Loading summary
Don Wildman
Want to explore even more history? Sign up to History Hit, where you will discover history from around the world. From the American Revolution to prehistoric Scotland, there is plenty to discover. With your subscription, you'll unlock hundreds of hours of exclusive documentaries with a brand new release every week, exploring everything from the ancient world to World War II. Just visit historyhit.com subscribe to bring the Past Alive
Tim Spengler
Leadership used to mean having all the answers, but today's best leaders embody a more human approach.
Jack Myers
I'm Jack Myers.
Tim Spengler
And I'm Tim Spengler.
Jack Myers
Tim and I have spent our careers inside media, marketing and culture and we
Tim Spengler
partnered with the ACAST Creator Network to start Lead Human to answer one simple question. What does it really look like to lead in this AI dominated world?
Jack Myers
The biggest tip for being a creator? It's a job.
Peter Coviello
What I learned from Michael Jackson Here's
Jack Myers
a man who understands precision. It's about answering the questions that are hard, not about answering a bunch of teed up questions that are fake.
Tim Spengler
What we're looking for are real stories and practical advice that you can use with your teams right away.
Jack Myers
Subscribe to Lead Human with Jack Myers and Tim Spengler wherever you get your podcasts.
Commercial Voice 1
At vrbo, we understand that even the best of plans sometimes need a little support, so we plan for the plot twists. Every booking is automatically backed by our VRBO Care Guarantee, giving you confidence from the very start. Whenever you need help, it's ready before your stay through the moments in between and after your trip. Because a great trip starts with peace of mind and maybe a good playlist. But we've got the peace of mind part covered.
Peter Coviello
O o o Ozempic hi, I'm Michael from the Warren Treaty. You know the jingle now discover the facts about ozempic. A GLP1 only Novo Nordisk makes FDA approved oz. Learn about the real thing.
Commercial Voice 1
Talk to your healthcare professional today. Call 1833 ozempic or visit ozempic.com to view the medication guide and to learn more about ozempic. Semaglutide injection 0.5 milligrams, 1 milligram and 2 milligrams.
Don Wildman
First, it's clouds of dust, thin, far away. Then on the horizon, a line takes shape. Wagons, uniforms, cavalry.
Peter Coviello
An army with a mission.
Don Wildman
The United States is coming. In Salt Lake City, Brigham Young gives the order. No pitched battles, no glorious stand. Scorch the grass, empty the outposts, scatter the herds. This army must march into a void. Better to destroy Zion than to surrender it. This is no rebellion of the standard variety. More Like a noose tightening on these troops, begging the question, whose land is this? Those who came to build a kingdom or the nation they left behind now marching to claim it as theirs. The Mormon Rebellion is about to begin. I'm Don Wildman, and this is American History Hit. To help tell us more about this important event, we welcome Professor Peter Coviello of the University of Illinois. His book Make Yourselves Mormons and the Unfinished Business of American Secularism was a finalist for the John Whitmer Historical Association Award for Best History. Hello, Peter.
Peter Coviello
Welcome back. Nice to see you again, Don.
Jack Myers
It's a pleasure to see you. Thank you for having me.
Peter Coviello
You were last with us in 2023. Another world ago. 300 episodes ago.
Jack Myers
Another World Ago.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. Check the archives for episode 86, Mormons and the Founding of Salt Lake City, in which we discussed, Peter and I, the origins and Western migrations of those people called Mormons through the 1830s and 40s. Today we dive more into the 1850s. After the establishment of Utah as a territory of the United States, all a consequence of the victorious Mexican American War, adherents to this highly controversial religion have now set up shop in Utah. That's what we're going to be talking about today. Three years is a long time ago, Peter. I'm a bit rusty. Let's briefly review those origins, shall we?
Jack Myers
Well, no one's more rusty than I, but we'll try. Yeah, let's do it.
Peter Coviello
We'll be quick about this. 1830 Mormonism is founded by Joseph Smith when he happens upon the golden plates in western New York State, undergoes a spiritual transformation. These plates contain a religious history of this ancient American religion. Take us through that and the bullet
Jack Myers
points of this subject very, very, very quickly. He writes the Book of Mormon in upstate New York and gathers around him a bunch of detractors, but also a lot of followers. Over the course of the decade, Mormons migrate west. Joseph Smith is intensely charismatic and also intensely theologically imaginative. So he writes the Book of Mormon, but he keeps writing it, keeps thinking, and he keeps proselytizing. And as he does so, the faith gathers to itself more adherents and a more vehement kind of detractor.
Peter Coviello
It's really the ultimate Protestant religion in that it's correcting what's wrong with Protestantism, isn't it?
Jack Myers
He's. Well, I mean, it depends on who you ask, right? They understand themselves as a vigorously counter Protestantism. That is to say, like the whole point of Mormonism or not the whole point, but a big point of Mormonism is millennia of Religion has conspired to get you to believe that God is different from you, that the world is fallen. In fact, this is incorrect. Christianity itself is an apostasy. Why? Because God is a brethren human. And you yourself in the mortal world are living in an unfallen body, and you yourself are speeding toward divinization. Because God wants everything that's best about human life, embodiment, joy, friendship, love. To be eternalized.
Peter Coviello
Wow.
Jack Myers
And to be yours, eternity. So, yeah, that's the.
