When Was the Revolutionary War Won?

Summary

---

American History Hit — “When Was the Revolutionary War Won?”

Host: Don Wildman
Guests: Dan Snow (podcast host, historian), Major Jonathan Bratton (engineer officer, command historian)
Date: May 25, 2026

---

Episode Overview

In this pivotal episode, Don Wildman is joined by British historian Dan Snow and U.S. military historian Major Jonathan Bratton to tackle a perennial question: When was the American Revolutionary War truly won? As the U.S. approaches the Semiquincentennial, they sift through military turning points, the fog of war, shifting alliances, and persistent myths to uncover decisive moments that shaped the war’s trajectory—from the early colonial struggles to the Treaty of Paris. The tone is lively, at times irreverent, and packed with sharp historical insight.

---

Key Themes & Discussion Points

1. What Was at Stake? Empire Versus Independence

• The British Perspective: Both sides are fighting for the fate of empire. The British want to preserve their imperial reach, the rebellious colonists want relief from taxes and more control over their future.

  • Major Jonathan Bratton (06:05):
    “You can boil it down from a colonial, provincial perspective… but at the end of the day, you're fighting a war for empire, as historian Fred Anderson called it.”
  • Dan Snow (06:53):
    “We think they are fighting to avoid paying any tax, avoid paying their fair share. That war was fought to protect these British colonies... and they don’t want to pay their fair share.”
  • The war is also deeply about who will shape and enjoy the benefits of the empire's expansion.

• Early American Disunity: The colonial states are notoriously fractious, making unity—and thus effective resistance—a challenge.

---

2. The Geography Problem: Home Turf or Oceanic Barrier?

• Home Advantage? The Americans’ greatest asset, Bratton argues, isn’t the terrain so much as the Atlantic Ocean, which slows British response, supply lines, and communication.
  • Major Bratton (08:47):
    "The biggest advantage—it’s the Atlantic Ocean that’s America's biggest advantage always... It means that anything that happens in the colonies, the information is going to take three weeks to a month or two to get back across the ocean."
  • The vastness and unforgiving landscape make it “hard to hold down vast amounts of terrain no matter how big your army is.” (Dan Snow, 10:28)

---

3. Myth and Reality: American Guerilla Tactics

• The “Mythologized” Guerillas: The famous image of ragtag colonial militias outfoxing the redcoats is only partly true. Bratton is particularly insistent on separating “mythology” from documented success.
  • Major Bratton (11:37):
    “Definitely mythology. Tons of mythology.”

---

4. The First Battles and The Siege of Boston (13:22 — 17:24)

• Lexington, Concord, and Siege of Boston: These early battles burnish the rebel cause but are more tactical scrambles than strategic masterstrokes.
  • Washington’s Challenge: Commanding a fractious, mostly part-time force, he has “critical shortages”—especially in manpower and ammunition.
  • Bratton (13:40):
    “Washington is dealing with an army that’s got about 13 rounds per man at the siege of Boston... would love a large scale assault... simply not practicable.”
  • The Dorchester Heights Move: Washington’s strategic placement of cannons forces the British to evacuate—but it’s not the “heroic” battlefield triumph he’d prefer.

---

5. Declaration of Independence: Propaganda and Polarization (20:43 — 24:06)

• A Public Act of Treason: The Declaration is both legal justification and a brilliantly disseminated act of propaganda—internally and externally.

  • Bratton (21:03):
    “If you’re going to have a rebellion, you got to do some specific things in public and very openly... The critical piece of the declaration is how rapidly it is disseminated after they wrangle over what it’s going to be.”
  • Notable Moment: Washington having the Declaration read at army camps to reinforce the cause.

• Dividing the Population: Only about a third of the population strongly supports independence. Many are just trying to survive, switching loyalties as circumstances shift.

  • Bratton (24:06):
    "It also creates a very firm dividing line down the middle. Either you are for independence or you are not."

---

6. Turning Point: Saratoga and Foreign Intervention (26:14 — 34:22)

• Saratoga’s Strategic Complexity: The failed British plan to slice the colonies is due as much to logistical failures and mismanagement as to American resistance. When Burgoyne’s force surrenders, the psychological and political impact is seismic.

  • Dan Snow (26:41):
    “The plan was very, very complex... None of those forces do what they're supposed to, and none of them arrive at the right time.”
  • Bratton (28:37):
    “It’s a great own goal because... Whitehall’s job [is] to oversee a cohesive war plan... They approve every plan that they’re given.”

• Aftermath: The French Enter the War:

  • The French are convinced by American resilience and potential.
  • Bratton (30:20):
    “You have the French crown, who very much have a policy of: We don’t really want to get heavily involved, but we would really love to bleed our traditional enemy as dry as possible.”
  • This transforms a colonial rebellion into a wider world war (with Spain and the Dutch joining), stretching British resources to breaking point.

• Notable Quote — Coalition Warfare:

  • Dan Snow (34:22):
    “Nearly all of [Britain’s] big important [military] successes have been achieved as part of coalitions... The most unsuccessful war in British history is the American Revolutionary War, when it's fighting absolutely on its own.”

---

7. Final Turning Point: Yorktown (37:26 — 46:44)

• Joint Operation, Decisive Siege: In 1781, American and French armies and navies coordinate the encirclement and siege of Yorktown. French naval superiority in Chesapeake Bay prevents British evacuation or reinforcement, leading to Cornwallis’s surrender.

  • Don Wildman (37:26):
    “Yorktown is under siege from September to October 1781... a total of 17,000 on land faced off against 8,000 Brits... On October 17, the drummer and officer signal. Surrender... Cornwallis does not attend... so British Brigadier General Charles O’Hara surrenders by handing his sword to [Washington’s] second-in-command.”

• A Catastrophic Blow:

  • Dan Snow (44:49):
    “No, no, no. Yorktown was a catastrophe. Another army, a second entire army surrenders... Yorktown puts the Brits out of their misery because it’s so decisive that they just go, look, we can’t do this."

• British Overextension:

  • By Yorktown, the British public, Parliament, and military leadership have no appetite (or resources) to continue. Political instability back in Britain only adds to the pressure for peace.
  • Dan Snow (45:57):
    “We can keep this going and sit in New York and sort of just exchange potshots... or we can just cut off this diseased limb and... defend our valuable sugar-producing islands in the Caribbean from the French, defend our possessions in India, defend our Gibraltar...”

---

8. Aftermath and The Treaty of Paris (46:44 — 54:36)

• A Delayed Resolution: Sporadic fighting continues until 1783, but the decisive political will to regain the colonies is gone from Britain.

• American Myths Versus Realities:

  • Americans celebrate July 4th, but not the Treaty of Paris (September 3), reflecting a tendency to valorize self-sufficiency and downplay foreign assistance.
    • Bratton (47:01):
      "We celebrate July 4th because otherwise we would have to say, yeah, we owe our independence probably mostly to France."
  • The final settlement is unexpectedly generous: Britain gives up the “whole of the Midwest,” not just the 13 colonies.

---

9. When Did the Colonists Know They’d Won? Uncertainty to the End (52:09 — 54:36)

• No “Eureka” Moment:

  • Bratton (52:28):
    “I don’t know if they actually do imagine it until 1783. Washington himself is in disbelief that there will be any end to the hostility... There’s this intense idea that the war cannot surely be over.”
  • Bratton (53:24):
    “I do think that when Britain loses the war is 1778, when it admits it cannot control the northern, most populous, most rebellious colonies.”

