Guilty on All Counts; Celebrity Real Estate Playboys Now Convicted Predators

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: "Guilty on All Counts; Celebrity Real Estate Playboys Now Convicted Predators"

Podcast: Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present
Hosts: Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes
Date: March 10, 2026
Producer: iHeartPodcasts

---

Episode Overview

This gripping episode dives into the dramatic trial and conviction of the Alexander brothers—once-celebrated luxury real estate agents in Manhattan, now guilty on all counts of sex trafficking, sexual exploitation, and sexual assault. Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes explore the details of the case, the courtroom dynamics, and the broader cultural implications, providing candid commentary and empathetic analysis.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Introduction to the Case

• Alexander Brothers' Rise and Fall
  • Oren and Allen (38, twins) and Tal (39), known for their high-profile clientele (e.g., Kim Kardashian, Kanye West, Lindsay Lohan) and "playboy" lifestyles, faced a dramatic reversal as they were convicted on 10 criminal counts.
  • Amy: “All three men convicted of 10 criminal counts. We're talking about sex trafficking, sexual exploitation of a minor. Their parents were in the courtroom watching.” (03:19)

Pattern of Celebrity Predators

• Familiar Legal Pattern
  • T.J. draws parallels between the trajectory of the Alexander case and other recent high-profile cases, noting the sequence of civil suits followed by federal investigations, criminal trials, and now convictions.
  • T.J.: “Let me ask if this sounds familiar. High profile rich playboys...civil lawsuits...federal authorities start looking into it, which leads to a criminal case, which leads to this trial, which leads to convictions.” (04:17)
  • Attorney Mark Agnifilo represented the brothers, as he had done for Sean "Diddy" Combs and others.

Evidence and Testimony

• Scale and Nature of the Crimes

  • Over 60 women came forward, 11 testified during the five-week trial. The brothers lured women via their elite status and resources, inviting them on lavish trips.
  • Prosecutors presented video and photographic evidence showing incapacitated, drugged victims.
  • Amy: “More than 60 women told federal prosecutors that they were raped by one or more of these brothers...these brothers would spike their drinks...they would be incapacitated and they would be attacked.” (05:02)
  • Amy: “...prosecutors, they even showed one of these videos to the jurors. The brothers would video themselves basically attacking incapacitated women....captions on these photos that were just horrific to read.” (05:54)

• Defense Tactics and Their Failure

  • The defense worked to portray the women as motivated by financial gain or regret, but this narrative faltered.
  • Most key witnesses had no monetary interest in the outcome.
  • T.J.: “Only two of them have civil suits. So you can't just say, hey, all here for the money. I think even one of them was the daughter of a billionaire.” (06:29)
  • Amy: “They wanted justice.... Several of them put their names out there, put their faces out there. They weren't...protected. Several of the women said, yeah, this is who I am. I don't want anything more than justice in this case.” (07:45)

Social Context and the Culture of Secrecy

• Open Secret and Abuse of Power
  • The podcast explores how the behavior spanned nearly two decades, with the brothers using wealth, power, and access to exploit women—often in plain sight.
  • T.J.: “There's a lifestyle attached to young guys having money, Jet set life...There's been rumblings about these guys for a decade plus.” (09:21)
  • Amy: “Are you a womanizer or are you a predator? That was the question and that was what was at stake at trial.” (10:05)
  • Amy recounts chilling testimony: “One of the victims, one of the women testified that she woke up and saw one of the brothers standing over her naked. And she said, I don't want to have sex with you. And she said he laughed and looked at her and said, ‘You already did that.’” (10:45)

The Prosecution and Impact

• Prosecution’s Commendation

  • The U.S. Attorney described the acts as "chilling, reprehensible, unacceptable" and commended the victims for their courage.
  • Amy: “They bravely overcame the pain of reliving the abuses inflicted upon them and as a result prevented others from becoming victims. And that's the point.” (11:14)

• Sentencing and Future

  • Sentencing is scheduled for August 6, 2026; brothers face life sentences. They have been detained since 2024 and are expected to appeal.

