Lootin'

Summary

Episode Summary: "Lootin'"

Aaron Mahnke's Cabinet of Curiosities
Date: April 16, 2026
Podcast by: iHeartPodcasts and Grim & Mild

Overview

In this episode titled "Lootin'," Aaron Mahnke explores two curious tales of people taking what didn’t belong to them—one a notorious modern bank robber in 1990s Texas, the other a final, tragic skirmish at the end of the American Civil War. Both stories delve into the themes of identity, timing, and the sometimes curious consequences of taking what you want, or acting on outdated information.

---

Story 1: The Robber Known as Cowboy Bob

[00:38 – 06:16]

Key Discussion Points

• Unusual Texas Bank Robberies:
  The story opens in Mesquite, Texas, 1992, with a quiet and composed bank robber dubbed “Cowboy Bob.” The bandit’s routine—leaving a note, remaining unarmed, and calmly escaping with the loot—confounds the FBI and the local police.

• The Investigation:
  Former FBI agent Steve Powell pursues “Cowboy Bob,” who is described as an older, wiry cowboy, always dressed in a white hat and gray suit. Despite multiple heists—three in Mesquite alone—Cowboy Bob evades capture thanks to a calm demeanor and careful planning.

• Break in the Case:
  A sharp eyewitness captures Cowboy Bob’s getaway car—a brown Pontiac Grand Prix. It’s traced to an apartment in Dallas, registered to Pete Tallis.

• Revelation of True Identity:
  When agents prepare to raid the apartment, a woman—Peggy Jo Johnson—enters the scene. The FBI, led by Powell, assumes she’s Cowboy Bob’s girlfriend. But when they visit her apartment, subtle clues—Peggy’s nervousness and a dab of white glue above her lip—lead to a shocking discovery:

  “Gentlemen, Powell said, Cowboy Bob is actually Cowboy Babette.” (Narrator, [05:34])

• Aftermath:
  Peggy Jo Johnson, a woman in her fifties caring for her sick mother, committed the robberies using a disguise, never using a weapon. Her sentence was mild: 33 months. Her motivation:

  “…she had started robbing banks to pay for her mother’s medications.” (Narrator, [05:51])

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the investigation:

  “He was making me start to pull my hair out,” Powell said. “How could this thin, little dried up cowboy be whipping us this bad, time after time?” (Narrator quoting Steve Powell, [03:27])

• On the revelation:

  “Cowboy Bob’s strong, silent Persona had more to do with Peggy’s higher pitched voice than anything else.” (Narrator, [05:59])

---

Story 2: The Last (or Not) Battle of the Civil War: Palmito Ranch

[07:23 – 12:55]

Key Discussion Points

• Setting the Stage:
  On April 9, 1865, General Lee surrendered to Grant at Appomattox Courthouse, effectively ending the Civil War. But word travels slowly, and in far-off Texas, fighting continued.

• The Combatants:
  Two commanders—Union Colonel Theodore H. Barrett and Confederate Colonel John Rip Ford—clash near the San Antonio River at Palmito Ranch.

  “Barrett…was a disciplined soldier, by all accounts a pragmatic man, but he still held out hope that he could make a name for himself.” (Narrator, [08:15])
  “Confederate Colonel Ford was still sure that the Confederacy could be saved. He was an impulsive man, famous for raids along the frontier.” (Narrator, [08:34])

• Communication Breakdown:
  With broken telegraphs and rampant rumors, neither side knows the war is officially over. Each acts as if the outcome depends on their actions.

• The Climax:
  The Union and Confederate forces unexpectedly face off. After failed warning shots and cavalry charges, both sides take heavy casualties—about 30 Union and 35 Confederate deaths.

