Closure Call: Switch Sitch

Summary

Podcast Summary: Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Episode Title: Closure Call: Switch Sitch
Release Date: April 20, 2025
Host/Author: iHeartPodcasts

---

Introduction

In this emotionally charged episode of Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update, hosts Brooke and Jeffrey delve into one of their most intense segments yet: a closure call with a listener named Marissa. This episode, titled "Closure Call: Switch Sitch," explores the complexities and emotional turmoil surrounding a claim of being swapped at birth—a narrative that intertwines deception, family secrets, and the quest for identity.

---

Setting the Stage: The Closure Call Segment

The episode begins with Brooke and Jeffrey introducing the concept of a closure call—a dedicated segment where they help listeners seek answers and finality regarding unresolved personal matters. Brooke describes this particular closure call as the most energy-intensive they have undertaken:

Brooke [01:11]: "...this one proves that our producer is amazing. To actually get this person the answers that they needed..."

Jeffrey acknowledges the dedication required to secure such calls, emphasizing the challenge of getting participants to engage:

Jeffrey [01:46]: "Because it's hard to get people to actually answer their phones for second date calls and phone taps."

---

Marissa’s Mysterious Message

Marissa, the guest, shares her unsettling experience of receiving a mysterious direct message from a woman named Aspen on Facebook. Aspen claims that they were accidentally swapped at birth 30 years ago, asserting that Aspen is Marissa's biological sister:

Marissa [03:58]: "She had a crazy story for me. Aspen hit me up. Instant or direct message... she just found out that 30 years ago she was accidentally swapped at birth for another baby... that baby was me."

Initially skeptical, Marissa dismissed the message as a potential scam due to its bizarre nature. However, Aspen provided compelling evidence, including photos strikingly similar to Marissa’s and her parents':

Marissa [05:52]: "The photos looked exactly like me of her parents."

---

Producer’s Tenacity and Efforts

Brooke and Jeffrey highlight the relentless efforts of their producer, Boyd, who spent a year tracking down Aspen to facilitate this closure call. Boyd's dedication is praised for finally eliciting responses from Aspen's side:

Brooke [02:21]: "And now, after a full year of our producer tracking this person down... we finally got some answers."

Jeffrey underscores the emotional weight of this achievement:

Jeffrey [11:55]: "She says I made up a fake Facebook account for her because I was too ashamed to speak directly to you."

---

Revelations and Emotional Turmoil

As the closure call progresses, significant revelations surface. Aspen admits that she fabricated the initial contact, revealing that the swap at birth was not accidental but a result of Aspen’s inability to raise Marissa:

Aspen [12:03]: "I made it up... I gave you up for adoption at birth."

This confession shatters Marissa’s hopes for straightforward answers, introducing doubt and confusion. Marissa grapples with the conflicting narratives, questioning the authenticity of both Aspen’s claims and her parents' silence:

Marissa [15:14]: "I really don't know what to believe. I'm really curious to know what she does next."

---

Psychological Impact and Listener Support

The hosts and fellow team members express empathy and concern for Marissa’s emotional state, acknowledging the psychological impact of such revelations. They encourage Marissa to approach the situation cautiously, suggesting DNA testing and involving her current parents in any future discussions with Aspen:

Brooke [16:34]: "My instinct would be this woman, because you don't even know her. You would trust your parents more."

Jeffrey [16:43]: "You need to bring your current parents with the biological mom and have them meet."

Listeners also reach out with support, emphasizing the community aspect of the show and the importance of seeking truth amidst uncertainty.

---

Conclusion: An Unresolved Journey

The episode concludes without definitive closure, leaving Marissa with more questions than answers. The hosts express their commitment to continue supporting her journey, hoping for future closure:

Brooke [17:15]: "Yeah. If she does meet up with your biological mom. If she is your biological mom."

Jeffrey [17:25]: "We'll stay in touch with you, and hopefully we can do a closure call update and figure out what's really going on."

The final moments highlight the complexity of identity and familial bonds, underscoring that some closures evolve into ongoing quests for truth.

