Book Riot - The Podcast: Episode Summary Episode: The It Books of March 2025
Release Date: March 5, 2025
Hosts: Jeff O'Neill & Rebecca Schinsky
Description: Jeff O'Neill and Rebecca Schinsky delve into the latest and most anticipated book releases of March 2025, discussing a diverse range of genres, authors, and publishing trends. This episode highlights key new titles, provides insightful commentary, and includes notable quotes from the hosts to guide listeners through their curated selections.

Introduction

The episode begins with a brief acknowledgment of a slower start to the year in terms of standout book releases. Jeff and Rebecca express anticipation for the March lineup, hinting at a selection of intriguing and potentially game-changing titles.

Jeff (00:50): "Been a slow start to the year... but March we get some interesting stuff happening."

Rebecca (01:42): "March is when it starts to heat up for sure a little bit here."

Book Selection Process

Jeff explains the methodology behind selecting the "Book of the Month," emphasizing the need for a combination of sales, literary quality, and cultural relevance.

Jeff (02:27): "It's the book of the month and we define that as having multiple things that could make it the book that matters the most... It has to have a little bit of all those things going on at the same time."

Rebecca (02:35): "One of the Four Bells is not enough on its own to get you to book. You've got to read ring two or three or ideally four."

Featured Books of March 2025

1. Harriet Tubman Live in Concert by Bob the Drag Queen

Release Date: March 25
Publisher: Gallery Books
Pages: 240

Jeff introduces this innovative title blending historical fiction with modern elements, noting its unique reading experience.

Jeff (04:02): "It's a knockout. Got a star review from Publishers Weekly... Harriet Tubman... comes back Bill and Ted style into the present."

Rebecca shares her excitement and high expectations, highlighting early positive reviews and the book's entertaining approach to serious themes.

Rebecca (04:35): "If I had not already read rave reviews of it, I would be saying it's either going to be amazing or terrible... My expectations are high."

Decision: Rebecca advocates advancing this title due to its strong reception and unique premise.

Rebecca (07:13): "I think it's going to do quite well. This has been on all of the, you know, most anticipated books of the year lists."

2. Stag Dance by Torrey Peters

Release Date: March 11
Publisher: Torrey Peters
Pages: 304

The conversation shifts to Torrey Peters' latest work, a novel paired with two short stories exploring themes of gender identity and personal transformation.

Jeff (06:12): "A novel and three stories... a group of restless lumberjacks... turns dark when a young crossroad must choose between two guides."

Rebecca expresses reservations about the packaging but acknowledges the potential impact based on Peters' previous success.

Rebecca (07:12): "It's very unusual as a packaging proposition... but this sounds really great."

Decision: Both hosts decide to pass on this title for the current selection.

3. Buffalo Hunter by Stephen Graham Jones

Release Date: March 18
Publisher: Saga Press
Pages: 448
Genre: Horror

Jeff presents this Indian revenge story, praising Jones' mastery in the horror genre.

Jeff (09:06): "An Indian revenge story written by a master of horror, Stephen Graham Jones."

Rebecca discusses the book's appeal within the horror community while noting its limited crossover appeal to mainstream literary readers.

Rebecca (10:22): "Horror is really big right now... But there's also, like, a real resistance to horror from another set of literary readers."

Decision: Rebecca chooses to keep "Harriet Tubman Live in Concert" over "Buffalo Hunter" due to broader headline potential.

4. Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaughey

Release Date: March 4
Publisher: Flat Iron
Pages: 250,000 print run
Genre: Literary Fiction with Climate Themes

Charlotte McConaughey returns with a family drama set against climate concerns, resonating with current environmental discourse.

Jeff (11:29): "A family on a remote island. A mysterious woman washes ashore... She's getting ready to have a baby."

Rebecca underscores McConaughey's consistent focus on climate and her strong readership, predicting high sales and book club interest.

Rebecca (12:37): "She's consistently concerned with climate in a literary fiction sort of way. That's really, you know, in the reading water right now."

Decision: Rebecca opts to advance "Wild Dark Shore" for its timely themes and author reputation.

5. This is Tuberculosis by John Green

Release Date: March 18
Publisher: Crash Course Books (Random House)
Pages: 208
Genre: Nonfiction/Narrative

John Green ventures into a non-fiction narrative exploring tuberculosis, blending personal storytelling with historical context.

Jeff (15:17): "It's structured around this kid that he met in 2019 who had tuberculosis... telling this kid's story, but then building a larger history."

Rebecca critiques the book's niche appeal and questions its broader market viability compared to Green's previous works.

Rebecca (16:07): "I want to read a book about tuberculosis by like a tuberculosis expert... I don't need that in my nonfiction."

