Loading summary
Shemitah Basu
Good morning. It's Wednesday, May 7th. I'm Shemitah Basu. This is Apple News Today. On today's show, escalating tensions between India and Pakistan. The conclave to choose a new pope begins today. And a mostly cordial meeting between Canada's new prime minister and President Trump. But first, to last week's communications meltdown at Newark Airport that put air traffic controllers completely in the dark and set off a chain reaction that's still resulting in canceled and delayed flights. Yesterday, audio from air traffic control was released, offering us a window into the incident.
Air Traffic Controller
No, you do not have a Bravo clearance. We lost our radar and it's not working correctly. Radar service terminates. Change approved. If you want a Bravo clearance, you can just call the towers and get closer. Okay, I'll wait for that frequency from you. Okay. Okay. No, just walk me as far. Look up the tower frequencies. We don't have a radar, so I don't know where you are.
Shemitah Basu
We called up Andrew Tangle, who covers aviation safety and regulation for the Wall Street Journal, to tell us what was happening there.
Andrew Tangle
They lost their radios and their radars for about 90 seconds, and they couldn't communicate with pilots. And that was a very scary situation for the controllers. They are managing busy, complex airspace, and they keep airplanes safely separated. They tell them where to go, where to point the nose, how fast to go, all of that, and keep them out of harm's way. And they do that with the tools that went dead.
Shemitah Basu
This blackout meant controllers couldn't see where each plane was and their backup systems didn't work.
Andrew Tangle
There are planes taking off, landing, going hundreds of miles per hour. They're all in sequence. They need to know where not to fly. They need to know not to go in a certain direction, to not have a conflict with another aircraft and crash into it. And when the basic tools that air traffic controllers use don't work, it's very scary for them. But it raises, obviously, safety issues for the traveling public.
Shemitah Basu
Ultimately, there were no crashes. Thousands of flights have been delayed or canceled since, and dozens more were diverted to other airports. Tangle says the whole experience was traumatizing for the controllers. Their union has said that many have since taken trauma leave. As for the cause, the Transportation Secretary, Sean Duffy, has blamed, quote, antiquated technology. He says he'll propose a plan to modernize the air traffic system later this week that will cost tens of billions, billions of dollars. What happened at Newark, along with other recent aviation disasters like the fatal collision near Reagan National Airport in January, have put longstanding problems in the industry into sharp focus Air traffic control alone has been facing issues for years due to inadequate funding, dated systems and staffing shortages. A report from the Government Accountability Office last year found that close to three quarters of air traffic systems were obsolete or potentially too hard to fix OR MAIN the FAA says it's understaffed by about 3,000 fully certified controllers nationwide, so.
Andrew Tangle
That results in controllers needing to work six day weeks, ten hour days. There are reports of fatigue, stress and so forth. I mean, controllers are known to like overtime, but some say that after a while they'd rather have a better life work balance.
Shemitah Basu
Duffy has rolled out new incentives aimed at increasing the number of certified controllers. In February, he announced a 30% pay increase for students at the Air Traffic Academy. More recently, he announced the FAA will give $5,000 to all graduates of that academy. And he announced annual bonuses for air traffic controllers who are eligible for retirement but choose to stay on the job. So far, controllers have been exempt from federal workforce cuts. As for what's going on at Newark Airport, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has now called for an investigation and it remains unclear how long it'll take for flights to resume their regular schedules. Now let's turn to some major military developments in Southeast Asia as the world is watching nervously after India sent a series of strikes into Pakistan and Pakistani administered Kashmir. Pakistan responded, according to an army spokesman, by shooting down Indian jet fighters. The strikes follow a recent militant attack in a part of Indian administered Kashmir in April which killed 26 people, primarily Indian tourists. India has accused Pakistan of having links to last month's attack which Pakistan has denied. A video shared by Reuters appeared to capture the moment bombs descended near the Pakistani administered city of Muzaffarabad. According to Pakistani officials, multiple civilians, including children, have died. We are now in the midst of a standoff between two nuclear powers engaged in some of the most dangerous fighting in years. But so far there's a lot of disagreement between them on what's taken place. Pakistan described India's attack as an act of war and said it will not go unpunished. An armed forces spokesperson claimed they had specifically targeted places of worship in a BBC interview. But India says it struck sites of, quote, terrorist infrastructure and insisted its actions were measured, responsible and designed to be non escalatory. Yesterday, President Trump was asked about the strikes shortly after they happened.
