Book Riot – The Podcast
Episode: The IT Books of May 2026
Hosts: Jeff O’Neal & Rebecca Schinsky
Release Date: May 6, 2026
Episode Overview
In this lively episode, Jeff and Rebecca walk listeners through the “IT Books” of May 2026, highlighting the most buzzworthy, anticipated, and conversation-worthy books scheduled for release this month. Following their signature knockout-style format, Jeff presents ten new releases, which Rebecca assesses round by round until one title is crowned as May’s “IT Book”—the release that best blends critical acclaim, cultural relevance, sales potential, and ineffable buzz. The episode shines a light on shifting literary discourse, big-name returns, genre phenomena, speculative debuts, and why essay collections rarely snag the “IT” crown.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
The “IT Book” Format: Criteria and Process
- Purpose: Predict rather than crown post-facto; aiming for the book most likely to hit all the key notes in today’s literary landscape.
- Books are evaluated for:
- Critical acclaim
- Cultural & zeitgeist relevance
- Sales potential and track record
- The elusive “je ne sais quoi”
- Book club and award potential
- Titles like major “romantasy” juggernauts or blockbusters are excluded if they’re automatic sales monsters; the focus is on books vying for crossover and critical resonance.
"You gotta ring multiple bells to be the IT Book of the Month." – Rebecca (05:24)
Main Segment: Book-by-Book Knockout
1. The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett
(00:10:25 – 00:19:42)
- Context: Stockett’s return 17 years after her divisive mega-hit The Help.
- Discourse: Hosts discuss The Help as an artifact of its time, now seen as problematic due to its white savior narrative and the evolved conversation around “own voices” in fiction.
- Buzz: Publisher switched, lower print run (250k), some critical “backhanded compliments” in reviews, 650 page length flagged as a hurdle, and doubts about broad book club adoption.
“...kind of a time capsule of the olden days … an artifact before the Internet—before own-voices discourse really kicked up.” – Rebecca (11:29)
“Can you get the Lessons in Chemistry crowd, the Where the Crawdads Sing crowd, just good story folk? Because you can sell plenty of books.” – Jeff (18:32)
Verdict: Not enough to unseat later contenders, but worthy of conversation.
2. John of John by Douglas Stuart
(00:19:44 – 00:26:43)
- Highlights:
- Latest by Booker-winning author (Shuggie Bain), current Oprah Book Club pick.
- Set in small-town Scotland; themes of family, secrets, and sexuality.
- Safe for literary readers, but Oprah’s pick means likely crossover to mainstream and serious award potential.
“Oprah has gone for it … not in such a literary zone that it will feel intimidating or difficult for a more commercial reader.” – Rebecca (21:58)
“Ann Patchett blurb on the front, Oprah sticker. Can’t ask for much more for a crossover upmarket literary-commercial title.” – Jeff (22:43)
Verdict: Vaults to the top; advances through several rounds.
3. The Things We Never Say by Elizabeth Strout
(00:22:43 – 00:25:47)
- Standalone (outside Strout’s known universe), “poignant meditation on loneliness, friendship, and parenthood.”
- Discussed as almost an “emeritus” literary force; reliable and acclaimed, but less likely to break into new readership.
“Elizabeth Strout’s … for better or worse, is pretty carved out. Folks are in the camp if they’re gonna read her.” – Rebecca (25:24)
Verdict: Strout’s new book gets edged out by John of John for both cultural currency and growth potential.
4. One Leg on Earth by Pemi Aguda
(00:27:04 – 00:30:59)
- Debut novel from acclaimed story collection (Ghost Roots).
- Eerie, fable-esque, speculative; pregnant women mysteriously drawn to water in Lagos.
- Literary, high-concept, atmospheric, but challenging and not especially “book club” friendly.
“It’s a difficult read. The language is … literary.” – Rebecca (29:42)
Verdict: Loved but not likely to have the broad commercial impact of John of John.
5. The Midnight Train by Matt Haig
(00:31:24 – 00:33:51)
- Attempt to recreate the massive success of The Midnight Library (feel-good, speculative, sentimental).
- Anticipated to sell very well but seen as more a repeat than a new peak.
“I did not love The Midnight Library … a feel-good nostalgic spec fic is a pretty good recipe to sell some books.” – Jeff (32:17)
Verdict: Popularity acknowledged but doesn’t rise above Stewart’s literary-crossover blend.
6. Happy-Go-Lucky: The Land and Its People by David Sedaris
(00:34:03 – 00:36:27)
- Consistently best-selling essayist; new collection, now with more about his partner Hugh.
- Achieves “IT Book Emeritus” status—so reliable and successful that it no longer breaks new ground; better experienced in audio.
“David Sedaris is so consistently great at what he does … but the window of what he does is pretty narrow.” – Jeff (34:35)
“Every dad in the country is getting David Sedaris for Father’s Day.” – Rebecca (35:50)
Verdict: Admired, beloved, but doesn’t fit the “IT Book” mold.