---

Notable Quotes

• Brooke [03:01]: "Or being forced by their friends to listen to us."
• Jeffrey [05:33]: "Dad forefathers of babies don't know."
• Marissa [07:01]: "I'm just kind of freaked out, to be honest. Like, this is the weirdest thing that I think has ever happened to me."

---

Final Thoughts

This episode of Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update masterfully navigates the intricate layers of personal identity, deception, and the quest for closure. Through Marissa's story, listeners are invited to contemplate the profound implications of family secrets and the enduring human desire to uncover one's true origins. The heartfelt discussions, combined with the hosts' unwavering support, make "Closure Call: Switch Sitch" a compelling and thought-provoking installment in the podcast series.

Transcript

[Jeffrey]

You need to check out legends.com today. Legends is a free to play social casino and sportsbook with all of the games that you know and love. They even have Plinko and live blackjack and that's L E G e n d z.com whether you're a seasoned player or just starting out, their games are designed to entertain and thrill. The best part is you get free coins every day so you can play for free. And redemption to your bank account is instant. It's legit and new players get an exclusive welcome bonus. Join thousands of players on legends with a Z.com today. No problem. Purchase necessary Legends International void where prohibited by law 18 + terms and conditions apply.

[Brooke]

You found it. The second Date Update podcast. It's Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. Thank you so much for being here and we love hearing how you found us. I know we've gotten a lot of comments about viral tick tocks about people finding us even on Facebook. Oh yeah.

[Jose]

Or being forced by their friends to listen to us.

[Brooke]

Oh, that's always when people say that one. Yeah, yeah, that's always a good one. And today we got a special treat. It's a closure call. If you haven't heard one of these, you know, like you've said before, Jose, it's kind of the most intense segment that we do. Yeah. And this one, out of all the closure calls we've ever done, definitely took the most amount of energy to make it happen for.

[Alex]

Yeah, I mean, think about it. Some people hold all this weight for so long to actually get that closure or have that conversation that they never had. Yeah, it could be crazy.

[Brooke]

And honestly, this one proves that our producer is amazing. To actually get this person the answers that they needed, the fact that he.

[Alex]

Can remember the next day, even follow up, is impressive to me.

[Jose]

Good thing he won't hear this to know we actually like him.

[Alex]

That's a great point.

[Brooke]

Good point. All right. Hey, here's the closure call. Enjoy.

[Jeffrey]

Despite what everyone listening may think, it actually takes a lot of work to put on this mediocre radio show.

[Brooke]

Go preach, Jeffrey.

[Jeffrey]

Mediocre. That's a generous term.

[Brooke]

Yeah, thank you.

[Jeffrey]

Because it's hard to get people to actually answer their phones for second date calls and phone taps.

[Alex]

So many failed ones.

[Brooke]

I blame Jinzy.

[Jose]

You can blame us. I'm not answering.

[Jeffrey]

Sometimes we wait days or weeks to get a response. But nothing compares to what our producer had to go through to make today's closure call happen. Cuz this all started when one of our listeners received a mysterious message on Facebook. And what it said was so shocking, she had to find out if it was true.

[Brooke]

Oh, my God.

[Jeffrey]

And now, after a full year of our producer tracking this person down, trying to convince them to respond, we finally got some answers. And it might be the most emotional email that we've ever had to send. You're gonna understand why in your brand new closure call. Next. We've been doing the closure calls for a while now, but today is a first.

[Brooke]

Oh, why?

[Jeffrey]

Because we reached out to someone that our listener has never even met before.

[Brooke]

Wait, what?

[Jeffrey]

Never seen in person either.

[Brooke]

Why would you need closure for someone who is not part of your life at all?

[Alex]

How does that work?

[Jeffrey]

These are good questions that we should ask her, but they desperately need to get closure on this. And from the little bit that I do know, it is a very interesting, very shocking, mysterious story.

[Brooke]

Okay. Because at first I was thinking, why is our producer picking this person? Yeah.

[Jeffrey]

Let's ask some of these questions to Marissa. And welcome to the show. Hey, Marissa. How's it going?

[Marissa]

Hey, guys. It's going okay. How are you?

[Alex]

Good.

[Brooke]

Confused.

[Alex]

Are you, like, hitting up, like, Madonna to ask her why she's not making music anymore?

