Making the Band’s Que - addressing the trial and finding healing from the pain

Podcast Summary: Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present: Aubrey O’Day, Covering the Diddy Trial

Episode: Making the Band’s Que - Addressing the Trial and Finding Healing from the Pain
Release Date: May 23, 2025
Hosted By: Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes
Special Guest: Aubrey O’Day

Introduction

In this poignant episode of Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present, Aubrey O’Day joins veteran journalists Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes to delve deep into the highly publicized trial of Sean “Diddy” Combs. Drawing from her personal experiences as Diddy’s former protege and her time with the band Day26, Aubrey provides a unique and heartfelt perspective on the events that have shocked fans and the music industry alike.

Emotional Impact on Participants

The discussion opens with Aubrey O’Day and Q (Quanelle Mosley) sharing their immediate reactions to the unfolding trial proceedings.

Aubrey O’Day (04:04): “I think this case is very disgusting to see and hear the things that went on in the relationship between Cassie and Diddy. I’m just overwhelmed.”
Q (03:39): “This is some heavy stuff. You’re having to relive a lot of trauma.”

Both guests convey a profound sense of distress and emotional turmoil as they navigate the revelations of the trial.

The Relationship with Diddy

Aubrey elaborates on her professional and personal relationship with Diddy, highlighting underlying tensions and perceived intentions.

Aubrey O’Day (05:00): “I call Diddy Mr. Mogul. I feel like he respected me being in Day26, but he didn’t respect that I was dating one of his artists.”
Aubrey O’Day (05:26): “I felt like he didn’t want any other man. He wanted full control.”

These statements shed light on the complexities of her interactions with Diddy, suggesting a power dynamic fraught with manipulation.

Specific Incidents and Memories

Aubrey recounts a particularly unsettling experience in the Hamptons, illustrating the blurred lines between professional obligations and personal safety.

Aubrey O’Day (07:38): “Diddy's energy just felt so weird... It was a friendly invitation to something.”
Aubrey O’Day (08:15): “I took ecstasy and blacked out, waking up screaming in the basement. It felt very sacrificial.”

This incident underscores the traumatic events that have significantly impacted her mental health.

Mental Health Consequences

The guests discuss the severe mental health repercussions resulting from their experiences.

Aubrey O’Day (09:38): “I felt scared and paranoid around him sometimes.”
Aubrey O’Day (47:57): “I was dealing with paranoia... I was walking around with a screwdriver, thinking I was seeing dinosaurs.”

These admissions highlight the long-term psychological effects of the alleged abuse and manipulation.

Family Perspective: Nicole (Q’s Mother)

Nicole shares her heartbreaking experience witnessing her son's descent into mental health struggles, attributing a significant portion to Diddy's influence.

Nicole (19:24): “I had to guide him right because he was so young.”
Nicole (43:25): “No parent should have to see their child go through anything like what I’ve seen.”

Her testimony adds a familial dimension to the narrative, emphasizing the widespread impact of Diddy's actions.

Abuse, Manipulation, and Influence in "Making the Band"

Aubrey and Q discuss the broader patterns of control and abuse within the environment fostered by Diddy during their time on "Making the Band."

Aubrey O’Day (22:35): “They come after the young, the oppressed, people they can manipulate.”
Q (31:47): “You’re either on the side of the victims or you defend the bad guy.”

This segment delves into how Diddy's influence extended beyond professional boundaries, exploiting the vulnerability of young artists.

Balancing Victim and Accomplice Narratives

The conversation shifts to the complex dynamics of being both a victim and an unintended accomplice within Diddy's sphere of influence.

Q (32:35): “As a woman, it's hard to think about being both a victim and being an accomplice.”
Aubrey O’Day (29:26): “Don’t believe everything before you hear the truth. Be respectful of everyone's trauma.”

The guests grapple with societal perceptions and the difficulty in defining their roles amidst abuse and manipulation.

Conclusion: Path to Healing

The episode concludes with reflections on the ongoing journey towards healing and understanding the full extent of their experiences.

Aubrey O’Day (48:19): “I am just healing. I’ve got better around 2020.”
Nicole (45:53): “If I could give it all back, I would. No parent should have to see their child go through this.”

Both Aubrey and Nicole emphasize the importance of healing and the desire to move forward while acknowledging the lingering pain and unanswered questions.

Key Takeaways

Personal Trauma: Both Aubrey O’Day and Q have endured significant emotional and psychological trauma due to their experiences with Diddy.
Manipulative Influence: Diddy's control extended beyond professional mentorship, impacting personal relationships and mental health.
Family Impact: Nicole’s testimony underscores the widespread effects of Diddy's actions on families and young individuals.
Complex Narratives: The guests explore the nuanced positions of being both victims and unwitting participants in a manipulative environment.
Healing and Recovery: Despite the harrowing experiences, both Aubrey and Nicole are on a path to healing, emphasizing resilience and the pursuit of truth.

Notable Quotes

Aubrey O’Day (04:04): “I think this case is very disgusting to see and hear the things that went on in the relationship between Cassie and Diddy. I’m just overwhelmed.”
Q (31:47): “You’re either on the side of the victims or you defend the bad guy.”
Nicole (19:24): “I had to guide him right because he was so young.”

This episode offers a raw and unfiltered look into the personal toll of public trials and the hidden struggles faced by those within the entertainment industry's inner circles. By sharing their stories, Aubrey O’Day, Q, and Nicole aim to shed light on the pervasive issues of abuse and manipulation, advocating for greater understanding and support for victims.