Decision: Jeff includes it in the selection, though Rebecca remains skeptical about its mass appeal.

6. Tilt by Emma Petit

Release Date: March 25
Publisher: Mary Sue Rucci Books
Pages: 240
Genre: Disaster Fiction

"Tilt" narrates the life of a woman facing personal and natural disasters within a single day in Portland.

Jeff (23:57): "It's about something and just really well measured. I was really impressed."

Rebecca anticipates strong word-of-mouth potential and buzz among readers, though she acknowledges it may not compete with more established titles.

Rebecca (24:45): "Tilt could do like, maybe it does get a big book club selection."

Decision: While impressed, Rebecca prioritizes advancing "The Dream Hotel" over "Tilt."

7. The River has Roots by Amal Elmho Tar

Publisher: Tor.com
Pages: 144
Genre: Fantasy

Amal Elmho Tar's novella explores a sisterly bond intertwined with magical stewardship of a river, blending fantasy elements with familial ties.

Jeff (26:14): "Two sisters... have to take care of a river on the edge of fairy wood... weird fantasy."

Rebecca raises concerns about the novella's pricing and marketability outside genre enthusiasts.

Rebecca (27:22): "$24.99 for a 144 page book is a tough sell... the general reading public... that's a tough sell."

Decision: Both hosts decide to pass on this novella due to cost and limited appeal.

8. Sunrise on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins

Release Date: March 18
Publisher: Scholastic Press
Genre: Dystopian Fiction (Hunger Games Series Prequel)

Suzanne Collins expands her iconic Hunger Games universe with a prequel focusing on protagonist Haymitch Abernathy's earlier years.

Jeff (29:32): "Haymitch Abernathy's Hunger Games... a new installment of one of the five grand franchises."

Rebecca concurs on the title's commercial strength but questions its literary impact.

Rebecca (31:24): "Songbirds and Snakes sold. It's a new installment of one of the five grand franchises... it's going to sell a million copies."

Decision: Jeff advocates advancing this high-profile franchise addition despite personal reservations.

9. The Dream Hotel by Leila Lalami

Publisher: Pantheon
Genre: Speculative Fiction

Leila Lalami's "The Dream Hotel" blends literary fiction with speculative elements, crafting a narrative that intertwines personal stories within a broader societal context.

Jeff (34:28): "The phrase prairie witch is in the description... could rope in."

Rebecca emphasizes the book's literary merit and potential for awards, making it a strong contender.

Rebecca (35:15): "Bookiness, like literary genre, excellent writing... it could sell. It could win awards. It could get picked for a book club."

Decision: Both hosts conclude that "The Dream Hotel" deserves the title of Book of the Month, acknowledging its literary strength and broad appeal.

Final Selections and Recommendations

After a thorough discussion, Jeff and Rebecca finalize their top picks for March 2025:

1. Harriet Tubman Live in Concert by Bob the Drag Queen – Selected for its unique narrative and strong early reviews.

2. Wild Dark Shore by Charlotte McConaughey – Chosen for its relevant climate themes and author's established reputation.

3. The Dream Hotel by Leila Lalami – Advanced as the Book of the Month due to its literary excellence and award potential.

Though several other titles were considered, including entries by John Green and Suzanne Collins, the hosts prioritize books that not only promise commercial success but also literary depth and cultural significance.

Listener Engagement and Future Episodes

Jeff and Rebecca encourage listeners to engage with the podcast through various platforms, sharing their thoughts and reactions to the selected books. They tease upcoming content and events, aiming to build a community around shared literary interests.

Jeff (33:05): "We should do a power ranking of the extant franchises right now."

Rebecca (40:05): "Send us a voice memo to... We call them text memos. They're called words. Write them."

Conclusion

This episode of Book Riot - The Podcast offers a comprehensive overview of March 2025's book landscape, highlighting standout titles across genres. Jeff and Rebecca provide insightful commentary, balancing personal preferences with broader market trends, ultimately spotlighting "The Dream Hotel" as the must-read book of the month. Listeners are left with a clear understanding of the upcoming releases and the reasoning behind each selection, catering both to dedicated readers and those seeking their next great read.

Notable Quotes:

• Jeff (00:50): "Been a slow start to the year... but March we get some interesting stuff happening."

• Rebecca (04:35): "If I had not already read rave reviews of it, I would be saying it's either going to be amazing or terrible."

• Jeff (09:06): "An Indian revenge story written by a master of horror, Stephen Graham Jones."

• Rebecca (35:15): "She could sell more than Bob the Drag Queen. And there's book club selection potential."

For more details and to listen to the full episode, visit Book Riot Podcast and explore their diverse range of media offerings tailored for passionate readers across all genres.