[Brooke]

She's actually still making music.

[Jeffrey]

Yeah.

[Marissa]

Good music.

[Alex]

Thank you, Jeff.

[Brooke]

Okay, thanks for the old reference.

[Jeffrey]

We can speculate, but let's just have Marissa tell us what made you email the show for help.

[Marissa]

Okay, so this is kind of a crazy story. It kind of blows my mind too. But this. This chick named Aspen hit me up. Instant or direct message?

[Brooke]

Okay.

[Marissa]

And she had a crazy story for me.

[Brooke]

Did she tell you the story right away, or was it one of those, like. I don't know, she's setting you up for a scam or something? Yeah, exactly.

[Alex]

Yeah, exactly.

[Marissa]

Funny you mentioned that. I thought it was a scam at first because it was so crazy, but she said she just found out that 30 years ago she was accidentally swapped at birth for another bab at the hospital, and that baby was me.

[Brooke]

What?

[Jeffrey]

What?

[Brooke]

Whoa, wait, she's claiming. How would she know? What?

[Marissa]

Yeah, Swap Sisters. I was like, okay, that sounds really weird.

[Jeffrey]

Like, swap Sisters. Dude, it sounds like a show on tlc.

[Brooke]

She's saying your parents aren't your parents. That they're her parents.

[Marissa]

Yeah. Crazy, right? So I deleted it.

[Brooke]

Yeah.

[Jeffrey]

Oh, you thought it was a scam?

[Alex]

I would have had questions.

[Brooke]

No way, dude. I would think it's a. I mean.

[Jose]

You can tell if you're related to your.

[Brooke]

Well, I mean, if you do a DNA test. I mean, you can do those Tests. And a lot of people are finding out stuff like. Like, oh, that's not really my dad is usually how it goes down.

[Jeffrey]

Oh, Brooklyn knows. Yeah, totally.

[Brooke]

Typically, you know who your mom is?

[Alex]

Yeah, kind of makes more sense.

[Marissa]

She sent me another message and she's like, this is not a scam. So I hit up my parents and I was like, mom, dad, can you tell me about this? And they seem totally shocked.

[Brooke]

Well, that's what happens with SWAT babies. The parents don't know. That's the big, like, to do about it, right? It's like back in the day, they'd take the babies into a room. Now, you're never separated from your baby after you give birth.

[Alex]

Really?

[Brooke]

Yeah, unless you ask them to take it away so you can sleep.

[Jeffrey]

So your parents who raised you, they didn't believe it.

[Marissa]

They thought it was a scam, too. Like some elaborate AI thing.

[Brooke]

Oh, my gosh. So wait, did you go to Aspen's page? Could you see any resemblance?

[Marissa]

Well, so she sent me some pictures, and what's weird is the photos looked exactly like me of her parents.

[Brooke]

Wait, what?

[Alex]

Oh, you look like her parents?

[Marissa]

Yeah. So I finally wrote back here, and I was like, how do you know all this information? Yeah, and what else can you tell me?

[Brooke]

What else can you tell me? Okay, what'd she say?

[Marissa]

Her last message was something totally mysterious. She thinks her mom and dad might know about it, but they're so mad at me for bringing it up, they won't talk about it.

[Brooke]

Oh, so she's saying she actually doesn't even know all the details. She just knows that their family all knows. It's like some big family secret and.

[Alex]

They don't want to.

[Marissa]

Yeah, I think she might have gotten in trouble for even reaching out to me.

[Alex]

So the fact that they don't want any information or, hey, drop it. Like that makes it sound like it is legit. But why would this, like, stop asking questions?

[Brooke]

Like, I mean, I guess, like, if you have an adult child, right, you've raised them your whole life, and then you just then find out that they were swapped at birth. It's like, you can't just be like.

[Alex]

I know you're 23, but we're sending you back to the hospital.

[Jeffrey]

Switch. What's that saying? Like, you know, not knowing is bliss.

[Brooke]

Ignorance is.

[Jeffrey]

Ignorance is bliss. Maybe that was their stance on it.

[Brooke]

So, like, how are you feeling?

[Marissa]

I'm just kind of freaked out, to be honest. Like, this is the weirdest thing that I think has ever happened to me. If it's true, but.