Broader Reflections

• Societal Implications and Victim Dynamics

  • The hosts discuss the additional barriers to reporting for victims enticed by luxury and status, including self-blame and disbelief.
  • Amy: “Maybe it's my fault because I drank too much or I agreed to take this drug or I put myself in this position. I chose to go on this yacht with them. I chose to get on this plane with them. So, yes, there is a moment where you probably say, that was on me. I shouldn't have gone.” (16:08)
  • T.J.: “You can't say. There are 60 women in the world who just decided to go after these guys because they got pissed, because they didn't want a relationship with them. That is. That's a tough defense.” (16:47)
  • The inclusion of minors among the victims adds “a whole other level of responsibility.” (Amy, 17:16)

• A Pivotal Piece of Evidence

  • The most damning was video evidence showing Oren Alexander with a passed-out 17-year-old, which was shown to the jury.
  • T.J.: “...video...Oren in this video with a 17-year-old. And how do you describe. He sets up the laptop...then you see him essentially lifting up someone's limp legs because she's passed out.” (17:49)
  • Amy: “How is that not a crime? I mean, right there, right there. How is that anything but a guilty verdict?” (18:18)
  • “The hubris of those men for videoing their own criminal acts and celebrating it on the video, it was undeniable.” (Amy, 18:39)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the defense’s inability to impugn all the victims:
  • T.J.: “This is not a situation where you can take attack 60 women and say, all of y'all are just dumping on these guys. It was just...You cannot impugn all of these women the way he was able to in the other case.” (06:29)
• On the verdict’s emotional impact:
  • Amy: “...makes me feel sick as a woman to think that they were able to continue this for two years because it's scary to step forward. That just shows you how frightened these women were or how powerful these men seemed...” (14:14)
• From the U.S. Attorney:
  • “These are chilling, reprehensible, unacceptable acts...They bravely overcame the pain of reliving the abuses inflicted upon them and as a result prevented others from becoming victims.” (Amy paraphrasing at 11:14)
• Defense's vow to appeal:
  • Amy (quoting Agnifilo): “‘We believe in our clients innocence and we're not going to stop fighting until we prevail. And we believe that one day we will prevail.’” (13:38)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 02:53 — Intro to the Alexander Brothers case and their celebrity status
• 04:17 — Parallels with other recent high-profile sex crime cases
• 05:02 – 07:45 — The scale of the abuse, evidence, and defense strategy
• 09:19 – 10:51 — Cultural analysis: “open secret,” power dynamics, “are you a womanizer or predator?” Discussion of key testimony
• 11:14 — U.S. Attorney’s statement and victims’ courage
• 14:15 — Sentencing information and impact of ongoing appeals
• 15:31 – 17:48 — Reflections on money, power, and the barriers victims face
• 17:49 – 18:39 — Discussion of video evidence and its decisive impact on the trial

---

Conclusion

Amy and T.J. close by reflecting on the tragic and infuriating nature of the case, the ironclad evidence that swayed the jury, and the hope that this verdict deters future abuses by the powerful. This episode thoughtfully unpacks both the legal intricacies and the larger social implications of the Alexander brothers' convictions, offering context and empathy for listeners seeking to understand how such a seismic fall can occur—and be stopped.

---

End of Episode Summary

Transcript

[Amy Robach]

This is an iHeart podcast guaranteed human

[T.J. Holmes]

Busted appliance. This is your sign to upgrade shop at Lowe's to get up to 35% off and next day delivery on hundreds of major appliances. Lowe's we help you Save valid through 318 while supplies last. Selection varies by location. Order by 4pm Available Monday through Saturday subject to availability, fees, exclusions and restrictions apply. See lowe's.com appliancedelivery for more details.

[Amy Robach]

Visit your nearby Lowes on Colorado Street Reed in Kennewick. Thank you for calling the Bombas Comfort line. Bombas make socks, slippers, tees and underwear made with the highest quality materials. Press 1 for comfort, 2 for style 3 for donation. You chose Style Bombas's styles for whatever you enjoy. You can run in Bombas lounge in Bombas. Dress them up, dress them down, but always give back in Bombas because with every item purchased another is donated.

[T.J. Holmes]

Bombas Comfort worth calling for.

