Books With Your Besties: The Idaho Follow Up Episode – Detailed Summary

Episode Title: The Idaho Follow Up Episode
Release Date: March 14, 2025
Hosts: Emily and Ashley

In this compelling follow-up episode of "Books With Your Besties," hosts Emily and Ashley delve deeper into the events surrounding a tragic incident at a town hall in Idaho. Building upon their previous discussions, they explore listener feedback, examine the psychological underpinnings of bystander behavior, and address the societal and political divides highlighted by the event. The episode is rich with personal anecdotes, expert insights, and thoughtful reflections, providing listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the complex issues at hand.

1. Introduction and Context

The episode begins with Ashley recounting a personal experience in Boise, Idaho, setting the stage for the in-depth discussion to follow.

Ashley [00:42]: "So funny that we're doing a second part of the Idaho episode. Since I was in Boise, we were at the airport..."

Ashley describes observing a tense encounter between groups of men and women at an airport bar, hinting at unresolved tensions from a previous night. This anecdote serves as a microcosm of the broader issues they aim to explore.

2. Listener Feedback and Community Responses

Following Ashley's story, Emily and Ashley transition to addressing the feedback received from their audience regarding the previous episode about the Idaho town hall incident.

Ashley [03:04]: "Thank you to you for educating and empowering all of us. I got so many messages from people basically saying how lucky I am to have your knowledge in my everyday life..."

Listeners shared their reflections on gender dynamics and systemic issues, with many women initially blaming other women rather than examining the patriarchal structures that may have facilitated the tragic events. Emily adds her perspective on differing viewpoints shaped by her background in psychology.

Emily [03:31]: "Good. I do think, you know, that it can be helpful to just hear different perspectives..."

The hosts acknowledge the pervasive sentiment of "everyone should have helped," emphasizing the complexity of bystander situations.

Emily [04:18]: "A lot of the same initial what we talked about that people really firmly believe if I had been there, I would have stepped in totally. Which is fun to believe, but you wouldn't have."

3. Understanding the Bystander Effect and Psychological Responses

Emily takes a moment to delve into the psychological aspects of bystander behavior, challenging the assumption that individuals can always predict their responses in crisis situations.

Emily [04:28]: "That is just one of my biggest, biggest pet peeves..."

Referencing the University of Idaho murders by Brian Kohberger, Emily discusses how rare and intense violent situations can overwhelm even the most well-intentioned individuals, making it unrealistic to hold bystanders solely accountable.

Emily [06:30]: "That's the question that someone asked in our question box. They, they wanted you..."

Ashley introduces a listener's question about the elements of fight, flight, or freeze in such scenarios, prompting Emily to explain the physiological responses that often dictate behavior in high-stress moments.

Emily [06:45]: "Of course. I'll just say your autonomic nervous system is, has arousal during these situations..."

The discussion highlights that actions like distracting, seeking help, or documenting events are safer and more practical responses than direct confrontation, which may escalate violence.

4. Social and Political Divides Reflected in the Idaho Incident

The conversation shifts to the broader societal and political undercurrents that influenced the Idaho town hall situation. Ashley brings up stereotypes and prejudices that communities hold, which can exacerbate tensions during crises.

Ashley [08:21]: "One comment that came up consistently from people who actually live in Idaho..."

Emily criticizes the oversimplification of complex communities, referencing Coeur d'Alene's historical ties to the KKK to illustrate deep-seated issues.

Emily [08:58]: "I mean, I understand that we can see cultural sort of differences in rural and urban areas..."

The hosts argue against projecting preconceived notions onto entire regions, emphasizing the bravery of individuals who stand up despite hostile environments.

Ashley [10:14]: "And be even more impressed and proud of the people who did show up there if they knew that that was going to potentially be the atmosphere."

5. Online Hate Comments and Social Media Dynamics

Emily and Ashley address the influx of hate comments received after their initial episode, using them as a springboard to discuss the toxicity present in online discourse.

Ashley [10:57]: "And then someone else on TikTok stormed the truth 201 said..."

Quotes from hostile comments reveal deep-seated prejudices and resistance to change, with dismissive and threatening language directed at women advocating for justice.

Emily [11:30]: "Oh wow. So is that a threat? I'm sound Seems like it."

These interactions underscore the challenges faced by those seeking to promote understanding and change in polarized environments.

6. Personal Stories Highlighting Acts of Courage

The hosts share an anonymized story from a listener who witnessed acts of courage during the Idaho incident, countering the narrative that no one helped.

Ashley [14:23]: "Can I share a story that was sent to us through direct messages..."

This account details how a fellow community member stood by a friend until she was safely released, illustrating that support often exists beyond what is visible in media portrayals.

Emily [16:02]: "I love that. There's, of course, more to the story than you're gonna see in some clip..."

7. Historical Perspectives and Repeating Patterns

Emily connects the current events to historical instances of societal upheaval, emphasizing the cyclical nature of such patterns.

Emily [28:18]: "I agree. Okay, can I bring up something about this that it's been making me think about?"

She references World War II and the Holocaust, drawing parallels to the importance of remembering history to prevent its repetition.

Emily [31:24]: "If you look at the Nazi movement and then the resistance to the Nazi movement..."

This reflection serves as a cautionary reminder of the consequences of inaction and the importance of collective memory.

8. Internal Community Dynamics and Support Systems

A discussion ensues about the fracturing within communities, particularly among women, and the reluctance to support one another in politically charged environments.

Ashley [26:16]: "You said infighting which made me think of this..."

Emily emphasizes the detrimental effects of internal conflicts and the necessity for solidarity, especially among marginalized groups.

Emily [26:55]: "Oh we absolutely do not. I think more of us are self proclaimed guys girls than should ever be the case..."

The conversation highlights the importance of fostering supportive relationships to combat external threats and societal pressures.

9. Conclusion and Future Directions

As the episode draws to a close, Emily and Ashley celebrate a milestone, noting their podcast's rise to the top 200 on Apple Podcasts, and express gratitude to their listeners.

Ashley [32:25]: "And I would think, if anything, if you're going to be saying, oh, that's northern Idaho..."

They announce their intention to continue engaging with their audience through future episodes and plan to focus on book discussions in upcoming shows.

Ashley [33:21]: "Top 200 podcasts. Listen, I'm gonna..."

Emily [34:13]: "Happy reading."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Ashley [00:42]: "So funny that we're doing a second part of the Idaho episode...

• Emily [04:28]: "That is just one of my biggest, biggest pet peeves..."

• Emily [06:45]: "Of course. I'll just say your autonomic nervous system is, has arousal during these situations..."

• Ashley [08:21]: "One comment that came up consistently from people who actually live in Idaho..."

• Emily [11:30]: "Oh wow. So is that a threat? I'm sound Seems like it."

• Emily [16:02]: "I love that. There's, of course, more to the story than you're gonna see in some clip..."

• Emily [31:24]: "If you look at the Nazi movement and then the resistance to the Nazi movement..."

• Ashley [32:25]: "And I would think, if anything, if you're going to be saying, oh, that's northern Idaho..."

Final Thoughts

In "The Idaho Follow Up Episode," Emily and Ashley adeptly navigate the intricate layers of a tragic event, intertwining personal narratives with broader societal critiques. Their thoughtful analysis encourages listeners to reflect on their own assumptions and the complexities of human behavior in crisis situations. By addressing both the micro and macro aspects of the incident, the hosts provide a nuanced perspective that fosters understanding and empathy among their audience.

For more insights and discussions, follow Books With Your Besties on Instagram and consider supporting them on Patreon for exclusive content.