
Loading summary
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual. Even if it means sitting front row at a comedy show.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Hey, everyone. Check out this guy and his bird. What is this, your first date?
Carvana Customer
Oh, no.
Liberty Mutual Agent
We help people customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual together.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
We're married. Me to a human, him to a bird.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Yeah, the bird looks out of your league.
Liberty Mutual Agent
Anyways, get a'@libertymutual.com or with your local agent.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Liberty, Liberty. Liberty. Liberty.
Carvana Customer
I sold my car in Carvana last night.
Kat Irving
Well, that's cool.
Carvana Customer
No, you don't understand. It went perfectly. Real offer down to the penny. They're picking it up tomorrow. Nothing went wrong.
Carvana Narrator
So what's the problem?
Carvana Customer
That is the problem. Nothing in my life goes as smoothly. I'm waiting for the catch.
Kat Irving
Maybe there's no catch.
Carvana Customer
That's exactly what a catch would want me to think.
Carvana Narrator
Wow. You need to relax.
Carvana Customer
I need to knock on wood. Do we have wood? Is this table wood?
Carvana Narrator
I think it's laminate.
Carvana Customer
Okay. Yeah, that's good. That's close enough.
Carvana Narrator
Car SELLING WITHOUT a CATCH Sell your car today. Pick up fees may apply.
Aura Narrator
Most people don't realize how much of their personal information is being bought and sold every day. Data brokers are making billions, pulling details about you from public records and the Internet, then packaging and selling it, usually without your consent. That's how your information lands in the hands of scammers, spammers, even stalkers. It's why you get endless robocalls and why ads seem to follow you everywhere. That's where Aura comes in. Aura actively removes your data from broker sites and keeps it off. They also instantly alert you if your information shows up in a breach or on the dark Web. But Aura goes beyond data protection. With one app, you get a vpn, antivirus, password manager, spam call protection, Dark web monitoring, and even up to $5 million in identity theft insurance. All backed by 24. 7 US based fraud support. Other companies might sell just credit monitoring or just a vpn. Aura gives you all of it together at the same price competitors charge for just one service. Start your free trial today@aura.com safety protect yourself now@aura.com safety.
Antony Delaney
Rotting flesh, blackened limbs. Genitals ravaged by disease. Behind a discreet doorway on Victorian London's Oxford street, visitors stepped into a world of wax. Glass cases revealed bodies frozen in decay. Skin blistered, eyes hollow. Limbs contorted by disease. But it would all end in scandal for Dr. Kahn and his museum but was this a place of medicine or of theater, A moral lesson? Or an attraction built on fear and shame? As respectable gentlemen filed past these grotesque displays, they're forced to confront not only the fragility of the body, but the uneasy question, is this education or exploitation? After Dark, listeners and viewers, we are going to take you right to the heart of 315 Oxford Street. It's the middle of the 19th century. You're going to be immersed in this bizarre, wonderful, questionable world of Dr. Kahn's anatomical museum. But it is so bizarre, so strange, so horrifying to some extent that I am not doing this alone. And because Maddie is currently collecting samples in the Andes, samples of what nobody knows. I have decided that the only person to help me through this bizarre world of anatomy is, of course, Kat Irving, human remains conservator at Surgeons hall in Edinburgh. Kat, you are my guest co host on After Dark for the next few weeks.
Kat Irving
Hello. It's wonderful to be here. I feel like. I feel like I've gone through the looking glass.
Antony Delaney
Yes, now you're part of the machine. Listen. If you're listening or watching these episodes on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts, get cozy, turn the volume up on your speakers or on your earphones, whatever it is, because these are really cat's histories are immersive. We are going to be going to some very strange corners of the past. And this is why, when I knew that we were looking for guest co hosts while Maddie was off, Kat was top of my list. I was like, we need to have Kat in. Because what we were about to discuss and what we have been discussing with Kat through the previous episodes, you can go back and look at will give you a taste of what is to come. And this particular history is bizarre in the best way possible. Now, before we go into that particular anatomical site in the middle of the 19th century, I'm gonna bring us right up to date because I visited Kat in her office in Edinburgh. I've been to a lot of offices. This one is the most unique, I think I can confidently say that I have ever been to. And so fitting as well. It was like, of course this is. And I couldn't take a picture in there because of the nature of what's in there. But I remember taking a pict of you at the door going, wow, this is such a location that nobody really gets to see. So for the listeners, give us a description of what your office in Edinburgh looks like.
Kat Irving
Well, it's a vaulted basement.
Antony Delaney
It is.
Kat Irving
So, you know, lots and lots of Arches. If you're taller than me, you have to duck at a number of places. And this is where we keep our human remains that are not on display. And so there are shelves upon shelves which contain human remains. And then I have a little desk in the corner. I have two laboratories which are somewhat dated now. And there I do my work. It looks a bit like you might expect something in a Frankenstein lab, but that is not what I am doing down there.
Antony Delaney
No, no, I can confirm she is not sewing together pieces of random bodies, which is great for everybody involved. I remember at one point, because there's different little compartments to what is the sweep of your office. And at one point I remember thinking to myself, we were in the middle compartment, we had two chairs out and we were chatting away about history and about books and about all this kind of thing, just industry stuff. And watching over us in the background were, what, what is it? What is it? Eight skeletons or something that were just overviewing our conversation. I was like, this does not happen in. In the history head offices on a daily basis. It is an experience. But I'm very glad that I got that experience.
Kat Irving
Yeah. And. And if I, you know, I. I do a lot of public talks and if I have to practice talk, I give it for the skeletons. So they're my first audience, actually. I do stop it.
