
Loading summary
Amy Robach
This is an I heart podcast. Yes.
Unknown iHeart Podcast Host
It'S me again. We prepped. A message for you. You gotta think sexual health no matter what, when, when, or with who.
Unknown Ad Voice
Yeah.
Josh Zieman
Yeah.
Unknown iHeart Podcast Host
To all you lovers out there, ain't no judgment. This is your cue.
Amy Robach
Yeah.
Unknown iHeart Podcast Host
It's time to talk about pre special prophylaxis, a part of HIV prevention. Talk to a healthcare provider and visit carefortheculture.com to learn more.
Unknown Ad Voice
Autotrader is powered by Auto Intelligence, the hyper personalized way to buy a car. With tools that sync with your exact budget and preferences. So you only see vehicles you can afford and actually want. Choose new or pre owned, narrow by style and select features, even trailer hitch. Go ahead and get picky. And with pricing, you'll see which listings are the best deals so you can feel like you're winning the negotiation without negotiating. Autotrader Powered by Auto Intelligence makes car buying less of a process. Visit autotrader.com to find your perfect ride.
Cal Penn
Hey, audiobook lovers. I'm Cal Penn.
Amy Robach
I'm Ed Helms.
Cal Penn
Ed and I are inviting you to join the best sounding book club you've ever heard with our new podcast, Irsay, The Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
Questlove
Each week we sit down with your.
Amy Robach
Favorite iHeart podcast hosts and some very special guests to discuss the latest and.
Cal Penn
Greatest audiobooks from audible, listen to Earsay on America's number one podcast network, iHeart. Follow Earsay and start listening on the free iHeartradio app today.
Amy Robach
TJ did you know there's clothing that can actually move your body in real time while improving your posture and your back health?
TJ Holmes
So like a posture gadget of some kind?
Amy Robach
No, it's called Form Form Science Engineers Smart posture clothing for your health and confidence. It's endorsed by Taylor Swift, Oprah, Olympians and orthopedic surgeons. All you have to do is wear it and it will change your posture whole body literally instantly on its own. Like Autopilot.
TJ Holmes
Oh, come on. That simple.
Amy Robach
Exactly. It's perfect for work, travel, sports, or even sleep. And it's made in the usa. Invest in your health and confidence. Check it out at Forum Science. That's F O R M E Science. Or on Instagram ORM Science.
Josh Zieman
A decade ago, I was on the trail of one of the country's most elusive serial killers. But it wasn't until 2023 when he was finally caught. The answers were there, hidden in plain sight. So why did it take so long to catch him? I'm Josh Zieman and this is Monster Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer, the investigation into the most notorious killer in New York since the Son of Sam. Available now listen for free on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, wherever you get your podcasts.
TJ Holmes
Hey there, folks. It is Friday, November 21, and a young lady, a former GOP staffer, was found with her hands tied behind her with zip ties. She had scrapes, she had cuts all over her body, and someone had written on her trump whore. She said three men did this to her. Well, federal authority authorities now say she did it to herself. And with that. Welcome to this episode of Amy and TJ Robes. I. I don't know how it's possible that this young lady would be willing to do this and go through what she went through, which was pretty extreme. All for the sake of what? Attention.
Amy Robach
Attention. I don't know. She's 26 years old. Her name's Natalie Green. You brought this story to my attention, and the more I read into it, the more I couldn't believe what I was reading.
TJ Holmes
Okay, so, yeah, we gave kind of the basics there, which are shocking enough. The details take this to a whole new level.
Amy Robach
It's unbelievable. So, first of all, she has been charged, by the way, with one count of conspiracy to convey false statements and hoaxes and. And another count of making false statements to federal law enforcement. But when you hear what those false statements and what this hoax is, it is. It's hard to get your head around it. This happened in July. She called 911. There was a co conspirator with her. We don't know who that person is. There was another person who was with her saying they had just been attacked by three men with a gun just outside of Atlantic City when law enforcement came upon her. She was in a wooded area. Her hood, I guess her shirt, T shirt was over her head. Her hands and her legs were zip tied. And the condition of her body was shocking. She had lacerations all over her body. On her face, on her neck, on her chest, on her stomach, on her back.