[Amy Robach]

Go to bombas.com audio and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase. That's B O-M-B-A-S.com and use code audio. Hi, it's Jill Interestein, host of the Spirit Daughter Podcast where we talk about astrology, natal charts and how to step into your most vibrant life. And today I'm talking with my dear friend Christa Williams. It can change you in the best way possible. Dance with the change, dance with the breakdowns. The embodiment of Pisces intuition with Capricorn power moves. So I'm like delusionally proud of my chart. Listen to the Spirit Daughter podcast starting on February 24th on the iHeartRadio app app Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcast. Next Monday, our 2026 iHeart Podcast Awards are happening live at south by Southwest.

[T.J. Holmes]

This is the biggest night in podcasting.

[Amy Robach]

We'll honor the very best in podcasting

[T.J. Holmes]

from the past year and celebrate the most innovative talent and creators in the industry.

[Amy Robach]

And the winner is.

[T.J. Holmes]

Creativity, knowledge and passion will all be on full display.

[Amy Robach]

Thank you so much iheartradio. Thank you to all the other nominees. You guys are awesome. Watch Live next Monday at 8pm Eastern, 5pm Pacific [e-mail] or the Veeps app. Safeway and Albertsons have made saving easier than ever with great savings on family favorites this week. 16 ounce sweet strawberries are two for $5 member price. And don't miss the incredible deal on Signature select boneless skinless chicken breast value packs for $2.97 per pound limit one plus medium avocados or mangoes are five for $5 member price. Fresh and delicious savings for every meal. Hurry in.

[T.J. Holmes]

These deals won't last.

[Amy Robach]

Visit safewayoralbertsons.deals and ways to save.

[T.J. Holmes]

Hey there folks. It is Tuesday, March 10, and they were real estate superstars, playboys. And now a jury says predators as well. With that, welcome to this episode of Amy and tj. The Alexander brothers. This has been a, a salacious story, a lot of people keeping an eye on but it, and to be quite no other way to put it, real estate stars to rapists is what this jury has said.

[Amy Robach]

That is exactly what happened. These three brothers, the Alexander brothers, two of them are twins, 38 year old Oren and Allen and then 39 year old Tal. All three men convicted of 10 criminal counts. We're talking about sex trafficking, sexual exploitation of a minor. Their parents were in the courtroom watching. All three of their sons convicted, just hearing guilty, guilty, guilty over and over in a Manhattan courtroom yesterday. But yes, this is a massive fall from the top of their game. Oren and Tal were two of the nation's most successful real estate brokers. They did luxury homes. We're talking their clients were Kim Kardashian, Kanye West, Lindsay Lohan. So these were well known prominent men who were good looking. And yes, a lot of folks knew them as playboys but it was apparently so much more than that.

[T.J. Holmes]

And this has been a very much in the headlines over the past couple years and has followed a familiar pattern. Let me ask if this sounds familiar. High profile rich playboys who start to get civil lawsuits. Civil lawsuits last couple years started popping up from women saying they were sexually assaulted. So what happens? Federal authorities start looking into it, which leads to a criminal case, which leads to this trial, which leads to convictions. And yes, it leads to them having Mark Agnafillo as their attorney. So this, it sounds wild robes, but yes, their attorney took on this case which is absolutely follows a very similar pattern to the one he defended with Sean Diddy Combs.

[Amy Robach]

You know, it's, I was so interested because obviously Mark Agnefillo knows how to try and defend at least these types of cases because yes, there were a lot of similar allegations including videos and multiple victims. In total, more than 60 women told federal prosecutors that they were raped by one or more of these brothers. And 60 women, 11 of them testified during this five week trial. They talk about how they met these brothers at nightclubs, at parties, even on dating apps. And what would happen is these brothers, because as you mentioned, rich, powerful, had celebrities all around them. They would invite these women to all expense paid getaways, to the Hamptons, to Aspen, to the Caribbean, to cruises, to be on their ships. And so, yes, these women would accept, but what would happen is they said they would have. The brothers would spike their drinks, they would be incapacitated and they would be attacked. And in many cases, according to prosecutors, they even showed one of these videos to the jurors. The brothers would video themselves basically attacking incapacitated women, women who were drugged, to take photos of them. So there was evidence, there were text messages, there were captions on these photos that were just horrific to read. And this was all played out for the jury. It's a tough thing to defend.

[T.J. Holmes]

It is the problem that Agnafillo had here that he maybe didn't necessarily have as badly in the Diddy case. I hate to just do direct comparisons, but we did just go through this with Diddy. The problem was the victims were not problematic in this case. He attacked a lot of people in the Diddy trial because they did have some questionable backgrounds. Their motives were questionable as well. When you have this many women come forward, out of the 11 you mentioned, I think only two of them have civil suits. So you can't just say, hey, all here for the money. I think even one of them was the daughter of a billionaire. So you can't even make an argument that she's doing some kind of cash grab. But these were women also robes that weren't robes that we're talking about drugging and raping and women not coming back and coming back and coming back because they wanted to be a part of a lifestyle, that this is a different, different situation. It's hard to get in front of this jury as many. This was not on television. So we depended on the reporting from people who are in the room. Ropes. This is not a situation where you can take attack 60 women and say, all of y' all are just dumping on these guys. It was just. You cannot impugn all of these women the way he was able to in the other case.

[Amy Robach]

Yeah, you make such a good point. Some of the women even said, because that was part of what the defense tried to tell the jurors saying, this is a cash grab. This is a money grab. These women just wanted to enjoy the lifestyle and then they wanted to be paid because they regretted what they did. And that oftentimes is what we hear from defense attorneys. This is obviously a very specific case. But as you pointed out, the two women, only two women who have the civil Lawsuits who testified basically said, yeah, I don't even want the money, I don't need the money. And one of them, as the daughter of a billionaire, could really back that up. But they were successful women who weren't trying to just get money from the Alexander brothers. They wanted justice. And so yes to actually. And several of them put their names out there, put their faces out there. They weren't. You know, oftentimes we have victims and certain folks, certainly women who testify about being sexually assaulted, especially as minors, their identities are protected. Several of the women said, yeah, this is who I am. I don't want anything more than justice in this case. And it looks like yesterday they got it. And these brothers are now looking at potentially going to jail for the rest of their lives. I was just. One of them is married. I believe Alan is married. So his wife and his parents in the courtroom listening to all that testimony, seeing the videos, I, I cannot imagine.

[T.J. Holmes]

And these are still young men, they're in their late 30s now. But this behavior that they've been convicted of now has gone back at least 10 years more. Almost 20 years.

[Amy Robach]

Two decades in some. In some cases.

[T.J. Holmes]

So these are guys. These guys were really young guys at the time with a lot of money, a lot of power, meaning they robes. Imagine a. We've known guys like this in New York, dudes running around, influx of cash, 25 years old. We've run into these guys. There's a. I'm. I don't know these guys at all, but I know these guys. You know what I mean?

[Amy Robach]

Exactly.

[T.J. Holmes]

This idea. And I'm not saying that all these guys are criminals, but I'm saying there's a lifestyle attached to young guys having money, Jet set life. And that is what is described. So they're in their 20s. They said this was an. What, an open secret is the way they put it. Yes, that everyone. There's been rumblings about these guys for a decade plus.

[Amy Robach]

And look, but here's the difference. Are you a womanizer or are you a predator? And that was the question and that was what was at stake at trial. And Mark Agnavillo and the defense team was trying to paint a picture that yes, they are obnoxious, yes, they are womanizers, yes, they are playboys. But all of this sex was consensual. However, the drugs, the pictures, the videos, the testimony. There was one bit of testimony that really stood out to me. This. One of the victims, one of the women testified that she woke up and saw one of the brothers standing over her Naked. And she said, I don't want to have sex with you. And she said he laughed and looked at her and said, you already did that. Hit me.

[T.J. Holmes]

Agnafilo, I think we have seen him do this before. He thought, yeah, my, my client is a jerk. Like, yes, not nice people, not a nice guy. But yes, did all this, but it doesn't mean he's a criminal. Did all this stuff. He's a. To your point, same same pattern. And it just didn't work for them this time. Obviously they will appeal this. Did you see when is the sentencing?