• Resolution & Echoes:
  Realizing the futility, Barrett and Ford meet on the battlefield and call a truce. The battle’s legacy is debated, but it emphasizes how slow information and misplaced conviction can prolong conflict.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the lesson of the battle:

  “It’s a lesson in the value of clear communication and a sobering reminder of what happens when…we’re faced with the spread of false information and an irrational loyalty to bias over fact.” (Narrator, [12:33])

• Final Reflection:

  “And in that sense, it is a curious curse, one that will remain long after the official end of any conflict.” (Narrator, [12:44])

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Cowboy Bob Story: [00:38 – 06:16]
  • The first heist and investigation: [00:47 – 03:27]
  • Stakeout and revelation: [03:27 – 05:34]
  • Aftermath and motives: [05:34 – 06:16]
• Palmito Ranch Battle Story: [07:23 – 12:55]
  • Civil War context and setting: [07:23 – 08:34]
  • Commanders and troop movements: [08:34 – 10:01]
  • Battle and aftermath: [10:01 – 12:44]
  • Final reflections: [12:44 – 12:55]

---

Tone and Language

• The episode blends suspense, surprise, and historical insight in Mahnke’s signature smooth, conversational storytelling.
• The tone is curious, reflective, and at times lightly humorous, especially in describing the antics of Cowboy Bob/Babette and the stubbornness of military men fighting an already concluded war.

---

Conclusion

“Lootin’” presents two tales of unlikely anti-heroes: one, a woman who became a Texas bank robbery legend out of necessity and cunning; the other, frontline soldiers caught in the echo of a war already ended, victims of slow communication and lingering stubbornness. Both illuminate the unpredictability of human motives and the strange turns history can take—perfectly encapsulating the “Cabinet of Curiosities” theme.

Notable Quote to Close

“Stay curious.” (Aaron Mahnke, [12:54])

Transcript

[Podcast Host]

This is an iHeart podcast.

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

Guaranteed Human Amazon Health AI presents painful

[Erin Menke]

thoughts why did I search the Internet for answers to my cold sore problem? Now I'm stuck down a rabbit hole filled with images of alarmingly graphic sores in various stages of ooze. I can clear my search history, but I can never unsee that.

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

Don't go down the rabbit hole. Amazon Health AI gets you the right care fast. Healthcare just got less painful.

[Erin Menke]

Welcome to Erin Menke's Cabinet of Curiosities, a production of iHeartRadio and Grim and Mild.

[Narrator (Cabinet of Curiosities Storyteller)]