• Unexpected Victory & the Seeds of Future Problems:

  • Dan Snow (54:03):
    “They didn’t know how big they’d won... They give them a whole ton of territory... almost a Trojan horse, too, because in it lies the seeds of the near destruction of this new republic.”

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Mythmaking:

  • Don Wildman (48:10):
    “We are very good storytellers, very good at building our own mythology to this day.”

• On Coalition and the Nature of Success:

  • Dan Snow (34:22):
    "Nearly all of them [British military successes] have been achieved... as part of coalitions.... The most unsuccessful war in British history is the American Revolutionary War, when it’s fighting absolutely on its own."

• On the End of the War:

  • Bratton (53:24):
    "When Britain loses the war is 1778, when it admits that it cannot control the northern, most populous, most rebellious colonies..."

---

Timeline & Timestamps for Major Segments

• [06:05] What Was at Stake: British & Colonial Motivations
• [08:47] Geography, Communication, and the Atlantic as Barrier
• [11:37] The Reality and Mythology of Militia Tactics
• [13:22–17:24] Siege of Boston & Early Battles
• [20:43–24:06] Declaration of Independence and Its Propaganda Power
• [26:14–34:22] Saratoga, Foreign Intervention, and the War as a Global Conflict
• [37:26–46:44] Yorktown: Allied Victory and British Catastrophe
• [46:44–54:36] The Treaty of Paris, American Mythmaking, and When Did the Colonists Know They’d Won?

---

Tone & Style

The episode is a mix of scholarly insight and banter, balancing deep analysis with memorable one-liners and riffs debunking national myths. Don moderates, Dan offers a British lens (often wry), and Jonathan provides military perspective and American context—sometimes clashing, always animated.

---

Conclusion: When Was the Revolutionary War Won?

There’s no single “Eureka!” moment for the American victory—rather a combination of fatal British overreach, effective American-French coalition, and war-weariness. Saratoga marked the shift toward plausible victory, but not until Yorktown and, even more so, the Treaty of Paris, was victory accepted as reality by both sides. The revolution’s final stage laid the groundwork not just for American independence, but also for the complexities and mythologies that would shape national identity for centuries to come.

---

For a deep dive into the making—and unmaking—of American independence, this episode is a must-listen for history nerds and mythbusters alike.

---

Transcript

[Don Wildman]

Want to explore even more history? Sign up to History Hit, where you will discover history from around the world. From the American Revolution to prehistoric Scotland, there is plenty to discover. With your subscription, you'll unlock hundreds of hours of exclusive documentaries with a brand new release every week exploring everything from the ancient world to World War II. Just visit historyhit.com subscribe to bring the Past alive

[Progressive Insurance Announcer]

Insurance isn't one size fits all. That's why drivers have enjoyed Progressive's name your price tool for years now. With the name your price tool, you tell them what you want to pay and they'll show you options that fit your budget. So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family, they make it easy to see your options. Visit progressive.com find a rate that works for you with the name your price tool Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state

[Dan Snow]

law Today we're talking about how you don't have to earn more when you can save more. So you brought me this stat. T Mobile customers had the lowest wireless bills versus Verizon and AT&T over the past five years. That seems surprising.

[T-Mobile Announcer]

Yeah, when I first heard it I thought mmkay. But when the experts at Harris X broke it down, it was true for millions of families. Five years of the lowest wireless bills versus Verizon and att. And in this area where every monthly bill gets noticed, that kind of savings makes a real difference.

[Dan Snow]

Plus a five year price guarantee on experience plans on America's best network. I'm not hearing any sacrifice here, which

[T-Mobile Announcer]

is what people need right now. Reliance, Reliability. Predictability. That kind of breathing room makes a weekend on the coast a little easier to plan. Affordable wireless service isn't a perk, it's a difference and listeners. If you don't believe me, you can check it out at t mobile.com switch

[Dan Snow]

savings based on Harris X billing snapshots from Q3 21 to Q4 25 compared to average AT&T and Verizon bills. Comparison excludes discounts, credits and optional charges. For more details, see harrisx.comtmobile-bills the to

[Grow Therapy Announcer]

do list doesn't stop and neither does the pressure to keep up with it. If you've been running on fumes. Growtherapee makes it easier to find care that's covered by insurance and actually built around you, whether it's your first time in therapy or your 50th grow makes it easier to find a therapist who fits you, not the other way around. You can search by what matters like insurance, specialty, identity or availability and get started in as little as two days. And if something comes up, you can Cancel up to 24 hours in advance at no cost. Grow helps you find therapy on your time. Whatever challenges you're facing, Grow Therapy is here to help. Grow accepts over 100 insurance plans. Sessions average about $21 with insurance, and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growththerapy.com acast today to get started. That's growthherapy.com acast growtherapy.com acast availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.

[Don Wildman]

In the beginning, the American Revolution seemed unlikely to succeed. The American colonies, now a new nation of just 2.5 million people, were facing off against the greatest military power on the planet at the time, Great Britain. And yet, in 1781, the British surrendered major forces at Yorktown. And two years later, in 1783, after eight and a half years of fighting, the British and Americans signed the Treaty of Paris. The American Revolution was over, the British army was defeated, and America had her independence. Welcome to American History hit. I'm Don Wildman and as we approach the 250th anniversary of the founding document of our nation, the Declaration of Independence, the one that began the whole process, we are heading into the archives for a conversation I had with fellow podcast host Dan Snow and engineer officer and command historian Major Jonathan Bratton. Together we explore how the British were somehow defeated and just when it became clear that the so called Continental army would reign victorious. Hello gentlemen, how you doing?

[Dan Snow]

Good to be on the podcast.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Pleasure to be here. Thank you so much. Wish I could be there in person.

[Don Wildman]

Take your positions. My job today is to keep you men at a friendly distance here. Before we get into the nitty gritty, let's give a quick overview from 1775 until 1783. After a hundred years of colonialization and almost 20 years of unrest, revolutionaries from 13 of Britain's north American colonies were at war with their British rulers. The war began in skirmishes, with the first shots fired at Lexington and Concord in April 1775. The Revolutionary forces were rudimentary, mostly using guerrilla tactics against the more organized forces of the British military. In the summer of 1776, July 4, the colonies declare independence from the British, giving their forces a much needed boost. Finally, the tables start to turn in favor of the Continental army, the Americans with the battles of Trenton and Saratoga. The Americans are further galvanized in 1778 when the French enter the fight with them and When Spain and the Dutch declare war against the British. Now, rather than just trying to subdue a rebellion in the colonies, the British find themselves in a global war. Finally, in October 1781, with victory at Yorktown, peace is in sight. For the Americans, the war was brutal. Both sides had moments of brilliance and disaster. But were the colonies always destined to win? Gentlemen, give me an overview of what's at stake for both sides here. What are they fighting for? Jonathan, you first.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

So they're fighting for empire. They're fighting for, essentially, the British, and remember, they're all British at this time, are fighting for this idea that the British Empire will extend to what is now Pittsburgh, to the Forks of the Ohio, it will extend to Canada, it will extend to the rest of the Sugar Islands, and of course, throughout the whole war will extend to India. But this. The idea is that you are fighting for empire. You can boil it down from a colonial, provincial perspective that they are fighting for a variety of reasons. Everything from a religious idea that, you know, those evil papists gotta go to the idea that they'd like to have a little bit of peace and quiet on their frontier. But at the end of the day, I think, you know, what you've got is you are. You're fighting a war for empire, as historian Fred Anderson called it.

