Podcast Summary: And That's Why We Drink – Episode E421: Frenemies in Relaxing and a Mid Nap Yap

Release Date: March 2, 2025

Hosts: Christine Schiefer & Em Schulz
Podcast: And That's Why We Drink
Episode Title: Frenemies in Relaxing and a Mid Nap Yap

Introduction & Banter (02:27 – 05:00)

The episode opens with Christine and Em engaging in their typical light-hearted banter, discussing the quirks of working in audio, their love for hearing themselves on the podcast, and the humorous dynamics of their friendship. They act out a playful scene anticipating a reunion, highlighting the chemistry that makes their show engaging for listeners.

Notable Quote:

Christine (02:27): "It's making me feel absolutely insane. Like, I feel like."

Em (02:35): "Is it like when you want to do this, you want to pop your ears?"

Stream and Drink Discussions (05:00 – 14:12)

Christine shares her excitement about starting a new streaming venture focused on cozy activities like puzzles and LEGO building, aiming to create a relaxing environment for viewers. Concurrently, both hosts discuss their beverage choices for the episode, ranging from iced coffees to quirky water cups, adding a personal touch that resonates with their audience.

Notable Quote:

Christine (10:54): "I just don't want to make Jacqueline send us any more free just because I keep breaking it."

Quentin Tarantino Anecdote (14:12 – 18:00)

Em tells an intriguing story about Quentin Tarantino’s filming techniques during the production of Inglourious Basterds. The anecdote about the sudden blood spray on extras to elicit genuine reactions underscores the blend of true crime and paranormal elements that define the podcast’s essence.

Notable Quote:

Em (07:03): "So he did it so that there would be an actual reaction. And I was like, nowadays, I don't think that would fly."

The Legend of Saint Ozith's The Cage (18:00 – 46:56)

Christine and Em delve into a historical true-crime narrative centered around a village named Saint Ozith and its infamous prison, known as "The Cage." They recount the tale of Ursula Kemp, an alleged witch imprisoned and later executed in the 1580s. The story intertwines folklore with documented events, including witch trials, familial betrayals, and the eventual transformation of The Cage into a haunted house and tourist attraction.

Key Highlights:

• Ursula Kemp’s Trials: Accused of witchcraft after a fallout with neighbors, resulting in tragic deaths and widespread fear.
• Discovery of Skeletons (1921): Charles, a local resident, unearths two skeletons in his garden, sparking rumors and establishing The Cage as a site of dark history.
• Haunted House Transformation (1970s): The Cage is renovated into a residence known for paranormal activities, further cementing its eerie reputation.

Notable Quotes:

Christine (34:26): "You had to bring the... hold the talking stick, you know, like."

Em (40:37): "But this is a quote, I think this was from a SMITHSONIAN article I read and I thought was very interesting..."

Modern Case: The Murder of Billy Joe Jenkins (46:56 – 130:44)

Transitioning from historical lore to contemporary true crime, Christine and Em narrate the harrowing case of Billy Joe Jenkins, a foster daughter brutally murdered in 1997. The story unfolds with detailed accounts of family dynamics, forensic investigations, and the subsequent arrest of Shawn Jenkins, Billy’s foster father.

Case Breakdown:

• Background: Billy Joe Jenkins, placed in foster care with the Jenkins family in Hastings, is described as a vibrant and ambitious child.
• The Crime Scene: On February 15, 1997, Billy is found dead with a heavy-duty tent stake embedded in her body, leading to immediate suspicion.
• Investigation & Arrest: Initial focus on a man with a plastic bag fetish is dismissed due to a solid alibi. Shawn Jenkins is later arrested amid mounting evidence, including witness testimonies of his violent behavior.
• Legal Proceedings: The narrative highlights the emotional turmoil of the foster family, the impact on Billy’s birth family, and the complexities of the justice system in prosecuting the case.

Notable Quotes:

Em (109:19): "Doesn't help your case right now. Like, you need to just roll with whatever everyone else. Totally."

Christine (118:37): "So Lois later told the officer that she had more to say about Sean if he wanted to know, but she would only reveal it if he was officially charged."

Emotional Insights & Guest Interactions (130:44 – 131:47)

As the episode progresses, Christine and Em reflect on the emotional weight of the cases discussed, emphasizing the human element behind true crime stories. They share personal anecdotes about coping mechanisms like visualization techniques to aid sleep, adding depth to their connection with listeners.

Notable Quote:

Em (113:34): "It's like the wall from a high school gym. Like, it's like that weird, like, overly painted, painted, like, brick or something, or, like, cinder blocks, whatever."

Closing Remarks & Upcoming Content (130:44 – End)

The hosts wrap up the episode by teasing forthcoming plot twists and additional parts to the ongoing stories. They encourage listeners to attend their live shows, participate in their tour, and engage with their content across platforms, maintaining the interactive and community-driven spirit of the podcast.

Notable Quote:

Christine (129:35): "Which, like, I set off balloons. I'm sorry. Fuck. God damn it. I got to figure out how to turn that off."

Conclusion

Episode E421 of And That's Why We Drink masterfully blends historical legends with modern true crime, delivered through the engaging and personable hosting of Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz. From the dark corridors of Saint Ozith's mythical Cage to the chilling murder case of Billy Joe Jenkins, listeners are treated to a rich tapestry of storytelling that captivates and informs. The episode not only recounts gripping narratives but also offers emotional insights, making it a compelling listen for true crime and paranormal enthusiasts alike.

Stay Tuned:
Next Episode Preview: The defense strategy in Shawn Jenkins' trial promises unexpected twists and deeper explorations into the psychology of the involved parties. Don't miss out on the continuation of this riveting case!

Note: This summary excludes advertisement segments, intros, and outros to focus solely on the episode's core content.