable. And I think it takes us sometimes out of being real people with each other, we're like, okay, yes, if you're awkward on a date, let's just say the reality is that there might be a person who says, that's too awkward for me. That is true. And I think sometimes dealing with anxiety is actually looking at the worst case scenario. So you go on that date and you say something real weird or you ask a question that is it meant to be asked on a first date? And I'm putting is it meant to? In quotes. Yes, it is so possible that the person leaves and says, oh, that was so weird. I'm never going to go on a date with them again and send you a text and says, I didn't feel it, but does that mean that that person wouldn't have worked with you in real life anyway? And so when you say my worst case fear is if I don't get it right, if I don't act right or I don't pick them right, that I'm going to get rejected, that actually shouldn't be your worst fear. Your worst fear should be if we don't both act like ourselves to the best of our ability. We don't want to put anxiety on that either. But if I don't try to be me and just kind of notice how they feel in my presence and allow them to be them and that I'm going to end up in a relationship where it's all about us matching each other's checklist and living a life through what Instagram says or a blog says or whatever, or my anxiety says, but, like, can do I actually, can I be like my real self with this person? Because in 15 years, I'm certainly still going to say something awkward for sure.
A
And isn't that so true that if we put on this perfect Persona, you're attracting someone who wants that perfect Persona, not the imperfect actual you?
B
Yeah, exactly. I, you know, like, full disclosure, I used to have terrible anxiety in dating. So I can relate very much with this. I. All I wanted was a relationship and to be married and have babies. And I was like hitting my 30s and hadn't met anybody and I was, I was very anxious and so I was going on lots of dates and I was trying to be perfect, right? Like, what, what am I supposed to look like? What are the types of questions I should ask? Like being very amenable to them, if they liked this food or if they wanted to go out at a certain time, I'm going to do it because I just want to meet somebody. And what if I never meet anybody? And at some point, I started working on my own differentiation, right? Like, I am me whether I'm with somebody or not with somebody. And how can I feel like me? How can I just be me? And the second I started doing that, I actually started getting rejected. Way more. Like, the other things, they weren't, like, big rejections, right? Like, we would go on a few dates and then maybe would, like, simmer out because it wasn't right. But as soon as I started to be like, oh, I'm going to actually, like, express my real opinion when somebody asks me something at dinner, or if they ask me, can you do 11pm on a Friday? Because I'm a doctor and I'm in residency and I can't meet until 11, I would say no. Like, I can't. Not because I'm dislike you or I want to change you, but just. It doesn't work for me. I work Saturday mornings. As soon as I did that, I started getting a lot more messages of, like, I don't think this is going to be a good fit. I don't know if we're going to work out. And because I had been working on that ability to be differentiated, those messages didn't sting very much. That, and I had been putting so much work into avoiding that rejection before that I was, like, living in this state of pain all the time. Like, these people aren't rejecting me, but I still feel it. I'm still afraid of it. And it wasn't happening, but it still felt bad. But the second that I was able to lean into, like, I'm gonna take a deep breath. I'm gonna hold on to, like, myself. I did start getting actual verbal rejections. And the pain wasn't as bad as my fear thought it was going to be.
A
Oh, it's so hard. It's so painful because it. Let me ask this, Amara, as a question. Would you agree that it hits on their core beliefs about themselves that they had before they were dating? Meaning, like, my body's not right, or I'm not smart enough, or I'm not pretty enough, or I'm not girly enough, or do you feel like that is why people are coming with this? Or is it because? Or I've had clients, when I've talked to them about that, they'll say no. It's actually harder to date now.
B
Like, yeah, I think it's both. I think sometimes the anxiety. And I'd like to hear your opinion, too. I think sometimes the anxiety is actually related to, like, dating is kind of the symbol, but the anxiety is really, like, I don't look good enough. I'm not smart enough. Like, all of these things that have already been pain points.
A
Yeah.
