Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Episode Summary: Armchair Anonymous: Bad Proposals
Release Date: February 14, 2025
Host: Randall Shepherd and Monica Lilly
Introduction: Setting the Stage for Bad Proposals
The episode opens with Randall Shepherd and Monica Lilly introducing the theme of "bad proposals," framing it as a series of stories where well-intentioned marriage proposals take unexpected and often disastrous turns. The hosts express both amusement and empathy as they prepare listeners for the chaotic proposals shared by their guests.
Monica Lilly:
"Yes, it was meant to pair up a little bit... Happy Valentine's Day."
[00:47]
Cole's Proposal Gone Wrong
Guest: Cole, a chemical engineer from Billings, Montana, shares his tumultuous proposal experience.
The Perfect Plan Falls Apart
Cole recounts his meticulously planned proposal, intended to occur on New Year's Eve during a ski trip to Park City. He describes his efforts to keep the engagement ring a secret by sending it to his parents' house for safekeeping. However, unforeseen logistical challenges arise, leading him to scramble to retrieve the ring without his fiancée discovering his plans.
Cole:
"We are supported by Tropical Smoothie Cafe... Prepare for love at first sip."
[02:28] (Note: This timestamp appears to be part of an advertisement and is likely misplaced in the transcript.)
Technical Troubles and Miscommunication
As Cole attempts to set up a camera to record the proposal, technical issues plague his efforts. A deceptive phone call offers him a fraudulent solution, adding to his stress. Despite these setbacks, he proceeds with the proposal, which initially elicits a hesitant response from his fiancée.
Cole:
"Wait, aren't you glad that you screwed it up yesterday?"
[12:25]
The Snow Drift Incident
Seeking redemption after the rocky proposal, Cole organizes a hiking trip. However, his decision to speed up his Honda Accord leads to the vehicle becoming stuck in a snow drift. Stranded in freezing temperatures with limited supplies, the silence grows tense until Cole's fiancée comments on the mishaps.
Cole:
"We got married on December 29th. Just celebrated our first year of marriage."
[12:59]
Randall Shepherd:
"Cole, do you recognize? You're an interesting mix of brilliant as hell and dumb as fuck."
[11:25]
Despite the chaotic start, Cole and his fiancée celebrate their first year of marriage, reflecting on the challenges they overcame together.
Olivia's Harrowing Proposal Experience
Guest: Olivia from Las Vegas recounts a harrowing proposal that turns into a life-threatening robbery.
Ambitious Plans Under Strain
Olivia and her boyfriend, who had been together since high school, decide to get engaged amidst personal and professional pressures. Olivia describes her boyfriend's intense planning to create an elaborate proposal, aiming to impress with a memorable experience.
Olivia:
"We were going to move back home... got really rough."
[38:18]
The Robbery Turned Shootout
At the jeweler's store, just as Olivia is about to receive the engagement ring, two armed robbers burst in. What was supposed to be a joyous moment devolves into chaos as the situation escalates quickly. One robber threatens her while the other begins a shootout, resulting in Olivia being accidentally shot.
Olivia:
"I was looking at your phone location because you just stormed out of the house... thinking maybe I need to work on my anger because of this."
[48:10]
Randall Shepherd:
"Do you resentful at the jeweler for escalating it to a gun battle?"
[49:50]
Aftermath and Reflection
Miraculously surviving the ordeal, Olivia reflects on the trauma and the emotional scars it left. Despite the severity of what happened, she expresses no bitterness towards the robbers, acknowledging the surreal nature of the event. The episode highlights her resilience and the enduring bond between her and her wife, who stayed by her side through the ordeal.
Olivia:
"I think overall I'm just glad I'm alive... I'm still not gonna even get close to that. I'm good."
[50:26]
Additional Stories: Jessica and Rob
Jessica's Story:
While Jessica's detailed narrative is less prominent in the transcript, she briefly shares her experience, which involves a humorous twist during a proposal setup, showcasing the unpredictable nature of such events.
Rob's Story:
Rob discusses a failed proposal attempt that involved an intense mountain hike, illustrating the lengths some individuals go to create the "perfect" moment, often ignoring their partners' comfort and desires.
Insights and Takeaways
Throughout the episode, the guests' stories underscore the unpredictability of proposals and the importance of considering the other person's feelings and circumstances. The hosts and guests reflect on lessons learned, emphasizing that even well-intentioned plans can go awry, highlighting the need for flexibility and genuine communication in relationships.
Rob:
"The big lesson is if you don't listen in life, it gets bigger and bigger... life forces you to change."
[31:28]
Monica Lilly:
"Love that."
[51:12]
Conclusion: Embracing Imperfection in Love
The episode concludes with reflections on the shared experiences of the guests, celebrating their resilience and the love that ultimately prevailed despite the disastrous proposals. The stories serve as a testament to the unpredictability of life and love, reminding listeners that imperfections often lead to the most memorable and meaningful moments.
Randall Shepherd:
"It's memorable for sure."
[32:23]
Notable Quotes
-
Cole:
"If that's what he was trying to say? I powered through it."
[10:22] -
Olivia:
"Everyone makes a joke. It's like a blood diamond... I had to go, yeah."
[51:09] -
Randall Shepherd:
"You're the first person we've talked to who's been shot."
[52:36]
Final Thoughts
"Armchair Anonymous: Bad Proposals" delves into the complexities and unexpected turns that can accompany marriage proposals. Through candid storytelling and heartfelt reflections, the episode highlights the importance of authenticity and adaptability in relationships, offering listeners both entertainment and valuable insights into the human experience of love and commitment.
Follow Armchair Expert:
Join Armchair Expert on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. For early and ad-free access, consider subscribing to Wondery+ via the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial at wondery.com/links/armchair-expert-with-dax-shepard/ now.