[Don Wildman]

What are the Americans fighting for, Dan, from a British perspective?

[Dan Snow]

Well, I guess we think they are fighting to avoid paying any tax, avoid paying their fair share. The Seven Years War, the French Indian wars cost a vast amount of money. That war was fought, started by the Americans, I should say. Young George Washington strolls into the Forks of the Ohio, strolls into the Pennsylvania backcountry, and inadvertently starts a global war. So that war is being fought to protect these British colonies, to ensure that they're freed from French and indigenous enemies, and they don't want to pay their fair share. So it's, I guess, but for me, really, it's a war about dealing with the messy endings of the previous war. Now, we've heard with that in the 20th century, they might think about the Second World War and how it grows out of the first. You might think about the Vietnam, in a way, grows out of the Second World War as well. That's the nature of these things. Britain ends up with this massive, unexpected, very expensive, enormous North American empire, stretches from. From really Florida up to Hudson Bay. And they've got to work out what to do, who's going to run it, who's going to pay for it, who's going to control it. And one element, don't you think, Jonathan, is actually this war is also about who gets to enjoy the benefits of that new big empire. People in Virginia, people in Pennsylvania, people in the lower colonies, they're saying, hang on, we think we should be not just extending up to the forks of the Ohio, we should be going even further. We want the land to the Mississippi and maybe even beyond. And actually the Brits are saying, no, no, no, no, no. This is not going to be just a free for all from our American colonies. We're going to take a more direct, you know, so this is an argument over the shape of this massive and unexpected gift, but it turns out to be a very, very poison gift that's landed in the British Empire's map.

[Don Wildman]

So I mentioned at the top, resources are obviously very different, outgunned and outmanned. Thank you, Hamilton, for making that phrase very common. One advantage that colonials have is home turf. Are they going to be able to use that, Jonathan, Is that really such an advantage?

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Well, the biggest advantage, it's the Atlantic Ocean that's America's biggest advantage always. And Dan can sit there and say, well, you know, the Atlantic Ocean is just a great surface to convey. The Royal Navy and the ships of the fleet and His Majesty's forces will, will crush the upright. No, it's a, it's a phenomenal barrier that means that anything that happens in the colonies, one, the information is going to take three weeks to a month or two to get back across the ocean. So the information war that can be fought in the colonies because from the purposes of these nascent Americans, these rebelling individuals, trying to convey this idea of what on earth are we fighting for and why you should fight with us is probably more important than what we are going to do to the British. Because first, in order to actually have anything to fight the British with, you actually have to have united colonies. And if there's anyone who's more fractious, prior to 1775, I mean, I guess Parliament, but also it's the 13American colonies. I mean, they just cannot get along at all. And so first, so you have to have that. And then also anything that happens, it means that if the British are going to have to ship massive amounts of supplies across this ocean, so this long supply line, this long line of communication, that's absolutely vital. So when we talk about home turf for the Americans, it's less the land. Now, I will say that the British officer perspective in North America, to quote a British officer who lands in 17, 1955, I believe and looks at the Ohio country and says, I cannot conceive how war is made in such country. That's probably a lot of the British perspective, but the terrain is going to be difficult for both sides.

[Dan Snow]

Yeah, yeah. And learning from Jonathan for the first time that occasionally these US States don't get on very well. I'm surprised to hear that. Fractious, you say? That's. That's exciting news. One to watch, maybe. I think you're totally right. The Atlantic Ocean's a big disadvantage. The landscape, it just swallows up armies. It breaks armies. It's. There's. There's far more water and marsh and bog and rock and trees than there are in the. The cockpit of war. Where the British army's used to fighting in France, in Northern France and Belgium. But I also think that get the same problem you do in maybe Vietnam. When this superpower goes a long way away, it is able. When the enemy standing in front of them, they're able to fight and often destroy them. It's when the enemy's not standing in front of them, it's when they just drift back. There's this. They're fighting communities. There are people that turn up, pick up a musket and just make life incredibly difficult for the British army across all of the. It's just hard to hold down vast amounts of terrain no matter how big your army is.

[Don Wildman]

Well, you're talking about the guerrilla tactics which all. Every American student is raised to honor. You know, working with what you have, you know, and they learned it from the Native Americans, all these sort of mythology things that we learned.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Definitely mythology. Yeah, definitely mythology. Tons of mythology.

[Don Wildman]

And yet it's the way things work at the battles of Lexington and Concord. But we, you know, lose these battles right through to the middle of the war. So at first everyone has at hand is working out pretty well for the British. Things are going to go pretty well for them for a long time in

[Dan Snow]

this war, I guess. So I guess the big problem the British army is not as big as it needs to be. The British have bet the farm since the 17th century or, you know, maybe even before on having a big navy.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Right.

[Dan Snow]

Britain's an island. You. You think, well, we can protect our homeland and we can start to enjoy the opportunities of global trade and maybe even some colonies in the rest of the world by keeping a big navy. So the idea of running a big navy and a big army at the same time. So. So Prussia has an army around 300,000 strong at this point. And Prussia is stretches I don't know from what is today Maine down to maybe D.C. the Chesapeake, that's just a small portion of these colonies. And Prussia has an army of 300,000 men. Britain has an army of like 50,000 men at this point, a lot of them in Ireland, which is itself in a near rebellious state most of the time. So actually, yeah, on paper Britain's got lots of troops, but doesn't have anything like the amount of troops you'd need to go town by town and stick a little union flag up the flagpole and leave a bunch of guys there to. And then move on to the next place. You know, that is, that requires massive manpower. So. So yeah, Britain's got an advantage straight away, but British people hope, the British planners hope that what they can do is just put the Navy up and down the east coast, blockade all these places like Charleston and Rhoda and Providence and New York and Boston. And then the provincials just are reminded of their loyalty to the British crown and decide to. But if that doesn't happen, Britain does have a problem. You gotta put boots on the ground. You gotta put a lot first.

[Don Wildman]

Turning Point Siege of Boston April 1775 to March 1776 following their victory at Lexington and Concord, the British troops are garrisoned in Boston. The colonial troops besieged them for 11 months. Jonathan, what are the revolutionary forces tactics during that siege?

