Second Date Update: Don't Take Me Out To The Ballgame - Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Podcast Summary: Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update – "Don't Take Me Out To The Ballgame"

Episode Information:

Title: Second Date Update: Don't Take Me Out To The Ballgame
Hosts: Brooke and Jeffrey
Publisher: iHeartPodcasts
Release Date: March 28, 2025

1. Introduction

In this episode of Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update, the hosts delve into the complexities of navigating second dates after a less-than-ideal first encounter. The episode centers around listener Noah's experience with his date, April, highlighting the challenges of meeting expectations and the importance of aligning date activities with mutual interests.

2. Listener Feedback and Community Engagement

Brooke and Jeffrey begin by acknowledging and appreciating feedback from their dedicated listeners, fostering a sense of community and interaction. Notable comments include:

Skyler’s Late-Night Listening Habit:
- “I stay up until 1 to 2 am to listen to this podcast slash radio station. I'm obsessed.” (Listener Skyler)
Support from International Listeners:
- A listener from Puerto Rico shares how they translate the podcast for their non-English speaking girlfriend, emphasizing the show's broad reach and impact.

These interactions underscore the show's loyal audience base and the personal connections listeners feel with the hosts.

3. Noah’s Date with April: A Missed Connection

The core of the episode revolves around Noah, a long-time listener, who reached out for advice after his first date with April didn't go as planned.

Initial Date Expectations:
- Noah intended to impress April by tailoring the date to her interest in singing, as she mentioned in her bio. He said, “She loves to sing. I thought taking her to sing somewhere would be fun.” (Noah)
The Baseball Game Surprise:
- Instead of a singing venue like karaoke, Noah took April to a baseball game, aiming for a unique and engaging experience. “I chose a baseball game because of the seventh inning stretch,” Noah explains.
April’s Disappointment:
- The mismatch between the intended activity and April’s expectations led to her feeling disconnected during the date. April shares, “A baseball game is a bad situation for a first date because you're not even facing each other.”

4. Analyzing the Misstep

Brooke and Jeffrey analyze where Noah’s date went awry:

Mismatch of Interests:
- The primary issue was the misalignment between Noah’s date choice and April’s stated interest in singing. Jeffrey remarks, “You thought a baseball game would incorporate the singing aspect.”
Lack of Communication:
- Noah admits, “I didn't clearly communicate the idea behind taking her to a baseball game.” This lack of clear communication contributed to April’s confusion and lack of enthusiasm.
Emotional Connection:
- The hosts emphasize the importance of shared interests and clear intentions to build an emotional connection, especially on a second date.

5. Facilitating the Second Date

Determined to help Noah and April find common ground, Brooke and Jeffrey orchestrate a live conversation between the two.

April’s Perspective:
- April expresses her desire to sing, stating, “I had my heart set on singing, and I didn’t get to do that on our date.”
Noah’s Apology and Realization:
- Noah acknowledges his mistake, saying, “I was trying to do something unique and safe, but I see now it wasn’t the best choice.”
Rekindling the Connection:
- The hosts offer a platform for Noah to reach out and arrange a more suitable second date. Noah asks, “April, will you please go out on another date with me and have some sushi, have some fun, and please sing as well?” April agrees enthusiastically, signaling a successful resolution.

6. Hosts’ Commentary and Final Thoughts

Brooke and Jeffrey reflect on the episode’s events, highlighting key takeaways:

Importance of Listening:
- “You need to listen to what the other person truly wants,” Brooke advises, emphasizing the need for attentiveness in dating.
Balancing Creativity with Compatibility:
- Jeffrey adds, “It’s great to be creative, but ensuring it aligns with your date’s interests is crucial.”
Encouraging Continuous Improvement:
- The hosts mention that despite Noah and April’s positive outcome, there are numerous listener requests for further improvements and tips, indicating ongoing engagement and support for their audience's dating journeys.

7. Conclusion and Upcoming Content

The episode wraps up with a nod to future content, announcing that more listener stories and second date updates will continue to be featured. Brooke and Jeffrey encourage listeners to submit their own experiences and questions, fostering an interactive and supportive community for those navigating the dating scene.