Antony Delaney
Yeah, I'm remembering them all now because they're all different heights and sizes and, you know, the plethora of humanity there. They are such a. They're such a ready audience. Like, it makes sense that you would do that. Actually. It's still a little bit crucifix, but. Yeah, I'm sure they are silent, but they're taking it all in as they would. Now, listen, we are going from your anatomical situation to Dr. Kahn's grand anatomical museum. We are, as I said, in the middle of the 19th century. We're going to go straight in and then we'll pull back a little bit and give some context. If you and I were walking down Oxford street, we came to number 315, we. And we go in through this door. What is a typical visit like to this particular anatomical museum?
Kat Irving
Well, there are lots of things that you can see there. You will see, you know, like if you come to surgeon's hall, you will see body parts that have been preserved in jars and fluids. You're also going to see those at Dr. Kahn's. He's got a number of those kind of jars showing human remains with lots and lots of different conditions. You're also going to see models, beautiful wax models, which will show the body at different stages of dissection, show some horrible diseases. You're also going to see things that you might not expect. So from 1857, he has what's called a heterodelph, and that's actually a living person.
Antony Delaney
Oh, I didn't realize it was a living person.
Kat Irving
So there is a crossover with the kind of freak show that, you know, I know that you've talked about in the past in After Dark.
Antony Delaney
Let's linger on that for a second, because I had heard that there was a heterodelf, and we'll talk about what that means in just a second. But I didn't realize there was living people.
Kat Irving
That seems to be the only one, only living person that he has.
Antony Delaney
I looked this up, this particular. And there are drawings of this particular heterodelf that you can see online. And I was really interested in what the breakdown of the language was in terms of heterodelphin. And it basically means an opposite brother. An opposite man.
Kat Irving
Yeah, it's effectively hetero. The same as in heterosexual. Yeah, you know, different. And then delf, sibling, brother, Greek words.
Antony Delaney
If you could describe what this. I did not realize this person was alive. If you could describe what the heterodelf was. So if we are seeing this person, this poor boy, actually, what would we. What condition was he. Was he living with?
Kat Irving
He has. It seems to be a form of conjoined twinism or supernumerary limbs. Again, we're not certain. So, you know, he has a young male body, and then coming out of just below his diaphragm is another lower torso and then another pair of limbs smaller than the, shall we say, the main lower body. So he has these extra legs.
Antony Delaney
And you may not know the answer to this because it might not survive in the archival material. Do we know if he had use of those extra limbs or was it an appendage that was not used?
Kat Irving
This is a really interesting question. We don't get so much of a description of that. But from similar conditions that I. I've read about, there is some use. So at surgeon's hall, we have an example of a supernumerary limb, a third leg, as it were, that was removed from a man in his 50s. And it's a really sad story. You know, effectively, his. His parents thought this was a punishment from God. So it was only after they died that he was able to get this. This leg removed. And he'd been kept hidden away so that people wouldn't see the shame. Till this point. But there's a very interesting report from the doctors who first exam. And as well as the extra leg, he also has an extra penis.
Antony Delaney
I knew you were going there. Sorry. Somehow I just knew it was gonna go there.
Kat Irving
And the doctors write that it will respond at the same time as the first one, but it doesn't produce. Whoa. Yeah.
Antony Delaney
Okay. That is something we have never heard at After Dark,
Kat Irving
but it's such a sad story. It is, you know, really, really want to just bring home that, you know, these are people.
Antony Delaney
People. Yeah.
Kat Irving
And that's. But, you know, through collections like ours, you get these insights into what people's lives must have been like. And it must have been so hard.
Antony Delaney
And here's the thing, actually, to take from that. In one sense, it's very easy to get caught up in the graphicness of the anatomy part of it, which, you know, you're anatomist, that's fine. But it's also that thing of there was a secret around this man's life, and he couldn't deal with it until his parents died. That's heartbreaking.
Kat Irving
It really, really is.
Antony Delaney
That it's hidden away.
Kat Irving
Yeah.
Antony Delaney
So that's the heterodelf that we have, or as it was termed at the time, that we have at this particular anatom museum, but we also have the Venus model. Now, this is intriguing. This was one of the stars of the show, Right. Not a real person, though, in this case.
Kat Irving
No, this is a wax model. And this was based on a style of wax model that was produced first in Italy in the 18th century. So the first model was a man called Clemente Susini. He works in Florence. And you can still see Clementi Susini's models. There are some in La Specola in Florence, in Vienna. There's even one of his anatomical Venuses in the Science Museum in London. So, you know, they're still about, but effectively what you have is a beautiful woman, and she's reclining. A lot of these models have jewels around the necks, sort of pearls or beads. They have very beautiful hair. Sometimes it's. It's braided over their shoulder, and they're. They're relaxing on a cushion and they laid back. Their head is reclined. Their lips are slightly parted. It looks almost orgasmic.
Antony Delaney
Sure, sure. Yeah.
Kat Irving
But then she has a wax panel on the front of her body that you can remove, and then you can look at her internal organs, and you can often take those internal organs out, you know, made of wax, right down to teeny, tiny wax. Fetus, which is, you know, there in her uterus, which there's absolutely no external sign of.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
So these are, they're beautiful. They're very idealized anatomy.
Antony Delaney
God, even the anatomy is idealized.
Kat Irving
Absolutely. You. This does not look like how you see the anatomy in a dissected view,
Antony Delaney
if you're actually opening something.
Kat Irving
So, you know, it's not anatomy as you see it in real life. It's a map to what you will see. But a very sexualized map.
Antony Delaney
Yeah, I was gonna say one of the things that I don't think I fully appreciated with this is that actually there's a cover for the internals, that if you, if you approach this at first, there can be a top over the stomach, I'm guessing.
Kat Irving
And often, you know, if you see one of these models in a museum that will be laying to one side,
Antony Delaney
you'll see that it will be open.