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Well, it's try to use small blows to make a statement. Wherever you can remember, Washington's working with an army that is under critical shortages. You know, Dan talks about the shortages of manpower for the Crown forces. Washington's facing the same thing. He can't even keep track of where his troops are day to day because half of them go home to tend their crops. Because this idea of serving in a long standing army, a thing we've been taught is very, very bad. It's part of our British tradition. That's another reason why the British army is not ever going to be large is because I guess you guys had some problems with a king using the army for bad things. I don't know, some guy Cromwell came along, some small, small history there, but this is very much a thing that is inherited by the Americans. There's not this idea that yes, we're going to have long serving armies. You mentioned Lexington and Concord earlier as an idea, as an example of success and also Boston. Well, the problem here is that it's a false measure of success. Lexington and Concord is a one in a hundred thousand chances that you get that exact scenario happening precisely where it did. Sure you have Massachusetts being prepared more than any other colony to be able to fight this type of war. And then that ability, people just think, oh, we can duplicate that anywhere. Well, no, you can't duplicate a culture of 150 years of independent mindedness and military tradition. And then the other piece is that, yes, Washington is dealing with an army that's got about 13 rounds per man and the siege of Boston. So you have to make little, little raids here and there's. But ultimately Washington would love a large scale assault to seize Boston, which is simply not practicable. His commanders tell him, hey, boss, you do this, you're going to stack up bodies like cordwood. Sure. And it's going to be Henry Knox bringing over the artillery over the Berkshire mountains, through those horrible swamps, awful terrain in the dead of winter to place artillery over on Dorchester Heights overlooking Boston. And so Washington gets a win, but it's not the win that he wants because no one respects a siege win. People respect the bloody battle, the pitched battle, the outmaneuvering your enemy, forcing them to flee ingloriously before you. And that's not what he gets. And so he has to now think about what are, how do I fight this war at the next battle, New

[Don Wildman]

York, what happens, I've always wondered what happens when they leave? Do the British go back and say, okay, so that didn't work out very well. We need to reconnoiter here and that's gonna lead to a lot of ships in New York Harbor.

[Dan Snow]

That's right. And you know, Jonathan's being very modest here. I don't wanna do his job for him, but I mean, Washington, I think, does brilliantly here. And they chase the British, they humiliate the British right at the beginning of the war. This is just shocking. Britain's poured reinforcements into this town to bring Massachusetts back to a state of subjugation to the crown law. And here they are, the people of Massachusetts and other New Englanders, and led by a man from Virginia, George Washington, they have strangled Boston. They forced the Brits to leave because of the shadow of the big cannon overhanging the city. Loyalists have left with them. The conditions were tough, like the British army's kind of starving. It's desperately rounding up cows. Everyone's laughing at it. This is just, this is brutal. And so, yeah, they head off to Halifax and then they think, you know, we need to go somewhere. We think there's plenty of loyalists in New York. We like the harbor in New York. It's a much better. It's a Much more sustainable place. It's easy to get food and all that kind of stuff. So, yeah, they end up sending a big old fleet to New York harbor. And this is where I think if we want to play this game, I think the Brits come nearest, achieving a pretty good result this campaign. They could have. Well, I'm sure we'll get onto it, but I think this is the bit where I think the Brits are let down by their leaders in this bit, but I'm sure we'll talk about that.

[Don Wildman]

So these are warning signs. Do you think the British were spooked at all at this point, Dan?

[Dan Snow]

I think the British definitely spooked. And in fact, British commanders are writing home going, we've got a serious problem out here. The locals do not want us here. And it's not just a band of troublemakers. It is very widespread feeling. We've kind of. We've lost control of the hinterland. We lost control. So, you know, we can control a port or two. We can't, actually. We can't. We've lost control of the countryside and we. And you need a huge manpower to get this back. And the politicians are like, pull yourselves together. It's a bunch of farmers.

[Don Wildman]

Yeah. They have demonstrated that the colonials have a certain will and determination to do what they want to do here. We have strengthened the authority of that institution, that Congress that is so controversial, suddenly sort of congeals, gets some authority behind it and George Washington has emerged. They have a central leader. This is not good for the British.

[Dan Snow]

No, this is not good. The Americans are on their way to building a state, on their way to building an army and a Marine Corps and a navy. I mean, this is bad news. This is not just a provincial rebellion,

[Don Wildman]

but this is also a paper lion in many ways, right, Jonathan? I mean, Bunker Hill was not a win. Lexington Concord was won in the retreat. You know, that's where they did the damage.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Oh, Lexington Concord is a great win. What are you talking about? This is utterly pulverizing an entire punitive expedition, driving it back, fleeing to its ranks in Lexington, Bunker Hill, you know, it's a British victory. That's a clear win. Right. You know, we've taken some ground at the cost of 10% of the officers in the British army. But, you know, it's, it's, it's pretty catastrophic fighting. That shows, I think it shows that the war is going to be long and it's going to be bloody and you're not going to get a quick victory by parading troops. Through towns in order to show the might of the British Empire. I think we're also forgetting we're being very Boston or New England or east coast centric. Remember America has also just done a thing in Quebec. The American army in the fall of 1775 launches a two pronged invasion of Canada that seizes Montreal. And but for you know, a very untimely whiff of grapeshot that blows Richard Montgomery into little bits outside the walls of Quebec City might have even taken Quebec City as well. And then you would be left with the situation of what on earth do you do with this 14th colony and how do you defend Canada? I think honestly it's probably good that the colonials are for out of Canada in the spring of 1776 because otherwise you're just pouring more and more troops into this sort of black hole a little bit akin to what the British will do in the South Post 1778. So there's a lot going on in the theater and it's showing that hey yeah, this is a ragtag but they all just mounted an invasion that had a general Guy Carlton fleeing for his life up to Quebec City from Montreal. And now the British are not only have to contend with hey, how do we put down this, this rebellious colonies in New England but how do we get one of our own loyal colonies back?

[Don Wildman]

Yeah, but then they build a little fleet and chase Benedict Arnold down Lake

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Champlain sinking Benedict Arnold stings right back with his little fleet that he built out of nothing but some hopes and dreams and Massachusetts sailors.

[Don Wildman]

All right, we're going to launch over vast territory here to July 1776 the Declaration of Independence. A hugely pivotal moment in the school textbooks and in the media. We have this kind of image of all the founding fathers standing together, lit by candlelight, gathered around a piece of parchment as they, you know, the whole image wasn't really this way at all, was it Jonathan?

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

No, I mean it was very public for one thing. If you're going to have a rebellion, you know, you got to do some specific things in public and very openly takes place in as with every, every good, you know, Constitutional Convention, Philadelphia. Stupidly hot Declaration planning at Philadelphia. Stupidly hot. I just can imagine that all these rooms stank to high heaven of all these perspiring would be politicians. But the, I think the critical piece of the decoration is how rapidly it is disseminated after they wrangle over what it's going to be. And it is, there's a lot of wrangling. There's, there's A Jefferson originally has a piece in there. You know, if you look at the grievances of, of, of the colonies to the Crown, which is what the Declaration really is, hey, here's the why of what we're doing. They're saying, hey, you're doing this, you're doing this, you're doing this. We don't like it. We feel like our rights are being trampled. And then there's contentions, as I said, you know, the colonies are going to fight each other. So there's a bit in there about, hey, the British are forcing the slave trade upon us. And South Carolina is like, wait a minute, hang on. No, take that one out and that one will. We'll revisit that in 1861. But the. So after all that is ironed out and then it is pushed out rapidly to the Continental army, to the army itself, to. There are readings of the Declaration of Independence in New York City, where Washington has it read to the Continental army there at Fort Ticonderoga on Mount Independence. At all these critical places where the troops are, it is explained to native allies. It is this mass effort to cause an information win that is something that I don't think the British foresaw was how this was going to be used to turn the narrative against, against specifically the Crown. George iii.

