And That's Why We Drink – Episode E412: Leona’s Ghost and High Definition Palm Sweat

Release Date: December 29, 2024
Hosts: Christine Schiefer (A) and Em Schulz (B)

Introduction

In this chilling episode of And That's Why We Drink, hosts Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz delve into a tapestry of the supernatural and the sinister. From ghostly encounters to unexplained UFO sightings and a harrowing true crime case, listeners are taken on a gripping journey through the eerie and the terrifying. Grab your favorite drink and settle in for an unforgettable storytime.

Leona’s Ghost and High Definition Palm Sweat

Timestamp: [04:30] – [09:42]

The episode opens with Christine recounting a spine-tingling experience involving her daughter, Leona. While organizing Leona's coloring supplies, Christine notices her daughter glancing nervously over her shoulder, whispering, "Where's that lady going?" This encounter leaves Christine on high alert, fearing the presence of a ghostly figure in their home.

Notable Quote:

• Christine: “It’s happening, it’s happening, everybody stay calm.” ([05:03])

Em supports Christine’s concerns, adding humor to lighten the tense moment but acknowledging the genuine fear they both feel.

Key Points:

• Christine sets up a high-definition camcorder to monitor any paranormal activity.
• Leona’s behavior suggests she might be interacting with an unseen presence.
• The mystery deepens as Leona refers to a "wife," a term not typically used by her.

Knowles Family UFO Incident

Timestamp: [18:07] – [50:30]

Transitioning from domestic hauntings to the vast skies, Christine and Em narrate the unsettling tale of the Knowles family’s UFO encounter in Australia’s Nullabar Plain. In 1988, while driving a 28-hour journey from Perth to Adelaide, the family witnesses a glowing, saucer-shaped light that appears to follow them.

Notable Quote:

• Em: “Everything I've ever imagined is happening right now.” ([05:34])

Key Points:

• Initial Sighting: Sean, the teenage driver, spots a bright light that seems to mimic their movements.
• Panic and Pursuit: Believing the light to be an ominous presence, Sean accelerates, but the UFO maintains its pace.
• Physical Effects: The family feels a heavy pressure as the UFO interacts with their vehicle, leading to a tire blowout.
• Investigation: After reporting the incident, evidence remains inconclusive, pointing towards natural phenomena like a superior mirage (fata morgana) rather than extraterrestrial activity.
• Corporate Involvement: Tire manufacturer Dunlop capitalizes on the incident with a humorous ad campaign, contrasting the family's traumatic experience.

Notable Quote:

• Christine: “I totally second guessing every time I thought I saw something.” ([53:32])

True Crime Story: The Abduction and Murder of Paulie Kloss

Timestamp: [58:07] – [107:05]

The core of this episode focuses on the tragic and haunting case of 12-year-old Paulie Kloss, who was abducted and murdered in Petaluma, California, in 1993. The story unfolds with detailed accounts of the kidnapping, the ensuing investigation, and the eventual capture of the perpetrator.

Notable Quotes:

• Christine: “It was just so terrifying to hear what was happening to her.” ([58:40])
• Em: “I have goosecam. I just love Gene Boylan.” ([107:05])

Key Points:

1. The Slumber Party Attack:

   • On October 1, 1993, Paulie and her friends were preparing for a sleepover when a man armed with a knife barged into their home.
   • He coerced Paulie into leaving with him under the guise of searching for valuables, binding the other girls.

2. The Investigation:

   • Initial police response was hampered by lack of immediate community awareness and absence of an Amber Alert system.
   • The family’s hometown, Petaluma, was unprepared for such a violent crime, leading to widespread fear and confusion.

3. Breakthrough and Arrest:

   • Forensic artist Gene Boylan played a pivotal role by creating a detailed sketch that matched Richard Allen Davis, the abductor.
   • Advanced fingerprint technology helped link Davis to the crime scene, leading to his arrest and conviction.

4. Trial and Aftermath:

   • Davis was sentenced to death, though California's moratorium on the death penalty leaves his status uncertain.
   • Paulie’s family continues to grapple with the loss, advocating against harsh sentencing laws like the three strikes law, which they believe disproportionately affects marginalized communities.

5. Legacy and Healing:

   • Paulie’s sisters have launched a podcast, A New Legacy, aimed at redefining justice and promoting restorative solutions.
   • The case influenced legislation and public perception of criminal justice, highlighting the need for compassionate approaches.

Notable Quote:

• Em: “Her legacy is strong, but I'd trade it for a hug.” ([102:31])

Conclusion

And That's Why We Drink Episode E412 masterfully intertwines tales of the supernatural with stark real-life horror, offering listeners a multifaceted exploration of fear and mystery. From ghostly whispers in the night to the vast, uncharted expanses of the Australian desert, and the heart-wrenching story of Paulie Kloss, Christine and Em deliver a compelling narrative that both chills and resonates deeply. This episode underscores the podcast’s commitment to unraveling the darkest corners of human experience, all while fostering a community of support and understanding.

Note: For additional insights, behind-the-scenes discussions, and exclusive content, consider joining the And That's Why We Drink community on Patreon.