What to know about the government’s new database to track citizens

Summary

Apple News Today: Summary of "What to Know About the Government’s New Database to Track Citizens"
Release Date: July 2, 2025
Host: Shemitha Basu

---

1. Introduction

In the July 2, 2025 episode of Apple News Today, host Shemitha Basu delves into several pressing national issues. The primary focus centers on the government's newly introduced database designed to track U.S. citizens, sparking debates on privacy and legality. Additionally, Basu explores President Trump's initiative to establish the nation's first national citizenship database in California, unexpected amendments to environmental laws, and an inspiring rescue story from a Disney cruise. The episode also touches upon the ongoing legislative battles over President Trump's substantial tax and spending bill.

---

2. House Republicans and the Tax & Spending Bill

The episode opens with a detailed overview of the legislative maneuvers surrounding President Trump's massive tax and spending bill. The Senate's passage of the bill was notably contentious, culminating in Vice President Vance casting the decisive tie-breaking vote after the Senate remained evenly split.

Key Highlights:

• Vice President Vance's Crucial Vote:
  [01:02]
  Vice President Vance: "On this vote, the yeas are 50, the nays are 50. The Senate being evenly divided, the Vice President votes in the affirmative. The bill as amended, is passed."

• Senator Lisa Murkowski's Reservations:
  [02:09]
  Senator Lisa Murkowski: "Do I like this bill? No, because I tried to take care of Alaska's interests. But I know that in many parts of the country there are Americans that are not going to be advantaged by this bill. I don't like that."

Murkowski expressed significant concerns regarding cuts to Medicaid and SNAP food assistance, ultimately voting in favor after securing specific concessions for Alaska, such as allowing whaling captains to write off more expenses. These concessions underscore the challenges House Republicans face in reconciling differing viewpoints within their caucus.

House Republicans' Response:

• Ralph Norman of South Carolina:
  [02:58]
  Ralph Norman: "It is my hope we'll go back to the drawing table and get very close to what we sent the Senate because instead of each individual senator getting a goodie bag and sacrificing the health of this country is an abomination."

• House Speaker Mike Johnson:
  [03:12]
  Speaker Mike Johnson: "The Senate went a little further than many would have preferred."

The House must finalize the legislation by Friday, facing hurdles such as the Senate version being approximately $1 trillion more expensive than the House's original bill passed in May. Concerns also loom over the potential loss of health insurance for millions, potentially undoing Affordable Care Act gains. Additionally, procedural tactics by the Senate to obscure the bill's true cost by categorizing certain tax cuts as non-impacting have added complexity to the House's decision-making process.

Political Implications: With the House narrowly passing their version of the bill in May (215-214), there's minimal room for error. The looming midterm elections add pressure, as Republicans risk losing votes over unpopular provisions like Medicaid cuts and state tax deductions. Delays in passing the final bill could jeopardize the President's Friday, July 4th deadline, especially given senators' early departure from D.C. post-vote, hindering swift reconvening if necessary.

---

3. The Government’s New Database to Track Citizens

A significant portion of the episode examines a controversial new system known as SAVE, which marks a pivotal shift in how the government manages citizen data.

Development of SAVE: Originally designed decades ago to verify the immigration status of non-citizens and determine eligibility for certain benefits, SAVE has recently been expanded by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in collaboration with Elon Musk's Doge team. This expansion transforms SAVE into a tool for local election officials to verify the citizenship status of voters.

Insights from NPR Reporter Jude Jaffe Block:

• Expanding SAVE's Capabilities:
  [05:09]
  Jude Jaffe Block: "The United States has never had a roster of US Citizens before, and this system that's being developed seems to inch us closer than we've ever been before."

• Functionality Overview:
  [05:21]
  Jaffe Block: "It can now query the Social Security Administration data. And so now, for the first time with a Social Security number, state and county election officials with the name and birth date of a voter can go into this system and find out if someone is a citizen. And it's just exclusively for foreign born individuals. It can also confirm citizenship for US Born citizens as well. And that's the real change here."

Driving Forces and Controversies: The move to enhance SAVE was motivated by President Trump and certain Republicans who assert, albeit inaccurately, that non-citizen voter fraud is a significant issue. Despite audits showing minimal instances of such fraud, an executive order in March mandated DHS to provide states with free systems to verify voter rolls.

