All Of It - Episode Summary: Benmont Tench Live in the Studio

Release Date: February 21, 2025
Host: David Fuerst (in place of Alison Stewart)
Guest: Benmont Tench, Co-founder of Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers

1. Welcome and Introduction

David Fuerst kicks off the episode by introducing Benmont Tench, renowned keyboardist and co-founder of Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers. Tench is in the studio to perform tracks from his upcoming solo album, The Melancholy Season, set for release on March 7, 2025. Additionally, listeners are informed about Tench's debut performances at Cafe Carlyle in Manhattan, spanning two nights.

2. Benmont Tench's Musical Journey

Benmont Tench shares insights into his illustrious career, highlighting his foundational role in shaping the Heartbreakers' sound with his signature organ and piano work. Reflecting on his decade-long hiatus from solo projects, Tench expresses excitement about returning to the spotlight:

Benmont Tench [00:16]: "I'm here with us in WNYC's Studio 5 and at the piano. Welcome Benmont Tench."

3. Performance of "The Melancholy Season"

The conversation begins musically as Tench performs the title track of his forthcoming album, The Melancholy Season. The live rendition showcases his emotive piano skills and sets the tone for the album's contemplative themes.

Benmont Tench [02:11]: "This is called the Melancholy Season."

4. The Inspiration Behind the Title Track

Delving into the creative process, Tench discusses the genesis of "The Melancholy Season." Initially conceived as free verse, the lyrics evolved into a song influenced by his experiences in Tarzana, California, where the changing seasons and the visibility of the constellation Orion inspired profound reflections on time and emotion.

Benmont Tench [06:30]: "I wrote out a long form... a window into putting a melody to it... it's very evident. It was dark enough that when the seasons changed... Orion would appear in the sky."

5. Debut at Cafe Carlyle: A Special Milestone

Tench expresses the significance of debuting at the esteemed Cafe Carlyle, a venue known for its intimate and revered performances. Despite initial nerves and the looming pressure of live solo performances after a hiatus, Tench finds the experience immensely rewarding.

Benmont Tench [08:06]: "Absolutely. You know, when I found out that I could play at Cafe Carlisle, I was knocked out."

6. Overcoming Personal Challenges and Their Impact

A poignant segment of the interview touches on Tench's recent health struggles, including a severe fall and a battle with oral cancer. These experiences have profoundly affected his perspective on life and his approach to music, fostering a sense of resilience and humor.

Benmont Tench [10:53]: "I've been dealing with the cancer for like 12 years... it was a really big deal. So hopefully it's made me unafraid because, you know, plenty can happen and more can happen."

7. Reflecting on the First Solo Album vs. the New Release

Comparing his first solo endeavor to The Melancholy Season, Tench highlights the differences in production and creative approach. His debut album was produced by legendary engineer Glen Johns, fostering a comfortable and collaborative environment. In contrast, his latest work with producer Jonathan Wilson emphasizes a minimalist, tape-based recording technique that brings a fresh sound to his music.

Benmont Tench [13:44]: "It's very different... he's got the old analog tape, does that. It makes a huge difference in the sound."

8. Collaborations and Choices in the Music Industry

Tench reflects on his extensive collaborations with iconic artists like Bob Dylan, the Rolling Stones, and Stevie Nicks. His reputation as a sought-after musician stems from his exceptional talent and the memorable performances that have become synonymous with classic tracks.

Benmont Tench [16:13]: "People say, get me that guy. Get me that guy."

9. Live Performance Insights

Discussing his live performances, Tench emphasizes the versatility required when transitioning from a full band setup to a solo piano arrangement. He explores how major songs like "American Girl" can be reinterpreted to fit a more intimate setting without losing their essence.

Benmont Tench [25:45]: "A really great song usually doesn't need anything. So if I have just those chords and just that melody and just those words, then I can play it any way I want to."

10. Upcoming Album and Future Performances

As the episode nears its conclusion, Tench performs additional tracks from his new album, including "Like Crystal" and "Under the Starlight." He expresses immense gratitude for the opportunity to release his music on George Harrison's Dark Horse Records label, aligning himself with a legacy of remarkable artists.

Benmont Tench [21:31]: "They always put out great stuff, you know, they always put out really great music."

11. Conclusion

David Fuerst wraps up the episode by reiterating the release date of The Melancholy Season and encouraging listeners to attend Tench's live performances at Cafe Carlyle. The heartfelt interactions and moving performances leave both the host and guest visibly touched, underscoring the emotional depth of Tench's musical journey.

This episode of All Of It with WNYC offers an intimate glimpse into Benmont Tench's artistic evolution, personal resilience, and the soulful melodies that define his latest work. Whether you're a longtime fan or new to his music, Tench's heartfelt storytelling and captivating performances make for a compelling listen.