Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities – Episode: "A Simple Kiss" Summary
Release Date: August 14, 2025
In this compelling episode of Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities, hosted by Erin Menke and Aaron Mahnke, two riveting stories unfold, delving into historical intrigue and the profound impact of seemingly simple acts. The episode, titled "A Simple Kiss," seamlessly intertwines the tales of Smedley Butler's courageous stand against a covert coup and the inspirational genesis of David Bowie's iconic song, "Heroes." Below is a detailed exploration of these narratives, enriched with notable quotes and timestamps for enriched understanding.
1. Smedley Butler: Heroic Integrity in the Face of Power
Background and Early Heroism
The episode opens with Erin Menke recounting the illustrious career of Smedley Butler, an esteemed American military leader born in 1881 in Philadelphia. Butler's distinguished service in the Marines from 1898 to 1931 saw him deployed across multiple continents, where he played pivotal roles in installing governments in nations such as Mexico, Haiti, Cuba, Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic, and Honduras. His valor earned him multiple Medals of Honor, and his legacy was immortalized in Marine Corps lore and song.
The Turn Against Corruption
By 1933, Butler had retired, dedicating himself to advocating for veterans' rights. His mission to improve the Veterans Administration led him to a fateful encounter with Gerald Maguire, a representative from the American Legion. Initially hopeful, Butler's optimism was swiftly dashed when Maguire proposed recruiting veterans to oppose President Franklin D. Roosevelt openly.
Notable Quote:
"Butler was shocked at his proposal and turned it down right away. He didn't believe in speaking out against the President like that." (03:15)
Unveiling the Conspiracy
Persistent in his efforts, Maguire revealed a more sinister agenda during a subsequent meeting. He disclosed that powerful business executives from JP Morgan, General Motors, Phillips Petroleum, and General Foods were funding a plan to utilize veterans as a private militia to overthrow Roosevelt, whom they opposed for his socialist New Deal policies.
Notable Quote:
"They believed that the veterans were an untapped private militia who could be used to carry out their desires." (04:50)
Butler's Moral Stand and Aftermath
Refusing to betray his principles, Butler exposed the conspiracy to the press and Congress. Despite facing disbelief from media outlets owned by the very businessmen involved, and a subsequent lack of prosecution from Congress, Butler's whistleblowing marked a courageous stand against corruption.
Notable Quote:
"Butler in fact harbored immense guilt for what he had already done in the Marine Corps... He was not about to help those same companies instigate yet another fascist coup." (05:45)
Legacy and Continuing Influence
Although the immediate aftermath saw Butler sidelined and Maguire's mysterious death the following year, his actions laid the groundwork for future historical reassessments. Decades later, historians have begun to validate Butler's accounts, though powerful descendants of the plotters continue to shield the full truth, maintaining their influence in industries like banking and politics.
Notable Quote:
"Coup or not, it's hard to disagree with Butler's ultimate goal. Our soldiers are heroes deserving of honor and support, not pawns in a game of power." (05:55)
2. David Bowie’s "Heroes" and the Spirit of Berlin
Berlin in the 1970s: A City Divided
Transitioning from the realm of political intrigue, the episode paints a vivid picture of Berlin during the 1970s—a city literally split by the Berlin Wall, symbolizing the Cold War divide between democracy in the West and Soviet control in the East. This setting serves as the backdrop for a transformative personal journey.
Introducing Dave: The Quest for Inspiration
At the heart of this narrative is Dave, a soft-spoken English musician whose quest for artistic inspiration leads him to Berlin. Living modestly and immersing himself in the city's vibrant yet oppressive environment, Dave grapples with creating a song that embodies hope without succumbing to the surrounding melancholy.
Notable Quote:
"The music was already finished and it was powerful, stirring and uplifting in a way that would demand a triumphant story to match." (09:25)
The Simple Act That Sparked a Masterpiece
In a moment of frustration and determination, Dave witnesses a poignant scene: a man and woman sharing a kiss near the heavily guarded Wall. This tender act amidst tension ignites the creative spark needed to complete his song, capturing the essence of ordinary humanity amidst extraordinary circumstances.
Notable Quote:
"He saw a man and a woman locked in a kiss... and that's when it clicked." (11:00)
The Birth of "Heroes" and Its Resonant Impact
The lyrics that emerge from this experience, though simple, resonate deeply with the raw authenticity of Berlin's spirit. A decade later, in 1987, Dave returns to Berlin, now an established artist known as David Bowie, to perform "Heroes" at a concert near the Wall. The song's powerful message becomes a catalyst for change, inspiring widespread riots and protests that contribute to the eventual fall of the Berlin Wall in 1980.
Notable Quote:
"The song... did create a crack, one of many that eventually broke through." (12:50)
Conclusion: The Power of Simple Gestures
Through Dave's story, the episode underscores how simple, genuine acts—like a kiss—can have profound ripple effects, inspiring movements and altering the course of history. David Bowie's "Heroes" stands as a testament to the enduring impact of authentic human emotion against oppressive forces.
Final Thoughts
"A Simple Kiss" masterfully intertwines narratives of heroism and inspiration, illustrating how individual integrity and simple human connections can challenge entrenched power structures and ignite significant cultural shifts. Aaron Mahnke's storytelling not only sheds light on lesser-known historical events but also celebrates the profound influence of personal moments in shaping our collective history.
Notable Quote:
"Once he got started, the words came quickly. The lyrics didn't quite match the triumphant music, but to Dave, that just made it better. It felt honest, like the city he had come to love." (12:00)
Listeners are left reflecting on the enduring legacy of those who stand firm in their principles and the unexpected ways in which simple acts can inspire monumental change.
Stay Curious: To delve deeper into these fascinating stories and explore more curious tales, subscribe to Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities on Apple Podcasts or visit curiositiespodcast.com.