Peter Coviello
You've already left me behind. I mean, Joseph Smith made a declaration that humans, more than following God, could become divine, themselves one with him of God.
Jack Myers
Exactly.
Peter Coviello
That's where the title of your book comes from, right?
Jack Myers
Yes. Make yourselves gods. Make yourselves gods. He. I mean, you can see the. The gorgeousness of the vision. He is willing to imagine a far more expansively loving kind of God, certainly than any Calvinist God. God is not only this, not this, like, radically other, occasionally malevolent figure. God is rather a sibling human.
Peter Coviello
Gotcha.
Jack Myers
A person that. That. That you are the God. And persons are different in degree, but not in kind.
Peter Coviello
Oh, wow. No wonder it's controversial. This would really, really ruffle the feathers of a lot of Puritans. This is why the Mormons have to increasingly migrate west, as we covered on our previous episode. They are being persecuted, they are being pushed away from communities they are in. Terrible things happen to them.
Jack Myers
Yes.
Peter Coviello
The growth of Mormonism led to earlier believers facing this persecution by moving onward.
Jack Myers
Yes.
Peter Coviello
From 1833, the Mormons were repeatedly forced out of towns. They moved into Illinois, where you are by 1838. Things have become so tense that Governor Lilburn Boggs in that state said Mormons must now be treated as enemies. They must be just exterminated or driven from the state. Boy, it gets intense. And by 1839, they have extermination order. Yeah. They have created something called Nauvoo.
Jack Myers
Nauvoo. Nauvoo. It's on the edge of Illinois. Yeah, it's a river town on the edge of Illinois, which is their sort of own town. And that's where, like, the grandest theological speculation that. That Smith will produce really happens. It's a scene of, like, super intense theological foment. It's where Smith comes to the revelation that one of the key components of exaltation, of the idea that humans can exalt themselves into gods, is polygamy, is plural, patriarchal marriage. And there's a lot, a lot, a lot of different ways of reading that. Is it a restoration of Old Testament beliefs? Is it a hyper patriarchalization of a. Of a world that's becoming more industrial and more gender equitable in the 19th century? Those. You can make those things stick. For me in my reading of Mormonism, it's really just an essential part of what Smith understands as the theology of Mormonism. That is to say the world is unfallen, we live in these, in unfallen bodies. And it's incredibly hard to believe that you need a discipline of practice that for him is plural marriage. Anyway, he has that revelation. They don't publicize it for a while, not surprisingly, because it makes people furious. But of course, already scandal surrounds them. They're accused of many things, but particularly being accused of, like being perverts, people whose pretend devotions have led them into perversity. And that accusation, of course allows people like Lil Burn Boggs to say what we should probably do is exterminate.
Peter Coviello
I mean, it's really deep. What does the Latter Day Saint refer to? What is that? The name of the movement?
Jack Myers
Saints of the World is like we are in a state of revelation in the present tense.
Peter Coviello
Okay.
Jack Myers
That revelation didn't end in the days of the Bible. It exists now. I see in the present tense. God speaks as much in the present tense. Now, of course, like that particular version of counter Protestant devotion has other analogues. Like the Mormons don't have to look around them very far to see what it looks like to be a kind of belief, practice askance, that of normative American Protestantism. That's how native peoples were persecuted explicitly as heathens, as people whose backwards counterproducts and beliefs made them again fit for extermination. So the Mormons feel this, like very complex identification with native peoples who appear in the Book of Mormon as Lamanites and stuff like that. So it's a super fraught identification because they also want to identify as, you know, white people with all the powers of empire belonging to them as well. So they take all that with them into the West.
Peter Coviello
The whole thing that we're not going to get into, but it's really about returning to the homeland for this movement because in their minds there have been previous tribes of, I guess white Europeans essentially have been here before they weren't Europeans. But this is like a very interesting cyclical story that's returning them essentially to a Garden of Eden. And so this makes North America and America that much more special when they consider this. And this was all what was written down on the plates that Joseph Smith creates the Book of Mormon. Out of Nauvoo was a very significant settlement. Largest. One of the largest cities in Illinois at the time. Had a militia, the Novu Nauvoo.
Jack Myers
Yeah. Legion.
Peter Coviello
Foreshadowing what's to come. A temple which has been rebuilt even today. A chartered city government. They were very serious about this. But then Joseph Smith is killed in 1844 in a mob.
Jack Myers
Yes. He's assassinated in a prison. You can still go. Carthage, Illinois. And the Mormons are not wrong. This is anticipating where we're going. In the 1850s, the Mormons surely cannot be blamed for thinking of themselves as persecuted and as persons that the state and elements of the state are free to murder. They had executed Joseph Smith. There'd been a massacre at Haun's Mill. Been the extermination order. So some historians will refer to the Mormons persecution complex. And I understand where that comes from, but they have some real data to go on in the 19th century, you know.
Peter Coviello
Sure. Yeah.
Jack Myers
The state itself had expressed a great willingness to massacre the Mormons.
Peter Coviello
Right.
Jack Myers
To the degree that they're even remotely identified with native peoples as fellow exiles from an imperial America. They also understand what extermination looks like. They also can see their own fates written out in the fate of native peoples.
