After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal
Episode Summary: Final Days of Thomas Cromwell
Release Date: February 24, 2025
Host/Author: History Hit (Anthony Delaney & Maddy Pelling)

1. Episode Opening: The Grim Execution of Thomas Cromwell ([00:20] - [03:46])

The episode begins with a vivid and harrowing portrayal of the execution of Thomas Cromwell on July 28, 1540. Set against the backdrop of a tense Tower Hill, listeners are transported to the moment Cromwell ascends the scaffold. Dressed plainly and exuding calm dignity, Cromwell addresses the crowd with words of resignation and forgiveness before succumbing to a brutal execution that leaves the onlookers shocked by its inefficiency and brutality.

Quote:
Anthony Delaney (00:20): "The executioner adjusts his stance, lifting the axe again... Blood pools, quickly, staining the wood... This was no clean death, no swift justice, they say."

2. Introduction of Hosts and Episode Focus ([03:46] - [04:21])

Hosts Anthony Delaney and Maddy Pelling introduce the episode's focus on the final days of Thomas Cromwell, setting the stage for an in-depth exploration of his life, political maneuvers, and eventual downfall.

3. The Tudor Era Context and Cromwell's Rise ([05:15] - [08:46])

Anthony Delaney provides essential historical context about the tumultuous Tudor period, highlighting the religious upheaval marked by Henry VIII's dissolution of the monasteries and the ensuing cultural and economic impacts on England. He outlines Cromwell's strategic marriage arrangements, particularly his orchestration of Henry VIII's fourth marriage to Anne of Cleves in 1540, aimed at securing alliances with Protestant German states. This marriage, however, quickly unravels, setting the stage for Cromwell's perilous position.

Quote:
Maddy Pelling (07:34): "This is one of the ways in which these Reformation ideas... are really to the fore. And we see that in England too."

4. Hilary Mantel's Influence on Cromwell's Portrayal ([10:26] - [17:43])

The discussion shifts to modern interpretations of Cromwell, particularly through Hilary Mantel's acclaimed novels—Wolf Hall, Bring Up the Bodies, and The Mirror and the Light. Maddy Pelling praises Mantel’s ability to humanize Cromwell, contrasting the traditional view of him as a Machiavellian antagonist in Tudor history. Anthony Delaney explores how Mantel's portrayal has reshaped contemporary understanding of Cromwell, emphasizing his ambition and strategic mind over sheer villainy.

Quote:
Anthony Delaney (10:47): "Prior to Wolf Hall... Cromwell was seen as this devious, sinister Machiavellian character... But now, in the wake of Hilary Mantel's book and then the TV series, there is this kind of recalculation of how we understand Thomas Cromwell."

5. Cromwell's Ambitious Journey: From Mercenary to Lord Chancellor ([17:02] - [21:19])

Delving into Cromwell's early life, the hosts discuss his humble beginnings as the son of a blacksmith in Putney and his adventurous youth, including time spent as a mercenary in the French army. Anthony highlights Cromwell's versatile career trajectory—from cloth merchant to banker's clerk, and eventually to a lawyer—underscoring his adaptability and ambition. Maddy Pelling reflects on Cromwell's relentless drive, noting, "He is someone who is pushing his way into society... young, scrappy and hungry."

Quote:
Maddy Pelling (18:12): "He's a thruster. He is."

6. The Failure of the Fourth Marriage and Political Turmoil ([20:45] - [26:24])

Anthony explains Cromwell's pivotal role in Henry VIII's fourth marriage to Anne of Cleves, intended to secure Protestant alliances amid rising tensions with Catholic France and Spain. However, the marriage is a swift disaster, leading to political backlash from key figures like the Duke of Norfolk and Bishop Stephen Gardiner. These adversaries exploit Cromwell's background and perceived overreach, branding him a radical reformer intent on dominating the king, thereby orchestrating his downfall.