Kat Irving
It will be open, it'll have been taken off because otherwise it's, you know, it's just a woman who looks like she's just had sex lying there on a table. If you have that covered over. The point is to see those wax
Antony Delaney
organs inside, those idealized wax organs.
Kat Irving
Absolutely.
Antony Delaney
And what is in the back of my mind, and maybe I'm drawing false comparisons here, but it's probably just worth flagging it as you're talking about these wax figures of women, idealized women in these semi sexual poses that are open. It's the 19th century, I know this is the 1840s and 50s, but actually you can't help jump ahead a little bit to the ripper cases later on where you get this mixture of gore and violence and sex where women are concerned. It's just a very interesting. I know it's a generation apart, but there's something in that, I think about
Kat Irving
taking a woman apart and almost to that kind of essence of what's inside you.
Antony Delaney
Yeah, yeah. It's very disturbing actually, when you, when you see it in that case. Right. One of the questions I have then, as you are describing this and you're describing what, what is inside these doors and you know they're being advertised. Anybody can. Well, I'm assuming anybody can go, but what kind of audience is. Are, are you and I just rocking up off the street? Is it just medical professionals? What's the audience for this?
Kat Irving
Well, that's really interesting because, you know, certainly Dr. Kahn's isn't the first of these type of museums. You know, there was Rackstro's museum in the 18th century. That was there For a little while, that close. Then you actually get somebody who takes one of these anatomical Venuses to a pub in Soho in 1825. And effectively, in that pub in Soho, anyone can go and see. See her lying there. And it's really popular. But the newspaper reports, you know, again, because of this sort of sexualized nature, they're not so popular. So we get under the pretense of imparting anatomical knowledge. This filthy figure, the property of one Monsieur Estnault, is exhibited. So, you know, it's disapproving.
Antony Delaney
Is this the one in Soho?
Kat Irving
This is 1825 in Soho. And they go on to say it is a large, disgusting doll. So, you know, we're getting that kind of idea that this is not proper.
Antony Delaney
Yes.
Kat Irving
But people go and see it, and we still get further cases like this. So, you know, we get Signor Sarti in the 1840s, and some of these museums will not allow women in. You know, they're just for men. And then even amongst the men, some rooms, the ones which will show certain STDs, venereal diseases, are just for medical people.
Antony Delaney
Right. So there is a distinction between who can go where, gendered distinctions, intellectual, educational distinctions, depending on what all of these different organizations have and hold and what their collections are. One thing I want to ask about that pub in Soho in the 1820s, first. First of all, it's interesting that it sounds to me like it was a French person who owned the. It's a French surname. Right. So obviously in the 1820s in England, Frenchness is not Derraguer.
Kat Irving
So there are two things to disapprove of there.
Antony Delaney
Yeah, yeah, yeah. But then the other thing that strikes me is that, okay, it's in a pub, and it seems inappropriate that that kind of an exposing is happening there anyway. But it also says something about. So that's the gender side, but let's talk about the class side for a moment, because I wonder if to a certain extent the disapproval is. This isn't for everybody's eyes. This anatomical literacy should be reserved for certain people. You know, it's more complicated than that. But do you think there's an element of that in there as well?
Kat Irving
Oh, I definitely think there is. It's not right that certain people know about these things. You still see that today, that there are certain museums that hold anatomical collections, and you can only go and see them if you are in the medical profession. So, you know, there is that still. We do see that, obviously at surgeon's hall, we allow everyone in.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual. Even if it means sitting front row at a comedy show.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Hey, everyone, check out this guy the in his bird. What is this, your first date?
Carvana Customer
Oh, no.
Liberty Mutual Agent
We help people customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual together.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
We're married. Me to a human, him to a bird.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Yeah, the bird looks out of your league.
Liberty Mutual Agent
Anyways, get a quote@libertymutual.com or with your local agent.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty.
Carvana User
Hey, sweetie. Your mother showed me this Carvana thing for selling the car. I'm gonna give it a try. Wish me luck. Me again. I put in the license plate. It gave me an offer. Unbelievable. Okay, I accepted the offer. They're picking it up Tuesday from the driveway. I haven't even left my chair. It's done. The car is gone. I'm holding a check anyway. Carvana, give it a whirl. Love ya.
Carvana Narrator
So good you'll want to leave a voicemail about it. Sell your car today on Carvana.
Kat Irving
Pick up.
Carvana Narrator
Fees may apply.
Tax Relief Advocates Narrator
We've all heard those scary IRS radio ads that try to frighten you into calling. But Tax Relief Advocates is different. If you owe the IRS 5,000, 50,000 or even $500,000, TRA has a solution for your tax problem. It doesn't matter if you're in your car, at work or with your kids. No matter where you are, visit tra.com don't lose hope. TRA could reduce or even eliminate what you owe. Their passion is taxes and helping people and businesses fix IRS problems. They have over 1000 five star Google reviews and an A rating with the Better Business Bureau. You no longer need to fear the irs. Generous tax relief programs are available now to give you a fresh start. So don't wait. Simply visit tra.com that's tra.com or call 800-583-6429. Once again, that's 800-583-6429. Tax relief advocates Real solutions for real people.
National Debt Relief Narrator
Debt doesn't usually happen all at once. It creeps in quietly. Charge here a larger balance there. It builds bill by bill, statement by statement, until it becomes too much. If you have $10,000 or more in credit card or personal loan debt, national debt relief can reduce the amount you owe and give you an easier way forward. Their team of experts takes over the hard part. Negotiating with your creditors, breaking down everything for you clearly, and building a plan that fits your budget. National debt relief has helped over 1 million people with their debt. And they can help you too. Because when you understand your options and have someone in your corner, debt doesn't feel so heavy anymore. It's quick, free and easy to apply. To see if you're eligible, just visit startndr.com if debt's been hanging over you, now's the time to take control. Visit startndr.com today.
