
Are We Getting a ‘Hadestown’ Proshot With the Original Leads? Sarah Hyland to Join ‘The Grat Gatsby’ Since 2016, “Today on Broadway” has been the first and only daily podcast recapping the top theatre headlines every Monday through Friday.
Loading summary
A
Welcome to Today on Broadway for Thursday, December 19, 2024. I'm Broadway Radio's Matt Tamminini and I'm.
B
Tell Me on a Sunday podcast. Grace Aki.
A
Grace, we are a walking mash unit. We are alive, but just barely. You have been under the weather food poisoning, right? Is that what it was?
B
You know, every time I hear someone say food poisoning, it sounds made up. And what I experienced was food poisoning. I am not kidding.
A
So yes, yeah, very bad. And then on I spent five hours in the emergency room with some severe pain that kind of worked its way up throughout the day. So I am not in New York. I am not seeing all those shows that I talked about. On yesterday's episode, they pumped me full of morphine and said you probably shouldn't travel for a few days. So I'm going to be here. We're doing the show like normal and it's been an interesting 24 to 48 hours for the two of us, Grace. But we will be riding through the storm. We have done our Q and A episode that'll hit the Patreon feeds on Saturday and then that'll carry us in through the holiday weeks where you and I are going to have episodes on many of the days, not all the days. Probably the main holidays will stay out. You know, we won't have episodes on like Christmas Eve and Christmas Day and New Year's Eve and New Year's Day, but the other days we'll have episodes. They won't necessarily be today on Broadway unless anything major breaks. But we will have a lot of things in there that we have planned. So make sure that you are sticking with us throughout the holidays. We do have one more regular today on Broadway episode that'll be tomorrow. It will not include the reviews for Gypsy. We talked about this earlier in the week. Gypsy opens tonight at the Majestic Theater, but the reviews are embargoed for midnight and ain't nobody, especially Grace, you and I, as we are sick staying up that late. So I will probably end up doing a standalone episode with just the reviews sometime on Friday, both for Patreon and in the regular feed. But Grace, they could not wait for us to get fully healthy because on Wednesday they dropped multiple major stories in us to us. And the first one I had heard about like a day or two ago from our friend Ashley Hufford as she was theorizing and hearing rumors. And we'll get into that a little bit. But it was confirmed yesterday that the original Broadway principal cast of Hadestown is returning to the show. In London starting in February. Yes, that is. Reeve Carney as Orpheus, Andre Deshields as Hermes, Amber Gray as Persephone, Eva Noblezada as Eurydice, and Patrick Page as Hades. They are going to do the show for just less than one month, February 11th through March 9th. We'll get into why here in a minute, but tickets will go on sale if you are part of the UK productions email list today, depending on when you're listening to this. Thursday early at noon, Greenwich Mean Time. So I do the translation. 7:00am, I think Eastern time. I signed up for it. I have no intention of going to London or I had no intention of going to London during that period. But to see this group, if I can get a ticket, I might do it. So you can get. Do that. You can get all those tickets, as Ashley Hufford has pointed out on her social media accounts, and you can go and look at those videos. If you look at the schedule, there's like a week off in the middle of their time doing this show. Or maybe towards the end, it sure looks like they're gonna film this Grace. And what a great way to have a pro shot of Hadestown. If you're not gonna be able to do it on Broadway because of all of the reasons we talked about in the past, get those five original principles back together in London and film it over there. I'm just ecstatic about the possibility of that happening. That has not been confirmed. But the fact that they are coming back together to do the show and there's, there's, you know, the potential of it being filmed makes me very, very, very excited.
B
It's really cool. But I also think it's interesting that, like, this is the second time in recent history that I've noticed where you finally get the ability and funds. Because there's a hundred things that have to happen in order for something like this to go down that, like, they maybe would have wanted to film this, you know, on Broadway, right? Like with the. With the company and whatnot. But then you've got, you know, all these logistics and there's a current cast and all of these things. And so, like, look at what happened with Frozen. I know that they had to film this and then there was, you know, a potential because they had reset it with the tour and then there was like a closing of the Broadway company. So then the only option was to do it in London. And, like, here you are presented with a similar thing, but it's separate. I don't know, it's just interesting to me that, like, these things take so much time. And I'm, I'm glad that all these people are coming together, but I know that that was not an easy thing to do. So I'm very excited to see it.
