
Loading summary
HomeServe Announcer
Owning a home is full of surprises, some wonderful, some not so much. And when something breaks, it can feel like the whole day unravels. That's why HomeServe exists for as little as $4.99 a month. You'll always have someone to call, a trusted professional ready to help, bringing peace of mind to four and a half million homeowners nationwide. For plans starting at just $4.99 a month, go to HomeServe.com that's HomeServe.com not available everywhere. Most plans range between $4.99 to $11.99 a month. Your first year terms apply on covered repairs.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance. And now we're customizing this ad for your morning commute to wake you up, which could help your driving. Science says that stimulating the brain increases alertness, so here's a pop. How many months have 28 days? What gets wetter as it dries? What has keys but can't open? Locks? If you don't want to hear the answers, turn off this Liberty Mutual AD. Now 12 months. A towel piano. Enjoy being fully alert.
Cash (Listener)
Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty.
Superhuman Podcast Host
Imagine an Olympics where doping is not only legal but encouraged. It's the Enhanced Games. Some call it grotesque, others say it's unleashing human potential. Either way, the podcast Superhuman documented it all, embedded in the Games and with the athletes for a full year.
Brooke
Within probably 10 days, I'd put on £10.
Jeffrey
I was having trouble stopping the muscle growth.
Superhuman Podcast Host
Listen to Superhuman on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Radio 831 Podcast Host
Why are we all so obsessed with romance on the Radio 831 podcast? Join us Sanjanah Bhasker and Tyler McCall as we unpack all the trending tropes, fuzzy adaptations, booktok drama and celebrity love stories with hot takes and sharp guests. Each episode digs into what these stories reveal about desire, fantasy, identity, and how we love. Now Listen to the Radio 831 podcast podcast on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Brooke
The story I told myself can then shape my behavior, and that can lead me to sabotage the possibility of connection
Debbie Brown
this Mental Health Awareness Month. Tune into the podcast Deeply well with Debbie Brown. If you've been searching for a soft place to land while doing the work to become whole, this podcast is for you. To hear more. Listen to Deeply well with Debbie Brown from the Black Effect Podcast Network on the iHeartRadio Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Brooke
You Asked, you demanded. And we sometimes listen. Sometimes. Yes, sometimes. Hey, it's Brooke and Jeffrey. And you found the Second Day podcast. We're trying out video with our podcast. Okay, so now for the first time, you can see a second date update. Yeah, you can see it. We've got it up right now on our YouTube page. It is one from last week. Yes. It took us a little while to edit the video to go with the audio. You know, we're working on it. It's a process. Process. Stick with us through the process. So if you want to watch a second date update, you can today on our YouTube page, just go to again, Brooke and Jeffrey. So there you go. Yeah, I'll be curious to see what people think in the comments of it. Maybe we'll have this one two weeks from now. Yeah, yeah. You know, yeah, we'll get there. You'll have to keep checking. Yeah, we'll get there. And you know, if your comments are only about how disappointed in what we look like you. You are, then that's okay, too. Yeah, we expect it. Exactly. But for now, let's get to a brand new awkward Tuesday phone call. It's gonna start. Here we go.
Jeffrey
Some things take every ounce of willpower not to do.
Brooke
Oh.
Jose
Oh, yes.
Brooke
Okay.
Jeffrey
Don't make a joke while you're in the middle of an adult circumcision. Don't make him laugh. Don't do it.
Brooke
That's a good point.
Jose
The doctor or the guy?
Brooke
You don't want anyone shaking.
Jeffrey
Oh, did it again.
Brooke
Too funny.
Jeffrey
Sorry, Tristan. Oh, we'll try again next Wednesday. No, but maybe even harder than that is finding the willpower to not text your ex back after a messy breakup. Don't do it. Well, one of our listeners was able to hold off for a long, long time. But today, he doesn't want to text her. He wants to call her.
Brooke
What?
Jeffrey
And you're going to find out why. What changed his mind? In your brand new awkward Tuesday phone call.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Next.
Jose
It's awkward.
Brooke
It's Tuesday.
Jose
It's awkward Tuesday phone call.
Jeffrey
You know what phrase you never hear?
Brooke
What's that, Jeff?
