Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard

Episode: Armchair Anonymous: Arrested
Date: September 19, 2025
Co-host: Monica Padman

Overview

In this lively “Armchair Anonymous” episode, Dax Shepard and Monica Padman hear from listeners who share their unforgettable stories about getting arrested. With vulnerability and humor, callers recount wild, embarrassing, and even oddly sweet brushes with the law—ranging from preposterous misunderstandings to ill-fated pranks and moments of personal reckoning. The episode is a celebration of the craziness, unpredictability, and growth that can emerge from life’s messiest setbacks.

Key Stories & Insights

1. Jackie’s Teenage Cab Ride from Hell

[02:56 – 13:44]

The Story

• Setting: Suburban Toronto, Ontario, 2008. Jackie (pseudonym from her first fake ID) is 16, with her boyfriend and his friend; they’re at a house party in a newly bought, empty house.
• After midnight, they responsibly choose a cab (minivan) to get home.
• The cab driver suddenly locks the doors and demands $200 cash, threatening to turn them in for underage drinking.
• With child locks engaged, panic ensues; at a red light, the boys attack the driver, doors open, and they scatter.
• Jackie runs to a park and calls her brother.
• As she reconnects with her brother, police pull up, cuff, and arrest her.

Notable Quotes

• “The cab driver goes, you need to pay me $200 cash right now, or I’m driving you to the police station and turning you in for underage drinking.” (Jackie, [05:02])
• “The friend sitting in the front seat, his door couldn’t have been child locked. But it’s a moving vehicle... it’s escalating into panic.” (Jackie, [05:51])
• “I did. I was a snitch... just word vomit.” (Jackie, reflecting on telling police everything, [08:31])
• Dax: “This guy’s got like three felonies: blackmail, and now abduction.” ([05:47])
• Monica: “That feels illegal.” ([05:25])

What Happened

• The cabbie accuses them of theft and assault in a dramatic police report. Jackie is released; the two boys receive probation, community service, and curfew. Jackie’s parents are mostly relieved.
• Jackie’s trust in cabs is gone: “I will say, to this day, I don’t love a cab. When rideshare came along... all the safety features, I was for that.” ([12:48])

2. David’s Toy Gun Prank Gone Wrong

[13:47 – 27:02]

The Story

• Setting: Issaquah, Washington, 1998. David and his friend Carl, both high school juniors, are bored on a Sunday drive.
• A car tailgates them. Trying to be funny, David pretends to hold Carl hostage with a toy cap gun, visible to the car behind.
• They think the prank’s over, park at Future Shop, and joke with friends.
• Moments later, multiple police cars surround the area: “There’s a lot of police outside.” (David, [15:52])
• The boys are followed, then boxed in at a park-and-ride. Armed officers—guns drawn—arrest them at gunpoint.

Notable Quotes

• Dax: “Doors open, their guns are drawn, lights are on, there’s somebody on a bullhorn giving instructions.” ([20:23])
• “You could have gotten your head blown off, pointing at me.” (Police sergeant, relayed by David, [23:07])
• Monica (reading newspaper): “Police were alerted to a hostage situation... turned out to be the work of two teen pranksters.” ([25:50])

What Happened

• The police confirm it was a prank with a toy gun and let them go after multiple attempts to reach their parents.
• The story makes the local paper, reappears at David’s wedding a decade later, and remains a “classic tale.”
• David later reflects on privilege: “If we were not where we were and who we were, that could have ended very differently.” ([25:07])

3. Laura’s One-and-Only Wild Arrest

[27:25 – 43:12]

The Story

• Setting: University of South Carolina, early 2010s. Laura, a “good girl” out of high school trouble, finds herself at a party, smoking weed with a new romantic interest.
• The party is raided. While trying to discreetly ditch her tiny stash, she’s caught by the police.
• Handcuffed and separated, she’s grouped with intoxicated peers.
• The processing involves a comedy of errors: fake IDs, a charming but dubious jail officer who leaves her his number, and the sobering realization she can’t contact family.