Antony Delaney
Speaking of who's allowing who in and how far into this whole situation can go, Dr. Kahn, in this specific case, in his anatomical museum, he's in charge of this. Who is he?
Kat Irving
Well, he's a German doctor and we're putting Dr. In scarecoats there.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
There is no evidence that he ever got a medical degree. And that will become very, very important later on. And he seems to have exhibited certain of these kind of things in Germany, toured them around. And again, touring these kind of collections has been going on since the, you know, the very end of the 17th century, you know, with a man called Guillaume de Nou. But, you know, he comes to London and in 1751 he opens up his anatomical and pathological museum.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
And it's, it's really interesting because he seems to have a genuine desire to impart anatomical knowledge.
Antony Delaney
Yeah. There seems to be two things going on here that there is. There is access to information. And as we will see, women are allowed into some of these places. As long as they're paying, of course.
Kat Irving
Yeah. Some. Often the women would be. They would have certain days for the women. And there was actually a Madame Capstan's that was purely for women.
Antony Delaney
Oh, okay.
Kat Irving
Yeah. And on the days that women were allowed into these places, certain of the models would be covered up or hidden away.
Antony Delaney
So, you know, women are allowed some knowledge.
Kat Irving
Yeah, yeah, some knowledge. Not the same kind of knowledge as men.
Antony Delaney
No. Heaven for femmes.
Kat Irving
Absolutely not. That's not where we're going.
Antony Delaney
But if there's a question over his doctorhood, and we'll talk about those distinctions in a minute, probably what there isn't a distinction about is his business acumen. Right. That this is a man who is trying to. Even from the outset, even if he is trying to educate whatever, he's also trying to make money.
Kat Irving
He's definitely trying to make a living from this. You know, he's. He's got to get something back.
Antony Delaney
Yeah. He's not, because, you know, if he wanted to be an anatomist in a medical school or in a private medical school, he could do that. Just head on up to Edinburgh. There's loads of people waiting there to to do that. But that's not what he's doing.
Kat Irving
That's not what he's doing. He has his museum, two shillings to get in.
Antony Delaney
Yeah.
Kat Irving
It's not making enough money. So he drops the price to one shilling in the hope that that will get more people through the door.
Antony Delaney
Okay. So he's adapting his business model, depending on.
Kat Irving
Yeah. And that's it. That you can see that kind of, let's say, the evolution of his business model.
Antony Delaney
Let's say that that's what it is. Right. One thing when producer Stu were talking to me about doing this episode, I was like, one question I will definitely have for Kat is I need to go through the formalities of all of these different names for the profession. And I think Khan brings up a good point at which for us to discuss that. So what you will hear often when you're Talking about early 19th cent century specifically is that we have physicians, we have surgeons, we have apothecaries, and we have then kind of cowboys on licensed practitioners, whatever the quack doctors. That's the word I was looking for. Now let's. Let's just walk people through this because it's very easy to get confused with all of these things, like what the distinction is, how formally qualified these people are, or not. Let's start with physicians specifically. If it is, let's say it's 1850, we're here, and I say I am a physician. What does that actually mean? Have I done anything to qualify as that?
Kat Irving
Very, very good question. Usually a physician is somebody who has been to university, a university educated man, and of course, they are all men at this point.
Antony Delaney
Yes, yes, yes, Yep.
Kat Irving
So it generally does indicate that there has been some kind of university education.
Antony Delaney
Okay.
Kat Irving
However, as with Dr. Khan, there isn't really anything for to stop you just saying you're a doctor, you know, there is no framework which really supports that. And then you have surgeons.
Antony Delaney
Right. There is a distinction between the physician and the surgeon.
Kat Irving
Absolutely. And Surgeons hall, we are the museum of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh and we have been responsible for making sure who is a surgeon in Edinburgh since 1505.
Antony Delaney
Oh, wow. So that's regulated so well.
Kat Irving
Well, they were making sure that unless you were a fellow of that guild, and it started off as a trade guild, so you had to be a member. Unless you were a member of that guild early on, you could not practice surgery in Edinburgh. So there was a bit of regulation there.
Antony Delaney
Can I just check here before we go on to any of the other categories? Barber surgeons Surgeons.
Kat Irving
So they start off as barber surgeons.
Antony Delaney
I see.
Kat Irving
And effectively that's because barbers were the people who had tools. They could do that cutting business earlier on. And even, I mean, certainly you see this in Edinburgh. Even when you have the incorporation of barbers and surgeons, there's still often a distinction between who's doing barberry and who was doing surgery. So, you know, while a lot of times you got people doing both, by the time we get into the 17th century, there does seem to be a distinction between who is cutting hair and trimming beards and who is cutting a leg off.
Antony Delaney
Thanks very much.
Kat Irving
Exactly. But the thing about surgery is that you didn't go to university to learn it. You learned it by apprenticeship. So you signed an indenture with a master that said, you know, how long you would be with him for what you would do. So, you know, there was a whole range of stipulations about, you know, not starting fights and not going with loose women and all these kind of things. There was a whole array of things, you, behaviors you had to follow while you were indentured to your master. And then you would be examined. Examined. And then you could practice surgery.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
So you don't have to have gone to university.
Antony Delaney
So in that sense, if we're talking about the distinction between the physician and the distinction between the surgeon, would you say that the physician is a little more gentlemanly?
Kat Irving
The physician is certainly more gentlemanly. There's a wonderful illustration from the 16th century that I like to use to illustrate this where you see the physician in a long robe. He's wearing glasses.
Antony Delaney
Yeah.
Kat Irving
So again, indicating that book learning thing,
Antony Delaney
because we've all gone blind for that.