[Don Wildman]

This is treason. This is an act of treason, Don,

[Dan Snow]

you're darn right it's treason. And we're still upset about it. Poor George III comes up. I mean, the list of grievances against George III in the Declaration of Independence is deranged. But anyway, we don't have to dwell on that. But I think, you know, and Jonathan mentions what's going on in New York. At the same time, there's this campaign in New York that I'm super interested. This is almost my key moment of the American Revolutionary War. And the British commanders in New York are a little bit hesitant, a little bit cautious. George Washington gets a little bit lucky maybe once or twice with the weather and you get the so called, you know, the miracle of when they manage to evacuate troops from Long Island. They managed to evacuate troops from Manhattan. And each time the Brits just keep failing to kind of put Washington in the bag. Just get that army, capture it, destroy it. Now, I'm not sure it would have made a huge difference, but it could have. If you lose the main field army of the rebellion, of the revolution, of this young, now young republic, then maybe that would have made a difference. So there's a moment here, I think, where the Brits could have pulled it off. But like I say, these, these British commanders, they're a little bit flat footed.

[Don Wildman]

Yeah, right. So, Jonathan, the final statement on the Declaration, it basically is. Piece of propaganda is a negative word, but I mean, it is that kind of thing, and people don't really take that into consideration, how important it was to get the message out, not only externally to foreign powers, but also internally.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Well, and it's also, it gives a purpose for the war because, remember, I say this a lot, but the, the action, the events of April, May 1775, and even in June, you know, all the way up through the Olive Branch petition, where the, where Congress says, hey, King George, you know, we could, I don't know, maybe come to an agreement, patch these things up. All of this is not. There's no widespread movement saying, oh, yes, we are going to be a united and independent American entity. And that is what the Declaration is doing. It is taking this thing that was probably so far outside people's minds in April of 1775 and making it a reality rapidly. That is one, really just one year and a few months from, from the beginning of hostilities to a full movement for independence. And yes, it shores up one side. It also creates a very firm dividing line down the middle. Either you are for independence or you are not. And if you're not for independence, you are with the enemy. We talk a lot about the sort of numbers involved on, on who was Loyalist, who was patriot, et cetera, et cetera. I also don't like those terms because I'm pretty sure all the loyalists love them themselves as very good, patriotic Britons. But really, you've got about 30% of the population going for independence, 30% loyalists, and 30 to 40% wholly in the middle, just trying to survive. Which is why you have these British commanders who are so frustrated when they go into a town and everyone pulls out a Union Jack and says, yay, George iii. And then they go, all right, cool, we've got this space. And then they march on. And then those people will immediately sell supplies to the rebels or, or send drafts off to the Continental army or support the militia. And you've got everyone from Cornwallis to Burgoyne to Sir Henry Clinton to Howe, who packs it up in 1777, 1778, he's just like, I'm sick of this, I'm going home. All these British commanders who can't actually grasp the problem on the ground, which is that it is very difficult to defeat an idea and a popular will. It's very Easy to defeat an army which. How does Burgoyne and Clinton and Cornwallis all defeat. Tactically defeat rebel forces, sure, but it doesn't matter.

[Don Wildman]

Well, within the year following the Declaration of Independence does not go well for the Continental army, with the exception of perhaps the Battle of Princeton. There's a lot of nooks and crannies there. But we head towards the middle of 1777 and the battle of Saratoga, which I think is fair to say is the next huge pivotal point when things could have gone a lot differently than they did. Dan, we have talked many times about Saratoga. It is a complex event. But what are the headlines of this?

[Dan Snow]

The headlines are that the plan was very, very complex. As you say now, it was hugely ambitious, probably overly ambitious. But then again, there are examples in North America, whether it's in 1760, in the French Indian War, or whether it's as Jonathan talks about in the American assault on Montreal in 1775, there are examples of big bodies of men moving across this very difficult landscape and all getting to the right place at the right time. This is not one of those examples. So the Brits, they have this smart idea, which is they're going to maybe try and just to divide, just create a firewall. These troublesome. The New England is the real problem here. And the middle colonies, the southern colonies, they may be a little more Tory, they may be a little more relaxed about the idea of the British Empire. There is perhaps some truth in that idea. And they thought, what we need to do is just build a wall between these two groups. So we've got. Let's get a force moving down from Canada, advancing south towards Albany, down that great invasion corridor that's seen so many armies marching to and fro over the. Over the decades. We'll get an army marching from Lake Ontario east towards Albany. So that's another prong coming in from Lake Ontario, coming towards Albany. And then we get a force moving up from New York, where we've captured New York and parts of New Jersey. So they come due north up the Hudson Valley. And so from three different directions, we kind of arrive at Albany and we cut off New England from the rest of the colonies. The problem is none of those forces do what they're supposed to, and none of them arrive at the right time. And none of the commanders do what

[Don Wildman]

they're supposed to do because of bad leadership.

[Dan Snow]

A little bit of bad legit, a little bit of just logistics. In the 8th century, tough boots fall apart, everyone gets sick. Lot of food and then bit of resistance by the Americans. I'm not doing them down here. So what is supposed to be a three way attack ends up with one force coming down from Canada and finding itself completely outnumbered at the end of a hideous supply route, dealing with far too many defenders outside Albany at a place called Saratoga. And the Brits know they're in big trouble.

[Don Wildman]

Yeah. This is the first big surrender, right? Of any kind of.

[Dan Snow]

Yeah, it is. Thanks, Don. It is.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

It's a great own goal.

[Dan Snow]

It's a great own goal.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

It's a great own goal because it's the British. You know, it's Whitehall's job to. To oversee a cohesive war plan. And the problem is they approve every plan that they're given, including the one where how in New York says, oh, actually, I'm not marching north, I'm marching south to Philadelphia.

[Dan Snow]

Yes.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Burgoyne knows this. Everyone knows this. And Burgoyne goes, yep, okay, I'll meet you in Albany. A and B are not leading to C. They're. They're doing A to F to Z. And it's. I honestly have massive sympathy for these poor British troops because they're doomed from the start by one of the most colossally poor oversights of planning on the British perspective. Don't approve all the plans. Don't leave it up to commanders to choose their own adventure, if you will. When it comes to strategy making gives

[Don Wildman]

a great showcase for the crazy Benedict Arnold to run around on his horse getting shot.

[Dan Snow]

He is, he's impressive at this point, but I think it. And once we got this battle at Saratoga, again, you see this problem for the Brits, that, yes, they do tend to perform better in battles in the American Revolutionary War. But when the Americans are well led, when they are supplied, and particularly when they have the advantages of ground or defenses, they can fire musket volleys that are as vicious as anything the Brits will come up against in Europe. And so you can't assume as the British army that you are just going to grind forward and disperse this group of amateurs. And actually, I think at Saratoga, the Brits find themselves repelled by very impressive American infantry tactics. And so that is to their credit as well.

[Don Wildman]

Jonathan, the upshot of this really is the French getting interested in joining this war. It's not a done deal, but this could be an advantage for them backing this army.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Right, yeah, it's Saratoga. But then it's also the. The survival of Washington's army following Brandywine. You know, he goes from a defeat at Brandywine on the defensive to a tactical Defeat in Germantown, where he's on the offensive. This is an army mounting an offensive after a defeat. That is resilience and, and not just through. In surviving these battles and then forcing what Germantown does. It forces Howe to keep his army inside Philadelphia. He can no longer move around the countryside. It's a thing that I think we, we, we don't see a lot when we look at just strict wins and losses. The French see a captured army in, in New York, then they see a penned up army in Pennsylvania and they're going, okay, you guys are demonstrating enough that you have, you have the French crown who very much have a policy of. We don't really want to get heavily involved, but we would really love to bleed our traditional enemy as dry as possible.