7. Vincent, You Seek Immediate Shelter by ??? (Debut Novelist)
(00:37:22 – 00:41:19)
- Asian American community in Massachusetts faces a false missile threat; social reckoning follows.
- Great premise and high debut print run; poised more for adaptation than breakout literary status.
“Debut novels need as much shine as they can get … Who knows? It’s a great premise. If it’s executed well, you have a high ceiling …” – Rebecca (38:44)
Verdict: Cheered for, discussed as a possible “debut play-in” candidate in future.
8. On Witness and Respair by Jesmyn Ward
(00:41:19 – 00:43:47)
- Essay collection by two-time National Book Award winner.
- More literary/lit-critical; hosts lament that essays rarely become “IT Books.”
“An essay collection by a two-time National Book Award winner…It’s not gonna sell a jillion copies, but I think we’re talking about awards, nominations, … best of the year lists.” – Rebecca (42:20)
“What essay collection…has ever won this? It just doesn’t happen.” – Jeff (43:08)
Verdict: Deep respect, but format is inherently limiting for this exercise.
9. Parade of Horribles (Dungeon Crawler Carl #8) by Matt Dinniman
(00:44:47 – 00:47:43)
- Genre juggernaut in the “litRPG” category; eighth in a surging, now-mainstream series.
- Fun, whimsical, and growing, but “Emeritus” candidate—success is largely confined to its genre world.
“Millions of people are reading these books … unlikely to ring bells beyond sales.” – Rebecca (45:46)
Verdict: Incredible within its own lane, but doesn’t break out for broader mainstream/critical recognition.
10. Mostly Hero by Anna Burns
(00:48:12 – 00:50:12)
- Booker Prize winner’s quirky new novel: an 82-year-old superheroine.
- High-concept, short, literary, but “poststructuralist” references flagged as barriers to big commercial/crossover appeal.
“This sounds like it could be a great time. … 144 pages, interesting. I think I would have a great time with this. I don’t know that it’s flying off the shelves at Barnes and Noble …” – Rebecca (49:41)
Verdict: Weird, fun, literary—labeled a “WLB” (Weird Little Book)—but not likely to win the month.
Winner: "IT Book of the Month"
John of John by Douglas Stuart
(Crowned at 50:41)
“A literary novel with crossover to commercial appeal and an Oprah pick is kind of everything I want.” – Rebecca (50:41)
“What else do you want?” – Jeff (50:50)
- Literary bona fides, wide appeal, and heavy book club–award attention make it the clear standout for May.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
- “It gets a little easier as I get into my later 40s to forget what I did literally five minutes ago.” – Jeff (02:47)
- “You gotta ring multiple bells to be the IT Book of the Month…” – Rebecca (05:24)
- “The review in the Times is like a real work of art in a Southern lady, bless-your-heart kind of way.” – Rebecca on The Calamity Club (16:15)
- “People who like Matt Haig love him and there are a lot of them… It will sell.” – Rebecca (32:35)
- “Audio is the way to experience David Sedaris. … Every dad in the country is getting David Sedaris for Father’s Day.” – Rebecca (35:50)
- “I do struggle with Dungeon Crawler Carl … but I do feel like I’m doing The Roger from 30 Rock every time I try to say Dungeon Crawler Carl.” – Rebecca (44:54)
- “Weird Little Book… WLB.” – Jeff (50:32)
Timestamps for Important Segments
- [01:49] Start of main content and new releases/“IT Book” format explanation
- [10:25] The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett (critical context/discussion)
- [19:44] John of John by Douglas Stuart (crossover/literary discussion)
- [27:04] One Leg on Earth by Pemi Aguda (speculative/literary debut)
- [31:24] The Midnight Train by Matt Haig (commercial/genre/feel-good discussion)
- [34:03] David Sedaris & “IT Book Emeritus” status
- [37:22] Vincent, You Seek Immediate Shelter (debut/false-alarm premise)
- [41:19] On Witness and Respair by Jesmyn Ward (essay collection limitations)
- [44:47] Dungeon Crawler Carl phenomenon (genre/series discussion)
- [48:12] Mostly Hero by Anna Burns (quirky Booker winner release)
- [50:41] Crowning of the “IT Book” of May 2026
Final Thoughts
- John of John is the “IT Book” for May 2026—combining literary merit, broader appeal, and endorsement from Oprah.
- Debuts, genre sensations, and essay collections were enthusiastically explored, but the mix of award potential, big readership, and critical buzz sealed the deal for Douglas Stuart.
- The hosts ponder new ways to make their knockouts more inclusive of debuts, seasonal lists, and maybe genre “Emeritus” recognition.
Want more? Visit Book Riot, subscribe to their Patreon for show notes, running “IT Book” lists, and much more as part of the vibrant Book Riot community.