President Trump
It's a shame we just heard about it just as we were walking in the doors of the Oval. Just heard about it. I guess people knew something was going to happen based on a little bit of the past They've been fighting for a long time. You know, they've been fighting for many, many decades and centuries actually if you really think about it. No, I just hope it ends very quickly.
Shemitah Basu
The Washington Post reports over the last week the United States has been urging de escalation between the two countries. A spokesperson for the UN Secretary General expressed concern saying, quote, the world cannot afford a military confrontation between India and Pakistan. This is not the first time the two countries have come dangerously close to escalation over Kashmir, a divided area that both make a claim to. There have been attacks as recently as 2016 and 2019, but they targeted security forces based in the region. Pakistan has consistently denied any involvement and in recent years at least tensions have been brought under control before escalating to all out war. For more on this quickly moving story, you can find the latest in the Apple News app. Conclave, the process to select a new pope begins today. It's a centuries old Catholic tradition where cardinal electors from around the world come to the Vatican, take an oath of secrecy, lock the doors of the Sistine Chapel and stay there until they select a new pontiff. In fact, the word conclave, which comes from the Latin with key, literally refers to being locked in. Bill Chappell, a correspondent for npr, told us about the voting process.
Bill Chappell
The ballots themselves will be secret. It's recommended for cardinals to use a handwriting style that's not necessarily highly identifiable to their own.
Shemitah Basu
And the commitment to secrecy extends beyond the cardinals. Workers at the chapel are instructed to sweep the room for bugs to make sure nothing gets recorded and leaked to the press. Selecting a new pope will require a two thirds majority vote from the 135 eligible electors, all of whom are men.
Bill Chappell
If there's no clear winner from that, with the two thirds majority, those ballots will be added to a pile that would then be burned to signal to people outside of the Sistine Chapel with black smoke that there's no new pope and the process will still have to continue.
Shemitah Basu
The process can go on for days. When a pope is eventually selected, white smoke is the signal and the largest bell at St. Peter's Basilica will ring. The new pontiff is then asked two questions.
Bill Chappell
The first is do you accept your election as pope? And the second is what will you be known as? Like, what will your name be?
Shemitah Basu
Then the cardinal deacon of the church emerges from the central balcony of St. Peter's to announce Habemus papam, which is Latin for we have a Pope. This conclave is unique in its makeup. While most of the electors hail from Europe, Chappell reports. This actually will be the least European conclave ever. At least 70 countries will be represented, and 17% of the electors are from Asia.
Bill Chappell
Francis famously was the first pope from South America. He installed cardinals in countries where there had been no cardinal before. You know, places like Mongolia, Rwanda, Haiti and Laos. His goal, I think, was to make the church reflect more of its global population. There are more than a billion Catholics around the world.
Shemitah Basu
There are a number of lists floating around naming cardinals who might possibly be the next pope. But observers point out Pope Francis was an obscure pick. It's better to wait and see the outcome. Before we let you go, a few other stories we're following. The Supreme Court will allow the Trump administration to implement its ban on transgender people serving in the military, while legal challenges will continue to play out in practice. Yesterday's decision from the court allows the armed forces to discharge current transgender members and to reject prospective recruits. The ban had previously been blocked by lower courts. An estimated 4,200 service members are transgender, representing about 0.2% of the military. Canada's newly elected Prime Minister, Mark Carney met with President Trump yesterday for the first time since his victory. Trump, who has leveled heavy tariffs against Canada and even threatened to make it the 51st US state, was much more cordial in this conversation as he said he just wanted to be Canada's friend and praised Carney for his victory. However, Carney did assert again to Trump that his country would never become part.
Mark Carney
Of the US as you know from real estate, there are some places that are never for sale.