B
And they show up in this dating situation as, like, the symbol I'm afraid to date. But really it's because I'm afraid I'm ugly or I'm afraid I'm not lovable or something like that. And so with that, that's also sometimes coupled or not coupled with the other experience of actually this has been really, really bad, and I've developed anxiety because of how genuinely bad the dating world is right now, where I'm. I truly am treated poorly, and I am truly rejected for no reason that I can. I can't even figure it out because I actually don't have these other anxieties. Yeah. Yep. And that's hard in the therapy room. That's hard. Like, if I'm talking to somebody, it sounds like you've had similar. Where it's like, okay, if we. If this is connected to, like, a sense of I'm not good enough, we can work with that a little bit. Yep. Like, okay, let's focus on that. But if it's somebody saying, I actually feel good enough. Yeah. I don't feel like I've been withdrawn or too anxious or I. I feel like I've presented a differentiated version of myself. Yeah. This experience has been so bad that now I. I just. I've lost hope. Yeah. And I've worked with a lot of people who. I do believe that that is their experience.
A
That's the hardest piece of this as a clinician and as a friend, and I'm sure as the person suffering with this is. These are truly, like, the folks listening to this, that my anxious, lovely community. Like, they're usually all incredibly intelligent, funny, complete, lovable people. Like, these people are so lovable.
B
With my clients, I'm always like, I wish that you guys could, like, see each other in the waiting room and fall in love. I know.
A
I know.
B
I know. I know all of you behind the scenes, and I even like your. You with your deep, dark secrets. I still. I still would recommend you to somebody. That's what I'm saying.
A
And so in my mind, when they say they've been ghosted multiple. Like a couple times or multiple times in a row, and they're. They're Literally go. And maybe they've talked to a family member or a friend, and now they're trying to think, like, what is they doing wrong?
B
And.
A
And all we can both come up with is like, I really don't think anything. Yeah, I really don't think you're doing anything wrong. What would you say to that?
B
What.
A
What do we do when it doesn't make sense in the dating world? Because I think our natural analytic mind is like, okay, there has to be an algorithm here. There has to be, like, if something has happened multiple times or I've been ghosted or I've been rejected multiple times, it must. There must be a solution. There must be a problem.
B
Right. What are your thoughts? Yeah, I mean, I think that this is actually one of the hardest types of anxieties to get past, because like I was saying before, if there is something that feels algorithmic, there's something you can work on. Right. If it's like, okay, the reason I'm having trouble is because truly my relational anxieties make me push people away. If I can work on bringing it in, having boundaries, whatever it is, maybe. Maybe things will open up for me, or I'm not confident enough in social situations. Let me work on that. Feels like, okay, I can change something. But when I'm working with people where we do come to the conclusion of like, look, we've talked about this. I've been with you through it. You've shown me some of the messages. I don't think you're doing anything wrong. And I don't know that being on more dating apps or being on less or saying it this way or that way is cool going to give you any sort of certainty. Yeah. First of all, I think just validating that is really hard and its own type of pain to say things are actually out of my hands in this in some ways because I've done the work, I'm presenting how I want to be. I'm actually showing up as me. Honestly, authentically, I'm not hiding. I'm not being. You know, this is my whole life. It's just something that I think I'm showing up well with. I think validating. Well, that really sucks. And it's similar with any. A lot of different types of loss, actually. Yeah, you're not responsible for that loss. And so often with. With clients who are dealing with this, we talk about grief. Yeah. You know, it's. It's like if somebody's struggling with fertility, for example, you might talk about grief where it's like, you aren't causing this. No. You've done all the things and like, I'm not going to be able to tell you some potion that's going to change this for you. In fact, it makes sense that you feel anxious. It makes sense that you feel sad. And I think it's similar in the dating world where it's like, there's not much else you can do to make this a certainty.
A
Yeah.
B
And maybe like, it doesn't mean you're never going to meet anybody. I think that's important to remember. But it's also okay to say I'm 32 and I wanted to have kids by this point and be in a marriage. And I'm not. And I want to grieve that. I'm not going to grieve that forever. I'm going to be alone because I don't know that. But I'd like maybe to. To let that person grieve now about what they feel like they've lost in the here and now and actually feel that. I think sometimes when we have anxiety, it can be pent up other feelings. So, you know, you're feeling that anxiety, but also like, what would happen if we just sat with how sad you are, that even though you're showing up in a healthy way for yourself, for other people, it's not working. And that at 28, 32, 45, 60, whatever age you are, you thought things would be different.
