Broadway Breakdown: ANGELS IN AMERICA (2nd Episode) with Ali Gordon

Release Date: March 6, 2025

Introduction

In the second episode of the "Grab Bag" series on Broadway Breakdown, host Matt Koplik welcomes theater enthusiasts to an in-depth exploration of Tony Kushner's seminal work, Angels in America. Joined by guest Ali Gordon, a seasoned performer with experience in the play, they delve into the complexities of the characters, various productions, and the enduring legacy of this groundbreaking piece.

Guest Introduction and Personal Connections

Matt introduces Ali Gordon, affectionately referred to as the "mother of the Breakdown," highlighting her previous appearance on the podcast from the episode on Passion. Ali shares her profound admiration for Angels in America, describing it as her favorite play and arguably the greatest piece of American drama from the 20th century.

Notable Quote:

Ali Gordon [02:08]: "I just want to say I'm taking, I'm taking like a sober tone because I know this one is serious. So I'm just like, I'm like, thank you for your consideration and I'm honored to be here."

Exploring Different Productions

The conversation transitions to various productions of Angels in America, comparing the original Broadway run, the National Theater production, and the acclaimed HBO miniseries directed by Mike Nichols. Matt and Ali discuss the portrayal of key characters like Prior Walter, Harper Pitt, Joe Pitt, and Roy Cohn, analyzing how different actors bring nuanced interpretations to their roles.

Key Discussions:

• Performance Nuances: Matt recalls seeing the original production and not fully grasping the humor until rewatching archived performances. Ali emphasizes the depth of the HBO adaptation, praising its faithful representation and the versatility of the cast.

• Casting Reflections: Both hosts express admiration for actors like Patrick Wilson and Bill Heck, discussing how their performances add layers to the characters. They also critique other portrayals, highlighting inconsistencies in conveying the characters' complexities.

Notable Quote:

Matt Koplik [03:54]: "We are doing another episode on the great works, Angels in America, part one and two, Millennium Approaches and Perestroika."

Character Analysis

**1. Harper Pitt:

• Depression and Control: Ali describes Harper as a sensitive soul struggling with addiction and paranoia, highlighting her agoraphobia and reliance on Valium. She underscores Harper's longing for control and stability in her tumultuous relationship with Joe.

• Visions and Prophethood: The discussion explores Harper's visions, suggesting she might be a prophet whose paperwork slipped through the heavenly bureaucratic cracks. This interpretation adds a poetic dimension to her character, aligning with the play's magical realism elements.

Notable Quote:

Ali Gordon [04:54]: "Harper is the wife of Joe Pitt. They are Mormons living in Brooklyn because Joe works as a clerk, so he works in law and so he's in New York. She is sort of unhappily in New York. She is a very sensitive soul who has obviously come from a very difficult life."

**2. Joe Pitt:

• Internal Struggles: Matt and Ali delve into Joe's internal conflict as a closeted gay man married to Harper. They discuss his relationship dynamics, fueled by his desire to protect Harper while grappling with his suppressed identity.

• Impact of Roy Cohn: Roy's influence on Joe serves as a catalyst for his eventual coming out, highlighting the toxic mentorship and the societal pressures that shape Joe's journey.

Notable Quote:

Ali Gordon [16:02]: "She's dying when she's on the airplane to San Francisco."

**3. Roy Cohn:

• Antagonistic Force: Roy embodies the oppressive societal norms and internalized homophobia prevalent during the Reagan era. His manipulative tactics and ruthless demeanor exacerbate Joe's struggle with his identity.

• Final Moments: The discussion touches on Roy's demise, interpreting it as both poetic justice and a reflection of the deep-seated hatred he harbored.

Notable Quote:

Matt Koplik [05:32]: "She can see right through him because she can see right through a lot of people."

**4. Prior Walter and Lewis:

• Friendship and Survival: The bond between Prior and Lewis is examined, showcasing their mutual support amidst the challenges posed by AIDS. Their interactions bring forth themes of friendship, resilience, and the quest for meaning.

Notable Quote:

Ali Gordon [13:36]: "It's a very interesting take on Prior because Prior's a very smart guy."

Themes and Storytelling Techniques

Magical Realism: Ali praises Kushner's use of magical realism, where supernatural elements coexist with harsh realities, allowing for a multifaceted exploration of themes like identity, faith, and mortality.

Ambiguity of the Angel: The episode delves into the symbolic role of the angel in the play, debating its literal existence versus a metaphorical manifestation of Prior's quest for purpose.

Notable Quote:

Ali Gordon [19:29]: "Do you know what I'm saying? But I think that is a strength of the script."

Casting and Performances

The hosts discuss ideal casting choices, reflecting on performances by actors like Zachary Quinto, Patrick Wilson, and Mary Louise Parker. They emphasize the importance of authenticity and the challenges of portraying complex characters without resorting to stereotypes.

Dream Casting Suggestions:

• Harper Pitt: Betty Gilpin
• Prior Walter: Kieran Culkin (as suggested by Matt)

Notable Quote:

Matt Koplik [114:11]: "I just love that moment. It's the same thing where it's like, it either cuts to something that undercuts it, that shows it's absurd. It cuts to him understanding it in a way that's like, really profound."

Personal Reflections and Connections

Matt shares his personal connection to the characters, drawing parallels between his own life experiences and the complexities of Joe and Lewis. Ali discusses her journey with understanding Holly's character, emphasizing the emotional depth and authenticity required to portray such roles effectively.

Notable Quote:

Ali Gordon [165:45]: "I genuinely mean that because this is such a huge piece and I have no real authority. I just really love it."

Conclusion and Future Discussions

As the episode wraps up, Matt and Ali highlight the enduring relevance of Angels in America, encouraging listeners to revisit the play and its various adaptations. They tease upcoming episodes, including conversations with other guests and deeper dives into specific characters and themes.

Final Thoughts:

Matt Koplik [179:30]: "Thank you so much for coming on. Where can people find you if you want them to find you?"

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Ali Gordon [04:54]: "Meg crosses her leg, very sexy."
• Matt Koplik [12:14]: "Every version of Angels we get is reliant on two things: who's the director and where are we in history when it's coming?"
• Ali Gordon [16:02]: "She's dying when she's on the airplane to San Francisco."
• Matt Koplik [19:22]: "But I think Kushner wants it to be like, no, look, you have to take this seriously."
• Al Gordon [25:45]: "I just want to know what happens to Joe."
• Matt Koplik [86:29]: "You're the top. Yeah, you're an arrow collar."

Final Remarks

This episode of Broadway Breakdown offers a comprehensive analysis of Angels in America, enriched by Ali Gordon's insights and Matt Koplik's passionate discourse. Whether you're a seasoned theater aficionado or a newcomer to the play, this episode provides valuable perspectives on its intricate characters and timeless themes.

For more episodes and in-depth discussions, subscribe to Broadway Breakdown and join the conversation on their Discord Channel.