Our world is full of the unexplainable, and if history is an open book, all of these amazing tales are right there on display, just waiting for us to explore. Welcome to the Cabinet of Curiosities. On a sunny Texas afternoon in 1992, an old cowboy in a wide, brimmed white hat and gray suit walked into the Mesquite nations bank. The town was so small, only one teller was working. She smiled at the old man when she saw him in line and beckoned him to the window. How can I help you today? Cowboy Bob pulled the brim from his hat a little lower, knowing without having to look that someone would review this. Moments later, when they checked the security cameras, the teller smiled again. While she waited for a response, Cowboy Bob stayed calm, never fidgeting, only sliding a note on the counter between them. The teller's face paled when she read the message. She turned, shaking, and placed every last bill from her cash drawer, a grand total of $5,317 inside a bag from the side of her desk. When the teller handed the bag over, she watched, horrified, as Cowboy Bob dug inside and removed a hidden dye pack from a stack of bills. He handed it back to her with the tip of his hat and strode back out of the bank. Former FBI agent Steve Powell was stumped. The nation's bank of Mesquite was the third in a line of robberies, all committed by the mysterious Cowboy Bob. Steve looked over the footage again. By the thief's calm demeanor, Powell knew that he was looking for a professional. Cowboy Bob's gray beard and strange gait was another clue. The man they were looking for would be at least 60 and maybe older. Steve Powell spent most of his 30 year career chasing bank robbers, so Cowboy Bob shouldn't have been much of a problem. He was making me start to pull my hair out, powell said. How could this thin, little dried up cowboy be whipping us this bad? Time after time? In September of 1992, a few months after Cowboy Bob robbed the nation's bank. Steve Powell received a call. The Cowboy Bob had just left the First Gibraltar bank in Mesquite with $1,700. Powell loaded into his car and raced to the scene to interview witnesses and review the footage. When he arrived, he learned that Mesquite's First Interstate bank had just been robbed as well. This time, Cowboy Bob had hit the jackpot, leaving with $13,000. And so Powell scrambled towards First Interstate and hit the first break in his case. An eyewitness had seen Cowboy Bob pulling away in a brown Pontiac Grand Prix. This wasn't the first time someone had noticed the car driving away from the scene of the crime. But it was the first time anyone got a look at the license plates. Two hours later, Powell and a team of FBI agents pulled into a Dallas apartment complex. It turns out that the car was registered to a man named Pete Tallis who lived at that address. Steve Powell was certain that he was about to catch the bank robbing cowboy red handed. But as they discussed the best ways to storm the apartment, a pretty woman walked out of the apartment and towards the car they had followed. This must be Cowboy Bob's girlfriend, Powell told the other agents. They allowed the woman to drive away from the apartment to avoid suspicion. And then they pulled her over a few blocks away. This woman named Peggy Jones was friendly. She explained that the car was hers and that she had driven it earlier that morning to a gardening center. Powell then asked her if they might have a look around her apartment. Just for a moment. Peggy Jo hesitated. No one was in the apartment except for her sick mother, she told them. But finally she agreed. Agents entered the apartment and began searching through cabinets, under the beds and questioning Peggy Jo's elderly mother. Steve Powell stayed with Peggy Joe because there was something nervous about her. She glanced toward the hallway closet and then back at her mother. And then she chewed on the top of her lip. And that was when Steve Powell took a closer look at Peggy's face. Just above her mouth was a dab of white glue. Steve's eyes widened. Check the closet, he told one of the agents. And inside, on the top shelf, was a styrofoam head with a wide brimmed hat perched on top and beneath it, a gray false beard. Gentlemen, Powell said, Cowboy Bob is actually Cowboy Babette. Because she carried out her crimes without using weapons, Peggy Jo received a mild 33 month sentence. She told police that she had started robbing banks to pay for her mother's medications. Powell put the rest of the pieces together. All by himself. It turns out that Cowboy Bob's strong, silent Persona had more to do with Peggy's higher pitched voice than anything else. A previous mastectomy also made it easier for her to fit into men's clothing. Her manners, however, were never faked. Cowboy Bob or Bobette was quite the gentleman.

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

Amazon Health AI presents Painful Thoughts why

[Erin Menke]

did I search the Internet for answers to my cold sore problem? Now I'm stuck down a rabbit hole filled with images of alarmingly graphic source in various stages of ooze. I can clear my search history, but I can never unsee that.

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

Don't go down the rabbit hole. Amazon Health AI gets you the right care fast. Healthcare just got less painful.

[American Public University Advertiser]

This show is sponsored by American Public University. The future won't wait and neither should you. That's why American Public University offers Master's programs designed for momentum, affordable, high quality and flexible. So you keep moving forward with career relevant programs in business, healthcare, education, it and more. You can gain skills you can use right away and the confidence to power your next move. American Public University made for what's next? Learn more at APU apus.edu.

[Narrator (Cabinet of Curiosities Storyteller)]