Jeffrey
I just had a great breakup with my girlfriend. It's Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. No, usually those are pretty messy. Pretty complicated. A little sexy. You know, maybe one last hurrah, but for the most part, not great. Yeah, but one of our listeners, Cash, says he achieved it. Maybe not right when it first happened, but shortly afterwards with the help of his friends. Oh, and somehow that has led to a whole another issue, and he needs our Help. We're going to find out about it right now.
Brooke
Why are we going to mess with a good thing? Just leave it alone. It ended well.
Jeffrey
Apparently it's not so well anymore. Cash, welcome to the show, man.
Cash (Listener)
Thank you.
Jose
Things are getting messy for you, bro.
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, you could say that.
Brooke
Okay, are we. Are we blaming the friends at this point or where are we at?
Cash (Listener)
No.
Jeffrey
What happened with you and your ex girlfriend?
Brooke
Is that right?
Cash (Listener)
So, yeah, I was dating a girl for a long time and.
Brooke
Define long time for us. Sorry.
Cash (Listener)
You know, over the course of like a year or two.
Jose
Why they broke up or it's one of those.
Brooke
We were on the we're off.
Jose
We're on the we're off.
Brooke
You know.
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, it was like that type of thing.
Jeffrey
Okay, so that was. It was on again, off again for. You said a year or two.
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, must be multiple years, I think. On and off again, you know. And about four months ago, she got really mad one night and just dumped me.
Brooke
Oh.
Jeffrey
Oh, that's the spicy side of her. But you like that.
Brooke
It sounds like that's the roller coaster you definitely knew you were on.
Cash (Listener)
Huh? She got spicy for sure. And of course, a couple weeks later, she texted me again saying she's sorry. Can we meet up and talk?
Jeffrey
Oh, back to the sweet side.
Jose
Uhoh. The other guy didn't work out.
Brooke
So did you guys get back together?
Cash (Listener)
Well, my friends were like, dude, you can't fall back into it. You gotta just ignore her. Cold turkey. Don't text back, you know, and it was tough, but I didn't.
Brooke
Oh.
Cash (Listener)
I stayed strong and.
Brooke
Wow. Whoa. You just left her on red?
Cash (Listener)
Yeah.
Brooke
Okay.
Cash (Listener)
All right.
Jose
That's a tough decision.
Brooke
I mean, it's honestly probably the healthiest thing. Like. Yeah, those up and down relationships are. Yeah, we've all been in them before, but they're hard.
Jeffrey
And if anything, it's only going to make her think that you're even sexier. She's gonna want you more.
Cash (Listener)
Right. But over the next few months, you know, she texted me every so often, like saying nice things, trying to lure me in. And my friends would kind of remind me, like, don't respond. Don't do it.
Brooke
Yeah.
Cash (Listener)
Okay.
Brooke
They are.
Cash (Listener)
Sometimes they take my phone for the night just to make sure I didn't text her back.
Jose
Oh, no, you started drinking a little bit.
Debbie Brown
Yeah.
Brooke
You gotta change your name and your phone to do not reply.
Jose
You're right.
Jeffrey
So clearly the temptation was still there for you.
Cash (Listener)
Yeah.
Jeffrey
And you needed some help with like an intervention to make sure it was Stopped.
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, it was hard not to fall back into the same kind of toxic pattern. And about a month ago, she texted me telling me that her grandmother just died. And I had met her grandmother a few times. I knew she wasn't in great health, but my friends were saying, you know, don't fall for it. She's baiting you. Don't text back.
Brooke
Oh, wow, that's hard, man. Yeah, it could or could not be. Yeah, totally.
Jeffrey
Brooke, how would you feel if you texted one of your exes that knew your grandma and they never responded back?
Brooke
Yeah, one time an ex texted me after a family thing, and it felt so good to write, who's this? I don't have your number saved.
Jeffrey
You did that?
Brooke
I really didn't have his number saved.
Jose
Oh, back.
Brooke
You were like, ooh, I didn't really know who it was. And then when he went back, I went, oh, well, that was, oh, you
Jose
should have doubled down. Still doesn't ring a bell.
Jeffrey
So after that message about her grandma, how many more did she send to you?
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, she didn't send me any more after that. That was the last time I heard from her text.
Brooke
I don't know. I think that means that she may really have needed somebody in that moment. Are you sure she actually passed away? That, like, did you stalk her socials? Like, posted anything? You checked the newspaper obituary?
Cash (Listener)
I didn't, but, I mean, I'm pretty sure it had. Like, I don't think she would lie about it. And like I said, she was in, like, really bad health. Okay.