Peter Coviello
So obviously there's talk among them of a homeland, and this would be where we're heading when we come back after a break. But before we get there, I just want to underscore the fact that polygamy really is a major issue for Americans at that time. And people still talk about it, still gives everybody the heebie jeebies. But back then, we're talking about a time of greater religion and, you know, established religions that really mix up with the politics, just as they do today. Of course. But back then, it was a big deal. When the wider US found out about polygamy in the 1850s, they were horrified. Mormons became a huge debating point in the 1956 presidential election of James Buchanan.
Jack Myers
They did.
Peter Coviello
Major, major point. So after the break, we'll come back and talk about how those tensions reach their peak in Utah.
Don Wildman
Hello, American history hit listeners. It is an honor that you choose to listen to us, but we also know it's important that someone listens to you. We may not be surviving the Oregon Trail or drafting the constitution of a new country, but these days can bring their own challenges. And finding a therapist who takes your insurance can make it all so much harder. That's where Rula comes in. Rula is a healthcare company that makes it simple to get high quality mental health care that works with your insurance, not against your budget. They partner with over 100 insurance plans and RULA patients typically copay around $15 per session when using insurance, sometimes even less depending on your benefits. Instead of being matched with the first random name on a list, Rula considers your goals, preferences and background, then offers a curated list of licensed in network therapists who are actually aligned with what you need. There are no wait lists, no endless back and forth emails, just real therapy from vetted professionals with appointments available as soon as tomorrow. Rula then stays with you throughout your journey helping you schedule check in, supporting your progress so you're not left navigating this alone. Thousands of people are already using Rula to get affordable, high quality therapy that's actually covered by Insurance. Visit rula.comhistoryhit to get started today. That's R U L A.comhistoryhit after you sign up, please support the show and let them know we sent you. You deserve mental health care that works with you, not against your budget.
Commercial Voice 1
We're lost. It feels like we're going round in circles. I'm gonna ask that man for directions.
Jack Myers
Hi there. We're trying to get to the state fairgrounds.
Peter Coviello
Well, you're going to take a left
Commercial Voice 2
at the old oak tree at this here road.
Peter Coviello
Nah, I'm just kidding. Let me get my phone out.
Commercial Voice 1
How is it their signal out here?
Commercial Voice 2
T Mobile and US Cellular are coming
Peter Coviello
together so the network out here is huge.
Commercial Voice 2
We get the same great signal as the city, saving a boatload with benefits. And there's a five year price guarantee too.
Peter Coviello
Okay, here's the turn.
Commercial Voice 1
Actually, can you pull up the way to a T Mobile store?
Commercial Voice 2
America's best network just got bigger. Switch to T Mobile today and get built in benefits the other guys leave out plus our five year price guarantee. And now T Mobile is available at US Cellular stores in Hermiston. Best Mobile Network Based on analysis by Ooklo Speed test intelligence data second half of 2025 bigger network the combination of T Mobile and US Cellular's network footprints will enhance the T Mobile network's coverage price guarantee on talk text and data exclusions like taxes and fees apply. See t mobile.com for details.
Jack Myers
Acast Powers the World's Best Podcasts Here's a show that we recommend.
Podcast Hosts Knox and Jamie
Do you like being educated on things that entertain but don't matter? Well then you need to be listening to the podcast with Knox and Jamie. Every Wednesday we put together an episode dedicated to delightful idiocy to give your brain a break from all the serious and important stuff.
Commercial Voice 1
Whether we're deep diving a classic movie, dissecting the true meanings behind the newest slang, or dunking on our own listeners for their bad takes or cringy stories, we always approach our topics with humor and just a little bit of side eye. And we end every episode with recommendations on all the best new movies, books, TV shows or music.
Podcast Hosts Knox and Jamie
To find out more, just search up the podcast with Knox and Jamie. Wherever you listen to podcasts and prepare to make Wednesday your new favorite day of the week.
Jack Myers
ACAST helps creators launch, grow and monetize their podcasts everywhere. Acast.com.
Peter Coviello
Welcome back. We're discussing the Mormon religion with Professor Peter Coviello. So we've established, Peter, some of the Mormon beliefs and why tensions began growing between them and eventually the federal government. First, the state government of Illinois, of course, was really on them. Events to keep in mind as we get further into Utah. 1847, Brigham Young, who is a lieutenant of Joseph Smith, takes over after Joseph Smith's assassination. And they head west. They go by way of Missouri, of course, like everybody does. Important to keep in mind at this point, 1847, where they will end up. Utah is still part of Mexican territory. The Mexican American War hasn't been fought yet. That's an 1848-49 kind of time. The land becomes US territory after we win that war. And the Treaty of Hidalgo gives us that massive amount of land in the West. Congress creates the Utah Territory as part of the Compromise of 1850. All right, so that sets the stage for all of what we're about to talk about.
Jack Myers
Yes. The fraught 1850s.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. By this time, as you have completely explained to us, there is good reason why these Mormons should be circling their wagons. And they are, they are very worried about what's coming next. Was Utah in their crosshairs or that area in the crosshairs that far west as they made their migration?
Jack Myers
Not necessarily. It was, you know, this is the place they, they found a place that looked habitable and looked like it could hold the Saints, the population of Mormons. But it was also at what for Brigham Young particularly was at like a saving distance from the eastern United States and its increasingly apocalyptic tensions. Of course, we're in the run up to slavery.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
And it also helped to foment the dream of a nation apart from the United States, the fallen and doomed United States, which is again, you can, it's very easy to read the Book of Mormon as prophesying the fall of the Americans whom the Mormons will call the Gentiles. And it's very easy to think that the native people will have a role in that destruction too.
