Podcast Summary: "Cola Wars with Miles Klee"
You're Wrong About episode titled "Cola Wars with Miles Klee" explores the intricate history and fierce rivalry between Coca-Cola and Pepsi. Hosted by Sarah Marshall, the episode features Miles Klee, a writer for Rolling Stone, who delves deep into how these two beverage giants have shaped American capitalism, culture, and global perceptions over more than a century.
1. Introduction to the Cola Wars
Sarah Marshall introduces the episode by expressing her fascination with one of Billy Joel's notable lyrics from "We Didn't Start the Fire," specifically referencing the "Cola Wars." She sets the stage for an exploration of the historical and socio-political dimensions of the rivalry between Coca-Cola and Pepsi.
Notable Quote:
Sarah Marshall [03:47]: "Our producer, Carolyn Kendrick, has a new album out each Machine. So things are busy all over in scary ways, in exciting ways."
2. Origins of Coca-Cola
Miles Klee recounts the creation of Coca-Cola by John Pemberton, a Confederate army veteran who developed the beverage as a remedy for his morphine addiction post-Civil War. Initially marketed as "French Wine Cola," it combined ingredients like cocaine and kola nuts, reflecting the patent medicine trends of the late 19th century.
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [07:51]: "He took a Saber wound to the chest. Unfortunate."
Miles Klee [08:35]: "Coca Cola has all the problems here. The Department of Agriculture seizes 40 barrels and 20 kegs of a shipment and brings a lawsuit against the company alleging that its caffeine content is a public health hazard."
3. Rise of Pepsi-Cola
Parallel to Coca-Cola's trajectory, Caleb Bradham created "Brad's Drink," which eventually became Pepsi-Cola. Originally marketed for its digestive benefits, Pepsi emphasized being a pure food drink, distinguishing itself from Coca-Cola's medicinal roots.
Notable Quotes:
Sarah Marshall [14:26]: "Pepsi was originally called Brad's drink."
Miles Klee [14:38]: "Pepsi was bought by Charles Guth, president of Loft Candy Company, who reformulated it and expanded aggressively during the Great Depression."
4. Early Competition and Marketing Strategies
As Asa Candler acquired Coca-Cola, he invested heavily in nationwide advertising, branding Coca-Cola as a refreshing and exhilarating beverage. Pepsi countered with similar strategies but positioned itself as the choice for the young and active, leveraging slogans like "Pepsi Generation."
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [13:46]: "Coca Cola has captured the attention of Asa Candler... securing ownership of the formula and brand for a total of $2,300."
Miles Klee [27:21]: "Pepsi is really stealing Coke's playbook here... they're hiring skywriters, putting the name everywhere."
5. Racial Dynamics and Marketing
The episode delves into how Coca-Cola, rooted in the Jim Crow South, marketed itself as a symbol of white respectability, often sidelining Black consumers. In contrast, under new leadership, Pepsi made strategic moves to target Black communities, utilizing multicultural marketing and partnerships with prominent Black figures, albeit amidst significant racial tensions and backlash.
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [28:36]: "It is the soda of White supremacy as well."
Miles Klee [31:22]: "Pepsi hires an African American sales team... featuring ads with Black models that don't conform to offensive stereotypes."
6. Global Expansion and "Coca Colonization"
Coca-Cola's global strategy, dubbed "Coca colonization," involved exporting American capitalist values alongside the beverage. The creation of Fanta in Nazi Germany during World War II exemplifies Coca-Cola's adaptability and its entanglement in geopolitical conflicts.
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [36:37]: "This process becomes known as Coca colonization... Americanism and globalization."
Miles Klee [35:30]: "Coca Cola had distributed sodas at Hitler Youth rallies and embraced the swastika bottling conventions in Germany."
7. The New Coke Fiasco and Pepsi Challenge
In the 1980s, Coca-Cola's attempt to reformulate its flagship drink into "New Coke" backfired, igniting consumer backlash and nostalgic clamor for the original formula. Concurrently, Pepsi capitalized on this turmoil with the "Pepsi Challenge," blind taste tests that suggested a preference for Pepsi over Coke, further intensifying the rivalry.
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [60:52]: "So Pepsi and Roger Enrico see this blunder as their moment of triumph."
Sarah Marshall [62:27]: "It's like this idea of Coke for better and for worse and in benign ways and in quite evil ways, building itself year by year as like the establishment drink."
8. Modern Marketing Battles and Controversies
The episode highlights ongoing marketing battles, including Pepsi's controversial Kendall Jenner ad, which attempted to align the brand with social movements but was swiftly pulled due to public backlash. Both companies continued expanding product lines and engaging in high-stakes advertising campaigns to maintain dominance.
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [72:26]: "The social media outreach is so intense that Pepsi pulls that commercial after a day."
Sarah Marshall [48:09]: "I have a personal favorite Tab commercial... it's about drinking Tabs."
9. Reflections on Brand Loyalty and Cultural Impact
Concluding the episode, Sarah and Miles reflect on why consumers remain loyal to either Coca-Cola or Pepsi. They suggest that deep-seated emotional connections and the companies' relentless competition have cemented their places in American culture, making the Cola Wars a prolonged saga of corporate rivalry intertwined with societal values.
Notable Quotes:
Miles Klee [73:08]: "We can't really uncouple our cola desires from the fact that they've been locked in combat for more than a century."
Sarah Marshall [73:29]: "It's like tracking the expansion of Christianity. It's a romp."
10. Closing Thoughts
Sarah Marshall wraps up the episode by acknowledging the extensive journey through the Cola Wars, highlighting the complexities of corporate strategies, cultural influences, and the enduring legacy of Coca-Cola and Pepsi in shaping consumer behavior and American identity.
Notable Quote:
Sarah Marshall [76:02]: "What a romp. You're gonna go get a Coke at some point, but until then, like, what are you up to?"
Conclusion The "Cola Wars with Miles Klee" episode offers a comprehensive look into the historical battles between Coca-Cola and Pepsi, revealing how their competition reflects broader themes of capitalism, race, globalization, and consumer loyalty. Through engaging storytelling and insightful analysis, Sarah Marshall and Miles Klee illuminate the profound impact these soda giants have had on both American society and the global market.
Further Information: