Brain Driven Brands: What Marketers Got Wrong in 2024…and How to Get It Right in 2025

Podcast: Brain Driven Brands
Host: Sarah Levinger
Episode: What Marketers Got Wrong in 2024…and How to Get It Right in 2025
Release Date: December 5, 2024

In Episode 40 of Brain Driven Brands, host Sarah Levinger delves deep into the successes and failures of marketing strategies in 2024, offering insightful predictions and actionable strategies for 2025. This comprehensive summary captures the key discussions, insights, and conclusions drawn from Sarah's analysis, enriched with notable quotes and timestamps for reference.

Introduction

Sarah Levinger opens the episode with enthusiasm, acknowledging the podcast's milestone of 40 episodes and giving a special shout-out to producer Scotty and co-host Nate Lagos. She sets the stage for the discussion by emphasizing the importance of reflecting on the past year’s marketing strategies to optimize for the upcoming year.

Sarah Levinger [00:03]: "I help brands use psychology to cut costs, boost sales, captivate the masses. That's my marketer speak for literally. I just study humans all day long."

She encourages marketers to take notes and fully engage with the episode to harness the lessons learned from 2024 to thrive in 2025.

What Worked in 2024

1. Personalized Marketing at Scale

Personalization emerged as a dominant trend, with brands effectively tailoring campaigns to resonate personally without being invasive. This approach made consumers feel seen and heard, enhancing their connection with the brand.

Sarah Levinger [08:15]: "Data that we're using on, especially on the paid advertising side is now being used to enhance the experience instead of create the experience."

Brands like Spotify with their Wrapped campaign and Nike with hyper-focused ads exemplified this success by aligning closely with customer identities.

Key Takeaways:

• Personalize beyond names; focus on customers' daily experiences and identities.
• Utilize data to enhance, not overshadow, the consumer experience.

2. Authenticity in Campaigns

Authenticity remained a critical factor, with campaigns sharing relatable, raw stories about real human experiences outperforming more polished but impersonal efforts. Brands like Dove continued to excel by staying true to their mission and cultural relevance.

Sarah Levinger [17:35]: "Consumers are starting to value brands that have a clear mission. If you say you're transparent, please be transparent."

Key Takeaways:

• Develop authentic narratives that align with the brand’s mission.
• Engage consumers through genuine stories that reflect real-life issues.

3. Simplicity in Messaging

Despite the varied trends, simplicity in marketing messages stood out. Clean, clear, and bold campaigns with minimalist designs outperformed more complex and cluttered advertisements.

Sarah Levinger [28:45]: "Liquid Death... used incredibly simple messages delivered in an interesting way, and it worked phenomenally."

Key Takeaways:

• Focus on conveying a single, strong message across multiple formats.
• Avoid overcomplicating designs and narratives; prioritize clarity.

What Didn’t Work in 2024

1. Overreliance on Trendy Platforms

Chasing the latest social media platforms proved ineffective for many brands. The swift migration to platforms like Threads did not yield the expected long-term engagement, highlighting the importance of maintaining presence where the audience already resides.

Sarah Levinger [35:20]: "Don't just jump ship entirely, leaving all of these other platforms... it's about being where it matters."

Key Takeaways:

• Prioritize established platforms where your audience is active.
• Assess the longevity and relevance of new platforms before investing heavily.

2. Tone Deaf Campaigns

Brands occasionally launched campaigns that misaligned with current cultural or societal contexts, leading to insensitivity and backlash. Sarah cites the infamous Pepsi ad as an example of how missteps in cultural engagement can damage brand reputation.

Sarah Levinger [39:10]: "Always, always, always align your campaigns with the current cultural and economic climates that make sense for your brand."

Key Takeaways:

• Ensure campaigns are culturally sensitive and relevant.
• Align marketing efforts with the brand’s mission and societal values.

3. Unfocused Discounting Strategies

Excessive and haphazard discounting during major sales events like Black Friday diluted brand value. Consumers grew skeptical of recurring discounts, perceiving them as a sign of reduced product value.

Sarah Levinger [44:50]: "The more we discount, the more consumers are going to want discounts, which drives me a little crazy."

Key Takeaways:

• Implement strategic discounting that aligns with brand value and customer expectations.
• Use psychology-driven pricing and bundling to enhance perceived value without over-reliance on discounts.

Predictions for 2025

1. Enhanced Personalization with Boundaries

Personalization will continue to thrive, but with a critical focus on respecting consumer privacy. Brands must balance tailored experiences with transparent data usage.

Sarah Levinger [51:30]: "Consumers are going to expect tailored experiences... but they're going to be incredibly concerned about privacy."

Strategy:

• Utilize intentional micro-segmentation to target specific identities within customer groups.
• Maintain transparency in data practices to build trust.

2. Value-Driven Spending

Consumers, particularly younger generations, will prioritize ethics, sustainability, and brand purpose over mere product features. Brands must demonstrate alignment with these values to foster loyalty.

Sarah Levinger [58:20]: "Consumers value alignment. You must align with the person they believe they are."

Strategy:

• Highlight ethical practices and sustainability initiatives in marketing messages.
• Ensure brand actions align with stated values to reinforce authenticity.

3. Balancing Convenience with Human Connection

While automation and efficiency remain important, brands must integrate human elements to maintain meaningful connections with consumers.

Sarah Levinger [1:03:10]: "AI is a tool. It should not replace the human element."

Strategy:

• Blend automated solutions with personalized human interactions.
• Focus on customer service that reflects human empathy and understanding.

4. Navigating Economic Uncertainty

With economic uncertainties looming, consumers will become more selective in their purchasing decisions. Brands should focus on providing value beyond products, such as practical, long-lasting content and genuine support.

Sarah Levinger [1:09:40]: "Consumers are going to be more selective... try to push brand this year, guys, brand."

Strategy:

• Develop value-driven content that resonates with consumer needs and enhances brand perception.
• Engage with customers through genuine support and meaningful interactions.

Actionable Takeaways for Marketers

1. Double Down on Authenticity

   • Incorporate real stories from consumers and team members.
   • Showcase genuine customer interactions beyond mere testimonials.

   Sarah Levinger [1:16:05]: "How can we incorporate real stories not just from our consumers, but from our team?"

2. Segment Smarter with Identity Focus

   • Move beyond broad use-case segmentation to target specific identities.
   • Create niche audiences based on consumer beliefs and lifestyles.

   Sarah Levinger [1:18:30]: "If you're the type of mom who believes that health is most important for her kids, this is the granola bar for you."

3. Stay Agile Amid Shortening Trend Lifespans

   • Launch smaller, targeted campaigns that can quickly adapt to changing trends.
   • Focus on message consistency across various creative formats before scaling.

   Sarah Levinger [1:21:15]: "Trends have every single year. But we're noticing trends are starting to shorten."

Conclusion

Sarah Levinger emphasizes that the lessons from 2024 are pivotal for shaping successful marketing strategies in 2025. By focusing on authenticity, intelligent segmentation, maintaining human connections, and providing genuine value, brands can navigate the evolving consumer landscape effectively.

Sarah Levinger [1:25:45]: "If you are ready to stop guessing and start scaling with science, you can DM me or check out tetherinsights IO."

She encourages marketers to engage deeply with their consumer base, align their strategies with cultural and ethical values, and remain adaptable to sustain and grow their brand presence in the competitive market of 2025.

Final Note: For those seeking to implement these strategies, Sarah offers further guidance through her consultancy, Tether Insights, which specializes in psychographic panels and emerging brand incubators.

Podcast Network: Learn and Laugh Series on the Quick Fire Podcast Network