Concerns Raised:

• Privacy and Legal Issues:
  [07:03]
  Kim Wyman: "It seems like it takes the federal government more than just four months to be able to make a comprehensive national database of information that's going to be accurate."

• Potential for Abuse:
  Privacy advocates and conservatives argue that centralizing personal information poses risks of misuse. Although Kim Wyman acknowledges potential benefits, such as reducing the burden on voters to provide documentation, the lack of public notification about the system's deployment raises legal and ethical questions.

Balancing Benefits and Risks: While most states are currently unable to utilize the expanded capabilities of SAVE, upgrades are anticipated. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem is expected to encourage all state election officials to process their voter rolls through the system. Proponents argue that it simplifies voter verification, potentially increasing electoral integrity, while opponents fear it could lead to invasive government surveillance and disenfranchise voters lacking proper documentation.

---

4. California's Rollback of Environmental Law (CEQA)

In California, significant legislative changes have been enacted to modify the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), a cornerstone of the state's environmental protection framework.

Governor Gavin Newsom's Reforms: Signed into law this week, the reforms aim to streamline the approval process for certain construction projects, thereby addressing the state's housing shortage. Exemptions now apply to specific home and manufacturing constructions, including electric vehicle (EV) plants and high-speed rail projects, removing them from stringent environmental reviews.

Insights from Liam Dhillon of the Los Angeles Times:

• CEQA's Complexity and Impact:
  [09:35]
  Liam Dhillon: "And so it sounds very simple, but when it comes down to how it's actually implemented, it gets very complicated very quickly."

• Historical Context and Reforms:
  [09:41]
  Dhillon: "The CEQA process can involve things like thousands of pages of environmental reports on issues like soil safety, noise, traffic shadows has just become this sort of in many ways kind of super sprawly kind of mess of a process."

Bipartisan Support and Opposition: While the reforms received bipartisan backing, they also faced backlash from environmental groups and some segments of the public. Critics argue that CEQA has been misused to stall essential projects like homeless shelters, food banks, and childcare centers. An illustrative case involved a gas station suing under CEQA to block a competitor, highlighting how environmental regulations can be exploited for business competition.

Governor Newsom's Justification:

• Necessity for Housing Development:
  [11:03]
  Governor Gavin Newsom: "Those six-story apartment complexes that you see popping up in your neighborhood... developers can just go right ahead. It's not just a urban housing project in Berkeley that no longer has to deal with CEQIS rules, but urban housing projects all over the state. And so that's really why people see this as a landmark reform."

These changes are part of a broader movement, influenced by thinkers like Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson, aimed at reducing bureaucratic red tape to facilitate faster housing development and address the affordability crisis.

---

5. Additional Stories

a. University of Pennsylvania's Policy on Transgender Athletes

The University of Pennsylvania has become the first Ivy League institution to comply with the Trump administration’s directives by banning transgender women from competing in women's sports teams. This decision halted a federal investigation and aligned with Title IX interpretations that the Department of Education argues prohibit such participation.

• Impact and Reactions:
  While the policy aims to address alleged disadvantages for cisgender women, it has faced criticism from advocates who argue it marginalizes transgender athletes. The NCAA's shift towards a sport-by-sport policy underscores the evolving landscape of gender and sports.

b. France’s Nationwide Smoking Ban

France has implemented one of the world's most restrictive anti-smoking policies, banning cigarettes in numerous public spaces including parks, beaches, bus stops, swimming pools, and sports venues. However, the ban notably excludes vaping products. This measure aligns with President Emmanuel Macron's vision of fostering a tobacco-free generation by 2032, primarily targeting the protection of children's health in public areas.

c. Disney Cruise Miracle

A heartwarming story emerged from a Disney cruise where a father heroically saved his five-year-old daughter after she went overboard. Witnesses captured the dramatic rescue, highlighting the crew's swift and effective response.

• Eyewitness Account:
  [14:25]
  Ralph Norman: "Oh my God. Thank you."

• Disney's Response:
  Disney commended their crew for ensuring the safe return of the guests, emphasizing the company's commitment to passenger safety.

