Loading summary
Amy Robach
This is an iHeart podcast.
TJ Holmes
Guaranteed Human success starts with your drive, and American Public University is here to fuel it.
American Public University Announcer
With affordable tuition and over 200 flexible online programs, APU helps you gain the skills and confidence to move forward.
TJ Holmes
Whether you're changing careers, starting fresh, or pursuing a lifelong passion, APU's programs are designed for people who never stop.
Amy Robach
You bring the fire.
American Public University Announcer
APU will fuel the journey. Learn more at apu Apus. Edu.
Josh Zeman
A decade ago, I was on the trail of one of the country's most elusive serial killers. But it wasn't until 2023 when he was finally caught, the answers were there, hidden in plain sight. So why did it take so long to catch him? I'm Josh Zeman, and this is Monster Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer, the investigation into the most notorious killer in New York since the Son of Sam. Available now listen for on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts. Wherever you get your podcasts.
Spencer Graves
A man with down syndrome tries the impossible, the grand slam in turkey hunting.
Justin (Cameraman/Hunter)
4:53 hits. We're legal shooting light. And he gives us this one last chust.
Amy Robach
Ow.
Justin (Cameraman/Hunter)
And he pitches off. And when he pitches off, he flies right into the gun barrel. I said to the cameraman, do you have him? He said, shoot him. I said, justin, shoot.
Spencer Graves
You can download this episode and others from lines and Ty Spencer Graves on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
TJ Holmes
Hey there, folks. It is Tuesday, January 13, and a man had an affair with his Brazilian au pair. And then his wife ends up dead in a double murder. Premeditated sexual fantasy plot. And that trial gets underway today. And with that, welcome to this episode of Amy and TJ Rove. Did I kind of get close to getting it right? Because this has so many cliches wrapped up in it and this is absolutely a true crime episode or a movie in the making.
Amy Robach
Yes, if you want to look up sensational murder trial, exhibit A will be in a Virginia courtroom today starting at 10am that is when opening statements are scheduled to begin. Yes, for a Virginia man who is accused of conspiring with his Brazilian au pair to murder his wife and a stranger that prosecutors say they lured to his home to make it look like some sexual fantasy gone bad. And he rushing, rushes in as the hero to save his wife. And it all unraveled because prosecutors say they figured out pretty quickly what happened with the help of the au pair.
TJ Holmes
So Brendan Banfield is the man's name, but the plot is that he's having an Affair and he tries to kill his wife and have someone else take responsibility and take the fall for it. So then he could be with his Brazilian au pair. How old was the au pair? He's 40.
Amy Robach
Right. I don't know how old she was.
TJ Holmes
But usually not mid-50s.
Amy Robach
I'm thinking in her 20s at the. Yes, that's probably a safe bet.
TJ Holmes
Okay, so we go back to 2023, I believe in February of when this all happened. And we set this up in that Brendan Banfield and his wife, Christine Banfield, did they have. They had a kid or two.
Amy Robach
Well, he had a four year old.
TJ Holmes
Daughter who was in the house at the time. That's part of the charges. But we'll. That's not the big selling point here. But what we're talking about is Christine Banfield. They. Can you say the au pair's name to me? I couldn't say her last name.
Amy Robach
It's Juliana Perez Magalhes is how I would best. I'm not great at Portuguese, but Juliana Perez Magales Magalhes is what we're gonna.
TJ Holmes
Go with for this episode.
Amy Robach
At least we'll go with Magalhes and then when we get to the trial and we hear her name pronounced differently, we'll adjust.
TJ Holmes
Okay. So the opening statements are actually going to start today in this trial. But as prosecutors describe, the setup here is that these two were involved in an affair, the man and the au pair. And they come up with this plan. Robes to kill the wife, but to make it look like some stranger did it.
Amy Robach
Correct. So according to the prosecutors, the au pair and Banfield created a fake profile on a website called FetLife.com and it's described as a BDSM and fantasy dating website. And according to prosecutors, the au pair and Banfield pretended to be Christine, his wife. So they set up a fake profile pretending to be his wife. Then the au pairs told prosecutors that she and Brendan logged onto Christine's work computer to use this fake account they set up to solicit someone to fulfill a sexual fantasy. So they find this guy who responds and they convince him to come to the home to carry out a rape fantasy involving a knife. This is the setup that they've created. So they even crazy this sounds.
TJ Holmes
This is the normal part already as crazy as it sounds, actually nothing wrong has taken place. These websites are out there. You do your thing, knock yourselves out. But at this point, this is an unsuspecting guy who's signing up for whatever he's into.
Amy Robach
39 year old Joseph Ryan, he's like, all right, I'll come and fulfill your sexual fantasy of a rape with a knife. They said that they got specific. According to the au pair, she actually got on the phone with him. So he heard a woman's voice. He felt confident that he was walking into a consensual situation. She said she wanted him to cut her clothes off, hold her at knifepoint and simulate a rape, basically. So the plan was, and what ended up happening is when Joseph Ryan shows up to the house and starts to carry out the plan, Brendan Banfield and the au pair then burst into the bedroom to save the day. But what actually happened is they claim that Banfield stabbed Christine with that knife and then shot Ryan. And then even the au pair admits she also shot Ryan for a final shot to make sure he was dead. That is what prosecutors they happen and they say they have the au pair there to verify everything that happened as it happened.
TJ Holmes
So they were both charged, Brendan Banfield and the au pair initially, but she pleaded to lesser charges. The reason we have all the details robes you just laid out and the reason prosecution know more about this story is because she turned essentially on Brendan Banfield. However, this is going to be a complicated case in that there were until she turned, they were flapping in the wind. They didn't seem to really have a full understanding of what actually took place in that house.
Amy Robach
Yeah, because I mean, imagine that scene and Brendan is telling them, hey guys, you know, look what happened. I walked in and I saw this man with a knife over my wife. And so I immediately shot him as he was stabbing my wife. So seemed like he thought he had the perfect murder plan.
TJ Holmes
Is he standing by? I know obviously not guilty, but is he standing by? Is his defense going to be what she lying?
Amy Robach
Yes, the defense is going to be that the au pair, for whatever reason, who knows what motivation they're going to give the au pair trying to save her own butt. Exactly. But they're going to claim that she made the whole thing up. Now he is facing two counts of aggravated murder, one count of use of a firearm in the commission of a felony, a count of felony child abuse and neglect and account of felony child cruelty because his 4 year old was at the home at the time of these murders. And that's all important because that creates the situation needed for them to give aggravated murder charges. When you have aggravated murder charges, you can seek the highest form of punishment possible, which could include the death penalty. So that's why these extra charges are important in a murder case like this. Also of note, the cameras are in the courtroom and this is really rare in Virginia. I was watching a local news reporter who said the last time this happened was in 2022. And we will all remember actually the last time cameras were in a courtroom in Virginia and that was for the Amber Heard Johnny Depp trial which we were pretty much all glued to. And the reason why those two things might be connected here is the same judge who oversaw that case is overseeing this case case and she said, hey, didn't see any problem with the transparency. The cameras worked well in that court case so I'm going to allow them in this court case. And so that's why there's even more attention on this particular murder trial. It's already salacious enough but to know that there are cameras in the courtroom is a big deal.
TJ Holmes
It's a big deal and it gives everybody a chance to follow this case. And again it's, we, we always have to be careful and I mean is it, it's, it's a tragedy.
Amy Robach
It's.
TJ Holmes
We say salacious and already the headlines you see with some are writing and being funny about the au pair and things like that, it's, I know it's become like, let's just be honest about it, crime has become a part of our entertainment unfortunately. But you have to remember the victims here in not just the dead, but including a child who was in that home who was going to be without at least one parent for an extended right. It was his child. It wasn't their child together all of.
Amy Robach
The, the way they have phrased it was his child, his 4 year old. So yes, and that you make a really good point. Christine banfield, the wife, 37 years old, she was a pediatric intensive care nurse. Think about pediatric intensive care nurses. You know, we don't know this woman but just by knowing what she did for a living says a lot about who she was and the profession she chose. And I just think that's important to remember. And yes, 39 year old Joseph Ryan, you know, people I'm sure just are very dismissive.
TJ Holmes
Oh, that's funny. We were talking about this the other day in a totally different context about just name some professions that as soon as you hear the profession you immediately jump to a conclusion about that person. And we were actually talking about fighter pilots and some different stuff. We were. And when you say pediatric intensive care nurse, like we know what an ICU is just in general and you're in bad shape to think that someone is caring for, for the most vulnerable in their Most vulnerable state. Yeah, that immediately I didn't know this about the woman.
That immediately tells you something.
Amy Robach
All of a sudden, your heart just.
TJ Holmes
In a different way.
Amy Robach
Yeah, it feels something different because you start to get an idea of who this woman was and the callousness. If this is all true, what prosecutors say, that because he didn't want to be married to her and he wanted to go right off into the sunset with his au pair, that's fine, Divorce her. I never understand. Is it then about money? Is it then about pride? Is it then about something else? Why go to that next level with this woman who clearly chose a life of service? It's just, it's. It's a sad story altogether.
TJ Holmes
But in terms of somebody she was a part of inviting into their home.
Amy Robach
Yes, yes.
Josh Zeman
To take.
Amy Robach
And yes, this is this. This au apparent, by the way, this. And this will likely play into the defense. And we'll get into this in just a moment. But as a part of the all pairs plea agreement, I think it's really important to note. So this happened in 2023. They are going to recommend Fairfax county prosecutors that she just gets a sentence of time already served, meaning she will not spend any time in jail other than what she spent already. So what is that? Two years at the most. Two years plus. So she's from Brazil, as we mentioned, and her sentencing, notably has been delayed until after this trial. So she will be cooperating with prosecutors, taking the witness stand, and then once the trial is over, she will be deported to Brazil a free woman. That is some compelling information to know. And surely the defense will capitalize on that, that she had every reason to turn on him.
TJ Holmes
And this makes her testimony now in this trial must see. You have to see. She is key because now she is being given a hell of a deal, a golden parachute. She is, it appears, robes, their only hope of convicting this guy.
Amy Robach
Yes. And so in addition to her testimony and what his defense will be, well, there is another twist in this case, guys. A hearing over the summer revealed that a Virginia detective, so someone who was with the Fairfax County Police Department, could also be a key part of the defense in dismantling a big part of the prosecution's allegations.
TJ Holmes
Success starts with your drive, and American Public University is here to fuel it.
American Public University Announcer
With affordable tuition and over 200 flexible online programs, APU helps you gain the skills and confidence to move forward, whether.
TJ Holmes
You'Re changing careers, starting fresh, or pursuing a lifelong passion. And APU's programs are designed for people who never stop.
American Public University Announcer
You bring the Fire APU will fuel the journey. Learn more at apu Apus.
Cindy Crawford
Edu hi, I'm Cindy Crawford, and I'm the founder of meaningful beauty. When Dr. Sabah and I decided to do a skincare line together, he said to me, we are going to give women meaningful beauty. And I said, that's exactly right. We want to give women meaningful beauty, which means each and every product is meaningful. It has a reason to exist. It's efficacious. You're going to get results, and then you just go out and live your life.
Amy Robach
Meaningful beauty confidence is beautiful.
Cindy Crawford
Learn more@meaningful beauty.com.
Josh Zeman
A decade ago, I was on the trail of one of the country's most elusive serial killers. But it wasn't until 2023 when he was finally caught, the answers were there, hidden in plain sight. So why did it take so long to catch him? Josh I'm Josh Zieman, and this is Monster Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer, the investigation into the most notorious killer in New York since the Son of Sam. Available now listen for free on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, wherever you get.
Spencer Graves
Your podcasts, Lines and tines with Spencer graves. On the iHeartRadio app is a podcast designed for hunters and fishermen to enjoy success.
I like the I idea of like, hey, put me on a big deer. You know, hey, there's a big deer out here. He's doing this. Be looking for this deer. But I also love doing it on my own. I love going out there and saying, running my cameras. I love patterning the deer. I like showing up at the right time, checking the wind, knowing what stand.
Amy Robach
I need to be in.
Spencer Graves
And then whenever it all comes together and it happens, that's the most satisfying thing ever. So when you do it on your own, it's like, I then can hang my hat. But if I had somebody say, hey, pull up on these dots and catch them right here and you're going to win. And then when I go in, it's like, yeah, it's cool. I won the tournament. The ultimate goal is done. But it's like, dude, when you find them and you make them bite, that's the puzzle.
TJ Holmes
I love it.
Spencer Graves
Listen to Lines and Tines with Spencer Graves on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
TJ Holmes
All right, folks, we continue here on Amy and tj. Brendan Banfield opening statements set for this morning in the case of what is being dubbed the au pair affair. Is that what that's what you're saying?
Amy Robach
Yes.
TJ Holmes
But yes, Brendan Banfield involved in an affair with the au pair, Brazilian au pair. His wife ends up dead along with another man who they had lured to the home of unsuspecting guy who thought he was coming for a sexual fetish fantasy, role playing thing with the wife. But instead the wife was stabbed and then they shot, according to prosecutors, this other man to make it look like they shot and killed the intruder, expecting to be heroes right off into the sunset and then can be together. But that's not the case. They are being or he is on trial today. She, however, Robes, very important point is not on trial. She has, for lack of a better, lack of a better term, she turned on him.
Amy Robach
Yes, exactly. And after opening statements this morning, which again begin at 10am, there are many legal experts who believe the prosecution may start out with a bang and they may call the au pair to the stand first. So a lot of electricity in that courtroom this morning as people wait to see who takes the stand first. Someone put it like this, only four people know exactly what happened in that bedroom. Two of them are dead. One of them is on trial for his life and the other is expected to testify. That's how important this testimony is today.
TJ Holmes
There are no. So the last two, the two that are alive, we have no reason to believe them. Like as a juror. Well, how am I gonna believe him? He's trying to save his ass. I'm gonna believe her. She's trying to save hers. So what does the actual evidence show? We always do this in these trials, Robes. You put yourself in the position of the juror. And looking at this, my question is that what is the evidence? Because I don't believe anybody, right?
Amy Robach
Because you can say whatever you want to say to conveniently fit your theory. That saves your butt the most. Now, there is another twist in this case that we teased before we went to break. So in a hearing over the summer, a Fairfax county detective who is trained in digital forensics, he testified that as he analyzed all of the digital data in this, in terms of that fetish site website that the prosecution claims and that the au pair says they went on and created in Christine's name on her computer and solicited this man to come over to the home. Well, this detective said that it is his professional conclusion that it was Christine on the computer, not Brendan and the au pair. Now, it's not just this one detective who says this. He actually had his team who prepared this analyzed by the University of Alabama. So they had it peer reviewed and the University of Alabama evidence analysis Team affirmed the detectives finding. So you have a group of people now who say after looking at the digital footprint left behind on Christine's computer, they believe it was Christine Dean who solicited this fetish worker. I don't know how to describe what that profession is.
TJ Holmes
Oh, was it a professional guy or just. I thought it was just a site for random, like, anybody.
Amy Robach
Oh, you're right. I guess maybe it was just a meetup, hookup thing. I guess maybe there was no money. You're right. Of course.
TJ Holmes
You're thinking Diddy, right?
Amy Robach
I'm thinking. Okay, so, yes, this was just a consensual mutual thing where two people agree to meet and play out sexual fantasies. So they're claiming it was Christine, not Brendan and the au pair. So how does that change.
TJ Holmes
It changes everything.
Amy Robach
Everything. Because now you can't believe anything the au pair has said on the jury.
TJ Holmes
If you prove to me, if you tell me that she was the one sending and recruiting and having that guy come over, I mean, what are you.
Amy Robach
Supposed to say, right? And could you make the jury believe, or at least plant a seed of reasonable doubt in their heads, that the au pair was upset that he ended an affair with her or that she was about to get fired or that he was about to maybe. And so this was her way to get back at him, to make the whole plot look like he did it. But see, she's still been behind bars and still admitted to shooting Ryan. So that's the only thing. Why would she do that?
TJ Holmes
There's a lot of whys with a lot of folks in this thing. But, Ro, you brought up what I think is key. If you want to tell. You're going to tell me somebody out there whose job it is. This is a we know about forensic examination now, and we even know about digital forensics these days. You telling me there's a guy who swear and this guy was moved from his position? The timing is weird. They say it had nothing to do with a disciplinary action or because he wasn't going along with the program. But he just happened to get.
Not fired. He was moved through a different division.
Yeah, there it is. So that for me, at least as a juror, if they allowed, I would raise my hand and ask questions, and this would be one of the first. But if somebody and a whole group backed him up. That's what you said.
Amy Robach
Yes, the University of Alabama.
TJ Holmes
Now, as sec, folks, we can say, ah, it's Alabama.
Amy Robach
I'm trying not to. To weigh in my feelings about Alabama.
TJ Holmes
We love you. That's just. That's just an sec joke. As rivals, you can't believe anything in Alabama. No, no, no. But they have backed it up. Then you are going to have to prove to me that these two are responsible for getting that guy to the house. Because if they're not, that means they did not premeditate and plan to murder him and her.
Amy Robach
This is a fascinating case. It'll be fascinating to watch the au pair take the stand and, yes, how the prosecution overcomes that big problem they have in terms of their timeline and their premeditation. You make such a good point. So we will be watching. We will keep you updated. Again, the trial begins at 10am Eastern Time in Virginia, but in the meantime, thank you everyone for listening to us. I'm Amy Robach alongside T.J. holmes. We will talk to you soon.
TJ Holmes
Success starts with your drive, and American Public University is here to fuel it.
American Public University Announcer
With affordable tuition and over 200 flexible online programs, APU helps you gain the skills and confidence to move move forward.
TJ Holmes
Whether you're changing careers, starting fresh, or pursuing a lifelong passion, APU's programs are designed for people who never stop.