President Trump
That's true.
Mark Carney
We're sitting in one right now. You know, Buckingham palace, you visited as well. That's true. And having met with the owners of Canada over the course of the campaign last several months, it's not for sale, won't be for sale ever. But the opportunity is in the partnership and what we can build together.
Shemitah Basu
And finally, one more update on real id, which we talked about on yesterday's show. Yesterday, Homeland Security Secretary Christy Noem said that travelers who have not already gotten their ID will still be able to fly for now with additional security checks. She also said that over 80% of travelers have identification that is compliant with the new federal requirements. The TSA said that if you travel today and don't have a real id, just be prepared to show up a bit earlier to the airport. You can find all these stories and more in the Apple News app. And if you're already listening in the news app right now, we've got a narrated article coming up next, Elle examines a group of women, often referred to as trad wives or traditional wives, that are privately meeting to discuss how trapped some of them feel by the traditional gender roles in their marriage and how they're ready to break out. If you're listening in the podcast app, follow Apple News plus Narrated to find that story. And I'll be back with the news tomorrow.
Apple News Today: Episode Summary – "The 90 Seconds That Shook Air-Traffic Controllers"
Release Date: May 7, 2025
Host: Shemitah Basu
In the spotlight of today’s episode is a harrowing incident that unfolded at Newark Airport last week, where a critical communications failure left air traffic controllers unable to monitor and direct aircraft for approximately 90 seconds. This blackout resulted in a cascade of flight delays and cancellations affecting thousands of travelers.
Incident Details: At [00:51], an audio clip from the air traffic control center captures the chaos:
Air Traffic Controller: "No, you do not have a Bravo clearance. We lost our radar and it's not working correctly... We don't have a radar, so I don't know where you are."
Shemitah Basu introduces the segment by highlighting the immediate aftermath: canceled and delayed flights, with dozens diverted to alternative airports. The disruption stemmed from simultaneous failures of both radar and radio systems, leaving controllers blind to the positions and movements of aircraft.
Expert Insights: Andrew Tangle, an aviation safety and regulation expert from the Wall Street Journal, elaborates on the gravity of the situation at [01:17]:
"They lost their radios and their radars for about 90 seconds, and they couldn't communicate with pilots. It was a very scary situation for the controllers... They keep airplanes safely separated, and without their tools, it raises significant safety issues for the traveling public."
Impact and Aftermath: The technical failure not only endangered lives by obscuring aircraft positions but also severely strained the controllers' ability to manage busy airspace. Although no crashes occurred, the incident has had lasting psychological effects on the controllers. Tangle notes that many have taken trauma leave following the event.
Systemic Issues: Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy attributes the malfunction to "antiquated technology" and has announced a plan to modernize the air traffic system, projected to cost "tens of billions" of dollars [03:36]. This meltdown echoes previous aviation disasters, such as the fatal collision near Reagan National Airport in January, underscoring persistent problems within the industry, including inadequate funding, outdated systems, and staffing shortages.
A Government Accountability Office report from the previous year highlighted that nearly three-quarters of air traffic systems are outdated or too complex to fix. Additionally, the FAA is currently understaffed by about 3,000 fully certified controllers nationwide. This shortage has led to overworked staff, with controllers managing "six day weeks, ten hour days" and experiencing high levels of fatigue and stress [03:36].
Government Response: In response to the staffing crisis, Secretary Duffy has introduced several incentives:
Despite these efforts, the situation at Newark remains precarious. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has called for an investigation [03:56], and the timeline for flights returning to normal schedules remains uncertain.
The episode shifts to a critical analysis of the deteriorating relations between India and Pakistan, two nuclear-armed neighbors embroiled in a severe standoff.
Recent Developments: India initiated a series of strikes into Pakistani-administered Kashmir in retaliation for a militant attack in April that resulted in 26 deaths, predominantly Indian tourists. Pakistan has responded by shooting down Indian jet fighters, heightening the risk of a larger military conflict.
Official Statements: Pakistan’s army spokesperson labeled India’s actions as an "act of war" and vowed not to remain unpunished. In a BBC interview, the spokesperson claimed that the strikes targeted "places of worship" [06:13]. Contrarily, India maintains that its attacks were against "terrorist infrastructure" and were "measured, responsible, and designed to be non-escalatory."
President Trump addressed the situation shortly after the assaults occurred:
President Trump [06:13]: "It's a shame we just heard about it... They’ve been fighting for many, many decades and centuries actually... I just hope it ends very quickly."
International Response: The United States has been actively urging both nations to de-escalate tensions. A spokesperson for the UN Secretary General emphasized that "the world cannot afford a military confrontation between India and Pakistan." This confrontation marks one of the most dangerous escalations between the two countries in recent years, with both sides holding longstanding grievances over the disputed region of Kashmir.
Historical Context: Kashmir has been a flashpoint between India and Pakistan, with previous conflicts in 2016 and 2019 primarily targeting security forces. Pakistan has consistently denied any involvement in militant activities within the region, striving to control tensions before they escalate into full-scale war.
The episode dives into the intricate and secretive process of selecting a new pope, marking the commencement of the conclave [07:00].
Conclave Process: Shemitah Basu explains that the conclave involves cardinal electors from around the globe who gather at the Vatican, take a secrecy oath, and seclude themselves in the Sistine Chapel until a new pontiff is chosen. The term "conclave" originates from the Latin word "with key," signifying their locked-in status [07:00].
Voting Mechanics: Bill Chappell, a correspondent for NPR, details the voting procedure [08:02]:
"The ballots themselves will be secret. It's recommended for cardinals to use a handwriting style that's not necessarily highly identifiable to their own."
Secrecy and Security: Basu highlights the stringent measures to maintain confidentiality, including bug sweeps of the chapel to prevent any recordings from leaking [08:11].
Election Criteria: A two-thirds majority is required from the 135 eligible male electors to elect the new pope. If no candidate achieves this majority, ballots are burned to produce black smoke, signaling to the public that the conclave continues. Conversely, white smoke and the ringing of St. Peter's Basilica’s largest bell denote a successful election, followed by the declaration "Habemus papam" (We have a Pope) [08:31].
Global Representation: This conclave is noted for its diversity, being the least European in its composition to date. Approximately 70 countries are represented, with 17% of the electors hailing from Asia [09:06]. This shift reflects Pope Francis's efforts to globalize the Church, appointing cardinals from underrepresented regions such as Mongolia, Rwanda, Haiti, and Laos [09:32].
Potential Candidates: While various lists circulate speculating on potential popes, observers advise patience, noting that Pope Francis himself was considered an unexpected choice. The true outcome remains to be seen, emphasizing the unpredictability of the conclave [09:54].
The Supreme Court has permitted the Trump administration's ban on transgender individuals serving in the military to take effect. This decision allows the armed forces to discharge current transgender service members and reject new recruits. Despite lower courts previously blocking the ban, the ruling affects approximately 4,200 transgender service members, constituting about 0.2% of the military [09:54].
Mark Carney, Canada’s newly elected Prime Minister, held his first meeting with President Trump. Contrary to recent tensions involving tariffs and Trump's remarks about Canada potentially becoming the "51st US state," the meeting was notably cordial. Carney reaffirmed Canada’s sovereignty, stating:
Mark Carney [11:13]: "Our country would never become part [of the US]... the opportunity is in the partnership and what we can build together."
Trump responded positively, acknowledging Carney’s victory and expressing a desire for friendship between the nations [11:19].
Homeland Security Secretary Christy Noem announced that travelers without a Real ID can still fly, albeit with additional security checks. She emphasized that over 80% of travelers already possess compliant identification. The TSA advised passengers without Real ID to arrive earlier at airports to accommodate the additional screening [11:40].
Shemitah Basu wraps up the episode by previewing upcoming stories, including an in-depth look at "trad wives" and their struggles with traditional gender roles in marriage. Listeners are encouraged to access these stories via the Apple News app or Apple News Plus Narrated podcast.
This comprehensive summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from the "Apple News Today" episode, providing a clear and detailed overview for those who haven't tuned in.