Bill C-15 and its impact on accessible materials

The panel discussed the proposed legislation that would remove mandatory free postal service for accessible materials.

Details
- Jeff: Learned about the bill through a LinkedIn message about “free postal service for accessible materials in jeopardy”; began spreading awareness to over 300 contacts
- Ali: Questioned whether the government is indirectly saying they don’t want to continue funding this service
- Jeff: Believes it’s not that they don’t have money, but that “they just didn’t want to put money towards it” despite it being a “relative drop in the bucket”
- Macara: Noted that Canada Post wants “unilateral control of changing the postage prices” without government consultation
- Jeff: Clarified that the bill doesn’t immediately end free shipping but removes the legal requirement for Canada Post to offer it
Conclusion
- The amendment would make free postal service for accessible materials optional rather than mandatory
- Canada Post has publicly stated they will continue to honor their obligation while simultaneously supporting the bill
- Advocates are concerned about future changes once the legal requirement is removed

Digital transition challenges for print-disabled users

The group discussed the challenges faced by print-disabled individuals when services transition to digital-only formats.

Details
- Ali: Noted that CELA stopped producing and mailing CDs, which impacts those who depend on physical media
- Jeff: Highlighted that many people, especially elderly users, struggle with technology adoption
- Ali: Acknowledged that while he can easily adapt to digital formats, many users find technology “confusing and difficult”
- Jeff: Mentioned inadequate training resources, with only 10 hours available through assistive devices programs
- Jeff: Pointed out that rural areas often lack broadband internet access, making digital-only solutions impractical
- Macara: Raised concerns about job losses for braille transcribers if physical formats are discontinued
Conclusion
- Digital-only solutions exclude many users who lack technology skills or access
- Training resources are insufficient for many users to make the transition
- Infrastructure limitations (like rural broadband) create additional barriers

The importance of choice in accessible formats

The panel emphasized that maintaining multiple format options is crucial for accessibility.

Details
- Jeff: Compared the situation to restaurants using tablets for ordering – people may use it when required but prefer traditional methods
- Macara: Asked why the blind community shouldn’t have the same choices as sighted readers who can choose between print and digital
- Jeff: Noted that print books remain popular despite digital alternatives, with Chapters/Indigo stores still thriving
- Ali: Suggested there needs to be a middle ground approach that maintains options
- Jeff: Questioned why CELA discontinued CDs and whether there was any consultation with users
Conclusion
- Choice is a fundamental aspect of accessibility
- The trend toward eliminating physical formats disproportionately impacts vulnerable populations
- A middle ground approach is needed that maintains multiple format options

Impact on specialized communities

The discussion touched on how these changes affect specific communities within the print-disabled population.

Details
- Jeff: Highlighted the deaf-blind community as a “minority within a minority” particularly impacted by these changes
- Macara: Noted that rural and remote communities often have less access to CNIB services
- Jeff: Mentioned that CNIB services vary by region, with some areas receiving minimal support
- Ali: Suggested that CELA may not be producing new braille materials but simply distributing existing stock
Conclusion
- Specialized communities face compounded barriers when services are reduced
- Geographic location creates additional accessibility challenges
- Service reductions disproportionately impact those with multiple disabilities

Observations on this Occuring Under a Mark Carney Government

An additional observation was made by Jeff, that it is very ironic that the Carney government is legislating de-regulation. In Carney’s book, Values, (which was discussed during a Panel), one of the reoccurring themes is the need to have regulations and safeguards in play in order to avoid complacency. Whether it be trust in the free market, past and future forms of currency, environmental endeavours, etc. Carney repeatedly emphasized regulations so that people would not become complacent.

The Following is the Link to Saturday’s The Ali and Macara Show, Where Bill C-15 was Briefly Discussed

https://thealiandmacarashow.ca/2025/12/13/sheryl-crow-saturday-dec-13-2025/

Follow the Books Panel

On Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/books-panel/id1810901361

On Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/2k8W4IQLgHgxqyDshZuar8?si=upOjdA68SHW-ajSuyOlY9g&nd=1&dlsi=ceb38dbda874450b

On Audible: https://www.audible.ca/podcast/Books-Panel/B0F92X1Q8B?qid=1757778516&sr=1-1&ref_pageloadid=not_applicable&pf_rd_p=b278ed0a-c3b2-4491-808c-7cb2190a487c&pf_rd_r=Z42MGK66TE8ZT9QH33NF&plink=Dtrnf9ZCkbAy1vWd&pageLoadId=fVeu0PZlIY7CWM1x&creativeId=0d6f6720-f41c-457e-a42b-8c8dceb62f2c&ref=a_search_c3_lProduct_1_1

On iHeart: https://www.iheart.com/podcast/269-books-panel-279640240/

On Tunein: https://tunein.com/podcasts/Books-Panel-p4644216/

On Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/@bookspanel

Like The Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61579006388583

Join the Discord server: Please note: if the link does not work, please let us know, and we will send you a new link privately. https://discord.gg/PuAGpKCM

Subscribe to the hub site so you never miss network updates and to learn more about all of the shows: http://www.themoosaslobodiannetwork.ca

Send us an email:

feedback@bookspanel.ca

Looking for tips and tricks on using your favourite devices? Check out Techstravaganza: http://www.techstravaganza...