Peter Coviello
Wouldn't it be cool to do a PhD thesis on apocalyptic thinking historically throughout all of American history? Because, boy, that's a big part of the mid 19th century. I mean, you've got the Mormons, you've got the. The whole south is thinking about themselves as apart from. And that's a very religious world down there. It's just gotta be boiled into the. Into the fat of America, isn't it?
Jack Myers
Yeah. Eschatology is a really, really tempting option at all. At all points, Don. I also appreciate that we're having this conversation on whatever day. Today is April 7th under the tweeted threat of the annihilation of an entire civilization. Like, eschatologies don't really go away. And eschatology is a real, real part of the Book of Mormon. The Book of Mormon is like, strangely, the account of a. Of a righteous people, the Nephites who are annihilated. It's the, like, remaining account of a people who backslide and are fallen, and so God sees fit to them being annihilated. The Mormons are read out into that a fate of backsliding America. How do they know they're backsliding? Because they've so persecuted us, because they have so cast out their most righteous people, the Mormons, the Saints. We've been cast out into the west that for us, prophesied. And this. Now I just sound like Brigham Young in the 1850s. This prophesies the doom of the nation. I would say that repeatedly.
Peter Coviello
It was named the state of Deseret. Am I getting that pronunciation correct?
Jack Myers
I believe you are correct.
Peter Coviello
Okay. And Deseret translates, I guess, probably loosely into by honeybee, like those brought by the original Jaredites from Jerusalem. I mentioned before that we've been here before according to the Mormons, and that was an early tribe. Yeah. The Book of Mormon says these guys, the Jaredites, quite literally after a guy named Jared, were here before and they had brought with them honeybees, which had, I guess, propagated and become, you know,
Jack Myers
spread around the North America and a symbol of industriousness.
Peter Coviello
Yes, exactly. Good for them.
Jack Myers
And indomitability. Yeah, right.
Peter Coviello
And little tiny cubicles where they feel very comfortable, I guess. But a year later, Utah becomes a US territory in 1850, as I mentioned, because of the Mexican American War victory. At that point, federal oversight in the area begins. That's got to be a, you know, Ominous note for the. For the Mormons.
Jack Myers
Very fraught. Very fraught.
Peter Coviello
Trouble is brewing. The Mormon rebellion that we're really talking about in this is not a war in a traditional sense. It's more of a. Of an ongoing standoff over sovereignty. Right.
Jack Myers
That's donuts. Perfectly said. That's exactly right. Who. And of course, what the Mormons want is the. What they will eventually get once they renounce polygamy at the end of the century, which is the protected, if limited sovereignty of statehood. Because, of course, statehood grants you all kinds of. Of sovereign powers, as we know, and the Civil War had litigated in blood what exactly the extent of those sovereign powers were. They don't have that. What they have is a territory which is much, much more disputed. Though, of course, what the Mormons have going for them is they're many thousands of miles away, east coast and the outposts of the federal government. And so that allows Brigham to maneuver rather more widely than he would have if he was in, say, Pennsylvania or Ohio. And the detractors of the Mormons call what's being created there a theocratic state or a theodemocracy. The Mormons think that they are practicing what on the east coast they like to call religious freedom. Of course, there's a lot of contestation over what gets to count as religion. That's now. And the Mormons on polygamy and on the way that polygamy made them like they were called all sorts of things in 1930. Mohammedans was a very favorite one. They were always being accused of being secretly Indian fomenting rebellions with the Indians. Right. So they understand themselves to be in possession of religious freedom.
Peter Coviello
Right.
Jack Myers
And I understand polygamy to be a part of that religious freedom. The federal government does not understand it that way. These are some of the interior tensions that are really roiling across the 1850s, which is, as you say, already a semi apocalyptic time because of the fight about slavery that is brewing and becoming more and more apocalyptic.
Peter Coviello
US President James Buchanan sends federal troops over to Utah to install a new government. He sends almost one third. Yeah. Of the entire army is sent out there. This is a very important and pressing
Jack Myers
issue, which is an amazing. Like that, that very. I remember when I was reading that I was like, Avnol sends like, I don't know, 2,500, 3,000 troops or something like that. But like, that's like a third of the standing army goes to Utah. And what Buchanan will say in Washington D.C. is that Brigham Young is in open rebellion against The United States of America. And Brigham Young will say, Buchanan is fighting a war of extermination.
Peter Coviello
Yeah, yeah.
Jack Myers
And Watts, a war of exter. And in a certain way, both of them are correct. They're both of them pretty near on to. Right. So it looks very much like that's gonna happen. The Mountain Meadows Massacre happens, which inflames things gravely. So, yeah.
Peter Coviello
In anticipation of this arrival, the Mormons prepare for defense. Their evacuation of Mormon settlements. They kind of practice a scorched earth policy of burning out grassy areas so there's nowhere for these horses to graze. They will target US Supply lines. And as mentioned before, there's no major pitched battles here. It's just kind of an ongoing practice of, let's starve these guys out so they'll turn around and go home. There is heavy duty bloodshed. In one event. It's called the Mountain Meadows massacre. 1857, members of a Mormon militia known as the Nauvoo Legion and local participants kill dozens of emigrants passing through Utah. This is a really hairy thing, isn't it?