TJ Holmes
And when you see it, folks, you say scrapes and scratches and cuts, and it almost looks like a grid, like she was scraped. Almost look like a grill, if you will. That's all over her body. On what? On the right side? A little bit on her face as well.
Amy Robach
On her face. It looked like something out of a horror movie. And I'm not exaggerating. And these pictures are online and it's. It looks painful. It looks horrific. It looks like she's been tortured.
TJ Holmes
And when they found her, right, she was Hysterical, screaming, yelling, crying, begging for help. So yeah, that's this type of story again, given robes. Sometimes what we see in our politics didn't necessarily, as shocking as it was, seem that necessarily far fetched back in July. Because the alternative would be what, that she's making it up?
Amy Robach
Nah, nah, not when you see the condition of her body, when you see the amount of cuts she has all over her. And then specifically, sorry, I just made a mess.
TJ Holmes
I just threw my glass all over the.
Amy Robach
Wow. I didn't know what I was saying was so, so offensive.
TJ Holmes
Well, this. I can't believe somebody would do this. I want to turn the table over next. Sorry about that, baby.
Amy Robach
Oh my goodness. No. So if so not just the, the violence that was done to her body, but then, yes, the messages, some of this cutting actually had words carved into her and it was Trump whore was written on her stomach. And then we, we don't know, there was a redacted name, but it said federal employee basically is racist. So look, she was working for a Republican congressman. And so yes, I guess if you're a police officer and you walk up on this, you think, my goodness, someone who hates Republicans, someone who is anti Trump, someone who is upset with the Republican Party has taken it to this extreme level and taken this poor staffer and, and abused her.
TJ Holmes
And it was, it was vicious and violent. You would, you would think this was a horrific crime. And given that she's 26, she's young, cute girl, all over social media, how could this happen to her? It was that kind of reaction at the time. I don't know at what point in the investigation their minds are even allowed to go there. How could you just not take this young woman looking at her, at her word?
Amy Robach
Initially, I would think the police would take her at her word. And as you mentioned, she was crying, she was yelling. She said that the men, these three men, had a gun, they restrained her, held her down there in the woods while they cut her. You know, it's, it's hard to believe, but when you're seeing the evidence right there in front of you, this woman is clearly injured. Why would you not believe her?
TJ Holmes
But then things start to come apart and, and Rose, they didn't have to do too much forensic analysis to start piecing together that this story didn't sound right.
Amy Robach
It, it came, it unraveled pretty quickly. So the first, I believe, clue was from police when they found zip ties in her car that matched like, were identical to the ones that they found binding her legs and her arms the night of the attack. So they find the zip ties in her car, then in this co conspirator who we haven't. This person who was with her. We don't know the name. Apparently when they looked at that person's.
TJ Holmes
Phone, this was hilarious.
Amy Robach
They found a Google search. Man, those Google searches do everybody in, don't they? What was.
TJ Holmes
This is funny?
Amy Robach
What was the Google search? Zip ties near me.
TJ Holmes
You know, if you look at mine, everybody has something in their phone right now, right. That you had that you did something. I probably got brunch near me. Mimosas at 10:30 near me. I probably got something like that. Yes, this was hilarious.
Amy Robach
Wine store near me.
TJ Holmes
Zip ties near me.
Amy Robach
What restaurant is open right now? Yes, all of those are. Those are our Google searches. Food and beverages. Not zip ties near me. But I believe perhaps the most incredible evidence, the most damning evidence was on her phone. So she followed up. She went back to the FBI and said, you know, I need this investigated. She didn't want this to go unanswered. She gives them her phone because she tells the FBI agent that after this attack, where police found her bound and brutalized, that she continued to receive threatening messages at work. So, see, she's still under attack. She's fearing for her life. And so, of course, the FBI said, let's take a look at your phone. Let's see who's sending you these vicious messages. What they found were some messages between this young lady, Greene, and someone with the job title of modification scarification artist.
TJ Holmes
Hmm. Scarification is that.
Amy Robach
Yes, there is. So I actually did a deep dive on a Google search on what a modification scarification artist is and what they do. And so they find these messages between the two and a scarification artist are apparently, this is something that has been done for centuries. This is an ancient cultural practice. So people have actually. They go into business where they use techniques to cut, scratch, or brand people. So they intentionally scar the skin. And it's something that people do for designs for. For cultural reasons. But, yes, you can hire someone to scar you.
