BroadwayRadio Podcast Summary Episode: This Week on Broadway for February 23, 2025: Redwood

Introduction In this episode of BroadwayRadio, host James Marino and his panelists—Peter, Michael Portantier, and Jenna—delve into the latest developments on Broadway, with a primary focus on the new musical Redwood. Released on February 23, 2025, Redwood has garnered significant attention, especially due to the involvement of Broadway sensation Idina Menzel. The episode also touches upon other noteworthy theater productions and experiences from the panelists.

Main Discussion: Redwood

Redwood marks a bold venture for Broadway, blending intricate storytelling with ambitious stagecraft. The panelists provide a comprehensive review, highlighting both strengths and areas of contention.

Plot Synopsis Redwood centers around Jesse, portrayed by Idina Menzel, who embarks on a spiritual journey into the redwood forests to cope with personal grief. The narrative weaves through her relationship with her wife, Mel, and introduces supporting characters Finn and Becca, who embody contrasting personalities essential for the storyline's progression.

Peter elaborates, saying:

"Jesse's journey is triggered by a pivotal incident that propels her to California, ultimately leading her to the redwood forests in Eureka. The dynamics between Jesse, Mel, Finn, and Becca form the crux of the emotional landscape of the show." [09:50]

Performance Highlights Idina Menzel's performance is a focal point of the discussion. The panelists commend her dedication, especially her physical feats on stage, such as climbing and hanging from wires while delivering powerful vocal performances.

Michael notes:

"The extent to which Idina Menzel is singing while hanging and tumbling from wires is unparalleled. It's a testament to her unwavering commitment to the role." [16:18]

However, the panel acknowledges that while Menzel's performance is stellar, it sometimes overshadows the narrative and other characters, leading to a mixed reception among audiences.

Production Elements The production design of Redwood receives praise for its innovative use of projections and stage mechanics. Hannah S. Kim's projections create an immersive environment, complementing the physical set design.

Jenna shares her admiration:

"Hannah S. Kim's video design works beautifully with the set, creating a vivid and real atmosphere that even IMAX movies can't rival." [22:25]

The aerial choreography by Alicia Estrella and Aerial Dance Company Bandeloop is highlighted as a standout feature, seamlessly integrating movement with the set to enhance the storytelling.

Critical Reception While Redwood boasts impressive technical elements and star power, the panelists express reservations about the script and character development. Issues such as skewed character motivations and unresolved plot points detract from the overall experience.

Peter critiques:

"The show contains numerous clichés and lacks the depth needed to elicit genuine emotional responses from the audience." [09:21]

Jenna echoes these sentiments, pointing out that despite Diaz's commendable efforts as a first-time musical theater composer, the lyrics and character portrayals fall short in creating a compelling narrative.

Quotes with Attribution and Timestamps

• Michael Portantier on Menzel's performance:

  "The extent to which Idina Menzel is singing while hanging and tumbling from these wires... is amazing." [16:18]

• Jenna on set design:

  "Hannah S. Kim's video design works so beautifully with the set... I gasped when the tree first appears." [22:25]

• Peter on the plot’s execution:

  "When Jesse wants to climb the redwoods, it's totally against the rules. The lack of plausibility in her motivations makes it hard to engage emotionally." [09:50]

Other Theater News

Garcia's Career at the Mint Theater Peter reviews Harold Brighouse's Garcia's Career, drawing parallels with classics like Hobson's Choice and June Moon. The revival showcases a strong cast, particularly highlighting Amelia White's fearless portrayal of the mother character.

Michael adds:

"Daniel Marconi shines in his role, bringing depth and nuance to his performance." [45:41]

Conversations with Mother at Theater555 Another highlight is Matthew Lombardo's Conversations with Mother, a poignant two-character play exploring the complex relationship between a mother and her son. The play is lauded for its authentic portrayal of familial bonds and the actors' compelling performances.

Peter remarks:

"Carolyn Aaron and Matt Doyle deliver stunning performances, making the audience feel the underlying love amidst the chaos." [51:35]

Kaylee at the Tank The panel briefly discusses the play Kaylee, noting its exploration of gender identity and the challenges of expanding it into a full-length production. Victoria Sasso's portrayal is particularly praised for capturing the character's internal struggle.

Choir of Man Cruise Show Michael shares his recent experience watching Choir of Man aboard the Norwegian Escape cruise ship. The energetic British show, featuring live musicians and audience participation, received high praise for its vibrant performances and engaging format.

Musical Moments

Opening Song: In the Heights Peter introduces the opening song from the original Broadway cast album of In the Heights, performed by Lin-Manuel Miranda, setting an inspiring tone for the episode.

Closing Song: Let It Go from Frozen The episode concludes with the iconic "Let It Go" from Frozen, highlighting Idina Menzel's enduring impact on Broadway.

Jenna emphasizes:

"'Let It Go' has transcended its origins to become a Broadway classic, showcasing the powerful vocal prowess of Idina Menzel." [68:14]

Trivia Segment The panel concludes with a trivia question related to musical theater, encouraging listener engagement and participation.

Conclusion BroadwayRadio's latest episode provides an in-depth analysis of Redwood, balancing praise for its technical achievements and Menzel's performance with constructive criticism of its narrative structure. Additionally, the panel offers insightful reviews of other theatrical productions, making this episode a must-listen for Broadway enthusiasts seeking comprehensive coverage of current and upcoming shows.

Notable Quotes:

• Michael Portantier on set contributions:

  "The projections by Hannah S. Kim are terrific, enhancing the overall aesthetic of the production." [09:50]

• Jenna on character development:

  "The character of Jesse fails to resonate emotionally due to her portrayal as whiny and petulant, undermining the show's intended depth." [16:14]

• Peter on the production's collaborative nature:

  "While 'Redwood' aims to be a collaborative masterpiece, the overlapping credits may have diluted the creative vision, leading to a disjointed final product." [36:01]

Final Thoughts The episode encapsulates a critical yet appreciative perspective on Broadway's evolving landscape, offering listeners a balanced view of Redwood and its place within the theater community. With expert insights and engaging discussions, BroadwayRadio continues to solidify its reputation as Broadway's premier podcast.