Jack Myers
Tremendously so. Tremendously so. It's. There's much contestation in the historiography. Did Young. So he certainly. The rhetoric and discourse around the area was definitely coming from Young, and it was definitely bloody in intent. Whether or not he authorized the actual attack on all of the emigrants is a different question. He will not be tried, but a different Mormon will be. They are in league with some Paiutes in the area. They clumsily attempt to blame it on the Paiutes. Oh, we didn't kill these immigrants. It was an Indian massacre that's exposed in the next year. So, of course, the Mormons think of emigrants as passageways for the state to get at them, and so they mistrust them violently. And when they murder these people, the state is like, okay, these are now. This is a party of people in bloody rebellion.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. There was a great series on this sort of miniseries last year on, I think it was Netflix, where it's called American Primeval. I mean, they at least cast this in an insanely violent tone. It was really heavy duty. And that's.
Jack Myers
I mean, again, you say it just right. There's an eschatological edge to the period. And Brigham is not shy about saying, the federal agents who've come here and maligned our civilization should have been hung in the streets. He just says things like that. You know what I mean?
Peter Coviello
Right.
Jack Myers
And so Buchanan is not exactly wrong. On the other hand, he did send a third of the federal army out presumably to destroy a religious sect in the West.
Peter Coviello
Right.
Jack Myers
For. For erotic practices that they didn't really believing in back East.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. At least 120 people are killed in this situation. A cover up was attempted trying to shift the blame to Native Americans nearby. It has the effect of damaging the Mormon moral standing even further. Right. This does no good for their reputation in America.
Jack Myers
Kind of though. I think that's right, though. It is also the case that polygamy outweighs everything. A violation. Yeah. Yeah. Polygamy was such a ready to handle way to dismiss any Mormon claim to dignity, sovereignty, peace, anything you wanted. And to do it as what happened in the 19th century. Frantically. In like, frantically racializing terms.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
Mohammedan. They're Indian. Like the followers are slave, like in their sycophancy to ecclesiastical leaders. So the Mormons are always being produced as dubiously white people.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
Like there's a great line in a Jack London story where the, you know, somebody says it's, well, can't get. Those are white. Oh, they ain't white. They're Mormons. And that's a real. That's of course in the 19th century. The Mormons are again not wrong to hear in that.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
The possibility of having become expendable life. They are not ignorant of what the federal government does to racialized life, to black populations, native populations. So they're not really wrong.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. This kind of wraps up in. In mid-1858, the US army ends up marching unopposed through to Salt Lake City and into it. It ends relatively quickly with a, with a negotiated peace. This was due, of course, because there was a lot going on back east. I mean, you know, there was a lot happening. This is, this is becomes a minor problem compared to what's boiling up real fast.
Jack Myers
That's very right.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. Buchanan is facing a lot of pressure at home to bring this crisis to an end. In the end, the whole affair, sending the army out, the whole bloodshed, everything was called Buchanan's blunder in the, in the press. He looks real bad. Buchanan was no, you know, he wasn't doing too well in many regards as a president. But this was certainly a stain on his character.
Jack Myers
Didn't help.
Peter Coviello
I want to circle back because we're about to talk about Brigham Young, you know, officially becoming the governor of Utah at this point. Tell me about this man. Who was Brigham Young and why did he step into the role?
Jack Myers
Yes. Well, Brigham Young in a certain way that I will both say and then invite you to mistrust slightly Brigham Young provides this excellent contrast to Joseph Smith, who was theologically minded, intensely charismatic, oratorically gifted and a graphomaniac. He just wrote and wrote and wrote with tremendous down home eloquence. Like a kind of, there's, there's a, there's a Whitmanian aspect to, to just. That's not Brigham Young. Brigham Young is an organizer.
Peter Coviello
Right.
Jack Myers
And he is called by many historians the great colonizer of the West. He is going to be the great systematizer. So where Joseph Smith has left behind this intense cosmology that's kind of under codified, he is going to turn it into a structure of leadership in which he sits at the top and he distributes authority carefully. And that makes him very shrewd. It's easy to think of him, I find in my own writing. I have to resist the urge, which I don't fully resist, to think of him as kind of a villain in as much as the theology of Mormonism is ungovernably multiple. Before Joseph Smith is murdered, polygamy is just for men. But is it just for men? Well, the women in the Female Relief Society had some other idea. And then Brigham systematize, systematizes. He patriarchalizes. An already patriarchal culture. He bans African American priesthood. He identifies with the racial state even as he disidentifies from the United States as such. He just thinks the Mormons deserve an imperial investiture. So he's that sort of complicated figure. He believes that the United States is doomed. He's also incredibly pragmatic and he wants to protect native peoples. That what you mentioned before about the Mormons fleeing Salt Lake, when people wonder why there are so many Mormon settlements out west, going all the way down to Mexico, all the way up the coast out to the west. It's in part because he thought the federal government is not going to slaughter all of us if we're scattered not just in Salt Lake, but in these outposts everywhere. That's a response to this sense of incursion and the sense of vulnerability that marks the landscape today.