Notable Quotes

• “She just starts going nuts, and I’m so stoned... I was immediately resigned... it is what it is.” (Laura, [31:41])
• “So I write the phone number down... they’re like, you can’t call long-distance, and at that point, I sober up and lose it.” ([37:21])
• “Pretty sure someone at the jail stole my identity... paid a $300 water bill.” ([40:57])

What Happened

• Her bank account is drained after her stay in jail, likely by jail staff.
• She chooses community service over expensive expungement fees: “I just looked at the judge and was like, I’m not paying for that. Someone working for you stole all of my money...” ([41:03])
• She waits on the arresting officer at her restaurant job weeks later.
• Laura: “I left the day after I graduated and I’ve never stepped foot in Columbia again.” ([42:33])

4. Dan & Sarah: Arrested on the Wedding Day

[43:21 – 54:20]

The Story

• Setting: Provo, Utah, early 2000s. On their wedding day—with Sarah pregnant—the couple is preparing for a backyard ceremony.
• Dan answers the door to a plainclothes officer, who, after verifying his identity, arrests him for “absconding from probation” for a past (minor) marijuana charge.
• The arrest is poorly timed: “I’m getting married an hour from now!” (Dan, [45:50])
• With quick intervention by family, a judge allows Dan out of jail for one hour—attended by a sheriff (his impromptu best man)—to get married.
• Ceremony proceeds with Dan in a tuxedo, but under escort, and the emotional toll is high. After vows and a quick kiss, Dan is whisked back to jail for two months.

Notable Quotes

• “The saddest wedding pictures you’ll ever see.” (Sarah, [49:20])
• “Came back, they’re like, did you consummate your marriage? I’m like, well, she’s pregnant, I think we’re good there.” (Dan, [54:00])
• “I was so relieved... I thought he left me at the altar. Thank God he was arrested.” (Sarah, [49:44])
• Dax: “What a fucking waste of money. There’s so many other fallouts from it, but just what a waste. Some manpower.” ([52:20])
• Monica: “This whole thing... from beginning to end is just an absolute disaster.” ([51:36])

What Happened

• Dan serves two months in jail directly after the wedding.
• The couple’s reception is awkward; Sarah leaves to be with friends instead.
• They eventually get their late honeymoon and are still together 25 years later: “That’s how I knew she was a keeper.” (Dan, [52:56])
• Dax and Monica dub it the most unexpectedly romantic—and disastrous—wedding story.

Highlights & Memorable Moments

• Privilege and Perspective: Several callers reflect on how their backgrounds affected the outcomes, as in David’s story: "We were probably pretty privileged in this situation."
• Coping with Authority: Multiple guests recall their naivety and blind trust in police, like Jackie flooding the cops with information or Laura’s resigned “good girl” compliance.
• Systemic Flaws: Both Laura and Dan’s stories highlight the arbitrary, sometimes corrupt nature of enforcement, from stolen identities to major jail time for marijuana.
• Comic Relief & Humanity: Despite trauma or embarrassment, humor abounds—whether it’s friends reading old news clippings, tough dads giving warnings, or Dax riffing on every twist.
• Resilience: Ultimately, each storyteller survives their ordeal—wiser, scarred, but often with a good story for the ages.

Episode Timestamps & Segments

• [02:56] “Jackie” talks teen cab kidnapping, panic and escape, then police overreaction.
• [13:47] “David” recounts how a toy-gun prank leads to a surreal, gunpoint arrest.
• [27:25] “Laura” describes her first (and only) arrest: weed, fake IDs, jail romance(?), and identity theft.
• [43:21] Dan & Sarah deliver an epic “wedding day arrest” saga—true love wins out over law and logistics.

Notable Quotes (by Timestamp & Speaker)

• Jackie: “The cab pulls out of the driveway and the doors lock... you need to pay me $200 or I’m driving you to the police station.” ([05:02])
• Monica: “That feels illegal.” ([05:25])
• David: “Doors open, their guns are drawn, lights are on, someone’s on a bullhorn...” ([20:23])
• Sgt. to David: “You could have gotten your head blown off.” ([23:07])
• Laura: “I was immediately resigned to, like, this is how my night’s gonna go. It is what it is.” ([31:41])
• Dan: “I’m getting married in an hour!” ([45:50])
• Sarah: “Honestly, I was so relieved. I thought he left me at the altar. Thank God he was arrested.” ([49:44])

Final Reflections

Dax and Monica celebrate the vulnerability and honesty of their callers (“Great job, everyone. Try not to get arrested. Love you.” [54:47]), highlighting the absurdity and randomness of getting in trouble—and the power of a good story to transform chaos into laughter, perspective, and (often hard-won) wisdom.