---

Conclusion

In this episode of Apple News Today, Shemitha Basu provides a comprehensive analysis of significant national and international issues, from legislative battles and privacy concerns to environmental reforms and inspiring rescue stories. The discussion around the government's new citizen-tracking database, in particular, underscores the delicate balance between security measures and individual privacy rights. Meanwhile, California's environmental policy shifts reflect the ongoing tension between development and preservation. Additional stories offer a broad perspective on societal changes and heroic acts, enriching listeners' understanding of current events.

---

For more detailed stories and ongoing coverage, visit the Apple News app.

Transcript

[Shemitha Basu]

Hey there, it's Shemitha. I've got a quick request for you. If Apple News Today is an essential part of your morning routine, follow the show in Apple Podcasts. And if you have another 30 seconds, leave us a rating and a review too. It helps other people find our show and it helps us know what you like about it. Thanks. Good morning. It's Wednesday, July 2nd. I'm Shemitah Basu. This is Apple News Today. On today's show, why Trump wants to build the country's first ever national citizenship database in California, a surprising walk back of environmental law, and a real life miracle on a Disney cruise. But first to Washington, where House Republicans have picked up the debate over President Trump's massive tax and spending bill after a fiercely divided Senate narrowly passed it yesterday.

[Vice President Vance]

On this vote, the yeas are 50, the nays are 50. The Senate being evenly divided, the Vice President votes in the affirmative. The bill as amended, is passed.

[Shemitha Basu]

That's Vice President Vance casting the tie breaking vote, which he had to do after three Republican senators, Susan Collins of Maine, Thom Tillis of North Carolina and Rand Paul of Kentucky voted against the bill, all for very different reasons and along with every single Democrat. Senators spent over 24 hours debating and amending the legislation, voting a record breaking 49 times in all before it passed. Now House Republicans are on the clock to finalize the legislation. The President gave Congress until Friday to deliver a final version of the bill, though he told reporters yesterday that he might be willing to consider an extension. The drawn out debates in the Senate revealed that even some Republicans who voted for the bill had major reservations. Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, who cast the deciding vote, claimed that it was agonizing and told NBC that she only supported it after getting very specific carve outs for her state.

[Lisa Murkowski]

Do I like this bill? No, because I tried to take care of Alaska's interests. But I know that in many parts of the country there are Americans that are not going to be advantaged by this bill. I don't like that.

[Shemitha Basu]

She later said she hoped this bill was not the final product. Murkowski has long expressed concerns about cuts to Medicaid aid and SNAP food assistance in the bill, but still voted for the legislation after she got some assistance for people in Alaska, including a provision that allowed whaling captains in the state to write off more of their expenses. Changes like this are indicative of why House Republicans might find it challenging to hastily pass this bill. Already members like Ralph Norman of South Carolina are saying things like this.

[Ralph Norman]

It is my hope we'll go back to the drawing table and get very close to what we sent the Senate because instead of each individual senator getting a goodie bag and sacrificing the health of this country is an abomination.

[Shemitha Basu]

House Speaker Mike Johnson also said that the Senate went a little further than many would have preferred. What exactly the final version of the bill will include is the big question for the coming days as the House deliberates. Many House lawmakers are not happy about the fact that the Senate version of the bill is roughly $1 trillion more expensive than the House version passed May, and that hundreds of thousands of more Americans would lose health insurance coverage under it. According to nonpartisan estimates and Experts, at least 17 million Americans would eventually lose health care coverage, wiping out many of the gains made by the Affordable Care Act. And other House lawmakers are concerned about the financial move pulled by the Senate that we explained on yesterday's show, how senators obscured the cost of the bill by claiming that extending trillions of dollars of expiring tax cuts does not count toward impact on the federal bud. In May, the House passed their version of the bill 215 to 214, leaving no meaningful margin of error in the days ahead. Republicans can only lose three votes among their caucus. And unlike in the Senate, all House members will have to face midterm elections next year, where Medicaid cuts, state and local tax deductions, and more could be politically consequential. If the House does change the legislation in the coming days, we could see Trump's Friday, July 4th deadline put in jeopardy. That's because the bill would have to go back to the Senate for another vote there. However, as the New York Times reports, most senators promptly left D.C. after voting yesterday, so it could be a challenge to reconvene lawmakers this week if it's needed. Let's turn now to exclusive reporting from NPR on a new tool the administration has rolled out to track citizens of the United States.