Jeffrey
Oh, God.
Brooke
So are you feeling, like, regret that
Jeffrey
you didn't, like, support her when she needed it?
Cash (Listener)
Absolutely. I felt bad in the moment. Like, it was really hard. But even, like three or four weeks later, I feel even worse because I was with her for two years. You know, we were really close.
Jose
That's sad, man.
Brooke
So what are you needing our help with in that situation?
Cash (Listener)
Well, I feel like now I've had enough time where I'm ready to talk to her and maybe we can be friends.
Brooke
Good.
Jose
That's really good.
Jeffrey
Right after you cold shouldered her about her grandma passing. Now you're in a good spot to be friends.
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, I think, like, you know, after a certain amount of time, it becomes healthier to kind of talk again. Yeah, but it's just awkward. It's just like finding the way to break the ice is the problem.
Brooke
Right. Because you want to go back and still have those boundaries, that you're not going to get back together, but you also want to be there for her. As someone who cares for her, I mean, kind of.
Cash (Listener)
You know, I do really. I do really want to be your friend. And it's been a while and, you know, I do miss her.
Brooke
Okay, so we may be getting back on the ride. Yeah.
Jeffrey
But I think that's our challenge, is how do we have this conversation without getting him back onto the ride?
Brooke
Bro, it doesn't sound like he's totally off.
Amber
Yeah.
Brooke
Are we sure he doesn't want to back on the ride? He's saying he does, kind of.
Jeffrey
Well, his brain is saying no. Who knows? What is hard to say?
Jose
We can kiss his friends, right?
Brooke
Yeah, exactly, Jose.
Jeffrey
Well, let's see what advice we can come up with for you when we come back. Give you our advice and let you call your ex girlfriend to say, sorry I didn't respond when your grandma passed away, but we cool now?
Amber
Yeah.
Brooke
Two thumbs up.
Cash (Listener)
See, it sounds weird when you say
Jeffrey
it, right, but when you say it, it's going to be flawless.
Brooke
Absolutely.
Jeffrey
During your awkward Tuesday phone call. Right after this.
Cash (Listener)
It's awkward.
Brooke
It's Tuesday.
Jose
It's awkward Tuesday phone call.
Jeffrey
I'm gonna try to quickly recap this so we can get to your awkward Tuesday phone call. It's Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. But a listener of ours named Cash reached out to us, and I don't think we've ever done a call quite like this before because he dated a young woman named Amber for a few years on and off. She dumped him and his buddy suggested that he go cold turkey.
Brooke
Yeah.
Jeffrey
Doesn't respond to her texts. No calling her at night. Well, zero contact.
Brooke
They'd been in that up and down cycle of breaking up, getting back together for a long time.
Jose
Exactly. It wasn't an easy breakup necessarily.
Jeffrey
And guess what? She reached out to him more than once.
Brooke
Yeah.
Jeffrey
And he stayed strong.
Brooke
Yeah.
Jeffrey
Until one night when she sent a text saying, hey, my grandma just passed away.
Brooke
A grandma that he knew, too.
Jeffrey
And what did Cash do? Nothing. Like he was supposed to. And that was a month ago. And now he's looking back, pretty regretful about not being there for her in her time of need. And Cash, it definitely sounds like you do miss her and you want to mend this friendship while still leaving the door open to the possibility of maybe more. Is that right?
Cash (Listener)
I mean, I guess never say never.
Brooke
Which is exactly what your friends don't want you to say, but. Okay.
Jeffrey
But Justin Bieber wants you to say that, so that's good. Brooke, how do you recommend he accomplish that? Through this phone call.
Brooke
What do you think I have? I think you need to realize, Cash, is that you left her on red after she texted you when she needed
Jeffrey
you like you were supposed to.
Jose
Good.
Brooke
So when you. I mean, honestly, this call is gonna come off like you're the one calling for a booty call.
Cash (Listener)
Oh.
Brooke
You know what I'm saying? Like, you only call her when you need something, not when she needs something.
Cash (Listener)
I didn't think of that.
Brooke
Yeah. So to save you from looking like a terrible person, I think you need to maybe say, hey, did you get the flowers? Well, I think. He never says, I sent them, but, like, did you get the flowers? Like, maybe let her just assume.
Jeffrey
What do you think about that, Cash? Imply that flowers were sent. Implied.