Kat Irving
Yes. He's just sort of, you know, there standing upright, not examining patients. He's just kind of standing there, whereas you have the surgeon sitting nearby in. He's wearing a short robe because, you know, it would be impractical to do these sort of things in a long robe. And he is sawing off a leg. And he's a much more practical person.
Antony Delaney
Sure.
Kat Irving
So this is the early distinction between physicians and surgeons. So that's, you know, we're talking sort of 16th century here.
Antony Delaney
Distinction.
Kat Irving
Yeah, yeah. But 19th century, the surgeons are trying to, you know, make sure that, you know, that they're better regarded.
Antony Delaney
Yes.
Kat Irving
You know, so that kind of thing is, you know, they're trying to raise their class. And you can see this. Anyone that's been to surgeon's hall, we are in a very, very grand neoclassical building that is really trying to make A statement going, look, we're important, we're legit. Absolutely, we are legit. So, you know, that building is part of that. Trying to get that in. And, and in the, you know, beginning of the 19th century, this is when you're starting to get a lot more surgeons also going to university. It's not compulsory. Yeah, but they are doing that, you know, you are getting that kind of crossover. And we get a man called Thomas Keith in 1845. He will do a lot of good work on the surgery of ovariotomy, which is removing the ovaries, so gynecological surgery. But in 1845 he apprenticed to James Young Simpson, who you might have heard of as the man who discovered chloroform as an anesthetic. And Thomas Keith was said to be the last surgical apprentice in Edinburgh. So, you know, that's about this, that's about this time. So, you know, you're still not getting that kind of surgeons as qualified medical men until, you know, we're getting that transition around this point.
Antony Delaney
And isn't it interesting that like two questions are now binging in my head. Isn't it interesting that now the surgeon has, has gone above the physician?
Kat Irving
Absolutely. But, you know, consultant surgeon will usually be.
Antony Delaney
Mr. That was going to be my next question.
Kat Irving
Is that because of this, that's, that's harking back to, you know, these days when you weren't qualified doctor.
Antony Delaney
I love like that. Right, okay. So we have our physicians and we have our surgeons and then the mixture of the two of them as we get on into the 19th century or the line becomes a little bit more blurred in my head. An apothecary is always a little bit more like a modern day pharmacist.
Kat Irving
Yeah.
Antony Delaney
Correct or incorrect?
Kat Irving
Absolutely. But you also get a bit more of a blurring because you have surgeon apothecaries.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Oh, right.
Kat Irving
Who are doing, you know, a bit of surgery, a bit of prescribing medicine,
Antony Delaney
say in a village or something.
Kat Irving
Absolutely.
Antony Delaney
You have to be a bit of everything.
Kat Irving
And in some ways you can maybe think about them as like the way we think of a gp, something you would go for if anything was wrong. And again, you've got to remember for a lot of times, time, you know, physicians, you would have to pay. So they would come to people's houses and they would, you know, they would visit people home, wealthy people at home, you know, people who had money and then they might, out of charity, goodwill, do things in hospitals where they, you know, they would see the poorer members of, of society.
Antony Delaney
Do you know in Ireland you still have to pay for a doctor? So like if you go and you have a sit down thing, it's like €70 for every.
Kat Irving
Oh, wow.
Antony Delaney
Thing you have. Yeah. And like, if so I know this is years ago, but when my granddad was dying, a doctor would come to the house and you would have to. Older people get it for free, but there is still this kind of expectation that you'd slip them €50 or something if they've come to the house. So that's still very much there. I will say this, if my GP ever tries to cut my leg off, they'll be hearing from me. But that's neither here nor there. Okay, so physicians, surgeons, apothecaries, unlicensed practitioners, quack doctors.
Kat Irving
Quack doctors.
Antony Delaney
This is where Khan's starting to come into it and this is his world.
Kat Irving
Yeah. So you've got to imagine that you've got pay for a physician. You know, you would go and get something a bit cheaper. And of course mistrust, you know, it's not quite this sort of seen as being the same kind of profession as we would see it nowadays. You might not get the treatment that you want. So there were a whole range of medicines that you might be able to buy effectively. Snake oil salesmen.
Antony Delaney
Sure.
Kat Irving
That, you know, people that would be selling things that would, would sort you out or allegedly sort you out.
Antony Delaney
Sounds very wellness industry nowadays. Allegedly.
Kat Irving
I feel there is a lot of crossover. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, take this vitamin and all your problems will be go heights.
Antony Delaney
Allegedly. I need to stop naming brands.
Kat Irving
Yes, yeah. So exactly that kind of thing. And these people were, you know, they would have advertisements and places, you know, selling you things, especially if it was certain kind of conditions that you might not want to go and see a doctor about, that there might be a little bit of stigma, you know, and so that there might be adverts and toilets about things that you might be able to get.
Antony Delaney
Oh, really? So we're talking about venereal disease here?
Kat Irving
We are.
Antony Delaney
Okay, let's talk about that because. Let's talk about venereal disease because to a certain extent Khan is capitalizing on this idea of taboo that surrounds venereal disease or STDs or STIs as we might call them today. And it is, as you say, there's, there's this, there's this idea that you're going to find out about treatments in toilets, in public toilets or there, there may be discreet places that you come across this information. But Here we are at 315 Oxford Street. Pretty public, pretty out there. Okay. It's behind a closed door. But he is putting on display the impact of venereal disease on the human body. And he. I guess you can tie that up as being educational, and to a large extent, it might very well be. But also he's saying, and give me my shilling now before you can see it. So how does that part of the display work in terms. Is that the real draw for people, or are people absolutely mortified by it?
Kat Irving
Well, well, there seems to be a lot going on. You know, he's definitely trying to educate people, and these things are not talked about very much. So people are fascinated. You know, there's several layers of the fascination. You know, first of all, the fact that we don't really know what the inside of our bodies look like.