Quote:
Maddy Pelling (22:13): "You can argue it any which way... he is such an enigmatic, difficult to pin down figure."

7. Cromwell's Fall: The Arrest and Execution ([34:36] - [50:02])

The hosts narrate the rapid and ruthless downfall of Thomas Cromwell. On June 10, 1540, Cromwell is abruptly arrested for high treason during a Privy Council meeting. Stripped of his titles, wealth, and honors, he is left vulnerable without the protection of his former allies. Maddy Pelling and Anthony discuss the strategic maneuvering surrounding his arrest, the lack of a formal trial (using an act of attainder instead), and the brutal nature of his execution, which deviates from the norm by requiring multiple axe blows.

Quote:
Anthony Delaney (34:36): "He is a courtier through and through, and so he stays... he then doesn't stop scheming."

Quote:
Maddy Pelling (49:59): "It's an axe, not a sword... a sort of snub... he's no longer the Earl of Essex."

8. Personal Interpretations of Cromwell's Final Moments ([42:14] - [50:02])

In the tense moments leading to his execution, Cromwell's final plea reflects a complex mix of resignation and strategic thinking. The hosts debate whether his words—"I cry for mercy, mercy, mercy"—indicate genuine desperation or a calculated attempt to appeal to Henry VIII's sense of mercy. They draw parallels between Cromwell's final speech and that of Anne Boleyn, highlighting the ingrained belief in the divine right of kings and the human vulnerability of those who fell from grace.

Quote:
Maddy Pelling (45:58): "It's difficult... he acknowledges that they exist and plays his part in that system as he goes to his death."

9. Cromwell's Legacy ([50:02] - [53:36])

Anthony Delaney reflects on Cromwell’s enduring legacy, acknowledging his significant contributions to the centralization and modernization of English governance. Despite his controversial role in religious reforms and the dissolution of monasteries, Cromwell's administrative prowess left a lasting imprint on British political structures. The hosts discuss the historiographical debates surrounding his character—whether viewed as a villainous schemer or a pragmatic statesman—underscoring his complex legacy that continues to captivate historians and audiences alike.

Quote:
Anthony Delaney (53:36): "His legacy is quite profound... his legacy is such profound."

10. Concluding Thoughts and Recommendations ([53:36] - End)

Maddy Pelling expresses the enigmatic nature of Cromwell, acknowledging that while the episode offers substantial insights, Cromwell remains a complex figure with layers yet to be fully understood. The hosts encourage listeners to further explore the Tudor period and Cromwell's life through additional resources, such as Susanna Lipscomb’s podcast, Not Just the Tudors.

Quote:
Maddy Pelling (53:36): "I in a lot of ways don't feel any nearer to understanding him because I think he's such an enigmatic, difficult to pin down figure."

Key Takeaways

• Thomas Cromwell's Rise: From humble beginnings, Cromwell’s ambition and strategic acumen enabled his ascent within Henry VIII’s court, playing a crucial role in significant political and religious reforms.

• Hilary Mantel's Portrayal: Modern interpretations, particularly through Hilary Mantel’s novels, have humanized Cromwell, presenting him as a multifaceted character rather than a one-dimensional villain.

• Downfall and Execution: Political intrigue and opposition from powerful figures led to Cromwell’s swift and brutal downfall, marked by his arrest and ghastly execution without a formal trial.

• Legacy and Historiographical Debate: Cromwell's contributions to English governance are significant, yet his legacy remains contested among historians, oscillating between views of him as a manipulative schemer and a pragmatic statesman.

Recommended Listening:
For those eager to delve deeper into the Tudor period and Thomas Cromwell's intricate life, Susanna Lipscomb’s Not Just the Tudors podcast is highly recommended.

Suggestions:
Listeners are encouraged to share their thoughts or suggest topics for future episodes by emailing us@afterdarkhistoryhit.com.

Subscribe to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with new releases every week and ad-free podcasts. Visit historyhit.com/subscribe to join.