[Jeffrey]

Oh, yeah. And how long has this been going on? You with the back and forth with this girl?

[Marissa]

This happened four years ago.

[Brooke]

Oh, four years ago. Wait, you've been sitting on this for four years?

[Jose]

Did you get DNA tested with your parents?

[Marissa]

No, but I think I found my mom on Facebook, but she wouldn't respond.

[Brooke]

Wait, you're already calling her my mom?

[Jeffrey]

What should she call her?

[Brooke]

Brooke, I think just the woman. I don't know what her name is, but, like, you know that. One for a fact and two, like, your mom is still your mom.

[Marissa]

Yeah.

[Brooke]

I mean, that's crazy. You've got to be happy. Like a whole identity crisis because of this.

[Jeffrey]

And so your biological, biological mom wasn't responding to your messages, and that's when you reached out to us.

[Marissa]

Right? My supposed biological mom that looks like me.

[Brooke]

Oh, my gosh.

[Alex]

Is that the case?

[Brooke]

Wait, is that who you wrote with our producer? You wrote the biological mom with the questions?

[Marissa]

Right.

[Jeffrey]

She actually emailed us about a year ago, it turns out. And our producer has been working on this every single week, trying to soften up the mom in order to respond. Marissa, you know that we wouldn't have you on the show right now if she did didn't answer us.

[Brooke]

She finally answered after a year.

[Alex]

Yeah, she said stop contacting.

[Jeffrey]

We got her responses back a couple days ago.

[Brooke]

Oh, my God. Aspen, are you sitting down? Are you in a safe place? Sorry, I mean, Marissa.

[Marissa]

Yes.

[Jeffrey]

Okay, maybe you should lie down for this one because it could get kind of emotional. But hopefully we can help give you some finality when we do your closure call right after this.

[Marissa]

Thank you.

[Jeffrey]

Just hold on.

[Brooke]

Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning.

[Jeffrey]

This could be such an emotional closure call. I think we need to have some sad piano music for it.

[Brooke]

What? No.

[Jeffrey]

Wait, what? No, I said. I said sad piano. Not bad piano. What is this?

[Brooke]

I see the mix up. Okay. Oh, my God.

[Jeffrey]

See, this is why I have to listen to the music ahead of time. Stop this.

[Brooke]

Yes.

[Jeffrey]

Let me. Let me get some sad piano music, please. No. Okay, now this is not sad. This is fast piano.

[Brooke]

It's kind of impressive.

[Jeffrey]

Yeah, but it doesn't fit the tone. Stop.

[Brooke]

What is this?

[Alex]

Your father? I feel like it's an evil.

[Jeffrey]

Bring the music down. No, no, no, no. I'm sad. Like emotional music. Okay, after the fast one, I know.

[Brooke]

I want to go back to the happy one.

[Jeffrey]

We're talking about swapped at birth. Just doesn't feel right anymore.

[Alex]

You missed your. You missed your window.

[Brooke]

You say it with frustration. You're Frustrated at the music.

[Jeffrey]

I'm not. But swapped at birth, this is something that you don't hear about much anymore, thankfully, because the hospitals are better at not doing it. But 30 years ago.

[Brooke]

Or they're better at hiding it.

[Jeffrey]

Yeah, maybe that' 30 years ago, though, it did happen to one of our listeners. Marissa maybe got a random message on her socials from a girl named Aspen claiming to be her swap sister.

[Brooke]

Yeah.

[Jeffrey]

Saying they were accidentally swapped at the hospital and they've been raised by each other's parents for years.

[Brooke]

Which, by the way, I wouldn't Google search the term swap sister. I just think that you're gonna end up with something you don't want to see.

[Jeffrey]

That's not an official term. Aspen came up with it, but the thing is, the details about it were a little bit sketchy and there was some hesitation to answer everything. That's why a year ago, Marissa reached out to us asking if we could contact her biological mom for her and hopefully get her some closure on what really happened.

[Alex]

Usually if you hit us up a year in advance, we don't get to it just because we're lazy. Apparently our producer's been working on this a lot.