Antony Delaney
We were talking about this on the walk. We were walking over together, and you said something about, you will never see the. Unless something awful goes wrong.
Kat Irving
Yeah, it's a bad day if you're actually seeing the inside of your own body. So, you know, the fact that. But it's so important to you, you know, the fact that things that are going on inside me are the reasons why I'm waving my hands around like this and the words are coming out my mouth. You know, the thought processes, you know, the. The complex hormonal soup and the way that. That interacts with everything. This makes you who you are, but
Antony Delaney
you'll never know it.
Kat Irving
You have this black space inside of you filled with these things that you. You probably never see and don't understand. And so you can understand why people are fascinated by. And then, you know that you have these things that go wrong that people aren't talking about. And maybe you're coming to a place like this and you get to see it. You know, you're getting to learn about these things that get hinted at but aren't really spoken about out in the open.
Antony Delaney
One of those things, which I've never come across this before is spermatorrhea. Spermatorrhea. Involuntary or excessive discharge of semen. The. Now, don't clip that and use that in any way for my showreel or any kind of thing, but that is. It's interesting, right? Because yes, we can laugh about our bodily functions. We all, you know, whatever, but at the same time. Well, first of all, that's not a condition, right? That's something that was kind of just made up in the 19th century.
Kat Irving
I mean, there was a lot of. They also have somebody There's a model of the head and face of somebody who practiced oninus.
Antony Delaney
What the hell's that?
Kat Irving
Masturbation. Oh, you know, so that's the other thing that there is a moralistic twist with all of this. You know, the idea that, you know, again, the Victorians, you know, we're not talking about this, but absolutely do not do it.
Antony Delaney
Yeah. Oh, wait, I think I've seen this before. There's the figure of a man and there's a head and it's normal. And then there's another head of the same man, but now his tongue is protruding and he's got some swelling maybe around his eyes or something.
Kat Irving
Is that this is the kind of thing that we're talking about, this idea of. It's just like, you do that, see what's going to happen to you, Right? Yeah. So you definitely are getting this kind of moralistic element to all of this.
Antony Delaney
So how is the establishment dealing with these kind of places, or Khan's place in specific? Because we know that there's an interaction action with the Lancet, right?
Kat Irving
Oh, absolutely.
Antony Delaney
We all know what the Lancet is. But for those who may. Let me, just in case. We don't all know what the Lancet is. The Lancet is a medical journal still around today.
Kat Irving
Still around today.
Antony Delaney
And it is. It is the benchmark, right?
Kat Irving
Yeah. I mean, it was founded in 1823 by a man called Thomas Wakely. And his idea was that you have something that's readable, that you can present medical information from so people can educate themselves. And he thought that by education you might avoid some of those quack doctors and their snake oil. He starts off with a brief, which is effectively what the Lancet is all about. And they're very, very positive. So he opens in 1851 and they say, we've paid a visit and we're much gratified with the collection of anatomical and surgical curiosities. Amongst the most interesting that deserves approbation is the anatomical Venus, which takes to pieces for the purpose of exposing the general anatomy and the relationships of the various visceral. Altogether, it is a splendid collection and a great deal of general information is to be obtained by visiting it. So this is really, really.
Antony Delaney
That's a five star review.
Kat Irving
Absolutely. You'd want this in TripAdvisor, wouldn't you? Yes, yes, absolutely.
Antony Delaney
Put that in your posters.
Kat Irving
Yeah.
Antony Delaney
So what goes wrong, then?
Kat Irving
Well, you know, we talked before about Khan and his business model.
Antony Delaney
Yes.
Kat Irving
Yeah. He's not making the kind of money that he wants.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
And he takes the collection on tour and. Yeah. So it goes to various places in the provinces. Provinces. I'm talking about places like Manchester and Sheffield, what they think of as the provinces. And so people are seeing it. And then he returns to London. He has a couple of different locations in London, obviously, that, you know, that first one. Bit too expensive.
Antony Delaney
Sure. You know, can imagine prime real estate.
Kat Irving
Exactly. And so he's still not making what he wants. And he sells some models to a company who are known. Known as Perry and Company.
Antony Delaney
Okay.
Kat Irving
And they make it out that it's a family business. Their name is Jordan, not Perry.
Antony Delaney
So much edge on that.
Kat Irving
Yeah. Effectively what they're doing is they are selling those kind of quack remedies for STDs that, you know, that we were talking about earlier. And so they think that if they have some of these models that they can use that for teaching people.
Antony Delaney
It legitimizes what they're selling. Yeah.
Kat Irving
And so Khan gets a bit of money that way. Way. And then he effectively goes into partnership with them.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
He's going into partnership with them. He's using his models so that he can educate people about venereal diseases. He's giving lectures. And then you exit through the gift shop and you can buy some of Perry and Co's remedies. So he's going from this fairly educational basis. And we talked about the heterodel earlier. The heterodelph only is born in 1857. But one of the things Kahn does is use the hetredelf, use this young boy to talk about the fact that maternal impressionism, the idea that things that you see while you're pregnant cause these kind of birth defects.
Antony Delaney
Joseph Merrick.
Kat Irving
Joseph Merrick. I mean, Joseph Merrick is born, what, five years later. And they were absolutely convinced that this was down to things that his mother had seen while she was pregnant.
Antony Delaney
She had seen an elephant crush him, man. Therefore. Yeah.
Kat Irving
But in 1857, Kahn is using the heterodel to say, that's bollocks.
Antony Delaney
Oh, yeah, Khan is doing that.
Kat Irving
Kahn is doing that. One of the things he's doing is talking about embryology and things like that. He's showing that this is not true.
Antony Delaney
So there really is this tension and dichotomy between Marty's doom, because he is educating, he is right in some ways, but then he's exploitative in other ways.