[Jude Jaffe Block]

The United States has never had a roster of US Citizens before, and this system that's being developed seems to inch us closer than we've ever been before.

[Shemitha Basu]

To that reporter Jude Jaffe Block told us about this system called save. It was originally built decades ago to check the immigration status of non citizens so local governments could determine if they were eligible for certain benefits. But in recent months, the Department of Homeland Security, in conjunction with Elon Musk's Doge team, expanded SAVE's capabilities to make it a tool for local election officials to check the status of everyone on their voter rolls.

[Jude Jaffe Block]

It can now query the Social Security Administration data. And so now, for the first time with a Social Security number, state and county election officials with the name and birth date of a voter can go into this system and find out if someone is a citizen. And it's just exclusively for foreign born individuals. It can also confirm citizenship for US Born citizens as well. And that's the real change here.

[Shemitha Basu]

The change was driven by President Trump and some Republicans who have made erroneous claims about non citizen voter fraud. Despite the fact that recent audits of voter rolls show instances of noncitizens voting are exceedingly rare, Trump signed an executive order in March instructing DHS to give states access to free systems to verify their voter rol. Election experts told Joffy Block they are wary about how the tool could end up being used given that context, because.

[Jude Jaffe Block]

This seems rooted in talking points about the threat of noncitizens voting. And even though that has been found to only be happening at low levels once there's a lot of data, you can kind of tell a story with data that can be quite misleading.

[Shemitha Basu]

There are also questions about the legality of how these changes to save have been rolled out. Someone who attended a recent DHS briefing told NPR the agency has run more than 9 million voter records through the system already. And Joffy Block says when federal agencies plan to collect or use data in new ways like this, they're supposed to inform the public beforehand.

[Jude Jaffe Block]

We couldn't find evidence of one of those notices. We asked the US Citizenship and Immigration Service and Social Security Administration if they had issued one and we didn't hear back from that.

[Shemitha Basu]

The U.S. citizenship and Immigration Service did, however, confirm to NPR that the tool exists. Centralizing the personal information of Americans in this way has long been considered a political third rail by privacy advocates and conservatives who worry that the information could be abused. Kim Wyman, a former Republican secretary of state for Washington State who now works for the Bipartisan Policy center, shared another concern with npr.

[Lisa Murkowski]

It seems like it takes the federal government more than just four months to be able to make a comprehensive national database of information that's going to be accurate.

[Shemitha Basu]

But Wyman also told NPR she's hopeful this tool could provide some benefits to voters. For years, election officials have pointed out, without a tool like this, it's voters who often bear the responsibility of proving their eligibility by providing a birth certificate or a passport that can risk disenfranchising millions of people who don't have access to those documents for whatever reason. And Wyman says taking that burden of proof off voters is a good thing right now. NPR reports that most states can't use the new save capabilities, but upgrades are coming soon. And sources said Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem is expected to reach out to every state election chief, urging them to run their rolls through the system. Now to California, which has just approved sweeping rollbacks to one of its signature environmental laws. In what's being seen as a major win for the YIMBYs against the NIMBYs and a prioritization of the need to build more housing, the California Environmental Quality act, or ceqa, required builders and developers to disclose study and red the environmental impact of a construction project.

[Liam Dhillon]

And so it sounds very simple, but when it comes down to how it's actually implemented, it gets very complicated very quickly.

[Shemitha Basu]

That's Liam Dhillon with the Los Angeles Times. He says that many see CEQA as responsible for preserving California's natural beauty and scenic vistas, but that its scale and bureaucracy has long drawn criticism.

[Liam Dhillon]

The CEQA process can involve things like thousands of pages of environmental reports on issues like soil safety, noise, traffic shadows has just become this sort of in many ways kind of super sprawly kind of mess of a process.