[Jeffrey]

We're running out of time thanks to all the bad piano music, so we better just get to it. We sent four questions to Marissa's mom. Marissa, are you ready to hear some answers to this? I know you've been waiting a long time.

[Marissa]

Yes. Yes, I am.

[Brooke]

What musical track do you want him to play behind it when he reads it?

[Alex]

It's not important. Why are we focusing on?

[Jose]

Maybe it's not your tears in the back when you start crying during this.

[Brooke]

I. I'm joking. I'm joking, Marissa. I mean, this is crazy because, I mean, you're going to finally know. Hopefully you're going to hear from the mom.

[Marissa]

Yeah, yeah. I mean, this has been a time coming just getting some of these answers I've been looking for. You know, it's just been such a mystery.

[Jeffrey]

Let's get to the first one. And this is going to be the first time I've read the answers too. I was just handed the sheet with what she wrote back.

[Brooke]

You needed to pre read them, Jeff, so that you weren't crying.

[Alex]

Producer Boyd went through all this.

[Jeffrey]

I'm sure I needed to focus on the piano music is what I needed.

[Brooke]

Let's get to the focus harder. So it would have gone better, but sure.

[Jeffrey]

Question one. We said your daughter Aspen reached out to me years ago, telling me you were my real biological mom.

[Brooke]

Right.

[Jeffrey]

Is this true? So she wrote back.

[Brooke]

Oh, my gosh. Are you ready for this?

[Marissa]

Yes, please.

[Jeffrey]

Okay, because if you said no, we would have had to stop the segment, and that would have been really annoying.

[Alex]

Jeff has a Blake. Y'all ready for this?

[Jeffrey]

She wrote back. It is true. But Aspen didn't reach out to you. I did.

[Brooke]

Wait, what?

[Alex]

I need to calm down.

[Brooke]

Wait, I'm confused. I'm confused. So she faked being Aspen?

[Jeffrey]

She says I made up a fake Facebook account for her because I was too ashamed to speak directly to you.

[Brooke]

Oh, my.

[Jeffrey]

I'm sorry.

[Brooke]

So is Aspen the girl that you were really swapped with? Oh, yeah.

[Jeffrey]

Marissa.

[Marissa]

Yeah.

[Brooke]

Are you okay?

[Jeffrey]

Do you have all the answers you need, or would you like to continue?

[Brooke]

Hey, check on her. She sounds upset.

[Jeffrey]

Are you okay?

[Marissa]

No, it's. It's just shocking. It's amazing and shocking, and I. I can't thank you guys enough for reaching out to her and helping me, but.

[Alex]

I mean, it's not.

[Brooke]

So wait, so you just believe her straight out the gate, like, this is a woman who's faking to be Aspen?

[Marissa]

Yeah, I mean, I really don't know what to believe. I'm really curious to know what she does next.

[Alex]

Sounds like you almost want it to be real.

[Jeffrey]

Well, let's get to the second question, which was, tell me what you know about me getting swapped at birth. How did you find out about that? She wrote back. Well, honestly, when I reached out four years ago, I made it up.

[Brooke]

Oh, what? Wait, she says, who is she?

[Jeffrey]

Then I knew I wanted to speak with you, but I didn't know how to do it without making it seem like I was a terrible parent. Because the truth is, I gave you up for adoption at birth.

[Alex]

All the twists and turns.

[Jeffrey]

She said. I'm sorry again.

[Alex]

Wait, so she still is your mom, but it wasn't a swat.

[Jeffrey]

Okay, so she was ashamed to admit the truth.

[Brooke]

Did you know you were adopted by your.

[Marissa]

By your mom?

[Brooke]

Your parents?

[Jeffrey]

Maybe the parents didn't know that they adopted her?

[Brooke]

No, they definitely could be in the dark, but the mom would be pretty clear.

[Alex]

A lot of paperwork involved, Jeff.

[Brooke]

But why would your parents not come clean with you when you approach them about being swapped at birth? They would know you were, like, gonna find something out.

[Alex]

They weren't lying.

[Marissa]

I don't know. I think it was just too much for them. You know, and just mentioning thing, we're.