[Don Wildman]

Was this just for the French and Indian War?

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Just French and Indian War. Dan, do you want to talk about

[Dan Snow]

how long this, I don't know if you know about this little we got going on this island of ours, but we got these neighbors called the French and it goes, it goes back a fair way actually. So.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Yeah, no, but then 66 and all that. Yeah, well, exactly.

[Dan Snow]

So there's been, look, particularly since 1688, 1689, the Brits and the French have fought some, I've followed some historians who call it the Second Hundred Years War. You get the Nine Years War, you get the War of Spanish Succession, you get the War of Austrian Succession, you get the French India War, the Seven Years War, you get the American Revolutionary War, then you get the French Revolutionary War, then you get the Napoleon War and it ends. And it's really a battle in some ways for kind of global hegemony just

[Don Wildman]

to get to World War I again.

[Dan Snow]

Exactly. Well then we're buddies again and it ends, I need not tell you, British cavalry watering their horses in the Seine and the Duke of Wellington bedding Napoleon's mistress. But anyway, so. But it is, this is just part of this century long struggle and it goes on in India and it goes on in the Caribbean. It goes on. And so, so the French are looking to take on the Brits wherever the British show weakness. They'll fight the Brits in Ireland, they'll fight the Brits in India, they'll fight the Brits in West Africa. But at this time it looks like the Brits are in a whole world of trouble on the east coast of America. And the French are happy to send

[Don Wildman]

muskets and they're going to bankrupt themselves doing it.

[Dan Snow]

That is a problem for later. They will bankrupt themselves.

[Don Wildman]

But you mentioned The Spanish, Jonath, they get involved. Most Americans don't even know about that.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

They get involved. I mean, it's not to the same extent as, as the French. The, the Spanish have lost very heavily. They are going to eventually enter the war after France on the condition of the famous Spanish. Condition always is we want Gibraltar back. You know, they're not going to get it. Spain's contribution to the war is rocky. They demonstrate that they are still a great, a part of the great power competition. They are still part of this great game, as it will later be called. But they don't demonstrate that they have this political will to openly support the Americans other than beyond sending some, some arms, a little bit of money, and then a small expedition through, through Florida and modern day Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana. And so what you, what you really have with Spain is it's another fleet, the addition of Spain's fleet into the war. And then also the Dutch. And the Dutch come in heavily with money. The Dutch are floating massive loans to the Americans which they'll be nice enough to, to, to sort of overlook the fact that we absolutely screw them on the back end and don't pay anybody back. But this is, again, these are items for the future. But for, from the British perspective, you now have, I think, probably what no one in Britain wanted in 1775, which is all of a sudden you have a world war again. You just had a world war. You, you're trying to figure out how to pay for the last one because, you know, William Pitt wrote a blank check to the colonies to do whatever they wanted and they, they took him at his word and they did. And now here we are with massive British debt and another war.

[Dan Snow]

And the worst thing about a world war is you're fighting without allies. And Winston Churchill said, the only thing worse than fighting with allies is fighting without allies. And so this is for all that, my fellow Brits. And we like talking about the British Empire, we like to make great British military successes. Nearly all of them have been achieved. The big important ones have been achieved as part of coalitions. Big, big coalitions. That's been Britain's secret source. And now the most unsuccessful war in British history is the American Revolutionary War. When it's fighting absolutely on its own,

[Grow Therapy Announcer]

The to do list doesn't stop and neither does the pressure to keep up with it. If you've been running on fumes, growtherapy makes it easier to find care that's covered by insurance and actually built around you, whether it's your first time in therapy or your 50th grow makes it easier to find a therapist who fits you, not the other way around. You can search by what matters like insurance, specialty, identity or availability and get started in as little as two days. And if something comes up, you can Cancel up to 24 hours in advance at no cost. Grow helps you find therapy on your time. Whatever challenges you're facing, Grow Therapy is here to help. Grow accepts over 100 insurance plans. Sessions average about $21 with insurance, and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growththerapy.com acast today to get started. That's growthherapy.com acast growtherapy.com acast availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.

[Progressive Insurance Announcer]

Insurance isn't one size fits all. That's why drivers have enjoyed Progressive's name your price tool for years now. With the name your price tool, you tell them what you want to pay, and they'll show you options that fit your budget. So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family, they make it easy to see your options. Visit progressive.com find a rate that works for you with the name your price tool Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state

[T-Mobile Announcer]

law this summer don't squeeze in. Spread out. Find homes big enough for your whole guest list on vrbo. From family reunions to trips with friends, VRBO has spacious summer stays for every group size and budget. That's vacation rentals done right. Start exploring on VRBO and book your next day. Now.

[Grow Therapy Announcer]

VRBO makes it easy to claim your dream summer spot with early booking deals from homes with pools to poolside loungers. When you book a vrbo, you don't have to reserve any loungers. They're all yours. All you have to do is book early Book with VRBO.

[Don Wildman]

So we're moving on from the Declaration of Independence as a pivotal moment, which really demonstrated the resilience of the colonists willing to fight through failure. I'm hearing from you, Saratoga is probably the biggest pivotal moment. We'll have to make this decision at the end, but definitely a huge moment of pivot when not only have the Americans won the battle, but also they've brought in foreign powers to fight them. They've made allies. So let's again move forward towards the end here, towards Yorktown with French support and money, it feels very much that by 1781, victory for the Americans is in the cards. Our final turning point comes with the last showdown. Yorktown is under Siege From September to October 1781, Washington's regiments joined by 4,500 French soldiers under the Marquis de Lafayette. Up to 17,000 on land. Yorktown is under siege from September to October 1781, Washington'S regiments are joined by 4,500 French soldiers Under the Marquis de Lafayette. That makes a total of 17,000 on land. Faced off against 8,000 Brits. French Admiral Francois Joseph de Grasse and his fleet are in the Chesapeake, preventing the escape of Cornwallis and the British army and reinforcement by the British Navy. On September 5, the French take a victory over a British fleet in the battle of Chesapeake. And it's clear Cornwallis troops have no chance of escape or reinforcement. Troops suffer from disease, dwindling supplies, and casualties. On October 17, the drummer and officer signal. Surrender negotiations take place on the 18th, and the official surrender ceremony occurs on the 19th. Cornwallis does not attend, citing illness. So British Brigadier General Charles o' Hara surrenders to Washington's second in command, Major General Benjamin Lincoln, by handing him his sword. This is such a pivotal battle in the revolution. Dan, what state are things in for the British at the time of Yorktown?

