Podcast Summary: "Orin O'Brien, First Woman Hired for NY Phil, Profiled in Oscar-Nominated Short"

Podcast Information:

• Title: All Of It
• Host: Alison Stewart
• Episode: Orin O'Brien, First Woman Hired for NY Phil, Profiled in Oscar-Nominated Short
• Release Date: February 24, 2025
• Description: ALL OF IT is a show about culture and its consumers, aiming to engage thinkers, doers, makers, and creators about the what and why of their work.

Introduction

In this compelling episode of ALL OF IT hosted by Alison Stewart, the spotlight is on Orrin O'Brien, the first woman hired by the New York Philharmonic (NY Phil). The discussion centers around O'Brien's groundbreaking career, her modest approach to fame, and the recently released short documentary, "Only Girl in the Orchestra," directed by her niece, Molly O'Brien. The documentary has garnered critical acclaim, including an Academy Award nomination.

Background on Orrin O'Brien

Alison Stewart introduces Orrin O'Brien as a trailblazer in the world of classical music. Hired in 1966 at the age of 31, O'Brien played the double bass for the NY Phil for an impressive 55 years. Despite her significant contributions, she remained largely out of the limelight.

Alison Stewart [00:50]: "Orrin O'Brien would not have liked [recognition]. She eschewed the limelight even though she broke through a glass ceiling."

Breaking Barriers in the New York Philharmonic

O'Brien's entry into the NY Phil was a monumental step for women in classical music. Her perseverance paid off after three auditions, encouraged by her teacher, Fred Zimmerman.

Molly O'Brien [08:28]: "She auditioned three times. It was on the third time that she got in."

Her role was pivotal, challenging the gender norms of the time and paving the way for future generations of female musicians.

Family and Early Influences

O'Brien hailed from a family deeply rooted in the arts. Her father, George O'Brien, was a prolific actor with over 80 Hollywood films, including significant roles in John Ford's "Iron Horse" and F.W. Murnau's "Sunrise." Her mother, Marguerite Churchill, was a Broadway actress and model who supported the family from a young age after her father passed away.

Molly O'Brien [04:13]: "Her mother took on a second job at one point to pay for bass lessons."

The supportive environment fostered O'Brien's musical talents, emphasizing the importance of the arts in personal development.

Choosing the Double Bass

Originally a pianist, O'Brien's transition to the double bass was serendipitous. During high school, her desire to join the orchestra was redirected when her prospective position was filled by a piano player, leading her to embrace the double bass.

Molly O'Brien [05:58]: "She fell in love with the tone, with the beauty of the double bass. It's an unsung hero of the orchestra."

Her dedication to the instrument not only highlighted its significance but also showcased her commitment to ensemble harmony over solo recognition.

Fame and Personal Philosophy

Despite her achievements, O'Brien remained humble and focused on her role within the ensemble rather than personal fame. Her aversion to the spotlight was influenced by witnessing her parents' relationship with fame in Hollywood.

Molly O'Brien [11:25]: "She turned her back on all of that, moved to New York City, picked up a 19th-century instrument and said, I'm going to be part of an ensemble."

O'Brien's philosophy centered on collaboration and collective success, valuing the contributions of her peers over individual accolades.

Teaching and Legacy

O'Brien's influence extended beyond performance. She was passionate about teaching, mentoring hundreds of students worldwide, with several joining the NY Phil.

Molly O'Brien [12:45]: "The film is really about her philosophy of life, which is if you want to be a happy person, learn how to play the second fiddle and pass it on, become a teacher, be generous."

Her legacy is not only in her performances but also in the generations of musicians she inspired and trained.

Challenges and Apartment Relocation

Life in New York City presented its own challenges, notably O'Brien's struggle with maintaining her long-term, rent-stabilized apartment. After over 50 years, neglect and deteriorating conditions forced her to relocate, marking a significant personal upheaval.

Molly O'Brien [13:43]: "She'd been there for over 50 years, so it was a great bargain. But the landlords were neglectful, and she couldn't live there anymore."

This episode highlights the personal sacrifices and challenges faced by even the most accomplished individuals.

The Documentary: "Only Girl in the Orchestra"

Directed by Molly O'Brien, the documentary "Only Girl in the Orchestra" delves into O'Brien's life, capturing her dedication to ensemble work and teaching. The film emphasizes the joy of collaboration and the beauty of being part of a collective effort.

Molly O'Brien [07:19]: "What she's looking at is her fellow musicians and artists. The joy of ensemble is what I think is in her eyes."

The score, composed by Laura Cartman, reflects this philosophy, incorporating isolated double bass segments that resonate with the film's themes.

Molly O'Brien [14:19]: "Laura operated on the same philosophy that Orin O'Brien has taught us all, to work in ensemble."

The documentary has been lauded for its intimate portrayal of O'Brien's life and her profound impact on the classical music world, earning an Academy Award nomination.

Notable Quotes

• Molly O'Brien [02:44]: "I want to make a movie about you." (Regarding her initial pitches to her aunt)
• Orrin O'Brien [10:35]: "She doesn't want any part of it. She wants to be seen as a professional musician."
• Molly O'Brien [12:45]: "If you want to be a happy person, learn how to play the second fiddle and pass it on."

Conclusion

This episode of ALL OF IT paints a comprehensive portrait of Orrin O'Brien, celebrating her as a pioneer who valued collective harmony over personal fame. Through the insightful conversation with her niece, Molly O'Brien, listeners gain a deep appreciation for O'Brien's contributions to the NY Phil, her teaching legacy, and the philosophical underpinnings that guided her illustrious career. The documentary "Only Girl in the Orchestra" serves as a testament to her enduring influence in the world of classical music.

For those interested in exploring O'Brien's remarkable journey further, "Only Girl in the Orchestra" is available for streaming on Netflix.