Kat Irving
Absolutely. And this is where the Lancet kind of. And he goes, we're not having that.
Antony Delaney
I see.
Kat Irving
You know, they're really. By 1857, in his partnership with Perry and Company, they come along and they refer to it as that den of obscenity.
Antony Delaney
Oh, wow. So now we've gone from five star view to a one star review.
Kat Irving
Absolutely. This is very, very, very different language. They say, disgusting and immoral, depraving the mind of the ignorant and unwary.
Antony Delaney
Oh, dear.
Kat Irving
Yeah, and I would just like to quickly do a shout out here to
Antony Delaney
the ignorant and unwary.
Kat Irving
Not to the ignorant, unwary. To our library and archive assistant, Robin Fixture Patterson, who. Who basically was the person who went and scanned all these issues of the Lancet for me when I was researching
Antony Delaney
these a couple of years ago.
Kat Irving
So he did an absolute. I mean, he's amazing at just magically making articles appear anyway. But he did physically go through old 19th century issues of the Lancet for me getting these out. So. Thanks, Robin.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual, even if it means sitting front row at a comedy show.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Hey, everyone, check out this guy and his bird. What is this, your first date?
Carvana Customer
Oh, no.
Liberty Mutual Agent
We help people customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual together.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
We're married. Me to a human, him to a bird.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Yeah, the bird looks out of your league.
Liberty Mutual Agent
Anyways, get a'@libertymutual.com or with your local agent.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty.
Kat Irving
Mom, can you tell me a story?
Carvana Narrator
Sure. Once upon a time, a mom needed a new car.
Kat Irving
Was she brave?
Carvana Narrator
She was tired mostly. But she went to Carvana.com and found a great car at a great price. No secret treasure map required.
Kat Irving
Did you have to fight a dragon? Nope.
Carvana Narrator
She bought it 100% online line from her bed, actually.
Kat Irving
Was it scary?
Carvana Narrator
Honey, it was as unscary as car buying could be.
Kat Irving
Did the car have a sunroof?
Carvana Narrator
It did, actually.
Kat Irving
Okay, good story.
Carvana Narrator
Car buying. You'll want to tell stories about. Buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply.
Antony Delaney
That is. It's. It's interesting to see that the switch, right, that they're going from five star view to one star starview. Because what it does is it shows, as so many people were in many ways, that Khan is trying to eke out a living in a city or in a country as he's up and down the country touring this. That is. It's difficult, right? It is. You are having to hustle. You're having to have side hustles. You're having to be a million things. We can all identify with those kind of things today, but it is him trying to find a way to survive. And, yes, I think when I was looking at some of these details, there is definitely a drive to educate. And I also was kind of thinking, you know, he's a. Letting women in to some of the spaces, Some of the spaces that other people are. Absolutely not. Yes, they have to pay. But there is access there, so there's something there, too. But by the time it comes to the. The kind of end of this particular museum, it does start to smell of exploitation and desperation, actually, to a certain extent. So what happens in the end? So. So we know it gets closed. Well, it. It kind of just passes over to Perry and Company, right?
Kat Irving
Yeah. So. So we get a thing. You know, we talked before about the difference in medical men. In 1858, we get a medical act which says that in order to be a doctor, you have to be registered.
Antony Delaney
I see Khan's not doing the admin.
Kat Irving
Khan can't do that. And he applies. And they kind of go, yeah, and they go, we've got no evidence that you. You practiced. And so he ends up leaving the country and we kind of lose sight of Khan and Perry and Kor take over the business. And you can imagine at this point,
Antony Delaney
we're into essentially freak show at this point, as they would have said.
Kat Irving
Yes, absolutely. But then another thing happens. So 1858, we get the Medical act the year before that. So 1857, the same year that the Lancet are referring to this as a den of obscenity, we get the Obscene Publications Act.
Antony Delaney
Yeah. So now what are we able to describe, to advertise these things? Is that gonna impact how this business is, information about the business is disseminated?
Kat Irving
Well, it's not only that, because the Obscene Publication Act, I mean, you say it, it makes me think of, like, people who are distributing porn. You know, it sounds like it's to do with pornography, but in the Victorian period, in 1858, this is not 1857, this is not just about porn. It's also about things that promote conduct inconsistent with public morals, which is a very different thing.
Antony Delaney
Very Victorian thing.
Kat Irving
Very Victorian thing. So you've got to imagine that they're able to basically frame it as if. If you go along to Kahn's Medical Museum, and it still is called Khan's.
Antony Delaney
Right.
Kat Irving
Perry and co are not changing the name. They're still having Dr. Khan, you know, giving it that air of legitimacy. If you're going along there. And effectively, it's like saying, well, if You've got an S.T.D. it's all right. This is what you can do about it. That's almost promoting the kind of behavior which is likely to get you a venereal disease in the Victorian imagination. And that. That, according to the Obscene Publications act, was not acceptable.
Antony Delaney
It's a. No, no.
Kat Irving
Yeah, yeah. And so you also get things like. There's one point when the Lancet says, maybe this Society for the Suppression of Vice should go and look at Dr. Kahn's. Yeah, exactly. And so in 1873, because of this, and you know, this has taken a
Antony Delaney
while, I was going to say, that's almost like a generation later. 1873.
Kat Irving
1873, some of these models are confiscated and. And prosecution takes place. And we get Mr. Collette, who is the head of the Society for the Suppression of Vice, flagrantly in contradiction to this act, he says, can I have the pleasure of smashing these models myself? And so this happens in court.
Antony Delaney
Oh, he does it in court.
Kat Irving
Absolutely. Drama. Yeah, yeah. And I mean, these are anatomical models. And I mean, I know you follow me on Instagram. You know how much I love a good anatomical model. You do. I have spent a lot of my time on holiday going to look at these very kind of models. The Times noted how elaborate and how expensive these models would be at the time.
Antony Delaney
Yeah.
Kat Irving
And they're getting smashed. That just. It just breaks my little heart.
Antony Delaney
Yeah, yeah. It breaks your gothic little heart.
Kat Irving
It does, it does.
Antony Delaney
It is. It's such a fascinating snapshot. And this is why I just. This is not somebody I'd known an awful lot about. And when I was researching for him, when I knew we were doing this episode, I googled him, as you generally would, just to see what's out there. And the answer is not very much at all.
Kat Irving
Absolutely.
Antony Delaney
It's not something that is just slap bang in the middle of the Internet. And, you know, I think I went on YouTube to see if there's anything there, just to see what's in the public sphere. There's not very much about him and this particular museum.
Kat Irving
No, we get some snapshots through publications. You know, there is a publication, you can find it digitally at the welcome Collection, about the heterodelph. And you know what he said about that. And you get this kind of progression through the Lancet, but. But it's just fleeting.
Antony Delaney
Yeah, yeah. It gives this idea that, you know, this idea that he's coming from Germany, traveling up and down the country, then leaves and I think comes back at some point. But that transitory thing has also meant that he's spread out, archival and slightly lost. I'm sure there's probably more sitting in archives somewhere across the world. But it's such an interesting snapshot of a moment in time and this kind of moralizing around one's body, even though the internal part of one's body and how that's being policed and who gets to see it and how women don't get to see it. But nonetheless it's women's anatomy that's being bared in this Venus model which is in pubs or in this particular place. Like it's, it's, it's exploitative, but it also seems to be educational. But at the same time, the people who are saying that it's exploitative are also exploiting it in their own way for other ends. It's, it's just so very Victorian and it's such a great little, little story. So I'm so glad that you've brought us particular one today, Kat. What a. What? I told you. I told you. This is going to be like completely immersive and we're going down dark alleys of the 19th century as we will continue to do. Not just the 19th century. If you've enjoyed this episode, and I know I have, this is why we thought up of After Dark. It's just such a. Oh, we love all this stuff. Then leave us a five star review wherever you get your podcasts. Did you know we are also on YouTube so you can go and watch us have this conversation there if you're not already on our YouTube channel. You can find me at Antony Delaney History if you'd like to follow me on social media. Cat. Where can they find you at?
Kat Irving
Anatomical cat.
Antony Delaney
I see what you did there. Bring it all to all to the people. Guys, until next time, go back and listen to Kat's older episodes. What we have about bougie candles. I remember that.
Kat Irving
That was Zosries. That was the Paris Catacombs.
Antony Delaney
Paris Catacombs. And there's other episodes.
Kat Irving
No, that's it. That's the only one I've done.
Antony Delaney
We've only had you on once.
Kat Irving
Yes.
Carvana User
No.
Kat Irving
Yes. We. We've recorded about Burke and hair and done filming.
Antony Delaney
But we did a documentary.
Kat Irving
Yeah.
Antony Delaney
Oh yeah, go and watch that. That's good. Yeah, yeah. If I say so myself. Anyway, that's enough from us. Until next time. Happy listening.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty. Even if it means sitting front row at a comedy show.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Hey everyone, check out this guy and his bird. What is this, your first date?
Carvana Customer
Oh, no.
Liberty Mutual Agent
We help people customize and save on car insurance With Liberty Mutual together.
Liberty Mutual Spokesperson
We're married. Me to a human, him to a bird.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Yeah, the bird looks out of your league.
Liberty Mutual Agent
Anyways, get a quote@libertymutual.com or with your local agent.
Liberty Mutual Friend/Commentator
Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty.
Antony Delaney
Apro vecha los ahoros de Memorial Day in los y compra los vasicos parelo gar pormenos ahoro centa dolores en la parria que madores char broil performance series.
Date: May 21, 2026
Host: Antony Delaney (with guest co-host Kat Irving)
Podcast: History Hit
This episode dives into the strange and controversial world of Dr. Kahn’s Anatomical Museum, a Victorian-era exhibit in London infamous for its morbid wax models, preserved human remains, and scandalous educational displays—especially concerning sexual health. Host Antony Delaney, joined by guest co-host Kat Irving (human remains conservator, Surgeons' Hall, Edinburgh), sheds light on the fine line between education, exploitation, morality, and spectacle in Kahn’s museum, unpacking its history, exhibits, audience, and ultimate downfall.
Typical Visit Experience (07:33): A heady mix of medical specimens in jars, lifelike wax models of anatomy and disease, and even a living "heterodelph"—a person with supernumerary limbs.
The Heterodelph (08:09–10:54):
The Anatomical Venus (11:36–13:44):
The conversation is intimate, thoughtful, and sometimes darkly humorous—balancing empathy for “the people behind the pathology” with curiosity about Victorian oddities. Antony is enthusiastic and irreverent, while Kat brings both expertise and compassion to the stories of those put on display. Their dialogue veers from vivid anatomical descriptions to social context, always returning to the essential question: where is the line between knowledge and spectacle?
The story of Dr. Kahn’s Anatomical Museum is revealed as a microcosm of Victorian anxieties about sex, disease, class, gender, and the human body. While intended as an educational space, it was ultimately swept aside as public attitudes shifted and authorities cracked down on what was deemed indecent. The episode is as much an exploration of historic shame and spectacle as it is a lament for lost stories—highlighting the fine line between teaching and exploiting, and the vulnerabilities of those whose bodies (alive or dead) were put on display.
“It’s exploitative, but it also seems to be educational. But at the same time, the people who are saying that it's exploitative are also exploiting it in their own way for other ends. It’s just so very Victorian and it's such a great little story.” – Antony Delaney (46:25)
[End of Summary]