BroadwayRadio Podcast Summary Episode: Class Notes: Erin Morton (Heathers)
Host: Lauren Clash Schneider
Release Date: July 9, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of BroadwayRadio, host Lauren Clash Schneider welcomes Erin L. Morton, a rising senior at Cincinnati's College Conservatory of Music, who portrays Martha Dunstock in the acclaimed musical Heathers at New World Stages. The conversation delves into Erin's journey, her interpretation of Martha, her collaboration with the creative team, and her unexpected viral success on social media.

Erin Morton’s Background and Education

Lauren begins by highlighting Erin's academic pursuits:

"First of all, you're a rising senior at Cincinnati's College Conservatory of Music. Is that accurate?"
[00:59]
"Yes, absolutely," Erin confirms. She shares that three of her classmates have seen Heathers in the past week, indicating the show's growing popularity within her academic circle.

Erin hints at her future plans but notes that details will emerge closer to graduation:

"It's a little too soon, but we plan to have some sort of plan closer to school time around August."
[01:16]

Portraying Martha Dunstock

Erin expresses her honor in playing Martha Dunstock, a pivotal character in Heathers:

"She is the type of person that just sees through rose-colored lenses always in the best way... She sees so much kindness and hope and goodness in everyone."
[01:41]

She emphasizes the importance of adding depth to Martha, ensuring she isn't a one-dimensional character:

"I really like to give this character a true world to live in... Just very fun and interesting to think about and to play with."
[02:45]

Navigating the Character’s Name

The discussion shifts to Martha's challenging name, Martha Dunst:

"Her optimism is the biggest thing about. It's like, the best thing about her is that in the face of just the worst things possible, her optimism shines through."
[03:12]

Erin shares her initial struggles and eventual appreciation for Martha's unwavering positivity:

"From playing this character, there's so much that you can take from that, and it is just like seeing true goodness and kindness from people."
[04:35]

Working with Director Andy Fickman

Erin talks about her collaboration with Andy Fickman, the production's director:

"But this was my first time working with him."
[04:58]

Despite Andy's impressive body of work, Erin felt at ease upon meeting him:

"From the moment I even auditioned... I felt so much at ease."
[05:38]
"It was just like, such fun, positive energy, such light..."
[05:41]

Audition Process and Character Interpretation

A memorable part of Erin's audition experience involved reinterpreting a key song:

"The script said 'Kindergarten Boyfriend' was about power and it was happy... Just try it out."
[06:47]

Erin initially performed the song with a sad, mellow tone but adapted to the creators' vision of conveying empowerment:

"There’s something so touching about her finding power in what she's about to do rather than feeling the pain and the sorrow..."
[08:10]

She believes this interpretation adds depth and aligns better with Martha's character arc.

Involvement of Show Creators in Rehearsals

Erin highlights the unique advantage of having the show’s creators present during rehearsals:

"Having the creators of a show in the room... you get to make sure you're staying within the realm while also being creative."
[09:14]

Both Larry and Kevin Murphy, the writers, were actively involved, offering valuable insights and fostering a collaborative environment:

"They were always there to give us notes and help us form this beautiful show that is now open."
[10:17]

Viral TikTok Cover of "Creep"

Shifting focus to her personal achievements, Erin discusses her unexpected viral success:

"It started off... by the first day, it was like at 60k and... now that I've done it that way, I don't see it being played another way."
[10:36-11:23]

Her cover of Radiohead’s "Creep" amassed over 14 million views and 3.5 million likes on TikTok, showcasing her versatility beyond musical theater.

Conclusion

Lauren wraps up the conversation by commending Erin's balance between her theatrical pursuits and social media presence:

"I love how you had that heading into this experience of Heather's for you and I thank you so much, Erin."
[12:03]

Erin expresses her gratitude, and the episode concludes with a heartfelt thank you from both sides.

Key Takeaways:

• Erin Morton's Dedication: Erin demonstrates a profound commitment to bringing depth and authenticity to her role as Martha Dunstock in Heathers.

• Collaborative Creative Process: Working closely with director Andy Fickman and creators Larry and Kevin Murphy enriches the production, fostering a supportive and innovative environment.

• Versatility and Reach: Beyond the stage, Erin's viral TikTok cover of "Creep" highlights her multifaceted talent and ability to connect with a broader audience.

This episode of BroadwayRadio offers an insightful glimpse into the life of a dedicated performer navigating the challenges and triumphs of Broadway productions while leveraging modern platforms to amplify her artistry.