A
That was not the only major story that we had on Wednesday. Grace, you and I earlier in the week talked about who could potentially be replacing Eva Noblezada as Daisy Buchanan in the Broadway production of the Great Gatsby. You theorized Lorna Courtney recently of Ann Juliet, which we both thought would make sense, but they went in a very different direction. They went not with a young, up and coming Broadway star, but they went with an established television star who has Broadway and Off Broadway roots, don't forget. But we now know that recent Off Broadway, Audrey from Little Shop of Horrors, Sarah Hyland is going to be taking over the role beginning on February 10th. She will replace Eva. Obviously, there's going to be a little bit of a gap between Eva leaves performances and when Sarah starts. But she will be joining Ryan McCarten, who is replacing Jeremy Jordan, and Terrence Mann, who is coming in to play the role of Meyer Wolfsheim. This was not on my bingo card of people Grace, that I thought would come in and do this show for a lot of different reasons, to be quite honest with you. But I texted you when I saw this. I was like, do I have to go back and see the Great Gatsby again? Because this is exciting. I missed her in Little Shop and this will be her return to Broadway since the original Broadway production of Grey Gardens when she played young Jacqueline Bouvier later Kennedy Onassis. So I think this is not the kind of casting that I would have guessed for this role, but a pretty brilliant move to pair her with with Ryan McCarten.
B
I think it's huge. It's actually huge. Like, I love her so much, but also, like, that's not a small thing. Like, you've got two people that have had TV clout, they've got that younger audience and also, like the wider, you know, TV viewing audience, like, loves her, like, in that, like, you know, 30 to 60 range. So I think this is a real slam dunk for them.
A
We talked about the fact that, like, Jeremy and Eva both have these, like, very distinct theater and then kind of a little theater, tangential fan bases that have really helped drive this show. Obviously the title, the Great Gatsby, as you have talked about so much with this and the Outsiders, like, that draws in audiences on their own. But I don't think that we can undersell how important Eva, and I think probably especially Jeremy's fan bases have sold this show through the first, whatever, nine months that it's been on Broadway. And I really thought that they were going to struggle to find people to replace them that had maybe not individually the same levels of fan bases, but, you know, collectively. And while Ryan probably doesn't rise to either the level of Eva or Jeremy, I think he's pretty close, maybe surpasses Eva. I don't. I don't know. But, like, Sarah, you're right. Like, she just has this huge families. I mean, Modern family was on TV for 11 years. Think of all the millions of people who have watched her on TV and loved her throughout her, you know, her adolescence and into adulthood. I think that this is, honestly, I think that probably as good of casting as they could have done from a marketing and ticket sales standpoint.
B
I agree. I don't know what other I. Yeah, I can't think of a better casting in all those circumstances, so good job for them.
A
Yeah. Unless they went with, like, a huge, like, pops. Unless Ariana Grande wanted to make this her Broadway return like that. This is probably about as smart as you can get. Speaking of people known for things outside of the theater world coming back to Broadway, yesterday it was announced that Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star Erika Jayne will be returning to the Broadway production of Chicago. She had previously been in the role in early 2020, and her run was cut short due to Covid, but she will now return to the production where she will play Roxie hart beginning on January 20th. It'll just be for three weeks. It is through February 9th. And it's important to know that while she is known for reality TV, she is. She does have, like, a Billboard number one hit on the dance chart from 2007 called Roller Coaster. She is somebody who has a music background, and they've done very, very well with these types of castings over the years over at Chicago. So while I am not as up to date on my housewives Grace, I think this one probably fits really well with the folks that they are continuing to bring in over at the Ambassador Theater.
B
Yeah. You know what? More of this. Am I sad that the last showgirl, Pamela Anderson, is not back? Of course I am. But I think that this is going to be, you know, really, really perfect for them. And, I mean, the housewives are having a moment again.
A
Are they? I didn't know that.
B
Yeah, I think that, like, it ebbs and flows, but I think that they are having another moment. They're all over my feed at least, so.
A
Okay, good to know. Yeah. And Pamela Anderson's probably going to be busy during awards season, so that might be why she's not back yet. But she is certainly having a moment of her own, as you mentioned, with the Housewives. All right, Grace, another story that is not happening in New York, but it is happening both in Florida and in New Jersey. This is one that you have known about for a while. I have known about it not as long as you, but I've known about it for a little bit because it is happening first down here in Florida. And they have announced the complete cast for the upcoming multiple productions and a couple little, I guess, tour stop kind of things for the next incarnation of the Mystic Pizza musical. The big standout of this is going to be the run at the Paper Mill Playhouse. That'll be happening at the end of January on January 29, but it is actually going to kick off down at the Riverside Theater here in Florida in the first week in January. But that cast will feature Christina Alabado, who had done all of the previous versions of the show. She's going to be joined by Elena Anderson and social media star and musical theater actress Deanna Gioletti. Those two are both new to this production, but joining them will be such names as Ben Fankhauser, Vincent Michael and F. Michael Haney. So F finished a run of Frozen in Maine, came by and saw you and Robin Sparkles for a couple hours, and then flew down here to Orlando and then drove over to Rivera beach in Florida.
B
That's exactly what happened. It was kind of insane that this worked out so well. We love Sandy Rustin and Casey Hession.
A
Just in character, writer and director.
B
Yeah. And I think that getting to work with these two women together is going to be very exciting. I think it's one of the first times, to my understanding, that they've worked specifically F, at least, you know, has worked with like an almost all female creative team, it seems. You know, Giancaprio on costumes and whatnot is also attached to help do costumes for Heart of Rock and Roll. So she's been in the 80s with F before. And I just, I'm. I'm thrilled that if F is just gonna book 80s shows where they sing Huey Lewis and Olaf for the next, you know, 20 years, I'm okay.
A
Yeah, that's not a bad way to make a living. You're taking what they're given because you're working for a living. I. I've got to get you Down. We' to get you down here to see the show because Oscar Sales, who is their communications and press rep over there, has been wonderful to me and the show over the years, and he has welcomed both you and me with open arms. So we've got to figure out how to get you down here to see it, even though obviously it's coming to your backyard in New Jersey as well. But it's a lot warmer down here than New Jersey right now, Grace.
B
I know. And things are so much cooler in summer. If you know, you know.
A
Oh, my God.
B
I'm sorry.
A
You just. You just quoted Olaf. Okay, that's fine. No, no, that's fine. Totally good. Totally good. But that's actually a perfect transition because speaking of Olaf and things that are warmer than New Jersey, yesterday it was announced that Disney will open a new experience during the 2025 EPCOT International Festival for the Arts. Now, this is the thing every year where they have all these different festivals. Food and wine, flower show, all these things. But the one at the beginning of the year always welcomes Disney on Broadway stars. And they do concerts. I've talked about the different concert pairings that they're going to happen throughout this year, but they have announced some new things that are going to be happening this year, including Once upon a stage, 30 years of Disney on Broadway. It is going to be a museum type of exhibit at the Communicore hall in Epcot, and it will celebrate all of the shows that they have done through Disney Theatricals. Lion King, Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast, things like that. But also Aida, Newsies, hopefully. We also get Peter and the Starcatcher, which people don't realize was a Disney Theatricals production. So that will kick off with the festival that will run from January 17th through February 24th. This is where my Disney annual pass comes in very handy because I plan on seeing every single one of those concert pairings that I can. And now that I know that this event is going to be happening, this exhibit is going to be happening, I'll be making sure to check that out and report back. Who knows, Grace? Maybe there will be some. Some F. Michael Haney memorabilia or photos from the. From the Frozen tour as well there.
B
Oh, I would like that. Who knows? I mean, listen, I'll fight a person again.
A
Again. Is there a story I don't know here?
B
Yeah, we'll do that off. Off the.
A
Okay. All right. Very fair. All right, everybody, that's all that we have for today. Thanks for listening to Today on Broadway. Follow us on Facebook Twitter and Instagram. Broadway radio. You can follow me on Instagram @bww. Matt. Grace. Where can people find you?
B
You can find me at. It's Graceaki.
A
All right, everybody, have a wonderful Thursday, and we'll be back to talk to you tomorrow.
BroadwayRadio Podcast Summary: "Today on Broadway: Thursday, Dec. 19, 2024"
Release Date: December 19, 2024
Hosts:
The episode opens with hosts Matt Tamminini and Grace Aki addressing Matt's recent struggle with severe food poisoning. Matt shares his ordeal, stating, “Grace, we are a walking mash unit. We are alive, but just barely” (00:07). He details his five-hour emergency room visit and the subsequent morphine treatment that advised against traveling. Despite his condition, Matt assures listeners that the show will continue as scheduled, navigating through the challenges of the past 24-48 hours. He mentions upcoming changes to their regular programming during the holiday season, including additional episodes on Patreon and sporadic releases outside of major holidays like Christmas and New Year’s (00:27).
A significant portion of the discussion centers on the confirmation that the original Broadway principal cast of Hadestown—including Reeve Carney, Andre De Shields, Amber Gray, Eva Noblezada, and Patrick Page—will reunite for a limited run in London from February 11th to March 9th (03:48). Matt expresses immense excitement about the potential filming of this reunion, highlighting its significance for fans who may not have the opportunity to see the show on Broadway. Grace adds depth to the conversation by comparing this development to previous productions like Frozen, emphasizing the logistical complexities involved in reassembling the original cast and the strategic decision to film in London instead of Broadway (04:37).
Notable Quote:
Matt states, “If you're not gonna be able to do it on Broadway… film it over there. I'm just ecstatic about the possibility of that happening” (03:48).
The hosts delve into the recent casting announcement for The Great Gatsby on Broadway. Eva Noblezada is set to be replaced by Sarah Hyland, known for her role in Modern Family, beginning February 10th (06:07). Matt discusses the strategic casting choice, noting Hyland’s broad appeal and substantial fan base from television, which is expected to bolster ticket sales and attract a diverse audience. Grace concurs, highlighting the potential marketing and ticket sales advantages of pairing Hyland with Ryan McCartan, who replaces Jeremy Jordan, and Terrence Mann as Meyer Wolfsheim (06:30).
Notable Quote:
Grace remarks, “Like, this is a real slam dunk for them” when discussing Sarah Hyland’s casting (06:30).
Matt and Grace discuss the return of Erika Jayne, a star from The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, to the Broadway production of Chicago. Erika will reprise her role as Roxie Hart from January 20th to February 9th, 2025 (07:54). Despite her reality TV fame, Erika brings a legitimate musical background, including a Billboard number one dance hit, aligning well with Chicago's history of casting performers with diverse entertainment backgrounds. Grace humorously laments the absence of Pamela Anderson, another reality TV star who previously starred in the same role, but acknowledges Erika’s fitting return (09:04).
Notable Quote:
Grace states, “More of this. Am I sad that the last showgirl, Pamela Anderson, is not back? Of course I am” expressing her enthusiasm for Erika Jayne’s return (09:04).
Transitioning to regional theater news, the hosts announce the full cast for the upcoming productions of the Mystic Pizza musical, which will premiere at the Riverside Theater in Florida in early January and later at the Paper Mill Playhouse in New Jersey on January 29th (09:17). The cast features Christina Alabado, Elena Anderson, and Deanna Gioletti, alongside veterans Ben Fankhauser, Vincent Michael, and F. Michael Haney. Matt and Grace express excitement about the collaboration between creative talents like Sandy Rustin and Casey Hession, emphasizing the significance of working with an all-female creative team for the production (10:56).
Notable Quote:
Matt enthuses, “I’ve got to get you Down. We' to get you down here to see the show” highlighting his eagerness to support the production (11:37).
Concluding the episode, Matt shares exciting news about Disney’s upcoming addition to the 2025 EPCOT International Festival for the Arts. The new exhibit, Once Upon a Stage: 30 Years of Disney on Broadway, will celebrate Disney Theatricals' prominent shows such as The Lion King, Aladdin, and Beauty and the Beast, as well as newer additions like Aida and Newsies (12:10). This museum-like exhibit is set to run alongside the festival from January 17th to February 24th. Matt anticipates attending the event, leveraging his Disney annual pass, and speculates about potential memorabilia from the Frozen tour being featured (12:11).
Notable Quote:
Matt shares his plans enthusiastically, “I plan on seeing every single one of those concert pairings that I can” emphasizing his commitment to engage with the new Disney experience (13:46).
Despite the challenges faced by Matt's health and the shifting schedules, the hosts maintain an upbeat and informative tone throughout the episode. They encourage listeners to follow them on social media for updates and express their dedication to delivering engaging Broadway content even during unforeseen circumstances.
Notable Quote:
Grace concludes with a light-hearted note, “I'll fight a person again,” underscoring the camaraderie and humor between the hosts (13:51).
Follow BroadwayRadio:
Note: Timestamps correspond to the podcast transcript provided and serve as reference points for the discussed topics.