[Dan Snow]

Well, it's just this. It's this old problem, which is the British army can move around America sometimes carried by ships this overwhelming maritime strength. Other times they'll march. They'll march up through the Carolinas into Virginia. But the problem is that every time they go somewhere and they liberate somewhere or they get the union flags out, as Jonathan says, and the crowds all come out and say, okay, fine, King George, we're back. The minute they leave town, like the Viet Cong in Vietnam or like the Taliban, I guess, in Afghanistan, the patriots, the rebels just drift back in and reassert their control. So you end up with marching this big distance of British armies march all the way into this part of Virginia, and they haven't got anything to show for it. What they then try and do is they do whatever British. They do exactly what British armies have always done. They just look towards the coast and be like, where the hell's the navy? We need the navy here. So. And they do that. They get. Yorktown's on the coast and they build a.

[Don Wildman]

And they're not gonna get the navy because of the French.

[Dan Snow]

Well, this is the killer fact, Don. This is an absolute disaster. So they've built this fort and they settled down. Normal service resumed. Here we are on the coast. We get the navy bringing supplies in, food, more powder and shot and reinforcements. Then the unimaginable happens. I mean, this is very difficult for me to talk about, really, but the French Navy turn up in an astonishing and lucky and skillful and remarkable bit of coordination that crosses two continents. And several months, the French navy turn up in force. There's an inconclusive battle off in the Chesapeake Bay. The British retreat afterwards to go and repair their ships. So it's actually a defeat for the British. And for the, you know, this astonishing new experience for the Brits, they find themselves sandwiched between an Emmy force, the Americans and the French, who are besieging them in Yorktown, and a French fleet out at sea. And the Brits do not like this situation.

[Don Wildman]

Jonathan, tell me about the American side of things at this point. Washington is. What is his aims, his strategic goals?

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

So he's trying to coordinate with this, you know, he's trying to take advantage of this new alliance, the 1778 Treaty of Alliance and amity with France to be able to make a joint. A joint combined attack. What he would really love to do, in his heart of hearts, is seize New York, get that festering insult away from him, get this thing that he's been carrying around with him, the loss of New York. I think really, he really, really feels. And there's been attempts to coordinate continental forces with the French army and Navy. You've got an attempt in Savannah that ends terribly. You've got an attempt in. In Rhode island that doesn't end well. You have a lot of failure, and I think that's important to emphasize is you have a lot of failure, a lot of disappointment and a lot of mistrust building on both sides. From the American side, I don't know if we can trust these guys to show up when we need them. And from the French side is. I don't know if we can trust these guys to fight. When we show up, there's so there's. There's a lot of tension that is going into this relationship, which makes 1781 that much more impressive. What the Americans are dealing with fundamentally is honestly a gift, which is that in 1778, the British turn to the South. They. They say, we're writing off the main colonies. We're writing off doing that. We'll do some stuff there. We'll keep our main forces in New York, but we are going to attempt a Southern strategy. We are going to win the American South. We will. We will have a limited victory. We will keep the south, the more lucrative colonies. And you know those dumb rebels, they in the north, they're intractable and they're poor and Cheap, anyway. Those dumb Yankees, we can live without them. And this is a gift because this is where British manpower is pouring into. And they're able to combat this with a relatively. The Continentals and the militia, the state troops are able to combat this with a relatively low number of troops. So by 1781, this. This weird assortment of Continentals and militia in the Carolinas have essentially caused Cornwallis to give up in frustration, to throw his hands up and say, I've beaten you everywhere. In every battle I pursue you. I keep having to cross rivers and I'm running out of boats and my men are destroyed, my horses are starving. I have to go refit. In Yorktown, where he. Even before that, he attempts to destroy a force of about 4,000 under Lafayette, which eventually ends up pinning him on the Virginia peninsula. And so it's this incredible combination of British strategic mishap, I would say, or unable to read the situation properly, and this unparalleled moment in space and time where you get Washington, Rochambeau and de Grass able to actually come, and the Comte d' Estaing able to come to the table and say, yes, we are going to attempt this. To move across an entire. Multiple theaters of war to converge in one space and time. Most of the troops for the. I think a lot of people don't understand. Most of the Continental and French troops, almost all of them, for the siege of Yorktown began in New Hampshire, Rhode island and New York.

[Don Wildman]

Yeah, right.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

There's only a couple thousand under Lafayette that have been sort of scrapping it out in Virginia. And so this is just this incredible feat to concentrate rapidly at that right moment. As Dan said, at this moment, where the British are going, oh, wait, we don't have naval superiority. What is that? I mean, that's like telling the American army today that, hey, you have to fight without air superiority.

[Don Wildman]

Right.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

That. That causes everything in my body to clinch up, and this would want to hide in a little hole.

[Don Wildman]

Dan, could they have come back after Yorktown, do you think? The British. Yeah.

[Dan Snow]

No, no, no. The. The Yorktown was a catastrophe. Another army, a second entire army surrenders just utterly, you know, something like 8,000 men. It would involve raising another army to send. And I think people had. They'd worked out that these armies, it wasn't like, oh, we were doing so well before the army got captured. But it's just stalemate at best. You're fighting a global war that the Spanish, you know, there's other interests around the world you want to defend, and the British have no option. You know, the British, British credit is under attack. The British government is, you know, Britain is still, you know, it's not a dictatorship. The British government is very shaky at this point. Parliament are doubting the strategy. So Lord north, who's the prime minister, his grip on power will soon come to an end. We're gonna have three prime ministers in one year after this, if you can believe that, which we only have in the gravest of crises like a couple of years ago. And so Yorktown is a symptom of just a gigantic failure to come to terms with how to pay for how to bring the Americans back to their obedience. And in a way, Yorktown puts the Brits out of their misery because it's so decisive that they just go, look, we can't do this.

[Don Wildman]

It's really a statement on how overextended they were.

[Dan Snow]

Yeah, we haven't got them and we can't send another army. So we can keep this going and sit in New York and sort of just exchange potshots with the Americans or we can just cut this Gordon, we can cut off this disease limb and we can get back doing what we want to do, which is defend our valuable sugar producing islands in the Caribbean from the French, defend our possessions in India, defend our Gibraltar, all those kind of things. And yep, it's super sad. We, you know, the Brits, they've secured Canada, so, you know, maybe they just, maybe they lose. The 13 colonies got the lumber, they got the lumber in Canada. You know, what's the best that's gonna happen? Those little 13 colonies.

[Don Wildman]

And maple syrup.

[Dan Snow]

Well, you tell me. Exactly. And beaver skin hats.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Oh, yeah.

[Dan Snow]

You know, I'm sure those little 13 colonies, they'll never come to an end. They'll fight, they'll squabble amongst themselves. They'll be back. They'll be back.

[Don Wildman]

Surprisingly, sporadic fighting does continue after this. There's a couple years here until this Treaty of Paris is signed. Jonathan. It seems interesting to me. As Americans, we celebrate the 4th of July, the Declaration of Independence, but we don't really celebrate the Treaty of Paris. It's weird, isn't it? 3rd of September.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

I mean, it's weird only from the perspective of actually asking Americans to look with a realistic light upon their own history. What's more popular? Oh, well, we manifested our own destiny into existence. To borrow a phrase that will come later on in American politics. But this idea that, oh well, we, we did it on our own. We willed it to happen. It's like Lexington and Concord. It was the embattled farmer who stood up and made this happen. No, it was fought as all American wars are always fought and won, which is with allies, which is very difficult for us to admit. It's fought by a mixture of professional forces and part time forces. Today we'd have the regular Army, Army Reserve, the Army National Guard, and it's fought by drafting individuals. So by, by the end, the Continental army is drafting people. It is forced service, right? Because that is how you keep armies in the field and how you win wars. All of this doesn't make for really good hand clapping. You know, Yay America feelings. And so yes, we celebrate the July 4th because otherwise we would have to say, yeah, we owe our independence probably mostly to France.