The small town of Appomattox Courthouse sat uneasy that morning on April 9th of 1865, as the two generals sat in the parlor of the McLean family home, mapping out terms to end the brutal Civil War that had engulfed the country for the previous four years. Finally, Robert E. Lee signed the document officially surrendering the army of Northern Virginia to Union General Ulysses S. Grant. An exhausted country breathed a sigh of relief. Weeks later, and hundreds of miles away on the dry Texas prairie, a small band of Union soldiers and an opposing force of Texas Rangers rode toward each other to meet in battle, unaware that the war they were fighting was already over. During the jubilant celebrations back east, word was only slowly trickling westward across the frontier after all communication lines across the south had been broken. Although Jefferson Davis had fled, there were still pockets of Confederates who continued to operate as though the war had continued in the hopes that the south would see a resurgence. Nowhere was this more true than in Texas, where the Union had never gained a real foothold in the area, instead keeping to a handful of forts. The rest of the state was at that point sparsely populated, a lawless frontier where the Southern cause was still deeply popular. The Rio Grande gave the Union troops more than enough to do Mexican smugglers still gave aid to the scattered Confederates, and onto this stage stepped two commanders, Union colonel Theodore H. Barrett and Confederate colonel John Rip Ford. Barrett had made a name for himself during campaigns in arkansas, and had been ordered to escort a supply convoy with 200 infantry north from brownsville, where he was to secure the crossing of the San antonio river. He was a disciplined soldier, by all accounts a pragmatic man, but he still held out hope that he could make a name for himself. Meanwhile, Confederate colonel Ford was still sure that the confederacy could be saved. He was an impulsive man, famous for raids that he conducted along the frontier. He had in his employ between 300 and 400 men, some cavalry and some Texas rangers. Neither commander had reliable ways to receive orders, Though telegraph service was still spotty on the outskirts of the country, and there were constant rumors of a confederate revival. Both men were sent to hold the shallow ford on the San Antonio at palmito ranch. It was a crucial supply route that both wanted. Both arrived within a day of one another. Both assumed the other to be a larger enemy force. And so when scouts from the confederate cohort discovered the advancing union troops, Shots were fired to hold them back. But instead of retreating, Barrett decided to stand his ground, Ordering a warning shot be fired from a cannon to scare off the would be attackers. It had the opposite of its intended effect, though. Ford ordered the confederate cavalry to charge at the union convoy, and what followed was a brief but intense battle. Union infantry firing from a shallow ditch While their artillery rained down cannon fire from arise. The confederate assault came in two waves. The first wave was rifle fire, and the second was cavalry advancing on the union line. And it looked like a stalemate until Barrett ordered that a portion of the union cavalry outflank Ford's men, which finally broke their line and scattered the soldiers. When it became clear that the battle would be lost, Barrett and Ford made their way onto the battlefield, shook hands, and called it a truce. Around 30 Union soldiers had been killed, to the Confederates. 35 in the weeks that followed, it became clear that the union's victory, however small, finally affirmed Union control, which helped to re establish federal governance on the frontier. Now there's some argument over which battle was actually the last of the war, Although the battle of Galveston on June 19th has a pretty good claim on that. But the battle of Palmito ranch does help illustrate that although the war officially ended at appomattox courthouse, it took some time for the actual fighting to subside out on the fringes of the nation. It's a lesson in the value of clear communication and a sobering reminder of what happens when, despite our near instant access to news and updates, we're faced with the spread of false information and an irrational loyalty to bias over fact. And in that sense, it is a curious curse, one that will remain long after the official end of any conflict. I hope you enjoyed today's guided tour through the Cabinet of Curiosities. This show was created by me, Erin Manke, in partnership with iHeart Podcasts, researched and written by the Grim and Mild team and produced by Jesse Funk. Learn more about the show and the people who make it [e-mail] curiosities. You'll also find a link to the official Cabinet of Curiosities hardcover book available in bookstores and online, as well as ebook and audiobook. And if you're looking for an ad free option, consider joining our Patreon. It's all the same stories but without the interruption for a small monthly fee. Learn more and sign up [e-mail] grim and mild. And until next time, stay curious.

[American Public University Advertiser]

This show is sponsored by American Public University. The future won't wait and neither should you. That's why American Public University offers Master's programs designed for momentum, affordable, high quality and flexible so you keep moving forward. With career relevant programs in business, healthcare, education, it and more. You can gain skills you can use right away and the confidence to power your next move. American Public University made for what's next. Learn more at Apu Apus. Edu.

[Podcast Host]

This is an iHeart podcast. Guaranteed Human.