Podcast Summary: "Bi-State Beach Bonanza: The Best Beaches in NJ and NY"

ALL Of It with Alison Stewart
Host: David Fuerst
Guests:

• Rosalyn Colgan - Things to Do Editor at TimeOut New York
• Brian Donahue - Jersey Journalist
  Release Date: June 27, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of ALL Of It, host David Fuerst delves into the sun-soaked shores of New York and New Jersey, exploring the best beaches each state has to offer. Joined by Rosalyn Colgan from TimeOut New York and Jersey journalist Brian Donahue, the discussion navigates through iconic spots, hidden gems, family-friendly locations, and surfer paradises. Additionally, listener calls provide personal insights and recommendations, enriching the conversation with diverse perspectives.

Key Criteria for Choosing the Perfect Beach

Rosalyn Colgan (02:11): Emphasizes the importance of having a spacious area to lay towels, minimal crowds, and the presence of a boardwalk. She values beaches that offer cultural experiences alongside sun and sand, citing Coney Island as her favorite for its historical exhibits and vibrant atmosphere.

Brian Donahue (02:42): Highlights a balance of natural beauty, boardwalk culture, and quality amenities like good restaurants. For him, a good beach must have gentle swimming areas to accommodate families with children and older visitors.

Top Recommendations in New York

Rosalyn Colgan (03:54):

• Coney Island: An iconic destination known for its vintage charm, lively boardwalk, and historical exhibits. Despite being crowded, the cultural attractions and family-friendly amusement rides make it worthwhile.

Rosalyn Colgan on Brighton Beach (16:35):

• Brighton Beach: Neighboring Coney Island, it offers a quieter, more relaxed vibe with a significant Russian community. Visitors can enjoy unique shops, authentic cuisine, and a less frenetic beach experience.

Orchard Beach in the Bronx (19:48):

• Orchard Beach: Dubbed the "Riviera of New York," this mile-long beach offers stunning views, diverse dining options, and activities like salsa dancing on Sundays. Rosalyn praises its facilities and unique charm.

Asbury Park (23:25):

• Asbury Park: Known for its vibrant art scene, surf schools, and live music venues like the Stone Pony. It combines beach activities with cultural and artistic engagements, making it a versatile destination.

Top Recommendations in New Jersey

Brian Donahue (05:20):

• Island Beach State Park: Praised for its pristine natural environment, dolphin sightings, and extensive protected land. Ideal for those seeking a tranquil escape with opportunities for fishing, bird watching, and kayaking.

• Seaside Heights Boardwalk: Offers a classic boardwalk experience with entertainment and dining options reminiscent of Coney Island. Brian notes concerns about gentrification but appreciates its enduring cultural feel.

Craig from Morganville (07:16):

• Sandy Hook Beach Park: Features diverse environments with inlets for fishing and swimming. It's part of a larger area that includes trails for bird watching and access to Highlands, NJ for fine dining.

• Seven Presidents Park in Long Branch: Combines beach access with family-friendly amenities like playgrounds and swimming areas. Brian highlights its historical significance and pleasant swimming conditions.

Brigantine (11:52):

• Brigantine: An island beach offering a peaceful retreat with a mix of nature and history. Brian shares anecdotes about local traditions, such as the annual Benny’s calendar featuring cars stuck in the sand.

Specialized Beach Experiences

Surfing Opportunities (20:59):

• Rockaway Beach: Recognized for its accessible surf culture within city limits. Rosalyn encourages visitors to explore local surf schools for lessons.

• Lavalette and Sea Bright: Home to dedicated surf schools like Sam Hammer Surf School, these beaches are ideal for both beginners and experienced surfers seeking quality waves.

Bird Watching (33:53):

• Cape May: Renowned as a global bird-watching hub due to its location on the Atlantic Flyway. Brian recommends it for enthusiasts keen on observing diverse bird species.

• Gunnison Beach: Besides being New Jersey’s only official nude beach, it also serves as a prime spot for bird watching, offering serene environments away from the bustling boardwalks.

Tips for Avoiding Crowds

Rosalyn Colgan (09:43): Suggests exploring less frequented areas like the Rockaways during off-peak times. Staying overnight at hotels nearby can provide early morning access to quieter beaches.

Brian Donahue (10:21): Recommends visiting beaches early in the morning or later in the evening to avoid the midday crowds. Bringing family members with incentives, such as treats, can encourage early arrivals and maximize solo beach time.

Environmental Concerns

Cleanliness of Beaches (26:51):
Both Rosalyn and Brian acknowledge the pervasive issue of beach pollution, particularly plastic waste. Brian attributes much of the debris to ocean currents and sewer overflows rather than individual littering. He advocates for collective action to reduce ocean plastics as the long-term solution.

Listener Highlights

• Jason from Brooklyn (13:56): Shares a heartfelt poem about Brighton Beach, encapsulating the serene and uplifting spirit of the location. Rosalyn connects his imagery to Brighton Beach’s unique cultural blend.

• Craig from Jersey City (28:20): Reiterates his fondness for Fire Island and other Jersey Shore beaches, noting facilities like surf schools and family-friendly environments.

• Rachel from Tarrytown (36:47): Introduces Rye Playland and Glen Island Park in Westchester County, highlighting their historical significance and picturesque settings along the Long Island Sound.

Unique Beach Features

• Gunnison Beach (31:47): As New Jersey’s official nude beach, Gunnison offers a unique and friendly environment. Brian discusses its controlled setting within a federal park, ensuring a respectful atmosphere for all visitors.

• Jones Beach (28:26): Celebrated for its expansive six-mile stretch, Jones Beach provides meticulously maintained facilities, live concerts, and diverse recreational activities, making it a quintessential summer destination.

Conclusion

The episode wraps up with enthusiastic plans from both guests to enjoy upcoming beach activities, encapsulating the joy and anticipation associated with the summer season. Rosalyn and Brian express their excitement for revisiting favorite spots and discovering new ones, encouraging listeners to explore and cherish the diverse beaches of New York and New Jersey.

Notable Quotes:

• Rosalyn Colgan (02:11):
  "It's gotta have a nice spot to lay out your towel, not too crowded, and a nice boardwalk with a bit of culture."

• Brian Donahue (02:42):
  "The sweet spot is finding a place that has great nature, funky boardwalk culture, and quality restaurant options."

• Brian Donahue (27:54):
  "The ocean is full of plastic and garbage, and it washes up on the beaches. It's distressing and upsetting to no end."

• Rosalyn Colgan (16:35):
  "Rockaway has a pretty cool surf culture within an hour and a half of midtown Manhattan. It's inspiring!"

This comprehensive discussion not only highlights the best beaches in the bi-state area but also underscores the importance of balancing leisure with environmental responsibility. Listeners are encouraged to explore these destinations thoughtfully, embracing both the natural beauty and cultural richness they offer.