Cash (Listener)
I mean, I guess that's one way to do it.
Jeffrey
It's not the worst idea I've ever heard. Jose, what do you think?
Jose
Well, it does look bad that you didn't respond to her for 30 days. All right, so that's why I think you need to say something along the lines of, I've been so broken up over this, over your grandma passing away.
Brooke
Oh, you're.
Jose
I'm now finally emotionally available to make this phone call.
Brooke
It was harder on you than it was on her.
Jose
She loved her grandma, bro.
Brooke
Right. Won't make her mad at all.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Come on.
Jeffrey
So you've got two pieces of advice, Two mediocre lies that you can toss her way.
Cash (Listener)
Wow, you guys are making it tough on me.
Jeffrey
I mean, you're the one who dug this hole for yourself, so we're giving you a ladder to maybe climb out.
Cash (Listener)
I guess you're right.
Jeffrey
You're ready.
Brooke
That's what you mean. I'm ready.
HomeServe Announcer
Here we go.
Jose
Doesn't sound very mentally athletic.
Jeffrey
Let's get ready to lie to your ex girlfriend. I'm dialing your number right now. Here we go.
Jose
Let's go.
Amber
Hello?
Cash (Listener)
Hey.
Amber
Why are you calling me?
Cash (Listener)
Well, it's been a while.
Amber
I know how long it's been.
Cash (Listener)
Right. So I just. I guess I kind of felt bad about how things ended and.
Amber
Okay,
Cash (Listener)
I wasn't in a really great place, but I just feel like neither
Amber
was I, so that's not an excuse, but. Okay, You can keep talking at any time. I had nothing to say.
Cash (Listener)
I mean, you seem angry, so I'm trying. I'm just doing my best.
Amber
Okay. If you have nothing to say, then I'll. I'll ask a question. How come I haven't heard from you for months and I was texting you and you never responded ever?
Cash (Listener)
Because I just Wasn't in a good place. I didn't.
Amber
Yeah, you said that already. Neither was I. Come up with a better excuse.
Cash (Listener)
Listen, I can explain it to you.
Amber
You're talking flow.
Cash (Listener)
That's not the first time you said that to me. Oh, my God.
Amber
I am aware I also have a memory of our relationship. No matter how long.
Cash (Listener)
If you have a memory, then you know that it was basically, we're in a toxic cycle, the same over and over again. So me not responding to you was an effort to break that.
Amber
Why are you calling me now? What's the point? Why are you calling me now?
Cash (Listener)
Because I feel bad about the way things. I felt bad about not responding when your grandmother died. I felt like I couldn't at that point. And it took me a while to process. Almost 30 days.
Amber
It took you a while to process my grandmother?
Cash (Listener)
Okay, so how is this funeral?
Amber
Funny thing about the whole situation.
Cash (Listener)
There's something funny about that situation.
Amber
Well, I mean, you're asking how the funeral is. Was. And I'm telling you that when I sent that text, I thought she was gonna die that night. But she didn't.
Cash (Listener)
Wait, what?
Amber
She, you know, pulled through. So there was no funeral. She's still alive.
Cash (Listener)
Your grandmother dying.
Radio 831 Podcast Host
Awkward.
Amber
But she looked like she was almost dead.
Cash (Listener)
Your grandmother always looked like she was almost dead.
Jeffrey
Guys. Amber? Amber, can you hear us?
Amber
Wait, I'm sorry. Who is that? Who's on this call?
Jeffrey
Yeah, this is a radio show. We're called Brooke and Jeffrey in the Morning. Yes, and we're doing a segment here. It's called the Awkward Tuesday Phone Call. Because you're.
Amber
Called me on a radio show.
Brooke
Dude. It has been eating him up that he didn't respond after that. Grandma.
Amber
Yeah, I'm sure. I'm sure it has.
Brooke
Do you not believe that?
Amber
No, I don't.
Cash (Listener)
Grandmother dying?
Amber
I didn't lie. I genuinely thought she was going to die. But then you never responded, so why would I update you?
Brooke
I mean, I feel like there's good
Jeffrey
points on both sides.
Brooke
Like why would you respond to your own text? So never mind.
Amber
Exactly.
Cash (Listener)
Why would you presume somebody dead before they're dead? I don't know.
Amber
My mom told me she was about to die that night and.
Cash (Listener)
Are you a priest?
