Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update — “Hired A Hinge Coach”

Original Air Date: February 9, 2026
Episode Theme:
This episode of “Second Date Update” explores the lengths people will go to improve their online dating outcomes—including hiring professional coaches. Roman, a listener who’s tried to break free from lackluster online dating routines, shares how he enlisted a Hinge coach to find success. After a promising first date, he faces radio silence and seeks Brooke and Jeffrey’s help to uncover what went wrong, leading to an unexpected revelation about “wedding season” anxieties.

Main Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Changing Landscape of Online Dating

[03:23] Jeffrey: Opens with nostalgia for “the good old days” of online dating, lamenting how today’s app experiences are rife with endless swiping but not much real connection.

• Brooke and Alexis highlight how dating fatigue and routine have set in—“You do get the sense that people are just over it.” [04:03]
• Jeffrey: “Let’s face it, there’s a really good Netflix show…you don’t need some random guy to be there and ruin that for you.” [04:09]

2. Roman’s Unorthodox Strategy: Hiring a Hinge Coach

[04:50] Roman: “So I hired a Hinge coach.”

• He explains the challenge of moving from chatting to real-life meetups and how a coach helped streamline this process.
• Brooke: “Dating coaches have been around for a long time.” [05:04]

Notable Coach Advice

• Roman: “He said something that was so simple, but it really changed my life. He said once you match...you just have to go for it and say, ‘I feel like getting to know each other would be more natural in person.’” [05:24]

• The hosts react humorously to this “secret” wisdom, with Brooke joking that Roman just “spilled all his information.” [05:47]

• Roman also shares a tip on numbers: “Don’t ask for her number. Give them your number.” [06:26]

  • Brooke: “You would feel more comfortable as a woman that way, right?” [06:35]

3. Roman’s Date With Haley

• They went to a Mediterranean restaurant and hit it off so well that they began planning a second date mid-dinner.
• Roman: “But it was going so well, even halfway through the date, we were talking about what we’re gonna do next time.” [07:19]
• Suddenly, Haley became “real quiet” as if rethinking things [07:30].
• Roman admits he doesn’t have “other women” lined up—he focuses on one person at a time.

4. Post-date Weirdness: Mixed Signals

• After the date (which ended with a kiss), Roman notices Haley’s communication shifts: she’s non-committal about meeting up again, saying, “I’ll get back to you on that.” [08:38]
• Brooke: “She’s brushing him off for sure.” [08:52]
• Roman hasn’t asked his coach (his trial expired!), so he turns to the show hosts for help. [09:29]

The Call to Haley – Unpacking the Issue

5. Haley’s Perspective: The Pressure of Wedding Season

[12:56] – The Call Begins

• Haley initially says she enjoyed the date, but planning future dates on a first date “was honestly really awkward...I just couldn’t believe that that was actually something we were talking about.” [13:46]
• She explains that she has four weddings coming up (“I’m in a wedding and going to three others”) [14:41] and is anxious about the social expectations:
  • “Am I going to have to invite this dude to all of these weddings now? And if I don’t, is he going to be upset?” [14:51]
  • She worries about awkwardness if he meets her friends and family so soon.

[15:56] – Haley’s Reason For Holding Back:

• “Let’s just wait until after wedding season is done.”
• She still enjoys texting and talking to Roman but is not ready for the level of commitment that bringing someone as a wedding guest implies.

6. Group Reactions and Guidance

• The hosts show empathy:
  • Brooke: “There is no such thing as perfect timing. It just doesn’t exist.” [17:42]
  • Alexis: “This actually makes sense to me.” [15:34]
• They urge Haley not to overthink; bringing someone to a wedding isn’t a binding commitment.
• Brooke: “Who cares if he meets your grandma and then ends up breaking up?” [18:14]

7. Roman’s Gentle Response

• Roman: “I hate that you’re putting so much pressure on yourself and us. I can work around your schedule. If it would make you uncomfortable for me to come to one of your weddings, I just won’t come...I just want to see her.” [18:55–19:12]
• This kindness and flexibility impress everyone, including Haley.

Resolution & Outcome

8. Second Date Secured!

• [19:35] Jeffrey offers to pay for Roman and Haley’s next date—whenever she’s ready.
• Haley: “I would love to see him again...We’ll just take it day by day, I guess.” [19:35–19:44]
• Lightheartedly, the team wants Haley’s grandma’s stamp of approval:
  • Haley: “You’d never get her off the phone.” [19:51]

Memorable Quotes & Moments

• Roman: “I feel like getting to know each other would be more natural in person.” [05:36] (Coach’s advice)
• Jeffrey: “Let’s face it, there’s a really good Netflix show...and you don’t need some random guy to be there and ruin that for you.” [04:09]
• Haley: “Am I going to have to invite this dude to all of these weddings now? And if I don’t, is he going to be upset?” [14:51]
• Brooke: “Who cares if he meets your grandma and then ends up breaking up? Come on.” [18:14]
• Roman: “You know what? I just want to see her. So whatever she feels comfortable with...I’m good.” [19:12]

Important Segment Timestamps

• [03:23] – Jeffrey on the state of online dating
• [04:50] – Roman describes hiring a Hinge coach
• [05:36] – Key coach advice about moving conversations offline
• [07:19] – Roman recounts planning a second date mid-dinner
• [08:38] – Roman describes Haley’s post-date distancing
• [12:56] – Start of call with Haley
• [14:41] – Haley discusses wedding season anxieties
• [18:55] – Roman’s empathetic response
• [19:35] – Haley agrees to a second date

Final Thoughts

• The episode showcases how small, unexpected emotional roadblocks—like wedding season pressure—can derail a budding romance, despite positive intentions on both sides.
• The panel gently confronts overthinking and supports open, honest dialogue.
• Ultimately, a kind, flexible response wins out over rigid social expectations—leaving Roman and Haley with a “day by day” approach, and the promise of a second date (plus the show’s treat).

Tone:
Lively, playful, and supportive, with gentle teasing but genuine empathy for both Roman and Haley.

Want more Second Date Updates or the full show?
Links are available on iHeartRadio, Apple, and Spotify.