Podcast Title: And That's Why We Drink
Episode: E432 A Techno Western Hotel and a Moonlit Bobcat Crime
Release Date: May 18, 2025
Hosts: Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz

Introduction and Personal Updates

In this episode of And That's Why We Drink, hosts Christine Schiefer and Em Schulz kick off with their characteristic banter, delving into personal anecdotes that set a relatable tone for their listeners. Early in the conversation, Christine shares her experiences adjusting to new family dynamics, particularly after adopting Hank, their energetic new puppy. Em adds humor to the discussion, jokingly mentioning moments when Hank's antics made home life both challenging and entertaining.

Adoption of Hank and Life Adjustments [05:03 - 09:16]

Christine and Em discuss the joys and trials of dog parenthood, detailing Hank's high energy levels and the adjustments they've had to make in their routines. Christine mentions, "I have been overwhelmed, but that's fine," highlighting the balance between the chaos a new pet brings and the happiness Hank adds to their lives. Em echoes this sentiment, sharing funny anecdotes about Hank's behavior and the community they've built at the local dog park.

Encounters with Local Community and Parenting Challenges [10:03 - 14:19]

The conversation shifts to their interactions with the broader community, including heartfelt moments like Em's appreciation for his mother and the playful dynamics within her family. They touch upon parenting challenges, such as dealing with a child's longing for their traveling parent, and the importance of maintaining strong family bonds despite life's inevitable stresses.

Exploration of Haunted Locations: Hotel Congress [21:06 - 53:54]

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the eerie Hotel Congress in Tucson, Arizona, a location steeped in history and paranormal lore. Christine recounts their stay at the hotel during one of their shows, describing it as "the weirdest hotel experience" with its vintage decor and haunted reputation. They delve into the hotel's rich history, including a devastating fire in 1934 and its ties to infamous gangster John Dillinger.

Em shares a chilling recount: "When we got there, I looked around and I was like, this place is obviously f***ing haunted." The hosts explore various haunted rooms within the hotel, each with its own ghostly tales—from doors unlocking on their own in room 212 to apparitions appearing in room 242. Christine adds, "Guests will wake up from nightmares and see someone standing over them," painting a vivid picture of the hotel's haunted ambiance.

True Crime Spotlight: The Murder of Elisa Sherman [61:00 - 107:34]

Transitioning from ghost stories to true crime, Christine brings to light the harrowing case of Elisa Sherman, a compassionate labor and delivery nurse from Cleveland whose life was tragically cut short. Born in 1959 to Holocaust survivors, Elisa was known for her unwavering dedication to her patients and her community. Her marriage to Sanford Sherman, an eye surgeon, appeared stable until mounting tensions led Elisa to file for divorce in 2011.

Tragedy struck on March 24th, a few days before her court date, when Elisa was brutally attacked and murdered outside her divorce attorney Gregory Moore's office. Em narrates the grim details: "She had been stabbed 11 times by..." The investigation initially pointed fingers towards Sanford, uncovering deep-seated financial fraud and coercive behavior during their marriage. However, recent developments in 2025 shed new light on the case, revealing Gregory Moore's direct involvement.

Christine relays the breakthrough: "Ohio authorities said they've solved the more than decade old fatal stabbing of a Cleveland clinic nurse, announcing recent murder charges against her former divorce attorney..." Moore, previously uncooperative and implicated in other dubious activities, was arrested and indicted for his role in Elisa's murder. This revelation brings a bittersweet closure to Elisa's grieving family, as Christine notes, "Glad they got the person. But the memories are painful."

Conclusion and Reflections

Throughout the episode, Christine and Em blend their personal stories with engaging discussions of historical hauntings and contemporary true crime, offering listeners a compelling mix of the paranormal and the poignant realities of human experiences. They reflect on themes of loss, justice, and the enduring impact one individual can have on their community.

Closing the episode, the hosts express gratitude to their audience and tease upcoming content, maintaining their signature blend of depth and lightheartedness.

Notable Quotes:

• Christine [03:10]: "I'm actively grieving the lack of freedom that's been taken away because all of a sudden, it happens overnight."

• Em [08:42]: "They're the most M thing I ever heard."

• Christine [24:30]: "Something else is going on. I wrote about it in our book."

• Em [49:07]: "They're like, that's actually something different. That has nothing to do with the robbery."

• Christine [65:48]: "There's nothing I'd rather be responsible for than telling some sort of legend and lore about how you go out."

• Em [97:22]: "Zocdoc is a free app and website where you can search and compare high quality in network doctors and click to instantly book an appointment."

This episode masterfully intertwines personal narratives with investigative storytelling, providing listeners with both entertainment and insightful reflections on the mysteries and tragedies that shape our lives.