A
Yeah, yeah. I mean, that speaks to so much of this. I do agree that the anxiety and the grief go hand in hand. And often we stay in anxiety and trying to troubleshoot it so that we don't have to feel the grief. And it brings me to a common question I get asked is, okay, let's say we make space for the grief. But I'm constantly seeing on social media this one's birth announcement and this one's engagement announcement and the gender reveal and all the things. It can be so hard. I think that grief and anxiety go hand in hand when you're watching other people's perfect role instead of their imperfect role that we see. How might someone manage seeing other people's success in this area when they're struggling?
B
It's so hard because in these experiences, often you're being pulled in multiple emotional directions. And then there's this other layer of like how you feel about being pulled into multiple directions. And so what I mean by that is let's say that your friend calls you. It's your best friend in the world. You love them so much. All they've ever wanted is to have a baby. And they call you and they say, I'm pregnant. And you are feeling like you're never going to meet anybody. And you've also always wanted a family and a child and all of those things. And so in that moment, you're. There's a part of you that is thinking, I should be really excited for my friend. Or maybe in fact, I am excited and happy for my friend, but it is overshadowed by my pain that's being reflected in this message being sent to me. Like, I'm seeing this kind of mirror of where I wish I was. I'm not. And it brings up this really incredible pain, anxiety, whatever. It brings up anger, maybe even towards your friend. Like, why are you sharing this with me? You know, I've been. I was just broken up with, or I haven't been able to find anybody. And so you're. You're having this tension within yourself of, like, what is it that I'm supposed to feel right now? And should I feel shame about the primary feeling I'm having? And I work with a lot of people that are like, I feel this primary. I feel a lot of anger towards my friend for inviting me to another baby shower when they know I'm. When they know I'm struggling. But I feel shame that I feel that because I also love my friend. And if I could step out of this anger I feel or this disappointment I feel for myself, I think I would be celebrating them. And so now I also feel loss because I can't celebrate my friend. I should be able to live a life where I get to jump up and down for my friend because I feel like I'm also jumping up and down for myself. But instead I'm living a life where I'm pitying myself and I'm putting my friend's happiness down. And now this feels really shitty all around, and I don't like myself for that. And so you're having the feelings related to what's happening, but you're also then having feelings about yourself, and that is really challenging. And when I'm working with people with this, and I'd also love to hear what. What you do, because it's so hard is it's a lot of kind of like dialectics, right? Like, well, let's peel apart the fact you can actually feel a lot of different things. The human nature is to say, well, which one am I feeling? I can only be feeling one. But what would it be like to say, I feel angry with my friend and I also feel silly for feeling angry with my friend. Yeah. I feel so happy for my friend. I can't wait to meet their baby. I can't wait to meet their fiance, whatever it is. And it actually breaks my heart. Yeah. To think about meeting their fiance and I might cry when I go to their wedding for myself. And so getting to that place with somebody, it's like you, you actually can feel all of these things. And what would it be like to just feel them and, like, let that person and for anybody listening, like, let yourself cry that your friend has met a partner. Yep. And then also say to yourself, okay, what else do I feel here? Is there other spaces inside of me? Am I also. This, this big space feels so sad. This small space feels happy. I think that when that doesn't totally work, you can also talk about, like, boundaries that you set. Not with, like, changing the person, but changing how you take in the information. So, like, if you keep getting hit with social media, like, people you hardly know anymore, like, don't get on and look at your high school friends.
A
Yeah.
B
On social media. And then feel kind of sad. So, like, maybe all you can take in is the happiness happening for your best friend, not for, like, the 10,000 people that you follow on social media. So you might have to put limits. And, like, how much do I give right now? I've had clients who have had to, you know, be honest with their friends. Yeah. Happy with you. And also, I know you want me to be your maid of honor, but I want to be really honest that, like, I'm just so depressed myself that I don't know if that role is going to be perfect for me right now. And I want you to have a happy wedding and I don't want to ruin that, but I wonder if, like, I could be in the bridal party instead or be a guest celebrating you instead. But those are also hard conversations to have. But I would love to know, like, your thoughts and.
A
No, I. I feel really empowered by that and it's giving permission again. I think it comes from that perfectionism that I'm supposed to handle this beautifully and well and be happy. But it's okay for this to be really yucky and hard and to have grief and anxiety about it because it is anxiety provoking and very sad. As well as that, I've also encouraged my patients and clients to find friends who are at the same stage as you so that you're in community with other people. And you can. Even if it means, like, you show up lovingly to the wedding. But together you kind of roll your eyes together and joke about it and that's okay. That's not ill hearted. That's just we're commiserating on the dating and we have someone to check in who's also in this dating pool with me or is also struggling with similar stresses. So I always sort of say like, if you can widen your community to having like minded people, it can feel more validating. You can, because I think a lot of this is you feel alone, you feel like you're the only one.
B
Yes. And I think that's so important with any life stage to think about it as life stages. And we all go through them differently. There's no timeline. Regardless of the life stage you're in, you're going to need to find your people. And I think that can also be really challenging. Is sometimes it's like, well, this friend is getting married and now I'm alone and they're with all these married people. And it's like, well yeah, your friend needed probably to find other people that maybe understood or whatever it is. It doesn't mean they're leaving you in the dust. But what it does mean is like you also need that type of community who is wanting to do the same things, needs the same type of support, needs to roll their eyes at the same types of things. Like your friend might be needing a friend, they can roll their eyes about their partner too. You need a friend that you can roll your eyes and say, oh my gosh, guess who just sent me a message that they're engaged. Now another one bites them the dust. And that that friend can say like, yeah, wtf? Like why do we always have to get this information like when's happening for us? And then there will be other life stages that you go through and you will need to meet people that kind of meet you there too. And so just thinking of this is like, this is where I'm at in life and I need people who are also there and trying to find those people.
A
Yes. This is so beautiful. I have one more question and I'm sort of circling back, but I feel like we could finish here. But actually I actually think I have two questions. But one question I wonder if my listeners are asking is like, okay, I'm anxious. What do I actually do on the date if I'm 10 out of 10 anxious?
B
That's hard. So what do you do on the date if you're 10 out of 10 anxious? Like likely you've been amping up since before the date you didn't just become the 10 out of 10. The moment you got there, maybe all day you've been thinking about it. And first of all, really hard, uncomfortable. I think that as you're leading up to it, what are the practices that you're doing physiologically for yourself before going on the date? So often the most uncomfortable part of anxiety is how it's feeling in your body. Yes, you can deal with the thoughts more than you think you can, because the pain in your body, the discomfort in your body is telling you that you're dying. That's actually what's happening. So whenever we feel that something is threatening, somebody going on a date can feel threatening. We are going to have a stress response to that. Right. And so if you feel that the date is so threatened, threatening that your body is kind of translating that as I could die. Which I know sounds silly, but is realistic, because anything relational can make your body think that then what's going to happen is you're going to have all these stress hormones pumped into your body and they are going to put you in fight, flight, or freeze. And you're going to feel that leading up to whatever this threat is. And so the first thing I tell people is, let's pay attention to how do you soothe that stress response first. So your body is thinking, I'm in danger. And its heart is pumping. Your heart is pumping really quickly. Your muscles are tensing, and your brain is going to start getting foggy because the only thing it should be focusing on is getting you to survive. So when you hear it tell you, maybe I should cancel the date, that's just survival. It's saying, play dead. Don't go to the lion's den. Just stay here and maybe nobody will see you and you won't die. So instead, what I want you to try to do is think about just one of those body parts that is impacted by the distress and try to soothe it. So heart, muscles, brain, all of those things are being impacted. And lungs, sorry. And so what you're going to be doing is you're going to say, okay, my lungs are impacted. I can tell that I'm like, feeling like I can't breathe. I'm just gonna sit here and I'm gonna breathe. Because if I breathe, I'm telling my body that a lion isn't waiting on that date to eat me, that I'm actually safe. I don't need to run, I don't need to play dead, don't need to fight. I can just be so you can breathe, you can do muscle relaxation, which is tensing all of your muscle groups. You can look this up online. Tensing all your muscle groups and letting them go. Tensing them, letting them go. Or, you know, to deal with the brain, you can do some sort of creative endeavor leading up to the date. So drawing, writing, listening to music, any of those types of things. And then dealing with the heart is dealing with, like letting your body know that you are actually moving and some way. So exercising, it could be any type of exercise. Taking a walk, yoga, going for a run. So all of these things are helping you to complete that stress cycle. Your hormones spiked. They said you're in danger. Now you're going to tell it. I'm not in danger. Look, I'm breathing, I'm exercising, I'm drawing. These are things I would not do when I'm in danger. So doing those types of things can help with that physiology. Now the second thing that can be helpful is that as you're dealing with that physiology, those thoughts are like running amok. What if, what if I say something weird? What if this is terrible? Like, what if I freeze up and I can't even speak? So just noticing those thoughts and then like letting them pass you, you know, I, I notice that. I'm really worried that if I go on this date, I'm gonna say something weird. Okay, I might say something weird. I noticed that if I say something weird, I'll never see the person again. Maybe. And that might be the worst case scenario. But my biggest advice is always deal with the physiology first, because the thoughts are there and they might not go away until after the date. But if you can deal with the fact that your heart is beating so loud it's in your ears, that's going to help you feel a little more relaxed. Yeah.