Peter Coviello
Right. You know, well remember that the, the army comes in order to support the idea that they're going to install their own governor. The fight is for the Mormons to be led by their own. And that is what is negotiated because Brigham Young becomes the new governor of Utah. I guess it gets named later on territory. Yeah, the territory of Utah. Buchanan pardons the Mormons for their rebellion after they accept this US Federal authority. The leader of the Nauvoo, sort of the capper on the story is a guy named John Lee and his fate. He's the leader of the Nauvoo Legion. John Lee is the only one charged with murder after that Mountain Meadows massacre and was executed years later.
Jack Myers
Yep, 77 I think many years later.
Peter Coviello
Like even Brigham Young has, has given this guy up. The time has come when they will try John D. Lee and not the Mormon Church. And that's what we have always wanted. So at that point they have really secured their place in this place they call Deseret, but is going to be renamed Utah. And after this break coming up, we will come back and talk about after the rebellion concludes, how Mormonism in Utah eventually settles into American life.
Tim Spengler
Leadership used to mean having all the answers, but today's best leaders embody a more human approach.
Jack Myers
I'm Jack Myers.
Tim Spengler
And I'm Tim Spengler.
Jack Myers
Tim and I have spent our careers inside media, marketing and culture and we
Tim Spengler
partnered with the ACAST Creator Network to start Lead Human to answer one simple question. What does it really look like to lead in this AI dominated world?
Jack Myers
World. The biggest tip for being a creator, it's a job.
Peter Coviello
What I learned from Michael Jackson, here's
Jack Myers
a man who understands precision. It's about answering the questions that are hard, not about answering a bunch of teed up questions that are fake.
Tim Spengler
What we're looking for are real stories and practical advice that you can use with your teams right away.
Jack Myers
Subscribe to Lead Human with Jack Myers and Tim Spengler. Wherever you get your podcasts.
Commercial Voice 1
Early birds always rise to the occasion for summer vacation planning because early gets
Jack Myers
you closer to the action.
Commercial Voice 1
So don't be late. Book your next vacation early on VRBO and save over $120. Rise and shine. Average savings $141.
Jack Myers
Select homes only.
Peter Coviello
Okay, we're back discussing the Mormons after the violence of the rebellion ends. We're in still pre civil war really, aren't we, Peter? Which I imagine has really changed the whole calculus of this situation. 1861, when that begins, a lot that had to do with Utah in effect gets. Gets eclipsed by what's happening back east.
Jack Myers
I think that's right though. What will be of real consequence for the Mormons? Only one way to think about the Civil War is as a clarifying contest over the extent and meaning of state sovereignty as opposed to federal sovereignty. And of course, federal sovereignty wins extremely. It wins with an enormous and unpredicted body count. So on the one hand, the Mormons survive triumphantly. They survived the Federal Incursion of 1857, 1858, and they returned to Salt Lake with a kind of triumphal look at us. On the other hand, what happens between 1866 and 1888 and 1890? A constant, constant, constant legal undermining of the conditions of existence of the Mormons, which to say a series of acts, one after another after another after another that criminalize polygamy, that make essentially make practicing the religion practicing particularly seditious and make all but impossible the continued existence of the Mormons. Yeah, well, it's inside the federal fold.
Peter Coviello
It's legislated by no less than Congress. Several different acts repeatedly. Yeah. The Moral Anti Bigamy act passed in 1862 by Congress outlawed plural marriage in US all US territories. Also limited church property ownership. It kind of weakly enforced during the American Civil War. Then comes the Edmonds act in 1882. This is 20 years later, which officially disenfranchises polygamists, made unlawful cohabitation a crime which was easier to prosecute than polygamy. Polygamists had no voting. If you were going to be a polygamist, you'd have no voting. You could not hold office, you could not be in a jury. Sounds pretty good to me. Yeah. Three Edmonds is. The third one is the Edmonds Tucker Act. Eighteen. Five years later, 1887 dissolves the LDS Church as a legal entity, imposes federal control over Utah institutions. That had to be the big one, right?
Jack Myers
Yeah. And that's. No. So the Mormons are, are, are populous and they have allies back east and they indeed have lobbyists and stuff like that. And there's a great. I've forgotten the man's name, but there's a. Their lobbyist in DC says something like, you know, I've been doing this a long time and I've never seen anything like it. Back when, when there were states in the south determined to hold on to slavery, there were many thousands of people willing to support them. Indeed, at the north, there are many thousands of people to support them. You are a body of three or four thousand people. And the fifty millions of the United States have decided polygamy will be exterminated. And the word he uses is exterminated. And what he doesn't have to say is, and if it's not, you will be wow. Of course. Incredible decimation of native peoples in the West. Once again, I will say the pretext for a lot of that decimation was not land theft, it was religion. And a religion that deranged people sexually. The native peoples, they didn't live in coupled households. They didn't have houses. They needed to be disciplined into that. This is how the native ill fittedness for American life was again and again spoken. Which of course had great resonances for the Mormons. And the Mormons polygamousness.
Peter Coviello
Interesting.
Jack Myers
They knew what extermination looked like.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
Was very near them. And so this is the context in which at the end of the century, they. They end up renouncing polygamy as a condition to gain statehood for Utah and with it the protections and sovereignty that come with statehood.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. The screws had been tightened. 1887.
Jack Myers
So much.