TJ Holmes
But this was specifically. What was the first part? You said scarification in something. What was the first part?
Amy Robach
It was a body modification scarification artist.
TJ Holmes
Okay. When I first heard that, I thought this was someone who worked in Hollywood, like this would be some kind of an artist. But you're saying. I didn't see anything that suggested that. But this is not that.
Amy Robach
No, this is like.
TJ Holmes
This is real, folks. Some cultures, yes.
Amy Robach
And it's. It's similar to what we would consider a tattoo artist. You know, people might think that's an abomination to put ink in your skin and change your skin. So this practice actually uses cutting to actually create scars. And so they found this back and forth between Green and this scarification artist in Pennsylvania. They reach out to this artist. She gives law enforcement a copy of a receipt. Greene actually paid this artist $500 to scar her body. And she actually provided the exact. Like she gave her a map of how she wanted her cuts and lacerations and scars to go in a predetermined area. She had it all planned out. I didn't know you could hire somebody to do this to you.
TJ Holmes
Apparently it's big in Pennsylvania.
Amy Robach
I didn't know that this is even a thing and I, I just. It's just. I imagine it's a painful process.
TJ Holmes
But the. What she. At least from the pictures it looks like she's going to be scarred for life. She has. Like she's been maimed.
Amy Robach
That was the intention.
TJ Holmes
But she looked like. This is a 26 year old young woman. Why would you put. Why would you do that to yourself voluntarily for the sake of. We don't know. Because I. Nothing I read suggested a motive. At least the federal authorities didn't say we believe she did this for this reason or anything. So we were left to guess and speculate. But she is messed up. She has scarred herself for life.
Amy Robach
It's. And I'm actually surprised. I don't know. Obviously it's a legal bona fide profession to be a body modification scarification artist. But I wonder, is there any sort of responsibility on the artist's part if someone asks you to do something pretty horrific to your body? Is there any sort of standard or practice that you have to consider before or check someone's mental health or check someone's, you know, just to just say.
TJ Holmes
Okay, tattoo when you're drunk.
Amy Robach
Yes, Exactly. Pay me $500 and I'll scar your whole body. That's just wild to me that this exists.
TJ Holmes
I'm sure I can't imagine the disclaimers you have to write and do for something like this. Is it that you make licensing. I'm very curious if you can be and should be licensed to do something.
Amy Robach
When you see these pictures. I'm just imagining and I'm not putting this profession in. Into any negative light. But I'm just thinking as a human being doing that to someone who's asking you to do it to them. What was that like? When you see the pictures, you'll know what we're talking about. This isn't just a cool design she wanted scarred on her body. This is like. It looks as if she was the victim of a brutal attack.
TJ Holmes
Yes. No questions. You're in business. Somebody comes in, here's the money. This is what I want. Okay, Knock yourself out. But this is, it's. I don't know. And again, the, the congressman that she worked for, I mean, he's come out. They don't have it in the official documents. Right. When they're as far as the court documents. But he's come out and mentioned and everybody knows who it is, right?
Amy Robach
Yes. And in fact, when we come back, we will tell you what this young woman's attorney has said about this situation and the charges that her client is being charged with. And we will tell you what the man who she once worked for, representative from New Jersey, Congressman, Republican Congressman Jeff vandrue. What he had to say about her arrest.
Unknown Ad Voice
AutoTrader is powered by Auto Intelligence, the hyper personalized way to buy a car. Autotrader's tools sync with your exact budget and preferences to tailor the car shopping experience totally to you. Budgeting lets you input your info to see listings in your price range. Search and inventory helps zero in on your dream car. You can choose from new or pre owned, the style of the car and the features like engine size, color, all the way down to whether you want a trailer hitch. Go ahead and get picky. Don't worry about scrolling endlessly. Autotrader Powered by Auto Intelligence only shows you vehicles based on what you can afford and what you want. And pricing shows you which listings are the best deal so you can feel like you're winning the negotiation without negotiating. You can even choose how to close the deal online at the dealership, or a little of both. AutoTrader powered by auto Intelligence makes the process of buying a car less of a process. Try it today. Visit autotrader.com to find your perfect ride.
Amy Robach
TJ did you know there is clothing that can actually move your body in real time while improving your posture and your back health?
TJ Holmes
So like a posture gadget of some kind?
Amy Robach
No, it's called form Form Science Engineers Smart posture clothing for your health and confidence. It's endorsed by Taylor Swift, Oprah, Olympians and orthopedic surgeons. Or all you have to do is wear it and it will change your posture whole body literally instantly on its own. Like Autopilot.
TJ Holmes
Oh, come on. That simple?
Amy Robach
Exactly. It's perfect for work, travel, sports or even sleep. And it's made in the usa. Invest in your health and confidence. Check it out at Form Science. That's F O R M E Science. Or on Instagram at Form Science.
Cal Penn
Hey, audiobook lovers. This week on the podcast I'm sitting down with musician, producer and walking encyclopedia Questlove. We're talking about Mark Ronson's memoir, Night how to be a DJ in 90s New York City. All right, like we talked about before, Mark Ronson found sanctuary in the DJ booth. What's a tool or piece of equipment in the studio or on stage that gives you the most control?
Questlove
So I have two microphones on stage. We have the microphone that you hear as the audience. Then we have a second microphone in which we communicate with each other. I feel like that second microphone kind of saved all of our friendships. No band likes each other after 20 years or 25 years. The Beatles broke up in seven and a half years and we're going on 35.
Cal Penn
Listen to earsay the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club on the audience iHeartradio app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Josh Zieman
A decade ago, I was on the trail of one of the country's most elusive serial killers. But it wasn't until 2023 when he was finally caught. The answers were there, hidden in plain sight. So why did it take so long to catch him? I'm Josh Zieman and this is Monster Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer, the investigation into the most notorious killer in New York since the Son of Sam. Available now listen for free on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hari Kundabolu
On the podcast Health Stuff, we are tackling all the health questions that keep you up at night.
Dr. Priyanka Walley
Yes, I'm Dr. Priyanka Walley, a double board certified physician.
Hari Kundabolu
And I'm Hari Kundabolu, a comedian and someone who once googled do I have scurvy at 3am on health stuff, we're.
Dr. Priyanka Walley
Talking about health and in a different way.
Hari Kundabolu
It's not only about what we can do to improve our health, but also.
Dr. Priyanka Walley
What our health says about us and the way we're living.
Hari Kundabolu
Like our episode where we look at.
Dr. Priyanka Walley
Diabetes in the United states. I mean, 50% of Americans are pre diabetic.
Hari Kundabolu
How preventable is type 2?
Dr. Priyanka Walley
Extremely. Or our in depth analysis of how incredible mangoes are.
Hari Kundabolu
Oh, it's hard to explain. Explain to rest of the world that like your mangoes are fine because mangoes are incredible. But like, you don't even know.
Dr. Priyanka Walley
You don't know. You don't know it's going to Be a fun ride.
Hari Kundabolu
So tune in, listen to health stuff on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Amy Robach
Continuing our conversation about this wild story out of New Jersey. A 26 year old former congressional staffer arrested and charged after she paid someone who is in business to be a body modification scarification artist to basically make it look as though she was brutally and viciously attacked, targeted for being or working with a Republican Congressman. She went to great lengths, paid a significant amount of money to literally be tortured and then try to pass it off to police as a brutal attack.
TJ Holmes
And the motive, I haven't seen anybody mention one. At least the authorities. What the motive might have been, you can only imagine here this was an attention seeking to an extreme level. And I obviously you hear something like this and you think about the story out of Chicago several years ago with justice. And I say that now. I thought about it of course, when the story came up and I'm reading through articles, I'm scrolling down and sure enough, off to the side, all those algorithm algorithms that put up stories about Jussie Smollett. It's all over. So yeah, they're making the connection and his motive.
Amy Robach
Look, not that it was ever a sound one or an okay one, but it was so he could get more money. He was looking to basically create sympathy and he was in the middle of negotiating a contract and he thought by becoming perhaps the victim of some politically motivated crime that there would be a groundswell of support for him and he could get more money in his contract.
TJ Holmes
That's at least the motive we were given. Okay, well that, that makes some sense. We have heard nothing about this one yet. And what this could mean, what her.
Amy Robach
Attorney had to say, this is, this is what she said. Following these charges being filed at the age of 26, my client served her community working full time to assist the constituents of the Congressman with loyalty and fidelity. She did that while being a full time student. Under the law, she is presumed innocent and reserves all of her defenses for presentation in a court of law.
TJ Holmes
We got nothing, right?
Amy Robach
We got nothing and we're not going to tell you anything. We'll save it for court. But just remember she was a full time student and working on behalf of the constituents in New Jersey. So she's otherwise a good person and a hard working person who maybe lost her way.
TJ Holmes
Sympathy for a student and for a public servant. Yes, yes, but you tell by that if he, if there was something more here, he would come out forcefully. These facts are not correct. Michael. Or even she's had a mental breakdown, he would say something.
Amy Robach
Please give her some grace. Exactly. Now, in terms of potential mental breakdown, we did also hear from Representative Andrew's office, who basically in some way alluded to this. This is what their official statement was. Knowing that this young woman did work for them. We are deeply sa. Deadened by yesterday's news. And while Natalie is no longer associated with the congressman's government office, our thoughts and prayers are with her. We hope she is getting the care she needs.
TJ Holmes
I mean, he. I mean, that could be physical care, that could be mental care, but I. I do. I mean, I. There's. I don't know. I take a beat. I would love to hear from this girl and what she's been going through and what her life has been like and what. Why she got to such a place. Place that she thought this was an option. This took a lot of planning. This took a lot of pain. This wasn't just a silly little something or make a bad decision. This was really thought she had a lot of moments and times to go, nah, I don't want to do this.
Amy Robach
And the other. Yes. Agreed with all of that. That, that. That isn't something that was a rash decision or, you know, kind of a spur of the moment thing. She had to research this scarification artist. She had to. Somehow, I don't know if she traveled to Pennsylvania to then go get these lacerations. I'm not sure what all those details are. The other thing that's glaring to me, that I'm hoping we'll get some more clarity on this other person, this co. Conspirator. So it's one thing if you're having some sort of an issue where you decide premeditated to do all of these things. This other person you would hope would be a voice of reason or at least a sounding board or someone who could say, wait, what are you doing? Why are you doing this? And certainly not let me help you do this. That's. That's another wrinkle in this that I have yet to iron out. I don't know.
TJ Holmes
That person has not been arrested.
Amy Robach
No.
TJ Holmes
Has not been identified.
Amy Robach
Exactly.
TJ Holmes
Okay, so we say co conspirator because obviously she had. Somebody had to tie her up. And somebody called 91 1.
Amy Robach
Yes.
TJ Holmes
That's more than. Just let me grab some zip ties for you.
Amy Robach
And perhaps, you know how these things work in criminal cases. Maybe that person will be the, you know, the. The number one witness to this, and they'll be able to build the case against her. And so they might not file charges against that person because they'll use that person in testimony against Green.
TJ Holmes
I don't know why for. I know she's. I don't know, man. I, I give this young lady, I, I'm reserving and I, I just want to give her such a break because there's something. Just feel. There's a desperation, something going on in her life that there. That's not. That's more than a matter of simple. Oh, we talk about social media all the time. If people want instant fame and attention and how do you go about getting it sound? This is more, More than just a. This isn't a plea for attention. This is a cry for help.
Amy Robach
It seems it is, but it's also. It's also a crime. And I, and I point that out because the valuable resources that were taken away from something meaningful and actually needed in the community were then given to her who created this elaborate hoax. So, you know, money was spent, time was wasted, and perhaps resources were misdirected when they could have been used somewhere else. I know people might say, oh, this is a victimless crime, but actually that's not the case. When you look and see what goes into someone making a false police report and making people believe that they've been harmed, where there is a search that goes on for these three unidentified men who were on a terror and, you know, tortured this young woman. So a lot of. A lot of time, a lot of money and a lot of wasted effort was spent.
TJ Holmes
Yeah, they had better to do yes than. Yes than do this. But you're right, you're 100. Right. And talking about the resources, but also the, The. The breach for the public because there are people who had real concern for her when all this happened, so concerned for her now for different reasons. But, yeah, she needs to face for a crime.
Amy Robach
She is facing a maximum of 10 years behind bars and up to $500,000 if convicted. So we'll follow this. It is a bizarre one. Certainly got our attention today, and we hope you enjoyed listening to this. And again, we'll stay on top of this and all the other wacky stories of the week. This has been.
Unknown Ad Voice
Wow.
Amy Robach
I know we've said this a lot, but this has been a hell of a news week, so we appreciate you hanging with us, everybody. I'm Amy Robach alongside TJ Holmes. We'll talk to you soon. This is an I Heart podcast.
Podcast: Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present
Episode: Former NJ Congressional Staffer FAKES Brutal, Racist Attack. The Details Are Jaw Dropping
Date: November 21, 2025
Hosts: Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes
In this compelling episode, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes dive deeply into the shocking case of Natalie Green, a 26-year-old former New Jersey Republican congressional staffer, who faked a violent, politically charged attack on herself. The hosts break down the details of the elaborate hoax, investigative twists, the real evidence, public reactions, and raise pressing questions about motivation, mental health, and the wider social impact.
[03:29]
“I don’t know how it’s possible that this young lady would be willing to go through what she went through, which was pretty extreme. All for the sake of what? Attention?” — TJ Holmes [03:29]
[04:13 – 06:21]
“It looked like something out of a horror movie. And I’m not exaggerating.” — Amy Robach [05:46]
[08:19]
“They found a Google search… What was the Google search? Zip ties near me.” — Amy Robach [09:10]
“She actually provided the exact… map of how she wanted her cuts and lacerations and scars to go in a predetermined area. She had it all planned out.” — Amy Robach [11:18]
[10:31 – 14:00]
“Is there any sort of responsibility on the artist’s part if someone asks you to do something pretty horrific to your body?” — Amy Robach [13:12]
[14:25 – 21:18]
“She is otherwise a good person and a hard-working person who maybe lost her way.” — Amy Robach [21:44]
[22:12 – 24:53]
“This took a lot of planning. This took a lot of pain. This wasn’t just a silly little something or make a bad decision. This was really thought… She had a lot of moments and times to go, ‘Nah, I don’t want to do this.’” — TJ Holmes [22:42]
[24:53–26:03]
“I know people might say, oh, this is a victimless crime, but actually that's not the case...a lot of time, a lot of money and a lot of wasted effort was spent.” — Amy Robach [24:53]
On the Unthinkable Nature of the Hoax:
“It looked like something out of a horror movie. And I’m not exaggerating.” — Amy Robach [05:46]
On Damning Digital Footprints:
“They found a Google search… What was the Google search? Zip ties near me.” — Amy Robach [09:10]
(TJ jokes about the innocence of most “near me” searches, contrasting with this alarming one.)
On Legal & Ethical Questions:
“Is there any sort of responsibility on the artist’s part if someone asks you to do something pretty horrific to your body?” — Amy Robach [13:12]
On Motive and Mental Health:
“This isn’t a plea for attention. This is a cry for help.” — TJ Holmes [24:26]
On Seriousness of False Reports:
“A lot of time, a lot of money and a lot of wasted effort was spent.” — Amy Robach [24:53]
The hosts maintain a mix of incredulity, concern, empathy, and seriousness. Humor is used momentarily, mostly in reaction to absurd or surreal details. Both Amy and TJ are critical of the crime’s impact on public trust and resources, but express sympathy and a desire to understand Natalie Green’s state of mind and motivations.
Amy and TJ conclude by underlining both the bizarre nature and the seriousness of the crime, its impact on public resources, and the ongoing legal process. The case remains under investigation, with many unanswered questions about motive and possible accomplices.
“She is facing a maximum of 10 years behind bars and up to $500,000 if convicted. So we'll follow this. It is a bizarre one. Certainly got our attention today.” — Amy Robach [26:03]
This episode is a riveting exploration of an extreme and perplexing crime, peppered with insightful commentary on contemporary social and psychological pressures, law enforcement challenges, and the far-reaching effects of fabricated hate crimes.