A
Amazing. Thank you. Okay, last question. Okay. If someone is feeling hopeless about their love life right now, what is one thing you would want them to hear?
B
Well, I think the first thing I would want them to hear is that I understand the pain related to not finding somebody to partner with. You know, we are species that likes to be with others. And we go from a primary home to wanting many of us to wanting to build some sort of secondary home when we grow up. Right. Having that person. And so I think first you need to have compassion for yourself. Compassion means telling yourself it makes sense that I feel this way and I love myself and I'm sorry that I feel this way and I'm going to let myself feel sad and be gentle with myself on that. The second Thing I think is really important, though, is to work on regaining hope that you will find connection in life. Because this is about connection. That that feels good for you, and that part of that work is learning how do I feel really connected to myself? Not as a replacement. I'm not going to be like, oh, it's a replacement. You can love yourself like you might. You might still grieve that you don't have that other person. But how do you feel connected with yourself enough that you feel like in all of your connections, romantic friendships, whatever it is, that you're you and that you're showing up as you and then second, to kind of regain some of this hope. How do you empower yourself to say, although I cannot control who I meet, when I meet them, if I meet them, what I can control is the way that I still put myself out into the world. And I can be hopeful because I don't know the future. I can be hopeful that if I am connected to me, if I show up as me, and if I keep making friends, showing up for hobbies, being open to meeting new people, that there is hope. Because hope is not certainty. Hope is different than certainty. And, you know, you need to be able to lean into. I feel uncertain, but I also feel hopeful instead of I need to be certain or I'm completely hopeless.
A
Yeah, Again, that's the dialectics of, you know, allowing two different things to be true at the same time. Amazing. I cannot thank you enough. I'm so grateful that you are here to have this conversation again. Everything you're saying is in line with what I believe. I could not have articulated it the way that you did. So thank you. Can you let us know where people can find you anything that you want to share about what you're up to these days?
B
Sure. So you can find me easily at my website, which is elizabethearnshaw.com or on Instagram at Liz Listens. I have a substack that goes out every single week that gives kind of relationship tools, if you're interested in that. I've also written two books. I want this to work until stress do us part. And those are available wherever books are sold.
A
Thank you. Probably, like, one of the most painful and difficult topics that seem to be circulating right now. So I am so incredibly grateful for your time.
B
Thank you for having me.
A
You guys. This concludes the month where we focus on social anxiety and relationships. And I hope that this recent episode hit exactly where you needed. So good. If you haven't listened to the other episodes in this month's, series about social anxiety. Please do go back and listen. Before we leave, let's do the I did a hard thing segment. This one is from justrut, which is at Instagram. J U S T R U G H T they went on to say, my wife and I went to dinner with friends we hadn't seen in a while and then back to their place. So constantly I worried that things would get awkward, conversations might drizzle out or might do something wrong, but I wanted to leave. But I first noted that this was what I was experiencing and then I practised maybe, maybe not. It might go bad, but it might not go bad. I value these friends and I'm going to stay. And we had so much warmth and laughter together and it made we then made more plans to meet up again. I avoided avoidance. I love that so much. And then we finally have the review of the week. This one is from Ari and they said your voice and approach is like a warm hug. I love your saying that it's a beautiful day to do hard things which is such a kind motivator for me. Love the self compassion approach because I can be hard on myself. I think we all can Ari and I hope that it has helped you in so many ways and and brought so much joy and openness to your life. All right my loves, I will see you in the next episode. Please note that this podcast or any other resources from CBTSchool.com should not replace professional mental health care. If you feel you would benefit, please reach out to a provider in your area. Have a wonderful day and thank you for supporting cbt. School school dot com.
