Are we building homes like we used to? That’s the million-dollar question Eric G and co-host John Dudley dive into, and trust me, it’s juicier than a ripe peach on a summer day! They kick off by exploring the nostalgic charm of old homes versus the cookie-cutter vibes of new builds, debating whether modern engineering has really upgraded our living spaces or if we’re just trading craftsmanship for speed. Spoiler alert: It's a mixed bag! They also tackle the age-old debate of old growth versus new growth lumber, dissecting whether the lumber of yesteryears truly outshines today’s tech-savvy alternatives. So grab your headphones, kick back, and join us for a lively chat that’s part history lesson, part construction critique, and all-around fun! Eric G and John Dudley kick off their podcast episode by plunging into a hot topic: the age-old question of whether homes today are built like they used to be. With the charm of a casual chat, they dissect the statement, “They don’t build them like they used to,” navigating through the nostalgia of classic homes and the realities of modern construction. Eric, a self-proclaimed lover of vintage homes, waxes poetic about the intricate craftsmanship and unique character that older houses possess. However, he quickly balances this affection with the practicality of modern engineering, arguing that while aesthetics were paramount in the past, today’s homes are built with a focus on safety, durability, and structural integrity that often wasn't a priority back in the day. Transitioning to the great lumber debate, Eric and John delve into the merits of old growth versus new growth lumber. Eric playfully challenges the notion that older timber is always superior, explaining how advancements in engineered materials have revolutionized construction. He sheds light on how modern engineering techniques ensure that new homes can withstand the test of time, providing a level of safety that older homes often lack. John adds a humorous touch, recalling his own experiences with older homes that, while beautiful, sometimes feel like they were built with a mix of sheer luck and questionable materials. Their banter is both entertaining and informative, as they explore how the materials and methods of construction have evolved, leading to a better understanding of what truly makes a home resilient. Wrapping up the first hour, Eric and John remind listeners that whether you’re a fan of the vintage charm or the sleek functionality of modern homes, the key takeaway is understanding what goes into the making of a house. They advocate for thorough inspections and informed decisions in home buying and renovations, emphasizing that in today's fast-paced construction environment, it’s crucial to know what you’re getting into. With a blend of humor and insightful commentary, they leave their audience pondering the complexities of home construction and the legacy of craftsmanship, ensuring that the conversation continues beyond the podcast.

Takeaways:

In the podcast, Eric G and John Dudley discuss the age-old debate about whether homes are built better today than in the past, and the conversation is rich with insights and a good dose of humor.
They tackle the topic of old growth versus new growth lumber, highlighting how technology has improved home building, yet nostalgia for craftsmanship remains strong.
One key insight is that while old homes may have charm, modern engineering ensures new houses are structurally sound and built to withstand the elements much better than their predecessors.
The co-hosts cleverly point out that the materials used in construction have evolved, leading to stronger homes, but sometimes at the cost of long-term durability due to cheaper alternatives.
Listeners are reminded that while building codes have improved, execution can vary widely, resulting in some new homes built with questionable practices that would make older builders cringe.
Ultimately, the episode emphasizes the balance between appreciating the craftsmanship of older homes and recognizing the advancements in safety and efficiency that modern techniques bring to today’s construction.

Links referenced in this episode:

Companies mentioned in this episode:

Red Wing
Panasonic
Simpson

Thanks for listening to Around the house if you want to hear more please subscribe so you get notified of the latest episode as it posts at https://around-the-house-with-e.captivate.fm/listen

If you want to join the Around the House Insider for access to the back catalog, Exclusive Content and a direct email to Eric G and access to the show early https://around-the-house-with-e.captivate.fm/support

We love comments and we would love reviews on how this information has helped you on your house! Thanks for listening! For more information about the show head to https://aroundthehouseonline.com/

Information given on the Around the House Show should not be considered construction or design advice for your specific project, nor is it intended to replace consulting at your home or jobsite by a building professional. The views and opinions expressed by those interviewed on the podcast are those of the guests and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of the Around the House Show.

Mentioned in this episode:

Subscribe to the podcast

Make sure and Subscribe on your favorite podcast player or the link below!

Podcast Subscribe 2026

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel to see every part of the project for Blacktail Ranch

Exciting collaboration alert! This playlist documents our joint project renovating Cam Anderson's new farm property on Blacktail Ranch—the home base for his adventures beyond the workshop. Cam (the woodworking wizard behind Blacktail Studio, with millions of fans loving his epoxy tables, live-edge builds, and creative furniture tutorials) is stepping into brand-new territory: his first-ever full home renovation and remodel. From the charming (but dated) farmhouse with its "lead paint chic" vibes to tackling structural updates, layout changes, and modern upgrades, we're transforming this 17-acre property into a functional, beautiful living space. I'm Eric G from Around the House, bringing my remodeling, construction, and design expertise to guide the process—planning layouts, solving real-world renovation challenges, handling the practical home improvement side, and making sure the build is smart, efficient, and homeowner-friendly. Expect step-by-step progress, honest discussions on budgets/timelines/hiccups, tool tips, design decisions, and the fun dynamic of blending Cam's woodworking flair with pro remodeling know-how. Whether you're a Blacktail Studio fan curious about Cam's new chapter, a DIYer tackling your own home reno, or just love watching big transformations, this series is for you! https://www.youtube.com/@aroundthehouseEricG/playlists

Blacktail Ranch

Take a second and leave us a review on your favorite podcast player!

Quick favor—if you're enjoying the show, the absolute best way you can support us is by leaving a quick review on your favorite podcast player.

Check out our nearly 1900 episode back catalog

If your podcast player doesnt support a large catalog of episodes. Click this link to listen to them all for free!

Around the House Back Catalog

Check out our New YouTube channel @AroundtheHouse HQ

Make sure you subscribe and RING THE BELL for our brand new channel with 4k content! Click the link to take you there!

YouTube Around the House HQ

InstaBid: Stop losing jobs to slow estimates

Turn 3 hours of manual estimating into 5 minutes. Real material prices. Real labor rates. Professional PDF quotes delivered instantly. Try it free at instabid.pro. Use code ATH50 for 50% off your first month. That's instabid.pro — code ATH50

Instabid<...

Old Homes vs. New Builds: Are We Doing It Wrong?