Youth Justice Transformation in Action: Steps for a Successful Implementation Process (ft. Robin Jenkins, PhD)
Released on September 26, 2022
Introduction
In this insightful episode of the RFK National Resource Center's podcast, Youth Justice Transformation in Action, hosts Jody Martin, John Toole, and Michelle Darling engage in a profound conversation with Dr. Robin Jenkins, PhD. Dr. Jenkins serves as the Senior Implementation Specialist and Associate Director at the IMPACT Center within the Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. With a rich background spanning clinical and community psychology, Dr. Jenkins brings decades of experience in juvenile justice, behavioral health, and child welfare to the discussion.
Understanding Implementation Science
John Toole opens the dialogue by highlighting Dr. Jenkins' extensive expertise and her pivotal role in the Denison Mondoro Project—a transformative initiative aimed at reforming youth justice systems through innovation and evidence-based practices.
Robin Jenkins elaborates on implementation science, defining it as:
"The study of methods to promote the adoption and integration, ongoing use of evidence-based practices, interventions, and policies into routine organizational activities."
(06:57)
She emphasizes that implementation science not only focuses on translating research into practice but also explores the mechanisms that facilitate effective change within organizations.
The Importance of Implementation Practice
Dr. Jenkins distinguishes between implementation science and implementation practice. While the former involves the theoretical frameworks and research, the latter pertains to the tailored, facilitated application of these frameworks within organizations. She underscores the necessity of customizing implementation strategies to fit the unique cultures and structures of different organizations, whether they are small teams or large institutions.
Challenges in Juvenile Justice Leadership
The conversation delves into the prevalent challenges faced by leaders in juvenile justice systems.
Robin Jenkins candidly addresses the gap in implementation science training among current leaders:
"Most organizations don't have a workforce development program or executive leadership program anywhere near approaching what it takes to understand implementation science."
(08:55)
She acknowledges that many juvenile justice leaders were promoted based on their operational expertise rather than their competencies in change management or implementation science, highlighting a critical area for development.
Core Components of Successful Implementation
Dr. Jenkins outlines several key components essential for successful implementation:
-
Co-Creation and Collaboration: Engaging key stakeholders—judges, district attorneys, public defenders, and community partners—to foster an environment conducive to change.
"Effective implementation always begins with what we call co-creation or collaborating."
(15:05) -
Clear Vision and Defined Success: Establishing a shared vision and concrete definitions of success to guide organizational efforts.
-
Adaptive Leadership: Embracing leadership styles that are inclusive, flexible, and open to innovation.
"Adaptive leaders understand that some of the best solutions come from those that are closest to the work."
(19:28) -
Dedicated Resources: Allocating sufficient time and personnel to implementation efforts, rather than overburdening existing staff.
-
Continuous Learning and Quality Improvement (CQI): Implementing systems that regularly assess and refine practices based on feedback and data.
-
Effective Communication and Feedback Loops: Ensuring transparent and ongoing communication across all organizational levels to maintain alignment and address challenges promptly.
Adaptive vs. Authority-Driven Leadership
A significant portion of the discussion contrasts adaptive leadership with traditional authority-driven approaches. Dr. Jenkins advocates for:
-
Inclusive Problem-Solving: Inviting diverse voices and frontline staff into the decision-making process to harness their unique insights and foster innovation.
"Implementation science and adaptive leadership really think about inviting diverse voices to the table."
(19:28) -
Shared Leadership Structures: Moving away from rigid hierarchies to more collaborative and flexible leadership models that empower all members of the organization.
Timing of Implementation Science in Reform Processes
When asked about the optimal point to integrate implementation science within reform initiatives, Dr. Jenkins emphasizes its role from the very beginning:
"The simple answer is at the very beginning, when you have an idea for adopting a new policy, program or practice."
(24:07)
She argues that embedding implementation strategies from the outset ensures thoughtful planning and increases the likelihood of sustainable success.
Organizational Structures that Promote Quality Outcomes
Dr. Jenkins identifies rare but effective organizational structures within juvenile justice systems that:
- Flatten Hierarchies: Reducing excessive authority structures to encourage collaboration and innovation.
- Foster Shared Leadership: Creating teams that include a mix of executive leaders and field-based staff to guide strategic initiatives.
"Adaptive leadership skills bring in the voice of this other group, but it also recognizes the leadership at these multiple levels in organizations and celebrates that leadership."
(23:08)
Advice for Youth Justice Stakeholders
For leaders new to implementation science, Dr. Jenkins offers practical advice:
- Embrace Learning: Acknowledge the gap in existing skills and commit to ongoing education in implementation practices.
- Utilize Available Resources: Engage with online platforms like the National Implementation Research Network and seek out training programs.
- Seek Peer Support: Connect with experienced leaders and practitioners for mentorship and collaborative learning.
"I would encourage you to reach out to… there are practitioners out there who are willing to talk to you."
(36:31)
Final Thoughts: Emphasizing Prevention
Concluding the episode, Dr. Jenkins highlights the paramount importance of prevention in juvenile justice:
"I would really put much more emphasis and resources in prevention. I really think the juvenile justice systems can play a really effective role in going out into communities and building relationships with communities to prevent young people from even entering those systems."
(42:02)
She advocates for a proactive approach that strengthens community ties and addresses issues before they escalate into system involvement.
Conclusion
This episode underscores the critical role of implementation science in transforming youth justice systems. Dr. Robin Jenkins provides a compelling argument for integrating evidence-based practices through adaptive leadership and collaborative efforts. Her insights offer a roadmap for juvenile justice stakeholders committed to achieving sustainable, equitable, and effective outcomes for youth and their families.
For those looking to delve deeper into implementation science and its applications in juvenile justice, additional resources are available on the RFK National Resource Center's website rfknrcjj.org, including training materials and an online resource library.
To stay connected with future episodes and updates, follow RFK National Resource Center for Juvenile Justice on Twitter and LinkedIn.