All Of It Podcast Summary
Episode Title:
Author Saratoga Schaefer Imagines a 'Serial Killer Support Group' in New Novel
Host:
Alison Stewart
Release Date:
April 16, 2025
Introduction to the Episode
In this episode of All Of It, hosted by Alison Stewart on WNYC, listener and culture enthusiasts are introduced to Saratoga Schaeffer, a member of the WNYC family and the author of their debut thriller, Serial Killer Support Group. The conversation delves into the novel's dark exploration of true crime, familial relationships, and the intricate psychology of serial killers.
Book Overview and Premise
Saratoga Schaeffer introduces their novel, focusing on the protagonist, Saira, whose younger sister, Mira, is brutally murdered—potentially by a serial killer. Frustrated with the slow pace of the NYPD investigation, Saira takes drastic measures to seek both justice and revenge. Instead of traditional methods like scouring the internet for leads or creating a podcast, Saira infiltrates a clandestine support group for serial killers on the Dark Web.
"There is sisterly devotion, and then there's Sarah Griffin, the protagonist of the debut thriller by writer and poet Saratoga Schaeffer." [00:39]
This unconventional approach sets the stage for a narrative that intertwines dark themes with the complexities of familial bonds.
Character Development and Motivation
Alison inquires about Saira's unique approach to avenging her sister. Schaeffer explains that Saira's motivation stems from a deep personal loss, compelling her to go beyond mere justice.
"For me, my first thought was if something happened to a loved one, that would be a motivator for a character to go to these lengths." [02:24]
Saira's determination to infiltrate a group of serial killers is portrayed not just as a quest for truth, but as a path to revenge, highlighting her emotionally closed-off nature necessary for navigating such a perilous environment.
"She's not very warm and fuzzy, but I think that is an advantage for her since she is diving into a very dangerous world." [05:38]
Research and Portrayal of the Dark Web
When discussing her research process, Schaeffer emphasizes the balance between thorough investigation and maintaining originality in character development.
"I did a lot more research, especially research into female serial killers, because Saira pretends to be one in order to infiltrate the group." [03:21]
She explores both informal avenues like Reddit and more structured sources such as books and articles, ensuring the depiction of the support group feels authentic without directly mirroring real-life serial killers.
"I wanted to make it feel as realistic as possible in a scenario where there is a serial killer support group." [04:19]
Moreover, Schaeffer acknowledges the complexity of the Dark Web but chooses not to immerse excessively, staying true to her strengths and narrative needs.
"I learned that I definitely couldn't use the Dark Web because it's very confusing to me." [09:38]
Setting and New York City's Influence
The novel is deeply rooted in the vibrancy of New York City, with specific nods to Park Slope and Queens, areas personally significant to Schaeffer. These settings serve as both love and hate letters, reflecting the author's intricate relationship with the city.
"Some of that comes through throughout the text... I have a very complicated relationship with New York City." [12:20]
She highlights both the allure and the overwhelming nature of NYC, which influences her characterization of Saira—mirroring her own experiences of the city's sensory overload.
"It can feel really overwhelming and overstimulating at all times." [12:59]
Themes: Serial Killers and Gender Dynamics
A significant portion of the discussion centers on the unique angle of having a support group for serial killers, particularly exploring the gender dynamics within this dark community.
Schaeffer chose parasite names for the group members, such as Lamprey, Whipworm, Pea, and Crab, to maintain anonymity and introduce a macabre sense of humor.
"So they all have a different nickname that is based off of a parasite." [14:33]
She also delves into the portrayal of female serial killers, challenging traditional perceptions that typically associate serial killing with males.
"There is a sort of inherent sexism in the serial killing industry, which is so weird that like, sexism is so prominent that it even affects serial killers." [16:48]
This exploration extends to how female serial killers receive different, often less threatening nicknames compared to their male counterparts, reflecting societal biases.
Writing Process and Personal Insights
When asked about her writing journey, Schaeffer shares personal growth insights, revealing resilience developed during challenging times.
"I learned a lot about my own resilience. I mean, this particular book I wrote during a very tumultuous period of my life." [18:50]
She offers advice to aspiring authors, emphasizing persistence, exploration of various ideas, and finding a personal writing path amidst industry challenges.
"Keep writing, for sure. And I would also say try not to get super stuck on one idea or one story... just keep going because it's a tough industry sometimes and there can be a lot of rejection." [20:05]
Upcoming Projects and Future Endeavors
In a brief reveal, Schaeffer shares information about her forthcoming novel, expanding her literary repertoire into the horror genre.
"It's called Traditional Wife and it is about a trad wife influencer who has a demon baby." [21:04]
This upcoming work marks her first foray into horror, promising an unhinged and thrilling narrative.
Notable Excerpts and Literary Highlights
Schaeffer provides listeners with a glimpse of her writing style through a dramatic reading from page 25 of her book, illustrating Saira's tense infiltration into the serial killer support group.
"Saira took the end to Astoria Boulevard and walked the extra mile to a tiny abandoned parking lot not far from LaGuardia Airport..." [10:01]
This excerpt showcases the novel's atmospheric tension and the protagonist's relentless pursuit of answers.
Conclusion
The episode offers a comprehensive look into Saratoga Schaeffer's debut novel, Serial Killer Support Group, highlighting the intricate weaving of true crime elements with deep psychological and societal themes. Through engaging discussions, Schaeffer provides valuable insights into her creative process, thematic choices, and personal motivations, making it a compelling listen for fans of thriller and true crime genres.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
-
Schaeffer on Inspiration:
"What if there was a support group specifically for serial killers?" [01:48] -
Character Motivation:
"It's I want revenge." [02:24] -
Research Approach:
"I wanted to make it feel as realistic as possible in a scenario where there is a serial killer support group." [04:19] -
NYC's Influence:
"I have a very complicated relationship with New York City." [12:20] -
Gender Dynamics:
"There is a sort of inherent sexism in the serial killing industry." [16:48] -
Writing Advice:
"Keep writing... just keep going because it's a tough industry sometimes." [20:05] -
Upcoming Novel:
"It's called Traditional Wife and it is about a trad wife influencer who has a demon baby." [21:04]
Closing Remarks
In this episode, Alison Stewart and Saratoga Schaeffer engage in a thought-provoking dialogue that not only unveils the layers of a gripping thriller but also offers listeners a glimpse into the intricate process of crafting a novel that challenges conventional narratives around true crime and serial killers. For those intrigued by the intersection of culture, psychology, and storytelling, this episode is an invaluable exploration.