Peter Coviello
Yeah. By 1890, the LDS Church's president now understand, three years later, is the Edmunds Tucker Act. 1887, which prior to this I'd never heard of. That really does the legal job of. Of disincorporating, corporating this. This church seizing church assets, imposing federal control over territorial institutions, including schools and elections. I mean, big time, they come down with a hammer. It's in 1890 that the LDS Church kind of relents and their president, Wilford Woodruff, issues a manifesto that officially ended plural marriages. So if you ever wondered, well, what happened to that polygamy that was such a big deal in the 1800s for the Mormons, this is what happened. The federal government came down hard.
Jack Myers
The federal government threatened to murder everyone. And that had a pretty normalizing effect. I'll read you a little passage in a letter Woodruff wrote to, which is for me, incredibly revealing. He writes this letter in 1889 to a friend of his name, William Ekin. He says we are now, politically speaking, the dependent or ward of the United States, but in a state capacity, we should be freed from such dependency and would possess the powers and independence of a sovereign state, a dependent or ward. What's striking to me about that is that is exactly, as you know, that is exactly the language with which the state described the relation of native tribes through the federal government. They were wards.
Peter Coviello
Wow.
Jack Myers
And this is 1889. This is the time of Wounded Knee. Man like Woodruff is not wrong to think that while we are a dependent or ward of the state, we are fit to be murdered.
Peter Coviello
Interesting.
Jack Myers
We know what that looks like. So those are the stakes. Yeah, those are the stakes of renouncing polygamy, which is, of course, an enormous, hugely disruptive act. You've been told for however many years, however many decades, that this is an essential part of the theology of your religion, which you've been willing to stake your life on.
Peter Coviello
Interesting.
Jack Myers
And then it's renounced.
Peter Coviello
Yes.
Jack Myers
In the course of the 1890s.
Peter Coviello
I'm going to ask you a last question here about legacy, but before we answer this, I just want to emphasize what is such an interesting piece of learning for myself, I hope for listeners as well that the real unique aspect of the story, the theme of this is that the. That the Mormons really related to Native American tribes so much because of course, their history, that which is written in the golden plates, puts them here as essentially native tribes. They're just coming back to where their previous civilization was. In their mythology would be the word for me. But I guess their Book of Mormon states it.
Jack Myers
Their scripture.
Peter Coviello
Yeah, their scripture. Sorry.
Jack Myers
A fantastic. And this is one of the things that I try to write about in my book. There's an environmental historian named Jared Farmer, I think writes very well. An intensely fraught identification with native people whose lands they, the Mormons feel they are entitled to, who they will attempt to colonize and biophilanthropize, one could say, but whom they also understand to be fellow refugees from an imperial America, but an imperial America that they also want to be a part of because they want to be imperialists. It makes for a fantastically fraught set of relations that stretches across the whole of the 19th century. The whole of the 19th century.
Peter Coviello
Have they been uniquely good in their relations with Native tribes within? No.
Jack Myers
I mean, they had been better than the federal government, but of course that's a tremendously low bar. Yeah, you know, they were one of the major players in the West. Of course, in the west at the time, there's a lot of warfare between different tribes. Equestrian tribes like the apaches and the Utes have the upper hand. Particularly they are a route for slave trading. The Mormons are opposed to slave trading. That makes the Paiutes an ally of theirs. But ally is a strong word. The Paiutes are trying to survive. There are a lot of talk about the Ghost Dance. Remember the Ghost Dance?
Peter Coviello
Sure.
Don Wildman
Of course.
Jack Myers
In the 1880s, the federal government will repeatedly say the Mormons are behind all. Oh, wow, the Mormons.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
Because it has an eschatological and redemptive end. And they think that the Mormons are secret. Throughout the 19th century, the federal government kept saying the Mormons are secretly in league with the native people to murder the Americans. And in some ways they were, you know, again, in ways they were totally willing to also murder native people themselves to take land themselves. It's hard to over describe the fraughtness of Mormon native relation in the west in the 19th century.
Peter Coviello
Utah becomes a state in 1896. And that's late, you know, when you consider that California became one in 1850, so almost 40 years earlier. There's a difference between that. But that's because of all these things that had to be legislated and worked out and nailed down before we're going to give you the state that you're insisting on having. Before you do that, we're going to have to integrate you into the American way of life, which they do. How does the legacy of this rebellion. And now we have completely defined it as an ongoing, many faceted aspect of things. The idea of their desert kingdom. How does that all square now?
Jack Myers
That's a great question in certain ways. The first thing I'll say is I'm the. I'm ill equipped to answer it because my. My scholarly interest in the Mormons ends at literally the moment they renounce polygamy. That's the part of the Mormon trajectory that, that I. Most interesting, though, I think you can see from the Mormon side, it's not entirely unfair to say what had been a vigorously counter Protestantism, something that understood itself as improving what they would read as the apostasy of American Christianity, becomes in essence another subset of American Christianity, another kind of belief that seems more tolerable, that is better able to sit at the table of American para Christianities which simply had not been before. Renouncing polygamy. That, of course, makes the Mormons a different kind of player on the national stage. And it's a kind of a. If you're me, it's a striking transformation. Like a people who really were willing to stake their lives on their opposition to the imperial United States, become like avatars of good citizenship.
Peter Coviello
Yeah.
Jack Myers
And Harold Bloom will call them the American religion. Yeah.
Peter Coviello
Huge patriotism. You know, if there's ever a place I think as patriotic, it's the state of Utah. You know, it's the Mormons. The irony is unbelievable.