Brooke
What does that have to do with anything?
Amber
A priest?
Jeffrey
Okay, I understand that this situation wasn't handled the best way, maybe on either side.
Brooke
You're an odd match to me.
Jose
That's probably why they worked.
Jeffrey
Yeah. There's a lot of history there, obviously. A lot of fire and chemistry and we're trying to get back to before the break in. Communication?
Cash (Listener)
Yeah, when we broke up. Something you don't know. My friends told me to go cold turkey and not talk to you. What?
Amber
Why would they even get involved?
Cash (Listener)
Well, because I think they saw the cycle that I was talking about.
Amber
Yeah, but normally there's a conversation when a friendship ends. Or anything ends.
Cash (Listener)
Normally we had one. It was a conversation with me, remember? You broke up with me, Right?
Amber
Yeah, but you could have, like, responded.
Jeffrey
He wanted to respond, but his friends wouldn't let him.
Brooke
That doesn't sound good, Joe.
Amber
Okay, so you only do what your friends tell you.
Jeffrey
Ignore what I just said, go back to arguing with each other.
Cash (Listener)
It wasn't just my friends. It was obvious.
Amber
Oh, my God. So who else have you talked to about us?
Jeffrey
You know what? I think what you need to do, Cash, is just tell her what you want.
Brooke
And, yeah, moving forward. Let's look forward.
Jeffrey
What do you want to get in the future?
Cash (Listener)
Well, I was hoping despite all this fake death, we could maybe go back to having some kind of friendship, because I have missed you.
Amber
Awkward.
Jeffrey
Oops. I meant to hit the aw button.
Brooke
Yeah, my bad.
Jeffrey
Okay, we're running out of time for our segment here, Amber, so I don't want to rush you into this, but what do you think?
Amber
Honestly, right now, I don't think I want to be your friend at the moment. Just, I. I don't think I want it anymore.
Brooke
So that's a good boundary.
Jeffrey
Well, Cash, call us back in two weeks and we can try this all over again. I'm sure it'll go better.
Amber
No, thanks.
Jose
We'll call the grandma.
Jeffrey
Yeah, we'll see how she's doing.
Cash (Listener)
Let me know when your grandmother really dies.
Jose
Don't say that.
Cash (Listener)
Oh, sorry. My condolences again.
Radio 831 Podcast Host
Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning.
HomeServe Announcer
It never happens at a good time. The pipe bursts at midnight. The heater quits on the coldest night. Suddenly, you're overwhelmed. That's when Homeserv is here. For 4.99amonth, you're never alone. Just call their 24.7hotline, and a local pro is on the way. Trusted by millions, Homeserve delivers peace of mind when you need it most. For plans starting at just 4.99amonth, go to homeserve.com. that's homeserve.com not available everywhere. Most plans range between $4.99 to $11.99 a month. Your first year terms apply on covered repairs.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance. And now we're customizing this ad for your morning commute to wake you up, which could help your driving. Science says that stimulating the brain increases alertness, so here's a pop quiz. How many months have 28 days? What gets wetter as it dries? What has keys but can't open? Locks. If you don't want to hear the answers, turn off this Liberty Mutual ad now. 12 months, a towel, piano. Enjoy being fully alert.
Cash (Listener)
Liberty. Liberty. Liberty.
Jeffrey
Liberty. You know they're hooking up tonight, right?
Brooke
No. There's no way.
Jeffrey
That's the type of couple that can't stay together but can't stay away from each other.
Jose
The love is good, dude.
Jeffrey
It is.
Brooke
I really heard in her voice that she wants nothing to do with him. Yeah, I'm not gonna lie, Jeff.
Jose
I'd like to agree with Jeff, but
Jeffrey
I think I know I heard the same thing in her voice, but in her body. That's a totally different story.
Jose
I'm telling you, bro is yearning.
Jeffrey
That's right.
Brooke
Money on this one.
Jeffrey
That's the vibe. That's the vibe that I got during the call. A lot of fireworks there, both good and bad, clearly.
Brooke
See, I got her just railroading him, like, just running him over.
Jeffrey
He would love to be railroaded tonight.
Brooke
I guarantee you my mom, the wrong thing.
Jeffrey
They definitely wanted to step back and process. Process what just happened. My money is on them processing it together. Close off.
Brooke
No way, man.
Jose
This makes me want to call them in, like, a week and be like, okay, guys, yeah, yeah.
Brooke
I don't think we're ever gonna get an update because I don't think they're ever gonna talk again. That's my money. That's my bad.
Jeffrey
Oh, that's too bad. But you know what? If you want to do some processing, you can go process the content on our podcast. A lot of good stuff on there.
Jose
Good segue.
Jeffrey
You find us at Brooke and Jeffrey. Listen, close off if you want.
Liberty Mutual Announcer
Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance, and now we're customizing this ad for your morning commute to wake you up, which could help your driving. Science says that stimulating the brain increases alertness, so here's a pop. How many months have. 28 days. What gets wetter as it dries? What has keys but can't open? Locks. If you don't want to hear the answers, turn off this Liberty Mutual ad now. 12 months, a towel, piano. Enjoy being fully alert.
Cash (Listener)
Liberty. Liberty.
Jose
Liberty.
Cash (Listener)
Liberty.
Superhuman Podcast Host
Imagine an Olympics where doping is not only legal, but encouraged. It's the Enhanced Games. Some call it grotesque. Others say it's unleashing human potential. Either way, the podcast Superhuman documented it all embedded in the Games and with the athletes for a full year.
Brooke
Within probably 10 days I put on 10 pounds.
Jeffrey
I was having trouble stopping the muscle growth.
Superhuman Podcast Host
Listen to Superhuman on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Brooke
The story I've told myself can then shape my behavior and that can lead me to sabotage the possibility of connection
Debbie Brown
this Mental Health Awareness Month. Tune into the podcast Deeply well with Debbie Brown if you've been searching for a soft place to land while doing the work to become this podcast is for you. To hear more. Listen to Deeply well with Debbie Brown from the Black Effect Podcast Network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Radio 831 Podcast Host
Why are we all so obsessed with romance on the Radio 831 podcast? Join us Sanjanah Bhasker and Tyler McCall as we unpack all the trending tropes, buzzy adaptations, booktok drama and celebrity love stories with hot takes and sharp guests. Each episode digs into what these stories reveal about desire, fantasy, identity and how we love. Now Listen to the Radio 831 podcast on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
Jose
American Soccer is about to explode.
Jeffrey
The World cup is coming. Ramer sending on Ernie Stewart the Chip. I'm Tab Ramos.
Jose
I'm Tom Bogle. On our podcast Inside American Soccer, you'll get the real storylines, the biggest decisions, and the truth about the U.S. national team.
Cash (Listener)
It wouldn't be a huge surprise if
Jeffrey
our team ends up in the quarterfinals or potentially a great run into the semifinals.
Jose
Listen to Inside American Soccer with Tom Boger and Tab ramos on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcast.
In this episode of “Awkward Tuesday Phone Call,” listener Cash needs help navigating a tricky situation with his ex-girlfriend, Amber. After two years of an on-again, off-again relationship and a recent breakup, Cash went “cold turkey”—cutting off all contact per his friends’ advice. Months later, he ignored Amber’s text about her grandmother dying, and now he regrets his silence. Cash wants to break the ice and apologize, but things get truly awkward when the phone call takes a turn—revealing the “death” may have been a false alarm. The team tries to guide Cash through this emotional minefield, resulting in memorable cringe, honest revelations, and trademark group banter.
[14:13–20:14] (Main event segment—highlights below)
Opening Cold
Confrontation & Justification
Critical Reveal — Granny’s Still Alive!
Hosts Go Public
Defensiveness, Blame, and Mockery
Ending with Humor and Awkwardness
The episode balances genuine emotion (regret, vulnerability) with the familiar, playful irreverence of the “Brooke and Jeffrey” crew. There’s open mockery, practical advice, and honest moments of cringe (“Let me know when your grandmother really dies.”), along with the signature energy fans expect. The segment showcases just how dramatically and awkwardly relationship miscommunications can spiral, providing both entertainment and moments of real empathy—albeit laced with sarcasm.
A classic “Awkward Tuesday Phone Call” saga: Cash tries to right a cold-shouldered wrong, only to find the crisis (and the relationship) is not what it seemed. Amber’s revelation—that her grandmother is alive—serves as a final twist in their cycle of miscommunication. Ultimately, Amber asserts her boundary, and the hosts leave the door (barely) open for more drama in the future. If you like your relationship drama awkward, funny, and fairly raw, this episode delivers from start to finish.