American Homicide: S1: Bonus Ep 3 - Bobby Cumber
Release Date: February 18, 2025
Summary by Sloane Glass
Introduction: The Unlikely Conviction
In this compelling bonus episode of American Homicide, host Sloane Glass delves into the heart-wrenching and improbable story of Bobby Cumber—a man wrongfully convicted of murder despite having a verifiable alibi. As Glass narrates, the episode serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of justice and the devastating impact of systemic failures.
Bobby Cumber’s Early Life and Background
Bobby Cumber, a 46-year-old Air Force veteran, led a modest and quiet life in Shreveport, Louisiana. After two decades of military service, including participation in the Vietnam War, Bobby sought stability and purpose by working as a clerk and bookkeeper at a local hardware store. Described by Glass as “the sweetest little guy, humble, accommodating and gullible with terrible luck” (04:03).
“He was the sweetest little guy, humble, accommodating and gullible with terrible luck.” – Sloane Glass [04:03]
Bobby’s personal life was equally unassuming. He and his wife Myra lived peacefully with their daughter Becky and two dogs. Their shared interests included bowling and country drives, embodying a life of simplicity and contentment (03:40).
The Fateful Encounter
In spring 1984, seeking a respite from his monotonous life, Bobby returned to his hometown of Perth Amboy, New Jersey. It was here that he encountered Robert and Maria Marshall at a high school reunion. Robert Marshall, an attractive insurance and IRA salesman with a reputation for smooth talk, befriended Bobby, subsequently requesting his assistance in finding a private detective to investigate missing gambling winnings (06:06).
“Marshall first tried to sell him an IRA because that was Robert Marshall. And then Marshall asked Bobby if he could find him a private detective.” – Sloane Glass [06:35]
Bobby, ever the obliging individual, connected Robert Marshall with Billy Wayne McKinnon, a former cop turned private detective. Unbeknownst to Bobby, Marshall harbored ulterior motives, including a motive for murder fueled by debt and a significant life insurance policy (09:58).
The Murder and Arrest
In early September 1984, Maria Marshall was brutally murdered at a rest stop off the Garden State Parkway in New Jersey. Upon investigation, police discovered Robert Marshall’s numerous phone calls to Bobby Cumber, sparking suspicion despite Bobby’s solid alibi—he was 1,400 miles away bowling with his wife on the night of the murder (08:59).
“Bobby is a very important footnote in judicial history as one of the most unlikely prosecutions that anyone had ever seen.” – Sloane Glass [37:10]
Despite clear evidence of his innocence, Bobby was arrested and subjected to harsh interrogation tactics, including being held without charges or proper recordings. The police were convinced of his involvement, leading to his wrongful conviction for conspiracy to commit murder (09:09).
“I’m not guilty of this crime. I just want to go back to Louisiana and live out the rest of my life with my family.” – Bobby Cumber [09:27]
The Trial and Conviction
Bobby’s trial in 1986 became a media sensation, overshadowing previous episodes’ coverage of Maria Marshall’s murder. Despite support from Robert Marshall and confessions from McKinnon that exonerated him, the prosecution’s case hinged solely on the problematic phone calls. The defense highlighted Bobby’s innocence, emphasizing the lack of motive, opportunity, and concrete evidence (18:06).
“No motive. No opportunity. No money trail. They really had nothing.” – Sloane Glass [18:06]
The jury, influenced by New Jersey’s mandatory minimum sentencing laws for accessories to major crimes, found Bobby guilty. He was sentenced to 30 years in prison without the possibility of parole (20:19).
“Thirty years.” – Judge Manuel Greenberg [21:04]
Life in Prison and Family Struggles
During his incarceration, Bobby’s life unraveled. His family faced severe repercussions: their home was lost, Myra received death threats, and his daughter Becky endured relentless bullying at school. Social isolation deepened as Bobby’s siblings in New Jersey disowned him, leaving only his wife and daughter in Louisiana as his support system (24:23).
“They lost their house, they lost their jobs. They lost everything.” – Sloane Glass [23:51]
The Fight for Justice
Journalist Judy Peet played a pivotal role in uncovering the truth behind Bobby’s wrongful conviction. In 1999, her investigative efforts led to the publication of “Flawed Judgment,” which reignited public interest and highlighted the grave injustices in Bobby’s case. Collaborating with Judge Greenberg, Peet orchestrated a grassroots campaign involving letter-writing by sixth-grade students, appealing to then-acting Governor Richard Cody for clemency (26:37).
“The only chance that he had then was to have the governor of New Jersey commute a sentence.” – Sloane Glass [27:12]
Clemency and Release
On his final day in office, Governor Richard Cody signed Bobby’s clemency petition, acknowledging the miscarriage of justice in his case. The emotional reunion with his family marked the end of a 20-year ordeal (28:24).
“Nearly 20 years after a jury convicted Bobby Cumber for conspiracy to commit murder, Acting New Jersey Governor Richard Cody granted Bobby clemency in 2006.” – Judy Peet [30:54]
Life After Prison and Legacy
Post-release, Bobby struggled to reintegrate into a world vastly changed by technological advancements. Despite these challenges, he focused on rebuilding his life with Myra and Becky. Bobby’s story, though largely absent from mainstream media portrayals of Maria Marshall’s murder, remains a testament to resilience and the enduring quest for justice.
“Bobby didn’t assign blame. He never did.” – Sloane Glass [32:15]
Bobby passed away in 2022 at the age of 83, leaving behind a legacy of wrongful conviction and the eventual triumph of truth through persistent advocacy and journalistic integrity.
Conclusion: A Cautionary Tale
Bobby Cumber’s narrative underscores the profound implications of wrongful convictions and the critical need for systemic reforms in the judicial process. Through Glass’s meticulous storytelling, listeners gain a deep appreciation for the human cost of judicial errors and the relentless pursuit of justice by dedicated individuals like Judy Peet.
“Bobby is a very important footnote in judicial history as one of the most unlikely prosecutions that anyone had ever seen.” – Sloane Glass [37:10]
Notable Quotes
- Sloane Glass [04:03]: “He was the sweetest little guy, humble, accommodating and gullible with terrible luck.”
- Bobby Cumber [09:27]: “I’m not guilty of this crime. I just want to go back to Louisiana and live out the rest of my life with my family.”
- Judge Manuel Greenberg [21:04]: “Thirty years.”
- Sloane Glass [32:15]: “Bobby didn’t assign blame. He never did.”
Key Takeaways
- Systemic Failures: Bobby’s case highlights significant flaws in the judicial system, including reliance on circumstantial evidence and the devastating effects of mandatory sentencing laws.
- Impact on Families: The wrongful conviction extended beyond Bobby, wreaking havoc on his family’s stability and well-being.
- Role of Journalism: Judy Peet’s investigative work was instrumental in uncovering the truth and advocating for Bobby’s release.
- Resilience and Forgiveness: Despite immense suffering, Bobby maintained a forgiving and resilient spirit, embodying the human capacity to endure and overcome injustice.
American Homicide continues to shed light on perplexing and tragic murder cases across America, intertwining personal narratives with broader societal issues. This episode serves as a powerful exploration of wrongful conviction and the enduring fight for justice.
Connect with American Homicide
For more stories and to share your thoughts, contact the American Homicide team at us@AmericanHomicidePodmail.com. Follow American Homicide on Apple Podcasts and rate and review the show to help others discover these impactful narratives.