Notable Quotes:

“I have met so many Latino people that have talked to me and been like, we started listening and we've learned English.” (Listener Feedback)
“A baseball game is a bad situation for a first date because you're not even facing each other.” (April)
“I was trying to do something unique and safe, but I see now it wasn’t the best choice.” (Noah)
“You need to listen to what the other person truly wants.” (Brooke)
“It’s great to be creative, but ensuring it aligns with your date’s interests is crucial.” (Jeffrey)

Episode Highlights:

Listener engagement showcases the podcast's strong community.
Noah’s initial misstep in planning a date rooted in misaligned interests.
Successful mediation leads to a renewed opportunity for Noah and April.
Hosts provide actionable advice on effective dating strategies.

For those interested in more stories and dating advice, tune into Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update available on iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify.

Transcript

Jenny Garth (0:00)

This is Jenny Garth from I do part two. You could have lost 10 pounds already if you started one month ago. So are you ready to start today? Find out if weight loss meds are right for you in just three minutes at tryfh.com try fh.com Results vary based on start weight and adherence to diet, exercise and program goals. Data based on independent study sponsored by Future Health. Future Health is not a healthcare services provider. Meds are prescribed at providers discretion. You need to check out legends.com today. Legends is a free to play social casino and sportsbook with all of the games that you know and love. They even have Plinko and Live Blackjack and that's L E G e n d z.com whether you're a seasoned player or just starting out, their games are designed to entertain and thrill. The best part is you get free coins every day so you can play for free and redemption to your bank account is instant. It's legit and new players get an exclusive welcome bonus. Join thousands of players on legends with a Z.com today. No purchase as necessary. Legends International void where prohibited by law. 18 + terms and conditions apply. Bring spring to your door with target circle 360. Get all you need for Easter hosting spring get togethers and more with unlimited same day Delivery through Target Circle360. From Easter Basket goodies to fresh florals, getting everything the same day is easy. Open the Target app and bring the magic of the season to your door with unlimited same day Delivery through Target Circle360. Visit target.com circle or the Target app for more details. Subscription required Same day delivery is subject to terms applies to orders over $35. Pro savings days are back at Lowe's with limited time savings on the supplies pros need. Get up to 40% off select major appliances plus save an additional $100 on every $1,000 you spend on select major appliances. And don't miss your chance to activate and earn three times the points on select DeWalt and Klein tools Lowes. We help you save valid the 328 selection varies by location while supplies last. See associate or lowe's.com for more details on qualifying items. Want to pull off the season's freshest trends? You just need the right shoes. That's where designer Shoe Warehouse comes in. Loving wide leg jeans? Pair them with sleek low profile sneakers. Obsessed with the sheer trend? Try it with mesh flats. Feeling Boho comfy sandals. Nail the whole free spirited thing. Find on trend shoes from the brands you love like Birkenstock Nike Adidas and more at dsw. All right, it's time for a brand new second date podcast. Thanks for being here with Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. And I'm just gonna say one of our listeners today made a very bold request during the second date. And yes, I am still offended by it. Okay, okay, I am. But I did agree to it anyway. You did? Just to help the guy out. I love when the listeners know the show that well that they can have, you know what I mean, such specific personal personality request. All right, you're gonna hear it in just a second. But first, we got some great comments from our amazing listeners. Thank you so much for being here. We love reading them. Yeah. Oh, Skyler said, I don't know if you saw this one. I stay up until 1 to 2am to listen to this podcast slash radio station. I'm obsessed. Oh, I love that. Someday you'll get old, Skyler, and then you could just listen in the morning. Yeah, you know, that's the nice thing about podcast. You could listen anytime. But I love that I do forget people, like normally do stay up pretty late, like later than us. Yeah, yeah, we wake up early, but yeah, we're early because, I mean, you think it's just a podcast, but we also do a morning radio show. So we're here early. Early. Any other good ones? Okay, so the username isn't a name but a number. Okay, let's not read it. Okay, I'm not gonna read it. It's probably somebody's phone number, but a bunch of numbers. It says listening from Puerto Rico every