Host: Kimberley Quinlan, LMFT
Guest: Elizabeth Earnshaw, Relationship Therapist & Author
Date: April 28, 2025
In this widely requested episode, Kimberley Quinlan is joined by renowned relationship therapist Elizabeth Earnshaw for a compassionate, practical conversation about one of anxiety’s most persistent fears: “What if I never find true love?” Together, they explore the unique pain, pressure, and hope around relationships, dating anxiety, the myth of “The One,” and managing both grief and hope when love feels out of reach. The episode is filled with expert insights, gentle normalization, memorable real-life stories, and concrete skills for anyone struggling with relationship worries—whether single, dating, or partnered.
Validation of Relationship Anxiety
Managing the Intensity
Freeze/Collapse Response
Overactivation/Desperation Response
Kimberley reflects that so many listeners feel tremendous urgency around the myth of “The One” and the ticking clock (08:36).
Debunking the Perfectionism Trap
What to Actually Look For
Checklist & Self-Monitor Anxiety
Real-life Relationships Aren’t Perfect
Self-Doubt & Core Beliefs
When There's No Apparent ‘Why’
Mixed Emotions and Self-Judgment
Setting Boundaries
Find Your Community
Anxiety is often amplified by physiological stress—address the body first:
Thoughts may still race—notice and let them pass, but focus on body soothing (36:00–39:11).
“My biggest advice is always deal with the physiology first, because the thoughts are there and they might not go away until after the date. But if you can deal with the fact that your heart is beating so loud it’s in your ears, that’s going to help you feel a little more relaxed.” – Elizabeth (39:00)
On Authenticity:
“If we put on this perfect persona, you're attracting someone who wants that perfect persona, not the imperfect actual you.” – Kimberley (16:49)
On Rejection:
“As soon as I started being like, ‘I'm going to actually, like, express my real opinion...’ I did start getting actual verbal rejections. And the pain wasn't as bad as my fear thought it was going to be.” – Elizabeth (17:00–19:13)
On Grief & Anxiety:
“Often we stay in anxiety and trying to troubleshoot it so that we don't have to feel the grief.” – Kimberley (26:09)
On the Myth of Certainty:
“Hope is not certainty. Hope is different than certainty. And, you know, you need to be able to lean into—I feel uncertain, but I also feel hopeful—instead of I need to be certain or I'm completely hopeless.” – Elizabeth (41:13)
Humorous/Relatable:
“I've had clients who—I'm always like, I wish you guys could see each other in the waiting room and fall in love.” – Elizabeth (21:55)
| Topic | Timestamp | |--------------------------------------------------------------------------------|---------------------| | Introduction to the Core Fear & Why It Hurts So Much | 00:02 – 04:42 | | Two Types of Relationship Anxiety Responses (Freeze vs Overactivation) | 04:57 – 08:36 | | The Myth of “The One” and Its Problems | 08:49 – 12:39 | | Perfectionism, Checklists, & Authenticity | 13:51 – 16:49 | | Elizabeth’s Personal Story on Rejection & Differentiation | 17:00 – 19:13 | | Are Dating Anxieties New or Old (Self-Doubt, the State of Modern Dating) | 19:13 – 21:29 | | Grief in Dating: When You’re Doing Everything ‘Right’ & Still Struggling | 22:35 – 26:30 | | Social Comparison, Announcements, & Mixed Emotions | 27:08 – 33:03 | | Community & Finding Your People | 33:03 – 34:20 | | Managing 10/10 Anxiety on Dates (Somatic Skills) | 34:42 – 39:11 | | Closing Words—Hope, Uncertainty, & Self-Compassion | 39:23 – 41:26 | | Resources from Elizabeth Earnshaw | 41:53 – 42:15 |
This heartfelt episode offers real hope, practical skills, and radical permission to feel, grieve, and hope again in the face of dating, loneliness, and the pursuit of love. Whether you’re single, actively dating, or struggling with relationship worries, Kimberley and Elizabeth’s warmth, wisdom, and honesty shine through every answer.
Find more from Elizabeth Earnshaw at:
Host: Kimberley Quinlan, LMFT
Podcast: Your Anxiety Toolkit
A beautiful life is possible—even if love hasn’t arrived yet.