Jack Myers
And what's also sort of puzzling is that the Mormons sort of stop living as though they live inside sacred time, but rather they treat the 19th century itself, the moment from 1830 to 1818 90, as their sacred history. But what that does, there are many effects of that. So there's lots of celebrations about the. The sacred history of the Mormons, but it installs statehood and national belonging as a kind of telos.
Peter Coviello
Yeah, right.
Jack Myers
And all that you and I have been talking about today was. Well, that was really not inevitable. And in many respects it wasn't Desired.
Peter Coviello
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Jack Myers
And it's almost like that was sacralization. Yeah.
Peter Coviello
Every religion has its. Its schism, you know, the division within it and then. And then the reunification of it. It seems like that's inevitable for all religions. For. For Mormonism, it's with the country itself. Right. That's the schism. And then when they reunite, it's a different kind of practice altogether.
Jack Myers
And of course, there are a lot of Mormons who do not accept the renunciation of. They think it is for cheap and worldly expedients. And that's where the f. LDS Fundamentalist Mormon Church comes from. And there's plenty of segments in still polygamous. Still polygamous west who understand themselves precisely as. As fundamentalists, as not having ceded the ground of what to them was essential to the theology. To the theology. To the lived theology of Mormonism.
Peter Coviello
Right.
Jack Myers
Which was given up, in their view, for the. The. The, you know, the cheap and expedient reason of statehood, which for Woodruff was like, well, that's going to save our lives.
Peter Coviello
Well, yeah.
Jack Myers
Keep us from being annihilated.
Peter Coviello
Nice to not have the federal government after you every day of your life.
Jack Myers
It's nice not have a third of the federal government ringing your city, although
Peter Coviello
those fundamentals don't have an opinion on the, you know, federal forces coming in any given day. Yeah, it's interesting.
Jack Myers
The ironies rebound and rebound and rebound across the 20th century.
Peter Coviello
Sure.
Jack Myers
Though others are better able to speak of that than I.
Peter Coviello
It's been a joy to talk to you. Peter Coviello is a professor of history at the University of Illinois, and we have been discussing his book, Make Yourselves Gods, Mormons and the Unfinished Business of American Secularism. What a fascinating book that is to get. Peter, is there a website that we should be looking at ways to keep track of you?
Jack Myers
I am the head of the English department at UIC in Chicago, and you can look. If you put in my name in Chicago, you'll find more than enough about me.
Peter Coviello
There'll be a line outside your office.
Jack Myers
But, Peter, thank you. What a pleasure. I appreciate it so much.
Don Wildman
Hey, thanks for listening to American history hit. You know, every week we release new episodes, two new episodes dropping Mondays and Thursdays, all kinds of content from mysterious missing colonies to powerful political movements to some of the biggest battles across the centuries. Don't miss an episode by hitting like and follow. You help us out, which is great, but you'll also be reminded when our shows are on. And while you're at it, share it with a friend. American history Hit with me. Don Wildman so grateful for your support.
Jack Myers
ACAST powers the world's best podcasts. Here's a show that we recommend
Podcast Hosts Knox and Jamie
do you like being educated on things that entertain but don't matter? Well, then you need to be listening to the Podcast with Knox and Jamie Every Wednesday we put together an episode dedicated to delightful idiocy to give your brain a break from all the serious and important stuff.
Commercial Voice 1
Whether we're deep diving a classic movie, dissecting the true meanings behind the newest slang, or dunking on our own listeners for their bad takes or cringy stories, we always approach our topics with humor and just a little bit of side eye. And we end every episode with recommendations on all the best new movies, books, TV shows, or music.
Podcast Hosts Knox and Jamie
To find out more, just search up the Podcast with Knox and Jamie wherever you listen to podcasts and prepare to make Wednesday your new favorite day of the week.
Jack Myers
ACAST helps creators launch, grow and monetize their podcasts everywhere.
Commercial Voice 1
Acast.com with Verbocare Help is always ready before, during and after your stay. We've planned for the plot twists, so support is always available because a great trip starts with peace of mind.
Host: Don Wildman
Guest: Prof. Peter Coviello (University of Illinois, author of Make Yourselves Gods)
Release Date: April 13, 2026
In this episode, Don Wildman and historian Prof. Peter Coviello explore the so-called Mormon Rebellion in mid-19th century America. The discussion uncovers the foundational beliefs, persecution, migration, and eventual confrontation between Mormon settlers in Utah and the U.S. federal government—culminating in what became known as the Utah War and its aftermath. The episode also addresses the theological and social underpinnings of Mormonism, the fraught dynamic with Native Americans, and how the legacy of this rebellion shaped both the Mormon experience and the broader American narrative.
Nature of the Rebellion:
Buchanan Sends in the Army:
Mormon Resistance:
The Mountain Meadows Massacre (1857):
Resolution:
This episode delivers a nuanced account of how Mormonism’s foundational distinctiveness, theological radicalism, and early persecution led to a dramatic confrontation with the United States—both a literal and symbolic “rebellion” that ultimately resolved through adaptation, compromise, and transformation. The conversation shines in tying together issues of faith, governance, American identity, and the complex entanglement with other marginalized groups. For history enthusiasts or those exploring the intersection of religion and American expansion, this is essential listening.