[Shemitha Basu]

The measures signed into law by Governor Gavin Newsom this week exempt some home and manufacturing construction projects like EV plants and high speed rail from this environmental review. They also make it more difficult to bring environmental lawsuits against developers. They passed with bipartisan support, but it was not without some public opposition and enraged environmental groups. Dylan told us that CEQA had empowered community groups to become involved in developments which can be essential for prioritizing local needs. But that power has also been exploited by some activists and business owners.

[Liam Dhillon]

In one case that I remember, a gas station across the street from a new proposed gas station sued under CEQA to try to stop that gas station from being built. Now they did it under environmental concerns. That was a stated reason, but really it was a business competition issue.

[Shemitha Basu]

But while the LA Times reports that CEQA has stalled projects like homeless shelters, food banks and childcare centers, politicians have long resisted taking it on. As he signed the law, Newsom said the reforms were long overdue. Now it might seem surprising that Democrats in one of the most environmentally friendly states in the US Voted to roll back an environmental protection law. But Dhillon points out that it's part of a broader movement spurred on by journalists Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson and their recent book Abund to reduce Bureaucratic red tape that prevents states from building housing and addressing the affordability crisis.

[Liam Dhillon]

Those six story apartment complexes that you see popping up in your neighborhood. Those buildings are no longer subject to the rules under the California Environmental Quality Act. And so that means that assuming they meet zoning rules and things like that, then developers can just go right ahead. It's not just a urban housing project in Berkeley that no longer has to deal with CEQIS rules, but urban housing projects all over the state. And so that's really why people are this is a landmark reform.

[Shemitha Basu]

Before we let you go, a few other stories we're following. The University of Pennsylvania has agreed to ban transgender women from competing for women's sports teams, putting an end to a federal investigation and making Penn the first Ivy League school to agree to the Trump administration's demands on changes to sports since it started targeting elite institutions. The case focused on Lia Thomas, who became the first openly transgender athlete to win a Division 1 title in swimming in 2022. The Department of Education argued her participation violated Title 9, a 1972 law forbidding sex discrimination in education. And the administration this year paused $175 million in federal funding to Penn, citing Thomas in particular. Her victory drew criticism from some former competitors who said they felt they were, quote, disadvantaged pen apologize to these athletes. At the time, Penn was following NCAA guidelines which allowed trans athletes. Since then, the NCAA has called for a sport by sport approach to its policy going overseas. France said au revoir this week to a vice that the country has long been culturally linked to. A new nationwide ban on smoking is in effect for many public spaces like parks, beaches, bus stops, swimming pools, sports venues and more. Now I should say this law only bans cigarettes, not vapes. Still, it's one of the most restrictive anti smoking policies implemented by any country. The primary goal is to protect the health of children in public spaces. It's the latest move in President Emmanuel Macron's push to create the first tobacco free generation of French residents by 2032. And finally, there was a Disney miracle of a very different kind as a father and his five year old daughter were saved after going overboard on a Disney cruise ship. It's still unclear exactly what happened, but after the girl fell in, her father reportedly jumped in after her and treaded water as they waited for crew to arrive. Morgan Rayner was on the cruise and spoke to ABC.

[Jude Jaffe Block]

All the music stopped.

[Shemitha Basu]

An announcement came on. Mr. Mob, which stands for man overboard. He couldn't get to the life preservers because he was holding on to his daughter. Another cruise goer, Tracy Robinson Hughes, captured it on tape and was clearly in awe of the father.

[Ralph Norman]

Oh my God. Thank you.

[Vice President Vance]

Jesus.

[Liam Dhillon]

What a dad.

[Jude Jaffe Block]

Oh my God.

[Ralph Norman]

That's a dad that needs to have a hero. He's a hero.

[Shemitha Basu]

In their statement, Disney commended their crew for their quick work in the safe return of their guests. You can find all these stories and more in the Apple News app. And if you're already listening in the News app right now, we've got a narrated article coming up next. Bloomberg Businessweek has the story of a mortgage fraud operation out of Canada that led to a shocking murder in suburban Toronto last year. If you're listening in the podcast app, follow Apple News Narrated to find that story. And a quick note before we let you go. Our team is taking the next two days off for the 4th of July holiday, so enjoy your weekend and I'll be back with the news on Monday.