[Don Wildman]

We are very good storytellers, very good at building our own mythology to this day, as a matter of fact Product.

[Progressive Insurance Announcer]

You're listening to this podcast, so I know you've got a curious mind. Here's a helpful fact you might not know yet. Drivers who switch and save with Progressive save over $900 on average. Pop over to progressive.com, answer some questions and you'll get a quick quote with discounts that are easy to come by. In fact, 99% of their auto customers earn at least one discount. Visit progressive.com and see if you can enjoy a little cash back. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates national average 12 month savings by $946 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2024 and May 2025. Potential savings will vary.

[Grow Therapy Announcer]

The to do list doesn't stop, and neither does the pressure to keep up with it. If you've been running on fumes. Growtherapy makes it easier to find care that's covered by insurance and actually built around you, whether it's your first time in therapy or your 50th. Grow makes it easier to find a therapist who fits you, not the other way around. You can search by what matters like insurance, specialty, identity or availability and get started in as little as two days. And if something comes up, you can Cancel up to 24 hours in advance at no cost. Grow helps you find therapy on your time. Whatever challenges you're facing. Grow Therapy is here to help. Grow accepts over 100 insurance plans. Sessions average about $21 with insur and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growththerapy.com acast today to get started. That's growtherapy.com acast growtherapy.com acast availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.

[Don Wildman]

Dan on this side of Things. What's the. There's a whole empire to build. I mean, you got plenty of work going on over here.

[Dan Snow]

Well, speaking of stories, this is the strange thing about the American Revolutionary War. It's the most disastrous war in British history. And what happens over the next 40 years is one of the most gigantic expansions of British power in the history of the world. It's very weird. So there's an industrial revolution happening in Britain which will give it huge advantages going into the 19th century. So its economy is absolutely. It's on fire. It's going through one of the most important events in human history, this industrial revolution that starts in little old England. And so although the loss of America is a catastrophe, and although there's a world in which Britain, North America go on being one great big imperial state and maybe fused together as a nation state at some state in the future, that's a very interesting world, but it's not the one we live in. But what does happen is chaos in Britain. Political chaos, huge existential crisis. What are we doing here? We've got no money. It's a disaster. But under the surface, there's enormous dynamism and excitement going on with Britain's economy. Amazing things are happening. And then France totally implodes.

[Don Wildman]

Exactly.

[Dan Snow]

French Revolution happens, as you pointed out, often to a large extent, because of the vast amount of money they spend in the American Revolutionary War and then the money they spend after that still trying to catch up with the British fleet. And so Britain is drawn into this enormous war in Europe, These enormous wars in Europe, perhaps a little bit like World War II in the US and sort of lifting the Americans out of the remains of the Depression. Those actually, although they're very tough wars and some very tough years, in those wars, they prove to have a kind of galvanizing effect on Britain. Britain ends up conquering other colonies around the world, place like southern Africa, and extends its possessions in. In India. So Britain, it's strange, it's a disaster, but it doesn't seem to halt the trajectory of Britain into what will become a great global empire.

[Don Wildman]

There it goes. Works out pretty well for them. So we've done a whirlwind tour of the biggest pivotal moments of this war. There were many, many in between. But, Jonathan, I think it's fair to say. Well, I'll leave this to you. What do you, as an American think was the pivotal moment when the colonials imagined that they'd won this war? When did it happen?

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

When did things turn as to when they imagined they won the war. I don't know if they actually do imagine it until 1783. Washington himself is in disbelief that there will be any end to the hostile. I mean, he is up. He is ready for the assault on New York. Up until the point where the British troops leave in 1783, there's this intense idea that the war cannot surely be over, that they could not have actually done this from a, you know, stepping back, a geopolitical perspective, highly unpopular. When we want to look at the patriotic idea of, of the revolution. I mean, I do think that when Britain loses the war is 1778, when it. When it admits that it cannot control the northern, most populous, most rebellious colonies, and that that is where they. They lose their way, so to speak. I mean, they give up. They essentially say, we are willing to achieve a very limited victory or a limited loss.

[Dan Snow]

Loss.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

Not unlike Vietnam, where Dan was talking about how the British Empire massively expands following this huge loss. Following Vietnam, the United States sees itself as the victor of the Cold War, sees itself coming out as the lone superpower. And then, of course, there's the big question that I think Britain also had in the 18, mid-1800s, is what do you do when you're the lone superpower? And how do you use that power? Those are for future podcasts. But I, I don't think that this is a simple answer. I would like to say it was Saratoga. That would be the easy answer. But I honestly don't think for the colonists themselves, I don't think that there was a time when they knew that they had won until it was actually

[Dan Snow]

done, and then they didn't know how big they'd won. Because the Brits make a really extraordinary decision, which is that they don't just give these 13. Thirteen colonies this independence, or they don't agree, accept the 13 colonies independence. They give them a whole ton of territory that the Americans didn't even know they were asking for.

[Don Wildman]

Right?

[Dan Snow]

And that is maybe a different podcast, but they give them the whole of the Midwest, the whole the Mississippi, Ohio valleys. So these 13 colonies we talk about, suddenly it is the eastern chunk of what is now the U.S. so overnight, the peace treaty is as big a victory for the Americans, although it's almost

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

a Trojan horse, too, because in it lies the seeds of the near destruction of this new republic that is going to get sorted out with the Constitution. But prior to that, you've got to imagine the Brits sitting back there going, yeah, you thought

[Dan Snow]

today we're talking about one of the bills that creeps up on families every year and how to help stop it. So you brought me this stat. T Mobile customers had the lowest wireless bills versus Verizon and AT&T over the past five years. That seems surprising.

[T-Mobile Announcer]

Yeah, when I first heard it I thought mmkay. But when the experts at Harris X broke it down, it was true for millions of families. Five years of the lowest wireless bills versus Verizon and attention. And in this area where every monthly bill gets noticed, that kind of savings makes a real difference.

[Dan Snow]

Plus a five year price guarantee on experience plans on America's best network. I'm not hearing any sacrifice here.

[T-Mobile Announcer]

Which is what people need right now. Reliability, predictability. That kind of breathing room makes a weekend on the coast a little easier to plan. Affordable wireless service isn't a perk, it's a difference. And listeners, if you don't believe me, you can check it out@t mobile.com Switch

[Dan Snow]

savings based on Harris X billing snapshots from Q3 21 to Q4 25 compared to average AT&T and Verizon bills. Comparison excludes discounts, credits and optional charges. For More details see harrisx.com T Mobile

[Progressive Insurance Announcer]

Bills this episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try [e-mail] Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.

[Major Jonathan Bratton]

It was real easy to govern. Yeah, yeah, you try dealing with you assholes.

[Don Wildman]

Thanks so much Dan and Jonathan for joining me. And you can get more history from Dan on his podcast, Dan Snow's History Hit. They cover everything from the ancient Egyptians to medieval kings and queens to Britain in the Second World War. You name it, they probably have an episode on it. See you next time.