day. My girl can't speak English and I take time to translate in Spanish. That's how good we love it. Mad love. That is so cool. I have met so many Latino people that have talked to me and been like, we started listening and we've learned English. That's so cute. You translated for your girlfriend. Y. I'm taking Spanish lessons. If you want me to broken translate for you like Yokomo Manzana. I don't think he's going to take you up on that. I'm just curious if he does different voices for each of us. Spanish men that can help as well that are fluent. There you go. There you go. All right, we're going to get to what you really came for. And that's a brand new second date. It's starting right now. Second date update. We've got a loyal listener to the show who says he's been tuning into our second dates for years. That's so cool. Thank you. And one of his worst fears finally came true. Oh, no. He had to email us to be in one of his own. And his name is Noah, so let's talk to him. Noah, I'm happy you're here, even if you're not. Glad you came to us for help. How you doing today? I'm pretty good. How you guys doing? I mean, it is such a double edged sword, right? Like you want to be part of the show, but then you don't. Yeah. Be careful what you wish for, right? Totally. Totally. Well, we'll try to make this as seamless and gentle on you as possible. Let's start with the girl that you met recently. What's her name? April. April. Okay. All right. Strong start. You almost forgot it. I appreciate that. Now I just nervous on the air, it's weird, but. No, you're good. You're good, man. You're doing great. So far our ratings have never been higher, so thank you. 30 seconds in, Jeff. I'm feeling good about it already, so let's keep going. How did you meet April? We met off an app. Dating app. Oh, our ratings just plummeted. You gotta need to be more fun. More fun. By the way, we have a live ratings meter. I'm kidding. Wait, how did you strike up conversation with her? The cool thing about apps, if you do them right, you have little bios and you can get a little nuggets from there. And I was able to kind of tap into a couple things I saw. And it was fun, but okay, she was funny. You know, she doesn't take things too seriously and has a. That kind of fun perspective on life. And that's kind of how I roll. It's. I'd like to think that's me. Oh, that's interesting. I mean, that's a cool thing. Like you guys match up. Your vibes are similar, right. When you're using apps. Right. That's how they work. Right? So yeah. That's awesome. So wait, you're like attributing like that you believed everything in her bio? Everything in your bio is legit and everything checked out. Well, you know, it's funny when she says something like that. She loves to sing. I would think that would be a weird thing to lie about. She's a singer. Okay. Hey, I love to sing, and that does not mean that you have to be good at it. Okay? Wait a minute. This is a good segue, actually. So, uh. Oh, I just said, hey, can I take you somewhere to go sing? And she got excited. Nice so, like, karaoke, right? Like, what is the other option? Well, yeah, karaoke would have been probably a choice. Oh, it wasn't that I chose. I chose a baseball game. A baseball game. Baseball game. Because of the seventh inning stretch. Yes. I know in retrospect, it's regretful, but that's. That's exactly it. Of course, she was bored out of her mind, and I just. I don't know, maybe I built it up too much or something about the singing part, and that's on me. No, I know you can't sing. See, Brooke right now in the studio, but she has never looked more confused and concerned in her entire life. Just the connection between baseball and singing. Yeah, I've never heard anyone make that connection. Like, do you go that hard with Take Me out to the Ball Game that you consider it a performance? Do you not go that hard with it? Brooke, you know, it's something that is fun and, you know, interactive and. And quite honestly, like, the singing's there kind of as an option, but, like, if she didn't want to, she didn't have to. A baseball game is a great date. It's just like, if she didn't know that's where she was going. Did you tell her? Not so much. I was just trying to keep it mysterious and, you know, cool and have a little guessing game. And, I mean, I went. I was all in. I was, like, superstitious with the specific chairs, like, for your team. Yeah, I was really into it. I just. I think this is great. Don't listen to everybody, like, trying to poke holes in your date idea and say that it was horrible or, like, not well said, it was a bad idea. He's not getting a call back right now, so he thinks maybe that was the reason. We don't know and he doesn't know. Well, here's the thing. I thought she would be playful with it and think it was cute, cool, whatever. But no, it was more. It was more eye roll. Eye roll. Eye roll. Ish. Isn't good. Did you guys make it to the seventh inning stretch to finally get to the singing? Long time. Yeah. And. And she was like, when are we singing? So is it something like. She doesn't know that in baseball, the seventh inning, like, in between your. Everybody sings a song together. She did not know that. No. Okay, this is gonna be. That's why I thought that would be cool. Alexa, I didn't know that. I know. That's what I'm saying. But now you say it. I've seen it happen, but I Didn't know. It's a good thing people look forward to. Yeah. Everyone's so happy all of a sudden. Weird lacrosse game. Okay, here's the deal. You know, you guys have done it. It's very, like, contagious. And you get there and. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And it was more just a symbolic gesture, right? Like. Okay, okay. Did you have any fun? Yeah, I mean, I did have fun, but she didn't really have fun, which is what I can. So you just want to redo? Yeah, that's a great word. I'd love a redo. And I need some help, you know, convincing her to do that, but I kind of have a rule for Brooke. Someone listens to the show a lot. Okay, stop you right there, sir. I do not listen to rules. Brooke, just hear it. Just hear him out, okay? He's a big listener to our show. No, he deserves heard you say this on the show to some of the guys. Like, don't say, oh, how much he loves spending time with you. Or he had such a great time with you. Like, don't make me sound simpish. You know, don't say that. He liked you. Ew, Bro. Yeah. Why just me? Like, just make me sound cool. It's a new thing girls do not like. I see. Like, he's pretty indifferent. Yeah. Yeah, you play hard to get. He's got so many options. That's why he called a radio show. Alexis, we're talking. I mean, this is going to be the easiest second day we ever done. If you talk like that to her when we get April on the phone. Seriously? God, I wouldn't go out with him. I think you're leaning too much the other way now. God, that guy's the worst. Okay, now you're jumping off the deep end. We need to find the happy medium when we come back. And reach out to April for your second date update. We'll do it right after this. Hold on. Second date update? We're in the middle of a second date update, and for maybe the first time ever, one of our listeners made a polite request of Brooke is gonna be a thing. Now, I am not the one that ruins dates for people. Okay, you're screaming already, and we're barely even. That was not a scream. Well, whatever it is, I just. Just hear this out. That is my disappointed voice. Okay, all right, well, even that it's coming off a little harsh because he has asked if Brooke can please, if we get this girl on the phone, not make him sound like a total simp by simply just not Saying that he likes her. He's going to regret he didn't ask you to stop saying other things. Besides that. I feel like there's worse. I don't need anyone to pile on. Right. Wow. Noah. Noah is a regular listener to our show and he's noticed that sometimes your sales pitch can make the guy sound a little bit desperate. Like laughing at Brooke. It is so funny. I wish you could see just the way. Guy's a little bit desperate already he's calling us. See, this is not a good look right here. I can. No, I can do this. From what I could understand, Noah wants you to make him sound like he is just a regular dude. He's a little confused. Just wants to know what's up. But hey, not a big deal either way. No, no. Is that right? That's exactly on the nose. Right? Okay. When it comes to chill, I am the chillest. Okay, you don't want Brooke to make you sound cool. I hype Alexis up all the time and look how cool people think she is. People think I'm co. Okay, well, no, we're going to try our best, but I'm dialing April's number right now. Here we go. Hello? Hey, we're looking to speak with April. This is April. Hey, April, thanks for picking up the phone. Yeah, that seems like a little much. Jeffrey. Oh, there's more than one of you? What's happening? Do I know you? I don't know if you know us. We're. We're a radio show called Rook and Jeffrey in the Morning. I'd say hi, April, but I don't know if I'm allowed to. I don't know how not to be myself. You don't have to say anything. Just. Hey, stop. April. April. Oh God, I'm so confused. We do a segment on this show. It's called Second Date Update. Okay, Most people to have that reaction when we tell them Second Date Update, but I don't know if you've heard of it. I. I mean, I've seen it on Tick Tock. Cool. Nice. Okay. I mean, it's not that big of a deal though. No, it's chill. You could always like scroll up if you don't want to watch it. I mean, I do usually scroll past them because I hate a two parter. Okay, well just go to the podcast and you can get all of it together. Brooke, that sounds desperate. It's problem solving, Alexis. Okay. You know, podcast and all that stuff aside, TikTok, whatever. What we're more focused on is one of Our listeners who's been trying to get a hold of you. His name is Noah. Like the guy went on a date with recently. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And, Brooke, why don't you tell April about Noah? Here we go. Noah's cool. He's got a lot of options, and he's just, like, wondering why you're not calling him back. There we go. Wait, hold on. You guys just called me to tell me that Noah has other options? No, that was. Said that. Yeah. He's just chill, you know? Yeah, he doesn't. He doesn't really care one way or the other, okay? He has a little bit of stake in the game. Am I being pranked right now? I can understand why you would think that, but that's not what's happening. We. We just want to know what your take was about your hangout with Noah the other day. I mean, I thought it was bad, or he was. I think it was. No, the question is, when did you start thinking it was bad? I mean, pretty much as soon as we got there, because I guess he was trying to surprise me. But he. I mean, he told me he was going to take me somewhere to sing because he, like, looked at my profile and we had talked about, like, I. I like to sing, and I, like, used to perform, and I don't anymore, so I thought it would be, like, karaoke or an open mic night or something. And he. We. It was a baseball game. Yeah, he knows. I mean, we made it clear that he messed that up. I mean, honestly, I hate sports. Like, I just. I will never be impressed by watching somebody throw or catch or hit a ball. Like, I couldn't care less. I need a plot if I'm going to be watching people do something. I think we get it. You didn't like his choice of D, and that's totally fine. You're allowed to feel that way. But we were more wondering, what did you think about Noah? Like, as a person? Yeah. Did he attempt to help you understand the game, or was he just fun to, like, chat with? Yeah, I mean, not really. A baseball game is kind of a bad situation for a first date because, like, you're not even facing each other, and then I'm like, am I supposed to be talking to you, or am I supposed to be watching the ball? Like, what? Yeah, I have heard that from a lot. I mean, I don't go to games, so I don't know what the vibe is. Gotcha. Okay, look, April, I know this is kind of a weird thing where we just blindside you and ask you all these questions. So thank you for opening up to us. The one thing that you may or may not realize is Noah is also here on the other line listening to this conversation. Oh, great. Oh, she never listens to part two. That's right. She skips all of her TikTok. This is actually the fun part, April, where Noah jumps in. I'm not being pranked. No, it's not a prank. It's not a prank. A small portion. Yeah. No, now's your time to come in and act cool. Go ahead, Noah. Hey. Hey, April, it's Noah. How are you? I mean, weird, I guess. Yeah, sorry. It is weird. The date was weird. Everything's weird. It is weird, Noah. Well, and listen, on that note, let me just. This is something I've been hoping to say to you. So I knew that singing was just something you love to do, and I was not trying to put pressure on you. I was trying to do the exact opposite by taking you somewhere to do something in your comfort zone and have fun. And I'm glad, though, that I was able to hear how you felt, because it helps put things in perspective for me. That was some emotional maturity right there. Are you into emotional maturity, April? Sure. I am confused about you saying you picked a place based on my interests and singing being the specific thing and choosing a football game. I understand. And obviously, looking back on it, it wasn't the smartest thing. I was trying to do something unique, something safe. So just real quick, what I'm hearing from April is she really wanted to sing on their date. She had her heart set on it. Yeah, I mean, that's. You know how that can feel. Totally. So this is what I'd like to offer, and it's 100% up to her, but in front of a nationwide audience listening all across the country. April, no pressure. April, seriously, no pressure. We would like to give you the chance to, right now on our show, finally get it out there and show Noah what he missed out on again. Totally. It's totally up to you. You can do it or not do it, but here's your shot. She sounds excited. I mean, I wanted to sing last week and I didn't get to, so I. I mean, I can. It's better late than never. All right, sing Take Me out to the Ball game in three. Well, maybe a non sports one for her. I don't even know that she ever knew. Song you sing Whatever's in your heart. Okay. Something's got a hold of me lately. Wow. There you go. I want to Go to open mic with you? Yeah. Amazing. Amazing. Dude, that was sexy. That was hot. That was like a turtle. That was hot. Yeah. It helps that my voice is a little scratchy today. It makes me sound better for that song. Yeah, you just did it on the fly. That's crazy impressive. So, April, I know this has been a lot, but we would like to send you out on another date. It could be like a karaoke date, or we could do something. Wait, hold on just a second. What? You're acting me out for him? Noah, Ask me yourself. Tell me you're taking me to karaoke. And I want sushi, too. I like this girl. Yeah. Oh, my God. Okay, get him. No. I guess you're right up. April, will you please go out on another date with me and have some sushi, have some fun, and please sing as well. Please? We'll do karaoke and we'll pay for it. Fine. I love it. All right. Congratulations. Thank you, guys. Thank you. April and Brooke, thank you. And I think you kind of came through for me there. I'll take it. That was so hard for me. She didn't throw a guy underneath the table. Well done, bro. I never throw one on the table. I want to tell them how much that they are like your voice get. I think it's great. Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. All right, here's the good news. Yeah, they said yes. Oh, my God. I want to update from them. I mean, I'll be really cool about it, but I really want an update for them. I want an update. Or not. Like, yeah, I thought they were so cute. They were. It turned out to be actually a good match. The bad news, though, and this isn't necessarily for me, but there are 15 more requests on the text board from guys wanting Brooke to do something better or improve in the second date. Update. I knew we were gonna open that. Listen, I'm not listening to any of y'all, okay? I live by my own rules, and I am myself. I can't help it. I can't be anybody else, Jeff. It's just who I am. No one's asking you to be anybody else. Just a better version of you. There is no cool or chill inside this body. I say any feedback is good feedback. Right, bro? They're invested in you and your success. All they want to see you do is be good block. Okay, well, you can still try. Doubt she'll listen. But keep your requests coming in to 78592. If you want help with your dating life, email the show. We'll call that person who's not calling you back and go check out all of our second day podcasts wherever you get yours at Brooke and Jeffrey we're up on YouTube so go subscribe and also Apple, Spotify, anywhere we're chill about it. Yeah, it doesn't sound like it right now. Jeff. Totally. Brooke and Jeffrey in the morning. This is Ashley Iconetti from the Ben and Ashley I Almost Famous podcast. If you could lose 10.4 pounds in one month, would you try? Well, with Future Health you can find out if weight loss meds are right for you in just 3 minutes at try fh.com that is try fh.com try fh.com results may vary based on start weight and adherence to diet, exercise and program goals Database based on independent studies sponsored by Future Health. Future Health is not a healthcare services provider. Meds are prescribed at provider's discretion okay, so we all need to get away from the world sometimes. Well, in the all new 2025 Nissan Murano, you don't even have to go anywhere. The Murano is the getaway. Just picture it. The Bose Premium sound system plays your favorite music as the Murano's massaging leather appointed seats melt away your stress. Yeah, that's a real getaway. Drive the all new 2025 Nissan Murano today. Day bows and massaging leather appointed seats are optional. Features Legends the greatest social, casino and sportsbook experience has arrived@legends.com with thousands of the best free to play casino style games, chances to earn millions of bonus coins and win real money, Legends is revolutionizing the Vegas experience wherever you are. If you love winning, then you'll love playing at Legendz. Legends is a free to play social casino void. We're prohibited. Play responsibly. Visit legends.com for more information. Legends with a Z.com is legendary fun this Valentine's Day. Celebrate every love story with Pandora. Whether it's romantic, platonic, familial or a gesture of self love, Pandora's versatile designs let you express your unique connections in meaningful ways. Each piece tells a story of love or friendship that transcends materialism, turning every gift into a heartfelt message that connects hearts. From best friends to significant others, Pandora helps you honor the bonds that make life richer and more meaningful. Make the feeling last from first sight to forever on Valentine's Day and every day. B Love Shop Pandora Jewelry today in store or online@pandora.net it's tax season and by now I know we're all a bit tired of numbers, but here's an important one you need to hear $16.5 billion. That's how much money in refunds the IRS flagged for possible identity fraud last year. Here's another 20%. That's the overall increase in identity theft related to tax fraud in 2024 alone. But it's not all grim news. Here's a good number. 100 million. That's how many data points Lifelock monitors every second. If your identity is stolen, LifeLock's US based restoration specialists will fix it, backed by another good number, the Million Dollar Protection Plan. In fact, restoration is guaranteed or your money back. Don't face identity theft and financial losses alone. There's strength in numbers with Lifelock Identity theft Protection for tax season and beyond. Join now and save up to 40% your first year. Call 1-800-LIFELOCK and use promo code iheart or go to lifelock.com iheart for 40% off. Terms apply.