[Jeffrey]

Getting a lot of Text in at 78592 from listeners who are supporting you, by the way. Yeah, so keep those coming we're going to forward those to her after the segment so that she could read them all. But this is already going way different than we thought this call was going to be. So I don't know if the third question is going to be relevant still, because again, we write all the questions before we know the answers. But the third question was, how do I know this is really my biological moment? My parents who raised me are both shocked and know nothing about it. Do you have any proof?

[Brooke]

That's still a valid question. I mean, valid question still.

[Alex]

We're talking right to her.

[Brooke]

Like, what if this is still someone who's. I mean, she already lied about, you know, whole story.

[Marissa]

What? What did she say?

[Jeffrey]

She wrote back, there are birth records that I had you, and we both have the same color blonde hair as I've shown you in the pictures I sent. Yeah, I'm not sure I'm ready for a DNA test, but it would also prove it as well.

[Brooke]

Huh?

[Jeffrey]

I'm sorry, lady. She keeps saying I'm sorry at the end of every answer, so she clearly feels pretty bad.

[Brooke]

Yeah, but she shouldn't feel bad. You have a great life. Like, I mean, if she couldn't provide you with what you needed as a child.

[Alex]

Yeah, well said.

[Marissa]

I don't understand. So that means my parents are lying or something?

[Brooke]

Or she's lying. I mean, somebody's not telling the truth in this situation, that's for sure.

[Jeffrey]

Maybe trying to protect you. One party is trying to protect you from something. But let's go to the fourth question because we are running out of time here. It says, is there anything else that I should know about what happened? We like to leave it kind of open in general for them to fill in the blanks.

[Brooke]

Well, thank God we did, since we didn't know what the hell was going on.

[Jeffrey]

It's definitely taking a turn. But your mom wrote back. She said, there is obviously a lot to tell you, but I'm sure you're angry at me about how I handled it. I am getting older, though, and I just wanted to have a chance to get to meet my daughter and know you. She says, I don't expect you to forgive me, but I would love to meet up with you in person, if you're willing.

[Marissa]

I guess I just need some time to think about it. I mean, I'm curious, too, but I have so many unanswered questions at this moment, even for my parents who raised me.

[Brooke]

You know, I know it feels like you have a lot to deal with before you even think about Meeting up with this woman who claims to be your biological mom. Yeah, like, who's your dad then, too? Like, there's so many.

[Jeffrey]

But again, this is a woman who, like, we've tried to reach out to on Facebook and is clearly used to lying. We don't know if any of this is actually true. So I wouldn't necessarily come in with guns ablaze.

[Brooke]

I totally agree. I would come in super guarded. I mean. Yeah, like I said, somebody's lying to you. My instinct would be this woman, because you don't even know her. You know, you would trust your parents more.

[Jeffrey]

You need to bring your current parents with the biological mom and have them meet, and they. Maybe something will become true.

[Brooke]

What does your birth certificate say?

[Marissa]

I don't know. I haven't really looked at it.

[Jeffrey]

Go get it. We'll wait, maybe come back with it later. But I'm sorry, I know this is a lot of information that was just tossed on you. We'll give you some time to process. But do you feel like maybe it helped get you a step towards closure?

[Marissa]

I feel like I have a lot more questions, to be honest.

[Jeffrey]

Okay.

[Brooke]

Yeah. I was thinking opens everything up, doesn't close anything.

[Jeffrey]

We'll stay in touch with you, and hopefully we can do a closure call update and figure out what's really going on if you do meet up with your biological mom. If she is your biological mom.

[Brooke]

Yeah.

[Marissa]

Okay. Thank you, guys.

[Jeffrey]

All right.

[Brooke]

I just want to give you a hug right now.

[Jeffrey]

Give me some happy piano music to play us out, please. Okay.

[Brooke]

It's kind of tense.

[Alex]

Yeah.

[Jeffrey]

All right. That was a.

[Alex]

That's dramatic.

[Jeffrey]

It's a successful closure call.

[Brooke]

Successful, Jeff.

[Jeffrey]

At all. All right, well, it was a closure call.

[Alex]

Yeah.

[Brooke]

With zero closure.

[Jeffrey]

It's Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. It's what you get when you email us for help.

[Brooke]

Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning.