Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Episode: Awkward Tuesday: Girls Trip Mystery

Release Date: November 4, 2025
Host: Brooke & Jeffrey (with Matt Rogers, Maggie Freeling, and others)

Episode Overview

This episode’s Awkward Tuesday Phone Call features Mick, who seeks the help of the Brooke and Jeffrey team after his girlfriend Adrian returns from a girls trip and suddenly becomes distant. Mick is worried something happened on the trip—possibly cheating or even something more serious—and is desperate for answers after both Adrian and her friends refuse to talk. The episode unpacks themes of trust, communication struggles in relationships, and the insecurity that can arise when partners act evasively after group outings.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Setting the Scene: “Girl Code” and Relationship Mysteries

• The hosts banter about the mysterious nature of girls’ trips compared to the typically “innocent” narrative of boys’ weekends.
• Quote [04:09]:
  • Jeffrey: "Everyone knows about bro code, but what about lady laws?"
  • Brooke: "Nobody calls it that."
  • Jeffrey: "The Gal Guide?"
  • Brooke: "I like these."
  • Jeffrey: "The she Scrolls."
• [04:19] Jeffrey contextualizes the episode, teasing that Mick suspects something happened during Adrian's girls trip and needs the hosts’ help to get answers.

2. Mick Shares His Concerns

• Mick explains that after a year of dating, Adrian is suddenly avoiding him post-trip (not returning texts, refusing to meet up).

• He’s tried to get information from her friends, but they stonewall him:

  • Quote [07:16]:
    • Mick: "They say if she wants to talk about it, she can, but they can't."
  • Jeffrey and Brooke suggest that such a vague response is a red flag.

• Mick’s main fears:

  1. Adrian may have gotten hurt.
  2. Adrian may have cheated.
  • Quote [07:46]:
    • Mick: "I'm worried she got hurt."
    • Brooke: "Oh, what?"
    • Mick: "I'm kind of worried about cheating, but, you know, people party, things get wild."

3. The Hosts’ Advice & Strategy

• Brooke suggests a “worst-case scenario” approach: Speculate something so outrageous that Adrian will be relieved to confess the real (lesser) truth.
  • Quote [11:18]:
    • Brooke: "Really speculate something even worse...Did you kill someone?"
  • Mick and the hosts joke the suggestion lightens the mood but agree it might lower Adrian’s guard.

4. The Awkward Phone Call

• [12:48–18:49]
• Mick gets through to Adrian by calling from a different number. The call quickly turns uncomfortable as he presses Adrian for details.
• Adrian gets defensive when Mick says he talked to her friends:
  • Quote [14:46]:
    • Adrian: "You should not be talking to my friends."
• After Mick expresses his worry and desperation, Adrian finally reveals the key event:
  • Quote [15:27]:
    • Adrian: "I never cheated on you, if that's what you're implying. Not once."
• The true story:
  • Adrian confesses that a semi-famous (former Bachelorette contestant) man who was present on the trip flirted heavily with her.
  • This led her to question if she was “dating down” and whether she should be with someone more exciting, causing her withdrawal from Mick.
  • Quote [16:24]:
    • Adrian: "...it just made me question things, like, if I settled and am I dating down, because he was, like, ripped."
• Adrian insists she did not cheat, but admits she is re-evaluating her relationship.

5. The Unexpected Twist: Adrian’s Reality TV Aspirations

• Adrian says the attention from a reality TV personality inspired her to start auditioning for reality shows herself and that she’s actively submitting audition tapes.
  • Quote [18:30]:
    • Adrian: "...I've been thinking, and I do really want to be on a reality TV show. And this week, I've been submitting audition tapes."

6. Mick Professes His Feelings — at the Worst Time

• In a (misguided) attempt to fix things, Mick declares his love for Adrian for the first time mid-call:
  • Quote [19:24]:
    • Mick: "I'm sorry I haven't told you this yet, but, like, I love you."
  • Adrian, clearly overwhelmed, says she needs a break.

7. The Outcome and Aftermath

• The hosts try to support Mick and offer some sympathy, but also warn him not to “watch ABC at 8pm weeknights” in case Adrian makes an appearance on reality TV.
  • Quote [19:57]:
    • Jeffrey: "Nick, man, I wish you the best, but I would recommend you don't watch ABC at 8pm weeknights. That's Eastern time."
• In the final wrap-up, the hosts debate whether the episode counts as a "successful" resolution for the couple, ultimately concluding that at least Mick got the truth.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

• [11:18] Brooke: “Really speculate something even worse...Did you kill someone?”
• [14:49] Adrian (defensively): "You should not be talking to my friends."
• [15:27] Adrian: "I never cheated on you, if that's what you're implying. Not once."
• [16:24] Adrian: "...it just made me question things, like if I settled and am I dating down because he was, like, ripped."
• [18:30] Adrian: "I just have to be totally honest with you...I do really want to be on a reality TV show."
• [19:24] Mick: "I'm sorry I haven’t told you this yet, but, like, I love you."
• [19:57] Jeffrey: "Nick, man, I wish you the best, but I would recommend you don’t watch ABC at 8pm weeknights."

Key Timestamps for Major Segments

• [04:03]: Teasing the episode's core mystery (the “girls’ trip mystery”)
• [06:27]: Mick explains his and Adrian’s relationship background
• [07:16]: The friends' evasive response is explained
• [11:18]: The hosts debate and offer their advice/phone call strategy
• [12:48]: The awkward call with Adrian begins
• [14:46]: Adrian gets defensive about friends being involved
• [15:27]: Adrian reveals the “no cheating” boundary
• [16:24]: Adrian admits to her doubts and feeling tempted by another man
• [18:30]: Adrian reveals her reality TV ambitions
• [19:24]: Mick tells Adrian he loves her
• [19:57]: Hosts’ post-call wrap-up and reality TV warning

Conclusion

This episode delivers a classic “Awkward Tuesday” phone call storyline full of escalating tension, awkward honesty, relatable insecurity, and a plot twist involving reality TV aspirations. The hosts’ playful tone and willingness to poke fun at the situation lighten the serious undertones of a couple veering toward breakup. Ultimately, the listener (Mick) gets his answer—but not the happy ending he hoped for, as Adrian’s newfound ambitions take center stage, providing a dose of realness about how relationships can unravel not only from infidelity but from shifting aspirations and self-discovery.

If you want to listen to more Awkward Tuesday Phone Calls or submit your story, follow Brooke and Jeffrey on your favorite podcast platform!