[Amy Robach]

August. It's in August, so. But they are looking at spending the rest of their lives behind bars. And look, we heard from both sides who came out after the verdict talking about their reaction to what the jury decided. But we heard from the U.S. attorney who prosecuted this. And look, I don't think you can describe it any other way. He said, these are chilling, reprehensible, unacceptable acts. And he talked about the victims and he commended them for their courage. It is courageous to, to sit there and to recount something that is humiliating, that is devastating to come forward and to testify. But he said they bravely overcame the pain of reliving the abuses inflicted upon them and as a result prevented others from becoming victims. And that's the point. So especially when we see cases like this where women do come forward and maybe they timidly came forward through a civil lawsuits then were basically most certainly emboldened by hearing other women come forward and tell their stories, they also step forward, agreed to testify. And now you have all three brothers convicted and most likely going to prison for the rest of their lives. When we come back, we will tell you what Mark Agnethillo had to say to the waiting press after the verdicts.

[T.J. Holmes]

All right, we continue here on Amy and TJ on this Tuesday morning. Word came down yesterday, high profile, pretty scandalous. I think you could say this was a tabloid heavy story as well, but certainly a mainstream story. These superstar real estate brothers, the Alexander brothers, have now been found guilty on all charges they were facing in federal court having to do with sex trafficking, sex with a minor. Oh, sexual assault. And what a lot of people say was a pattern over the past two decades, almost of them not just womanizing, but being sexual predators, drugging women and sexually assaulting them. Rogue. We're talking about 60 women. They say 60 women at least were victims of these guys. And look, Morgan, the fellow did what he does. I don't, he, he needs to take. I don't know how he has time to do anything. The cases, he has robes going from Diddy to Mangione. He's been handling this case. He just, he doesn't have a moment. I don't know what that dude's life is like.

[Amy Robach]

Right. We think we're busy. You see him, it seems like weekly defending incredibly high profile clients with incredibly complicated cases where their lives are literally on the line. The pressure of that is hard to even get my head around. But Mark Agniflo came out after everything we heard and all of what we certainly read about on this salacious trial. And he told this to reporters. We believe in our clients innocence and we're not going to stop fighting until we prevail. And we believe that one day we will prevail.

[T.J. Holmes]

One day.

[Amy Robach]

Okay, well, sentencing is August 6th, as we mentioned, all three brothers facing life in prison for these convictions. And they have been in prison, by the way, since they were arrested in 2024 in Miami. So they've been behind bars for at least the past or rounding up two years, but looks like they're not getting out anytime soon. And certainly they will appeal. But it just. Look, Agnafillo has his work cut out for him. He knows what he's doing. But this case was just so heavily weighed in the prosecution's favor. When you see not just the number of women coming forward, but as you pointed out, the women who didn't have an agenda, there was no other. They couldn't poke enough holes or any holes truly in a lot of these witnesses who came forward with unbelievable tales. And to hear you just when we came back to just kind of go over what these brothers were convicted of doing for more than two decades, it makes me feel sick as a woman to think that they were able to continue this for two years because it's scary to step forward. That just shows you how frightened these women were or how powerful these men seemed to not stop them before. Two decades of this type of abuse is just alarming. And hopefully these types of cases prevent that type of thing from happening again.

[T.J. Holmes]

It's still happening. Money, power, pressure. I mean there's. How can you. That's what it is. Money, power and the pressure, I guess, these women. And how do you prove, how do you prove all these cases? Because they didn't know there was another victim out there when they became a victim. Right. And they not weren't even sure of what happened to them. We have seen cases like this where, when it comes to drugs, when it comes to money, when it comes to power, when it comes to influence, when it comes to. Yes. Fame to a certain degree, these guys had. Where are you going to come forward and say, I think this very powerful rich guy with all these powerful rich friends raped me? I think he did.

[Amy Robach]

And I think that police will believe me. Probably not. No. You know, it's just one. You're right. That is such a good point. And look, I also think there's the element of these women going on these luxury vacations. You think somebody who could afford to fly me to Aspen and to have me be around all these important pretty people who are all rich and famous. Maybe I imagined it. Maybe I agreed to take the drugs. Maybe it's my fault because I drank too much or I agreed to take this drug or I put myself in this position. I chose to go on this yacht with them. I chose to get on this plane with them. So, yes, there is a moment where you probably say, that was on me. I shouldn't have gone.

[T.J. Holmes]

But what as a. As a defense, maybe couple women you could question couple women, maybe you could say, yes, they just wanted the vacation. A couple victims were there robes. We're talking about 11 testified and 60 are the count for how many. You can't say. There are 60 women in the world who just decided to go after these guys because they got pissed, because they didn't want a relationship with them. That is. That's a tough defense.

[Amy Robach]

It is tough demount. And in addition to know that some of these women, at least two of them testified they were minors when this happened, that is a whole other level of responsibility.

[T.J. Holmes]

And those two points, the. The minor one was the ugliest part of this trial, probably. And the other part, you. We were just talking about who has the power, who is willing to. What's the lady's name from Tracy Tudor from Million Dollar Listing. She just came out in the past week or two also with a lawsuit saying she was sexually assaulted. Again, this is somebo. You look at and you're not thinking, okay, she wants her payday with these.

[Amy Robach]

She doesn't need money.

[T.J. Holmes]

We're right. So that kind of stuff. But the, The. The video wrote that they played this in court. They didn't play it for the. The courtroom to see, but the jury saw it. Rose, this is the way they described this video. Was it. Or. I think it was Oren. Oren in this video with a 17 year old. And how do you describe. He sets up the laptop with a certain way, with a certain angle, and then you see him essentially lifting up someone's limp legs because she's passed out.

[Amy Robach]

How is that not a crime? I mean, right there, right there. How is that anything but a guilty verdict?

[T.J. Holmes]

We don't even need to. What are we going to keep talking about, Right? How do you defend 17? That's just tough. And I think that moment, that video, that story, robes, I guess, probably gets at the heart of just how heinous some of the things we heard were.

[Amy Robach]

Yes. And the hubris of those men for videoing their own criminal acts and celebrating it on the video, it was undeniable. The jury agreed. And yes, the Alexander brothers almost certainly will be going to prison for the rest of their life. And with that, everyone, thank you for listening to us. We always appreciate you. I'm Amy Robach alongside T.J. holmes. We will talk to you soon.

[T.J. Holmes]

Foreign.

[Amy Robach]

This is Chelsea Handler from Dear Chelsea, after the Big Game. Like most people, I kept thinking about the commercials, and there was one that stayed with me. It was from the Blue Square Alliance Against Hate, and it wasn't loud or flashy. It showed a Jewish kid being targeted at school and another student who chose not to ignore it. As someone who was Jewish, that moment felt very real to me. Not dramatic, just familiar. And what struck me was how clearly it showed that hate doesn't always announce itself, but the impact is still huge. If you saw the blue square spot during the Big game, it's worth thinking about. And if you want to show support, sharing the blue square is one small way to do that. I'm U.S. transportation Secretary Sean Duffy. We all get distracted when we drive, whether it's from our phones or kids in the backseat bickering. But how we handle these distractions can be a matter of life or death. Before you get on the road for your next road trip, please put your phones on silent and take a mental note to focus on driving. Paid for by nhtsa. If you're a maintenance supervisor at a

[T.J. Holmes]

manufacturing facility and your machinery isn't working

[Amy Robach]

right, Grainger knows you need to understand

[T.J. Holmes]

what's wrong as soon as possible. So when a conveyor motor falters, Grainger offers diagnostic tools like calibration kits and multimeters to help you identify and fix the problem. With Grainger, you can be confident you have everything you need to keep your facility running smoothly. Call 1-800-GRAINGER Click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done. I'm caught up in the game. My attention is on every play and every whistle. But what I'm missing is a signal coming from my kidney. That signal isn't like a ref's whistle. It's more of a silent sos, which could be warning me of an increased risk for events like heart attack or stroke. And a way I can catch that signal a simple urine test called UACR. If you have type 2 diabetes or high blood pressure, talk to your doctor about the UACR test. Detect the SOS. Visit detectthesos.com to learn more.

[Amy Robach]

Hi, it's Jo Interestine, host of the Spirit Daughter Podcast where we talk about astrology and natal charts and how to step into your most vibrant life. And today I'm talking with my dear friend Krista Williams. It can change you in the best way possible. Dance with the change. Dance with the breakdowns. The embodiment of Pisces intuition with Capricorn power moves. Just so. I'm, like delusionally proud of my chart. Listen to the Spirit Daughter podcast starting on February 24th on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your podcast us. This is an iHeart podcast. Guaranteed Human.