American Public University Announcer
You bring the fire. Apu will fuel the journey. Learn more at apu.apus.edu.
Josh Zeman
A decade ago, I was on the trail of one of the country's most elusive serial killers. But it wasn't until 2023 when he was finally caught. The answers were there, hidden in plain sight. So why did it take so long to catch him? Josh I'm Josh Zieman, and this is Monster Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer, the investigation into the most notorious killer in New York since the Son of Sam. Available now listen for free on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts. Wherever you get your podcasts.
Spencer Graves
A man with down syndrome tries the impossible, the grand slam in turkey hunting.
Justin (Cameraman/Hunter)
4:53 hits. We're legal, shooting light. And he gives us the this one last chust and he pitches off. And when he pitches off, he flies right into the gun barrel. I said to the cameraman, do you have him? He said, shoot him. I said, justin, shoot.
Spencer Graves
You can download this episode and others from lines and tines with Spencer Graves on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Amy Robach
This is an iHeart podcast, Guaranteed Human.
Amy Robach & T.J. Holmes Present
Date: January 13, 2026
Podcast: iHeartPodcasts
This episode delves into the sensational Virginia double murder trial dubbed "The Au Pair Affair." Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes break down the case against Brendan Banfield, a man accused of conspiring with his Brazilian au pair, Juliana Perez Magalhães, to murder his wife in a complex plot designed to frame an unsuspecting stranger. The hosts explore the salacious details, legal strategies, and dramatic twists as opening statements unfold, with particular attention given to key testimony and digital forensic evidence.
[01:47–04:29]
"According to prosecutors, the au pair and Banfield created a fake profile on a website called FetLife.com…pretending to be his wife. Then…the au pair and Brendan logged onto Christine’s work computer to use this fake account…to solicit someone to fulfill a sexual fantasy." – Amy Robach [04:29]
[06:43–07:11]
"She turned essentially on Brendan Banfield. However, this is going to be a complicated case in that…they didn’t seem to really have a full understanding of what actually took place in that house." – T.J. Holmes [06:43]
[07:37–08:57]
"When you have aggravated murder charges, you can seek the highest form of punishment possible, which could include the death penalty. So that’s why these extra charges are important..." – Amy Robach [08:35]
[09:44–10:45]
"Think about pediatric intensive care nurses…just by knowing what she did for a living says a lot about who she was and the profession she chose." – Amy Robach [09:44]
"It’s a tragedy…crime has become a part of our entertainment, unfortunately. But you have to remember the victims here…including a child who was in that home…" – T.J. Holmes [09:07]
[11:20–12:34]
"She will be cooperating with prosecutors, taking the witness stand, and then once the trial is over, she will be deported to Brazil a free woman. That is some compelling information to know." – Amy Robach [11:54]
[12:34–13:03], [17:31–21:13]
"This detective said that it is his professional conclusion that it was Christine on the computer, not Brendan and the au pair. Now…it was peer reviewed…and affirmed the detective’s finding." – Amy Robach [17:31]
"If you want to tell…somebody out there whose job it is…to do forensic examination…he was moved from his position…the timing is weird." – T.J. Holmes [19:58]
[15:44–17:09]
"Only four people know exactly what happened in that bedroom. Two of them are dead. One of them is on trial for his life and the other is expected to testify." – Amy Robach [16:53]
| Time | Segment | |------------|----------------------------------------------| | 01:47 | Case introduction and summary by the hosts | | 04:29 | FetLife.com plot explanation | | 06:43 | Investigation hinges on au pair’s testimony | | 07:37 | Charges, legal stakes, and courtroom setup | | 09:44 | Remembering the victims | | 11:20 | Details of the au pair’s plea deal | | 12:34 | The digital forensics twist emerges | | 15:44 | Opening statements and trial expectations | | 16:53 | Importance of the au pair’s testimony | | 17:31 | Digital forensics detective’s findings | | 19:23 | Hosts debate implications of new evidence | | 21:13 | Hosts conclude and preview ongoing coverage |
The episode sets up a dramatic and unpredictable trial centered on complicated motives, plea deals, and disputed digital evidence. The only surviving eyewitness (the au pair) has negotiated a favorable plea, while the digital forensics suggest an alternative narrative that could upend the prosecution’s theory. Robach and Holmes stress the importance of not losing sight of the tragedy’s human cost and promise regular updates as the trial unfolds.
This summary covers the core discussions and insights for listeners who want the essence of the episode without the need for ad interruptions or banter unrelated to the main story.